opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/180/2005

Genf · 2005-03-14 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (2 Absätze)

E. 7 " 4

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

", (!8 5C45456  ""!, + G" 0&,&!,!"

E. 8 4D5 " R   $ . $     !" *&&!,,!",)*" ` 2<F< " N8 %-&   ! &-,+&",! ,B !& ' !!, ""   0) % 00" !&"!"0  " Q ,B !& %" J"!  & M!"8 254 8 5 N8  +!! "",&!",  " !&", !%& %>& ' +!& - ,- - ,"" > " !"& ,&,",  !&  32,&)! 56658 "",&!", %"& " !   &"& !0""  ! ! +"&!& - + ""&8

  - !&:,   "  &"& %)" 00"& !  (,"  32,&)! 56658 D8   ,+ : +%!, %  &"& !&,", "" %!& " !&  32,&)! 56658 "0   "" ';" ""!  (,"  !), & "" -  !&%> *), +!& + ) ,"8  +" " ' ,, ,& ,B 0!

1223415664 7 <126 7,"", !&%> &8 + !E %" "! ! +%"!,  *" " +"! 0& '  (," " !"&   " ! 7;-+'  ,,!" B !"", %8 ,B  """ +%!, !&%> "", +!& - "  ! ! ,,"8  " B"   "" +!& -  0", %!!  ""  &!!  B &*  + 0"  (," !, %!" !% ' ," %!, 2! ! 2<<@ %  8  " %", "B"  ) ""  0"8 ," ""0 J"! , - "" !!! + ,  ,+ :  , 0:!8  !!"  00", ;! !, !&"& M5 8D6<15663N - "!!" B &*&, +!& ""  !"", )! * &  ""!,+%!, % -  00"& '  ! !&"&,+ *" ", 0!, !&%> &8

,!"  C* &-  !"" "  J)" -+ " "",B,"& ' %!! ), !&%> !0, +!&8  B" 0""  ! !" &!, B"& "!  !"" %!&  ""!,+-",+ *", )", !&%> "  !"&   ", )!7 *8

! A- !&  !"", )! *  32,&)! 5665,", A*", >":  ""&  "" ",  " & !* ,%,8

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

 %,  - !&:, ,,," J"! !;"&8 0!&"  !  & ! +!"8 =3 8 5   !&,! " *!""8

1223415664 7 26126 7 8 !" 4," +, ! , "  !" !,"

 91   7  0  0 :; $<',=  1 

28 &! ,, !%)8  10

58  !;""8 38 " " "" - +%!, !&%>  !:,  (   b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

 *!00:!U

#!7  /

 !&," U

 S

   0!, !&" !!J" " "0& B !"  -+' +00 0&,&!, !  !  *!00 

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

      

  

   ! "  

        

#$$%&#'((& #$)(#'((* "  +, ! , "  !" !," $- . / 0 '' 12 '((*

   0  3333333333   !" ! # $!%&  %" ' (!)!*  + ",,-  &",,,!

"! 40 0 2   12 0  0 !2 0 5 0 6-2  7 6-2   !" ! # !!, . /  + ",,-  &",

,&0,!

1223415664 7 5126 7 " 4

28 #, .9999999999 7 !: +!& " &  26;%! 2   0%!, !, !%"!, #-, :% 7 !:  (,"8 58 "" (," !  !, !%"! "!  &-, +?*, +%,"& ",,&:8   &"&;-+ 5663 !*&   ! ,  !"&, !""8   &"& !&* %" ! ! !:*" "" +  %*!, 2!;%! 2 ": ",+!*"  ,  !"&, ""8 38 ! ""!, 25  " 3; 2 & "  !&,! '  -- !&," ,0" !  "8   "" ! & -   !& B*) %"  &A&" J"!  & " - +%!, %,  ,"  !&"  "" ,",+B*)"&8   ;"& -   (," "" J"! !&:! ' !,+ "! %!&    !"",+**!  !&,!  !)!"8

