opencaselaw.ch

ATA/791/2005

Genf · 2005-11-22 · Deutsch GE

Résumé: Dans le cadre d'une fusion de sociétés par absorption, admissibilité de la provision constituée par la société mère pour couvrir les coûts inhérents au plan social. En revanche, la provision pour le rachat de ses propres actions et celle pour couvrir d'éventuels frais futurs sont refusées et l'AFC obtient gain de cause sur ces deux postes.

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

         

        

              

     ! "# " ! #      $$$$$$$$$$ %% !! "#$  %& &        "!! " ! # # #"! #  &# '() 

'()*+'

)(,(()(--, #  *&  .......... /%"0 %& & /"' 12  "3304   "15 "" 67"$ 161865&%3 "9: ""93;& (&  &  "33="!!"8?>-@"*AAB8="" -?*A**/"8";"1?2" 3"5"/ '%((-0&="!!""5"?? B!?3*AAB& !! 3"!="=="""?? /"' 12D% 0*,!?3*AAB&,& 

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

'>)*+'

)(,(()(--, : FD>AGAI+GB*>&' ""? 3 FD*,G+I+G(A,&':  FD*,IG(I+GIA(49"? EJ!"=":!6 FDA>+GA*B4I-&   :!"  "" "!"+B4->*K& I& 

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

9 !?3!!="="!?" "8":!!4 6?H?4:!" 9 D &   % 4  ="  "3  !"  ? 3 9 "" "!""?"?""8?!?!!69"(*"!(

',)*+'

)(,(()(--, ,M;"=":""? !"8??"!?  "" ";"  "  8   "" "4 "?"! ="="?9?"""L"=&  

!;4="?"""=4="=""""; ?"?"!6 "" "!"6?H?!"? 3  "" "4 "   3!!="  =" 3&  !;4  J  =" 9!8 6 FD +G,I(G>B-&'  8"  H !"  3!!="  =" 3 !    "  (AG>>+&'4"?9 D &     =" ?"""=4  "33 ?"    !!  9 D ;"!8"6 FD*G-*IG,I+&'&"?H?  ="="";"9!8"6 FD*-(GB-(&'&   "33"8"6";:!"  "" "8"9==?"1"82   3!!="="8"H ";9"="5"!" "334 ""8":!!8" " ?H?  "="?"""=="=""2  !!="="     FD(-G>(AG>>+&'  D"?"""= ' FD*G-*IG,IC&'  ' "!H ' FD*-(GB-(&'  "8":!!     FD*AG(*-G-II&'  

14:!"!""82,B4-IIK B&  !""(-!?3(--(49 D ?" ""  " "!"!  8"" ? FD+G,I(G>B-&' !"  "" "& 4=":!? ="?"""=6$ FDC,>G>,B&'4;" "6+K ?3 "" "!?"="?&:!" !" !6>+4-B(K"82  !!="="     FD(-G>(AG>>+&'  !  8"""!6=" ' FD+G,I(G>B-&'  ?3 "" "   FD*,GBIIGA++&'  D"?"""=/=="+K0 FDC,>G>,B&'

'+)*+'

)(,(()(--,  ' "!H ' FD*-(GB-(&'  ? "" " FD*,G-(-GB-(&'  !!=""? 3/!!0 FD>AGAI+GB*>&'  !"  "" "2 FD *,G-(-GB-+ : *--) FD >AGAI+GB*>&' N>+4-B(K&

9 D 4!  8""8"H !!" 3!!="=" FD(-G>(AG>>+&'"8"!!? ? 3""!8="?  G((I&'&   %"?!? 9 D   =" 8" 6  "33  3 "=""=*AAB?"="!4 9"? E6 FD*G+,BGB+C4A-& ="8" 3!!=""? 3 FDIGC*>G((I&': FD>AGAI+GB*>&'  ""? 3 FD*,G+I+G(A,&': FD*,IG(I+GIA(&'& A&   (( @8" (-->4  "33     !""  (- !?3(--( 1??""?"19"? E /"' 12 M0&  !"!9?3!;9!" ? ="=" FD+G,I(G>B-&';"!"?"4?" "?  :!"&     "   M " 9" *AAB /"' 12  M% 04  "33 : ";";  "8  ?  8"" !"4 ";:"  "363"4?"L"5" 8  4 8" H !?"!&  ""4  @  """!" 8""&  

94 ""= "= G---G---&'08"=";" 8" H "  $5   "33 ! !;9" !" "?"!6!""="& 6!"9 8""  $  "/ FD*G,>+G---&'04@"=""?S  "" ?"""  & ""  ! "" "  3!!=" "? 3 ==!  " ?   "!H    "  "& % "  ""5 ;"   !?"":!"  "" "&   9 D 4J"!6="!""$!68"6 55? &  !""(+3(--,4 M?"8L!  " 6 9 D    8 !""  :" =? : "!&    M93!69 D ;9955"6  "    ! "" "  3!!=" "? 3 ="53"=""=(-!?3(--(4 31?L!! !9""&  

