ACOM/151/2003, Genf

Résumé: Pour qu'une décision concernant un contrôle de connaissance soit annulée, il faut que les limites de l'arbitraire soient franchies.

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

p.a Tribunal administratif, rue des Chaudronniers 3, 1204 Genève, tél. : (022) 388 23 30

!"##$ %&'(%%' Madame G______

contre FACULTE DES LETTRES et

UNIVERSITE DE GENEVE

A/1080/2003-CRUNI contrôle des connaissances – élimination –recevabilité partielle pour défaut d’opposition)

- 2 - ! %%))))))*&&+,*-. /0/&(0% *'-'1/%1 /(2(-&/3 '/1 &43 & %1.& ++5! (( '-'1 /&' /1 2 (-.( (%&0 1 /3/(/'%1/.& 6 %&7%/'' 8/9%: 4'; .2(%'''/.&-.1. +++*))))))%.1&( 1/6/%1 -1'6 %&7%/''2(%'''/.&% '"###!

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

''//&(- %&'2)))))):. A-((.1/&&(/:(?'.>%/1!.&1/& (/%. -%1 ' .0%1/.&' 3/& %/12 &/&0%(/1%1 /&1'%&/%1'A/661%/&1 &. %(&1( '1'%&'(' ' 0(&1%/ '*H'-/('3%/&1%''/6%/ 6%2' /66/(1'%&'( 3/: /31: '.&&((! !

&1%&1A-/('1/ /0.&1 (%/'/.&' .::.'/1/.&,C/&"##$*( . '%1 /&1 C1&1:'1/(1'1 3%(8% 1!,"(%(./' (-&/3 '/1",%/+5$99 $#N% 1!@5 40(&1(-&/3 '/15':1 +@@99$#!#,N% 1!",1"5 40(&1/&1 & (%1/6%B: . '-.::.'/1/.&1 . '"63 / +559=! "! ( '(1(-&1H1(-%1 . '#C/&"##$A))))))&1&6%/ .::.'/1/.& 2 (% /'/.& %/ "##$ : .&.&7%&1 '.& (//&%1/.& (% 6%(1! -% 1/( " : 3./1A'((%/'/.&' .::.'/1/.&'1'C112 . '8% 1!@+=!-'1.&2

1. 1A))))))%'%/'// 1&1(%1((9/ &3 %(.''/ ' :./&12 (-%1. /1%/&/'1 %1/3.:1&18% 1!,E%(!"(%(./' (%: . %/&/'1 %1/3" ':1 +@8 9 #=! $! % . %&1 '1 /%1 /( 2 (-&/3 '/1 &43 :/' ( ''1 ->/3 ++5!

((%.&(J(: :% %&1%/:(?-1'6 %&7%/''8 /66 E*/(: /'A(-1/%&1%/'%&'(J(: :% %&1% .&1/A/&10 %.(N 8!!!= !

&(-':4*(% . %&1%.1&(%&.1$%.(2(%'''/.&63 / "##$*1%&1: /'A-1%/1%(. ''%1 ./'/41&1%1/38&C/((1"###((&'-'1:%': '&1 1((%.1&(%&.1D .1&C/((1"##((%.1&(%&.1"*5=! ,! % . %&1.&1'1(%&.1$A/(/%1%11 /! %!

& %1/4 :.3./ -B%&* (% ./''/.& -.::.'/1/.& % & :.3./ (//1 2 (-% /1 %/ A%&12(-%:: /%1/.&'0 /6'6.&8% 1!"#%("=!C /': &.&'1%&1*

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

- 6 - .&/A(%: '&1/'/.&2%%))))))*26%(1'(11 '*%' 3/ C //A(-&/3 '/1&43*%/&'/A%:% 1&1(/&'1 1/.&:(/A!! /0%&1'; .3J*: '/&1*! &/. J* %&&* '! &.(%./''/.& . '; (%0 66/4 ; (%: '/&1; !<%(A1 !.3J .:/.&6. 11/'/.&%1.&/A%B:% 1/'! &43*( (%0 66/4 ; ! %&/