238 ! , 26  5664  (,"  ! !  B "8   ! %!   !!!  %!"  2! ! 2   %*!, 2!;%! 2 ,  00&8 .  +),,!" - ! +!&  2!;%! 5663 ", (!8 D3387 % -+ " ""&, (!8 5D@C3=487 " (!8 4C3D587 ,&,"  "!, %!" !&%&, (!8 5F5C3 !&,!,: - )8  ! !, ! !   "," "" ,&)"", ,,!8

" 

2  !&" ",,!" ,"!"0  0, ! +!" =3 & 2 " 3,   0&,&!, 5D; 2  !0 % !%%" " %,"& M . @32846N " +!" DF 8 2 "),   *% ! +!*";,! MN8  !) ", !  "  &"" ' !,  ":! M!"8 =3 8 2 N8  +" &*" ' !, ,  ! Q +00&  &"& **&  !:,+  >!  + :  0," *% B!E"  "%"& ' :% M!"8 =3 8 3 N8 5 +);", ,, ;"  " !"! - !, -";!,- ","  &- "A" !:"" ;")8 ;! !, ,"  ,"  !%)"&,+ "  """  

1223415664 7 D126 7,,!   "&!J",*, !"" '  """ &,",+ ! !",,!" "*B8  "&!J", 0" 00" ! "" -+ +*,+ "&!J" " " &,"8  :!  *&&! +"&!J",*, !"" !- 0",&0"  !:* !,! !- ;") ")"!   0%! ;*" ,"! M (22  +"  ! B*)8 !""  !&",,," J"!,&!& !%)8 3  !" 36  " &"& "!," !   0&,&!, 2=,&)! 2 ,  !&%> !0  %*!,   2!;%! 2 ,  !&%> !0 ((2  M 0!,+ %!" " & !"8 36 N " !    **, !,!" %!, """, !&%> M!"8 36) N8  !"8 36   "!L" "&"  """,+ "! 0!, !&%> &  ,  !" ",  "8  00"  ! !&"&, *" ! !&" 7 J  &&",  !"", !&%> , )! * -  !"" "A& !,  !%,+ , !&%> , )! * " !&," ! !""  %!" " & M!"8 36 8 4 R #*, 2   +%"",  *" "G" -+  0" '  """, !&%> , )! * "" !-+ "" -+))! " B ' J, "!  )", ! !&%> MS!! .. # SA*"0T!,!* ", #"",!)!0A !!* U !0A !!* (!VW**X" , SA*"0T!,!* $ . $# Y&,8Z 2  ,!"  %!",+ "" !  ! !&"&,+ *" !  ! !)8 + !: +!"8 36, 8 3 ""!    !)!" ' +""", !&%>, "" !E " "!&;-+' "!  %"  ,,!" B !"", %8 .  !"8 36, 8 2 ""!  36, 8 D " 36 8 2    *"  ! !&"& " %, +!&," !)!! ' +""", !&%>  %!" " & !E 7 ' A"!, !," !&& [ "" !"!",,!",+&!,%" J"! "&  *"! 0! M!"8 36 8 5 N8 +)*", !)!"  )" ""0 -;-+' "!  %"  ,,!" '  !", % M!"8 36 8 F N "  " "  J"! !,& "!  %"  ,,!" B !"", % M!"8 36 8 3 ""!  N8 48    !"! +!& ,,& '  (,",)&&0!,  0"&  !&% ' +!"8 36  0,+"!,!"" +%!, !&%> - ! 0! +-",+ *"8  "" %!& ' +!&  %, +-",  ! !&"&,+ *" !  ! !)  0" +);",+ !!!, -""&8   )&!&  2! ! 2   !:,  (,"8 +!& "" )70,&, "" &!"8  "" -   (,",%" +"! !&:!, "! %!&    !",!",+**!  !&,!  !)!"8

N !"   &  ":!,C!  !:*"   ", !& M ! B U !"8 56 8 5  . Y (22D  345 %8

,8 5)Z !"8 D6   !"8 D6 

" "" +!"8 3 ! ' +""", !&%> 7   " !" !&*& !  ! 

