opencaselaw.ch

DCSO/58/2007

Genf · 2007-02-13 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

  

        

DCSO/58/07          ! " "     #$$ " $%&!   "" $'()*(+,-( . !"! 

/$! !%011102%  34&$ #3"!  " "! !'(011(05( 6- &4 ""$$ 78'(011(+( 6-( .! 8!  8$$% &%&#&! 9 "%.8!'(25 6-( 

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

           @           @                !         @ "                #$   %&&'      !      

     !  ((     %&&) @               (                       !         ! 2 !/511*%#$$ ! ! ? @ *         

  *+   , #- %&&)  *./0120.3 @ 0      @ " ! ,4

- 5 - @ 1   !       

             5

                     @ +         ! !      6 

         78        @ .    

      

        @ /  *+*2   

  %-%

 @ /                        5  5             9 

   9 

      5  ! !              %-%

  3 !!!!&!3"!! >=CCCCCC (#$#/4 #""   ! !$( 6(  55 !/ 511*% #$$      CCCCCC     3J  ;      !J(   J    J  # 3      55 !/511*(       55 !/ 511* &       ! 'J   # "J ' 3 -  J    J ' 3 -- "!! : $!"?'- ""  #(5+1(0  J   JM'-  $ #(*%(  J   # "J%&%  # $  CCCCCC %$$$$  CCCCCC 4  /!M'-"" #(A J   J"#   # " M'- !8>#(5(/ J  

- 6 - # "J%    & CCCCCC   #88 >  "!   &   >  78   %  !  #(0;() M'-"!&#(0+(5 J    J".N" CCCCCC &## " % #$$  #(0A(0  M'-" #(0+ J   J"  #(05B(2"!9&#&! !$ /  8!."8&! #"3   &  . $! >     4      3 7%&  8%3 #!.>)O( #(B "!&J   !      



  ! 

! ! J&J    'P-     !   

   &""&! !88  =CCCCCC      6  "G   =   ! 3"!  #7""%"!&  ! #& " #7 > CCCCCC %   !"%   #&'()%"(+-( ( " 38!  !!9!"$ > =CCCCCC   "  !&  #$$  05 4 511;(  3>#"!!>=CCCCCC ( D( @8 554511;%=CCCCCC $!"J             Q((   !  55 !/511*RJ(  =CCCCCC " $&8!55 !/511*" #$$% CCCCCC    &# !>#$$ "   55 !/511* !! "  CCCCCC J5

 ! ! 

       

- 7 -   !            '-                 5   

 #-  %&&) 4  

            

           5(

         55'- 8 0 >3  + 

     ?'-   5     5

       ! @J   /  J       Q(( &! ""R

        +?  #-  %&&)-J%=CCCCCC >& 0B$!511; ( (    52 4 511;% 014511;(  "9  $  #$$(   >  !8  3"! !  !!"" $" >78 7&! &!&=CCCCCC  6"G = !>""(#$$ $"!!&=CCCCCC 6"G =  "3  "&#> ! " ' 5#0;1#A*+ $(01 " =CCCCCC    52)#A)A $(01 "  6"G = -( F( )$!511;%#$$&!3"3!! # 37&8!/" CCCCCC "   #4" $ 00711027+1!F7> L7%"!$#/4 &# !  !/(  8 !/ " CCCCCC    &     5+0  8 !/ " CCCCCC  %  8    8(   " "  "! $"!" 55 !/511*%

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

                     :       

- 10 -   5            5             8                            5   7   A 7 !  J( =CCCCCC     &    " &   9!&#36"G = 4G  $  "3%  !"   $ &  "       !$ $!% !8  "! 3"8!(=CCCCCC   "! $ & J    

        ? @    3     4  5  

   (

         ? 3  @   5      

 4J(=CCCCCC  &  #""&#"%     ! > !   & &# &$  $ (  =CCCCCC "!!J/"!J 00$!511; "   05 $! 511;% 3  &  8 &   "J

 5 

       5J(   "! &   J !         5       5  ! !                   ? B! !B   !@8 J($%=CCCCCC "!& &"&#J   5        

 7 5  5    

       !   5     J(    "&  05 $! 511;% #$$ 3" &#  #! #""/! S7%!8!/%  /% &   "        #"" 8( CCCCCC     >  !8  .  !! &   3  #$$(#$$3""&#3   "  >" #"7!%J(    != 

    :        5  !     J( " 9     ! 7! ! !8! >  "! #!8! (%#$$%! $ !!     #3    "  =CCCCCC      6  "G   =   #  ( #$$"! $ & #3   "#!!8! &J  !      5  A      (     !    !

