ATA/37/2005, Genf

Résumé: Recours contre le refus de l'autorisation de construire un jardin d'hiver admis. Le refus n'étant justifié par aucun intérêt public au vu des circonstances (caractère particulierement hétéroclite du quartier). En outre, le seul préavis négatif émis par la sous-commission d'architecture n'emporte pas la conviction du tribunal vu son caractère trop général et peu motivé.

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

!" # $#% &$#' (% )*!+,!-./ !"+,, !! "#$%& 0((0 (0( 1 0( 0 (

'()*+'

)*,*-)(++, *. "/."#.. #!# *(0-% 1% //2 #''#3#' 45//6. 27,(1/(#!8#, !9!%#*:#!(;(:# 3 '*0+6.

;# /# 2$;## ?( /( @# 7/ 2A!/#! 2;/##9B%##@299*1/(. (. *- =# (++0% "/ ". . ! ! 4 ! / 6&#A !/ ! = 3!#?=#(++06.

2 # @D% "/ ". . # 9 $9 $#@ !;# 2A# #@ =# 2$#& #//!#. 0. ! /## !&#!#. // !! 2&# /@ G 7/ 3 !&# 0=#(++06. //##//%#3#' 45"H6% '//##2$#3H 6!/# !&#!7&;*? =# (++0. &! !# # ! G /# @# 7## # 2 /;##@ #!/!@# #7F. % H #9# !! &2/;.,. !##*:I(++0%! /7!2####!% 2 ## # *? *+- # # ###&*,&#*:113'?+?6.2=&!!# #$!#@ ## !!. ! / !# 7# # !&#H .

'0)*+'

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

',)*+'

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

! @ 2#//; #& # ! A . / !9/A 9.'##/D/$%#/D/9;#. 2;#2$/@!;.2#//; ##G #! A./ // #9% =#!!$$#/@&##;##!.

&F$/#D%=9!!9!!@A&#% #! #&/*0#$/#A &=# 2$#&.289//!97!. #/$/@!;.

'?)*+'

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

#% H $! L!7&;% / / !/M. **. # (? &/; (++,% ! / 7#/! #; /###7@&!)*+'

)*,*-)(++, $@7#@ ;*::+6. &$%@ //## . @ !! #; /###7% !H /#@2#!'#2#//;!#&#9 #@%#&##!#!%# $#. !#!@&2&#/%H # DGG2A#927#/#!G*?/(. O@2&#@ !##279!#A2 !!@4 #/#&# 2/;H . !&#C#7*-&/;(++,/!#7#@@!7A#. H 7#/ ## ## @2 2 7#A! # =# 2$#& P @2 &. ## /#2 !## ## @## #/2A/2. #% H ! @2 # % 2 4 G # A #%&!# /%/#4@2! 77@# =!/ 4!$/#&2! 2/; 7F;2#//;!. 77% 9;#=#2$#&! A.#; #@ 9 &##% # # #9! G 7F 2#//; //#@#&G2A!/#!#'#7##&# # #. 2 /% #4 # 2$/#/#& H #7//;7!.

7#% 4&#&#9! #G###%H $! L!7&;% / / !/M #! ! / / =##A#77! #!#!.29#G2 &K #% A;# G 2;= ##9% @ ! / 2 !! A !/#.249 &#7#@@!/$ . 1.

2 4%4 9!!/#&# &# !&#%!9 !#! A.%##;/###7G 2!G7#/!##//##% ;# !##G! /@;#&9 ## # &#2A/.

77% 42##G@# !!%#;! @ @ 7 ! / 2 =#7#! #!D ;# 77#. ##@2# 2&# %##!D /## 4 &#9# G 2$/# @# 2 4 @#

':)*+'

)*,*-)(++, #A# # 2/ 2#!D #&! ! A.G# =# 2$#& % /% 9#/ ! # 2$!#@. %! /27! !&#!7&;H ' !&# !9#7 2 4' # @# @2# !! !;# /!#. :. ! / =! !## //## 7#/!. # !! / @2#!#& 2####!. *+. @#!%!// F.#/#! ! QO *<?++.' !A! A.@# ## %G$92 4&. RRRRR

0(& 234."*!5 ! &; #=! ? =# (++, ! / </!9/% <!@# / 9/ !## //## /#4#(,/#(++,N 4.)5 =N &##! /2/!9/%2!@# /9/ @2#!#&2####!N #@<#< F<!//N #/#! !QO*<?++.'G"/."#..%G $92 4&N //#@ !D! /</!9/%<!@# / 9/%G//##/#4###@<G "#$%&"/."#...

'*+)*+'

)*,*-)(++, H#!95".C$4% !#%"/&C%Q#%".$!#%=9%".% =9 !.

/#; /###75 977#4'=#5 .#'H#9# !#5 O.C$4 #7/D!!//#@!A #. 4&% 977#45