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

'A)*+'

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

"?""6"" 2 8""  $    "4  8""   "4  8""  !8="=&  & ?="; 8"" $  " "  "334 G D   "  3"'=!&  ==4 9;"""    "  "" "   "33 8" 

'*-)*+'

)(,(()(--, 3@"=  !??5  "" ?"""  *!?3(---&

'**)*+'

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

!;44 ! !4 ;9"3"" 6"33 !; " ?  !"  "" "G"(* M2 8"" $  "4 8""  "  8"" !8="=& "3?"""=9:?" ;" & >& &  8""!" !6$5? ! "? !  ?:G?  G   !3"  =T " /U&  %4 " =" "4 18'V'M"$(--(4 &*>A0&"?""8  "H8 G:"??"/ D*AC+ &>++0& 8""1 8"""H@"="! G5??"&

'*()*+'

)(,(()(--,

 " 4 =?!?  ""   !"""!4   ="  G"5"! !"/U& % &"& &*>AR H  "3 =!! (&*B,)(--,  (* @" (--, R, &(B*)(--(  (+ =!8"(-->R

)>*)(--,*>@8"(--,R

)IIA)(-->( ?3 (-->0&"4$5"H5"!1;G:"3"5"  L&$?G$56:"G"8" ?? ? 3""" "??"6""G3"5" / $"8 (- & (,IR & M&  4 G"? ""  8    =4 $V4*AB-4 &,*>0&  3& %@"  "3?"""=4:"" "8H!" ; 8"""?"2=";" "; "8GH "G:"   !"R"; "H";""4?" !"? !="""=&  "4 G !""  "; " H ="  ? ="63??  ="!";"8""="?"="?? 8"" /

)>*)(--, !"!0&   G5? 8!   "33  @"="  8""  8"  ="    3!!=" G  "   8"" =="" ="=6G!8="="!6="4="; : 8""!!"1?">*!?3(---& 8 ;" !1@"=""?36=:& ==4"";G"!!: ";! "'4  !"""G 8""4 "?  =" !"3?? 4"" :""=& 5?!!4 "3?"""=:?""'  1G?""3""!"L  8"" !"!&,& 

 ;"   8""  $     "4  "33  : ";!;    ="  8" J !??5  "" ?""" )*+'

)(,(()(--,   ="!G""5"G !"1 ""?"""6&1;:'"!"!??5! ""334;"8"68"$"  - @" *AAB4  ? L!  -@"*AABG6;8""?3$55!!!  ""?&4 8"""!$=?  "33@"="!&   G" !";?"G"": !?46 "G:?  8""4 8"" "/M% *AAB4? (&>,(>4"& &(>*0&   "H@! "& I& 

="4  "33 8" "!  8"" ==""  =" =6G!8="="!6="4"!4: ""46 "? ! "? !8?:G!"  =T"6E? &  

 8  ;" !14  8"" "!   $= G!" !?"!";6?";6"5"48""; 8!!??3?? & ! "  6!=""" 8""8"H=!&   "H!5??" "& C&     "? ?"&  "3 ?"""= 8  " 6 G D  ;G "="  8 !""  :"  ?  ?" "6!"" M"";  ?" !H "3!&

'*,)*+'

)(,(()(--, B&  G""?!L G"5"8 ML W "?5"8"3!4"" !"?"! ! FD(G+--&'6$5G 18&    !??  FD (G+--&'  ?" 6  $5  9?""" /"BC 0& $5? ";!;5";  ! $ 8"9 18;"=!8  "&!5?$!8 "" 9?" 8"@"""? "" 8":!"=9 8"@"""9 &="=?6 4;  "  95 6 9:!" L!?";  9   18  !?? !/

),(>)(--+*,@"(--+0&  XXXXX ( "# !  #       * +, - . !83"@!(I8?3(--, G?"""=" !""??""?"1G"? E (+3(--,R, - . G? "?R 8"  " 6 G?""" ="    8 !""  :"=?:"!R ";G" T FD(G+--&'G!??46$5R 6G""?!"?"! FD(G+--&'6"! 6$5G  18R ??";  ! H 6 9?""" =" 4 6 "#$  %& &4?"........../%"0%& &"";G6 ??""?"1G"? E& %"!52M& L$14 !"4 M? 8L  F"4 M& $!"4 M? 4 @5&

'*+)*+'

)(,(()(--,

? "3?"""=2 5=="1'@"2   &"'%"5"   !"2   D&L$1   "=?H!!??";!: "&

184       5=="12