1223415664 7 =126 7 *&&!B " , ", ,,)*" M!"8 256  N "  ) ! * M (25@  55@ ,8 5)R . 2 ,CB",,&)"! M%! ! B 

(22D  343 ,8 5 222  263 ,8 3)N8 "" B* " ' ! !A!, C!"8 25D A8 5  B "!,-  %" J"! &"" !  "  !&,"  "!  & B*"  " 00"0 "!  , !&! " -, "   ! )" &! ' C"!",,&)"! ",  0 M (26@  4= ,8 5N8  :! *&&!   " ,!" ) 7 ", "" ,!", !  7 " )!,& '  ," -,B ! " !& !-" !&:! ",&)"! C, C"! 0!&" '  !:* & ! C!"8 256 8 2  M%!    "! !,,,)*"  ` D  , !"8 256 R

(25@  55@ ,8 3)R . 2   %*!, 2!;%! 2 ":  , "& !! , ' , +!"8 36 8 4   -  %!" "!L "&"  !&,", !"", !&%>, +!&8 ,, 0! " &*" 0! B !  *&&!B,,!"  - !-+,&)"! "  !&! "  J "  !&! ",&)"! +, +"! +!"8 256, ,,)*" M N  "! '  ! !,"" % ! !&8    -"! ," '   "8  ) '  !" - %"  !&%!,   ",+ !"!  !% -  ," 0! " "&! " !& M!"8 25D N8 ,,+B"",,""   +,""&;!,- "  !& !"&, ;",)*" U,&)"! " !&!, ,""  & M-,&,+)*";!,- 

1223415664 7 @126 7 0!, "!" M2 & ' +!& - ,- - ,"" > " !"& ,&,",  !&  32,&)! 56658 "",&!", %"& " !   &"& !0""  ! ! +"&!& - + ""&8

  - !&:,   "  &"& %)" 00"& !  (,"  32,&)! 56658 D8   ,+ : +%!, %  &"& !&,", "" %!& " !&  32,&)! 56658 "0   "" ';" ""!  (,"  !), & "" -  !&%> *), +!& + ) ,"8  +" " ' ,, ,& ,B 0!

1223415664 7  &8 + !E %" "! ! +%"!,  *" " +"! 0& '  (," " !"&   " ! 7;-+'  ,,!" B !"", %8 ,B  """ +%!, !&%> "", +!& - "  ! ! ,,"8  " B"   "" +!& -  0", %!!  ""  &!!  B &*  + 0"  (," !, %!" !% ' ," %!, 2! ! 2  &8

,!"  C* &-  !"" "  J)" -+ " "",B,"& ' %!! ), !&%> !0, +!&8  B" 0""  ! !" &!, B"& "!  !"" %!&  ""!,+-",+ *", )", !&%> "  !"&   ", )!7 *8

! A- !&  !"", )! *  32,&)! 5665,", A*", >":  ""&  "" ",  " & !* ,%,8

" &*!,  !), & "" - +%!   ", !&%> !0, +!& &"", (!8 D3387 ' "","8 F8 +!& "" ! %! ) ,*, 0" -+  &"& & !   "", %!" " &, (!8 52  !&,"8  !!L" + G" %!& + &"& !   !&" !E  ""!, %!" " &8 ! +&A", !"!", 0,, !&%> "  > !,+ "", +& 0,  ! Q   !"!&,  J B! 0,&"!"  "B,+ "  ) " Q  " "! - ,!! " !*!08 : ! ,* %-& +"  &")8 =8

 %,  - !&:, ,,," J"! !;"&8 0!&"  !  & ! +!"8 =3 8 5   !&,! " *!""8

1223415664 7 26126 7 8 !" 4," +, ! , "  !" !,"

 91   7  0  0 :; $   !:,  (   b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

 *!00:!U

#!7  /

 !&," U

 S

   0!, !&" !!J" " "0& B !"  -+' +00 0&,&!, !  !  *!00