J(

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

         5

                J-($& . !!   7 0B$!511;(&#"% 8!/" CCCCCC &!!3!># 9! "#$$3!"3!!( & 8! 55 !/511*%"""Z  /(8$! ""$ ""       "/!  7  !!% &   ! #$$ )$!511;( 0((  !"& %%4#7 7& "/!& ! "/%"!!>& "! . !'(05)(+-% !"$$  ( !"&  % T $8" #"/! #"!&!" "% &    / "    7   #7'@/!%  (05) E+5M=!/7% @% (05)E0;-( 0((  #"% " $   8$ !   " !"!  55 4 511;% =CCCCCC    I & #   &   !! &!%8 !/" CCCCCC "   %"" ! #$$ )$!511;(9    !&#"" 55 !/ 511*%"8&! "!# &!)$!511;(  & /! "!""$% T ! .4!$ (

- 13 - 4$ " #! "! ($ $$   &#> !" # ! #/!   " !"!     55 !/ 511*%  . 8$  7$"!   !"/ #" # &!)$!511;( %  ""&.#/ #"!" 3 38!8%& #"%  ! "    !   !  '( 55 -    ' 60+121; (5(0%, 511);*-(T "8 & #!8! "/  7  0B$! 511; $ [ "!/     88     [7 " "%9 #$  ""$ !8( 5((   %  9     &   &  "8     3(  #8% # "% #  3 7 "/& $!    #!8   #$$  &    ! 8! # " !!  7(38  % CCCCCC   8  &! #3  #$$ '@/ !% %   ( 05)% E0+-( #    "" &#> # J7$!J %  7 %   !7!% $     &# 48  " "  #$'$(=!/7% @% (05*% E01-( #8% #"% #37"/&'(55B(5 -  #79"7 T%   #7%    ! 8!  #$$  (     $$ !! ! "/& '  " !%  8  #% -% #""   "&  "">  #9$ $$  ! !@. "! >  7"/& '$( ( 0)  55 !/511*M   #37"/&%$(,@!9%  @ % ((55B@5+*EA-(7"/& 3(55B>5+) (#(5+* !#!   " &#  !8 "   $! ! ', 511*% "( 5**  ( 2--(  %#37"/& 524 0BA+'5+1-&#""&( L7%J;  !,!C  ;    D

!  E   ;! ! J  0B !/ 0B;B'5+)(0)-""/337"/&(

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

- 15 -  "!$!!!@&@>@ "  "!$!"  !%4" Z   J"J  "3 # 4     &   / #$$ "'=!/7%((M@/!%( (   !$! !-( =  / $! !% J      5         (J "! &J   'P- (  

            7          

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

- 16 - 7%"!!   ! "%&#">$8   (" =CCCCCC  $ ! .4!"( =#8 #/8&#9 #&! !88   "8% $    &    " "   /8( !  $ # & J  5          

     

    B  B  7   'P-5 

G           

 'P-           (  5         5    !       

!  

  J'@/!% (05)E50!$!> # 6 55  *2)-( " " & T "" #$$$$ "!>#(05*#""&(  """&# 4 "&#$$" !!  "! >    ! 8 " 88 &  !!  &!   '( 01*  M =!/ 7%  @%   (05*E5-(>"!888& &!88  "!   "%  $ .  . "  &!  "( # &&#9 ##3  /8/>!( # &! >$88"%#9/8!8 #  88%"" #9">."!( % T=CCCCCC %># 6"G = %!"9& 88% 8$/>$3" .4!"!8( +( = ! [3" !!#"%"!  " 8'(51(0-(#" $>78 "'(*0 (5(-%".! !"'(*5(5-(  \  \  \  \  \ 

- 17 -               *                                              +   0( 4%      /!%  " :525:511; $!  554511;"=CCCCCC ( 5( !/" (  ",-$./? [$$!" 83""8$$