opencaselaw.ch

ATA/474/2006

Genf · 2006-08-31 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

         

                         !" #$%&'( !"&%" &)%"#*"+&)#   &)%"# ",&-   &)%"#.#/01(  0 2  03032   4   52   35   03032  42 -  4   52   35  !"#$%     !" +#%) %&"" &)%"#633  !".&7)" &)%"# &%)*)8 !"9" &)%"#:)";+-0  ! "&!&' ()#$%   % 

  

*+,-+*.,,/ '.' 0 42     !"-%&" ")  "))%"#)"#&#%)" :"& -  ( %" "6-079 2 $" %0-.#"-,.% ;%" 1  1 !%"(%2&5 %" "6-09, 2 $" %0-0#"-,+% ;%" 1   %    %  ""    >" +-   %22  ?$#  @'"$ %  "%" >%  "A(%  $" 2" %5 ">"   " +-   %22  ?$#   @'"$ F" %(   "%$"' 2 1 !2)" "   !%"     !2 (?   !%" = ""% %%" "6-/9/F "( 2"%A) %   "  # ("#"-987#%"F "6.8-./'.8/I"' ?MC" J1 01 

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

 ""#-2.,,,#$"  5( 2" $">$% >" %  " "%"$" " L "F % "%(%" %>%2@  "%2 %(2 1 " "%(%(2 2"$">$% % 2 %2%2"1    2"  $" >$% L % "2  "%C%  "%%$'% C $ $"="(1 >"#-999 $">$% > $"#2"?%CFS  "" "$ C %" "%  % "I698-89*-J5 %% %2 "% $"="(#C@ "%%'%""F%  "%(("  %1 '" "$.9%T .,,-#" @$">$% %2@%2G%>%$" C "   L2 "% %N " # "$  " 1    %" "%% " 2%"%  "22" 2 2"L %>" #  $" ="( %2%   %2"  %'% @"   "" FC %$((1 -,1  8%T / 2 " A%  12" @'"#!2452#!!2&" (% @"2  C%%" "%%22+ 2 %2%%" "%1  1

>"#  :  2 %2   %% #  %N      " %  $" .,,0# L  %$ %N     6 .9-,+ '.8/# $%5 @ "%"2? $"" -9991    C("2 )2"" 2%">" "%C? "@" 2"?"C22  %  "%R-R=$$"="(#C(%  "  #  "  " " "% >> #  %$@ $" %    %"" # % 22    !=# %"  %   = ! # F A   2"     .0 N"  .,,01 % "2   $"  22 #2 "  >%"%  "%C%$ $  %N 1 -01 

 "%  2%">" "% %   %N #  % % C%%" "% %$ -/%T -/ 2 " "% C %  "%-,#,2-/#,2"2? C$% "%1#C2" %$@ %  "%%'%#FC"F">""  %  "%C"2% C "-%"%  "%  "  "%"$-+$"-977I '/,/J#>"("  %$   L C"   C"2  "% %" > 2%">" "%2" " C2" %$%  "%%@""F%" " F%"%" %"%22%%" "%1  >2"  S 'I"'?M%% J% (2 >%2%%" "%1   " "F" "2" D "FE%'"2? $ "  F"2 "  C$("@%U " "( 2"%%$5 $"="(1  ""#C">" "%C " F  > # !%"  >#">"%%  "%  "22 "#">""   "$%" "%%  C? LC"22 "" $%"% 22 F 2N%" %" "%>"  "

'7*.+'

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

'9*.+'

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

'-,*.+'

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

0  -1 1 %F">> >>"%  L"  "%" "F%L  N""F %22# A %"    A%>>"  N%"   2S2 %I 18,1- J1   @%%  " "("@I *+,-+*.,,/  *+,-:*.,,/J %   L   N""F %22# " %  N%"    2S2 %#%2% *+,-+*.,,/1    2"# " A5  "   F"  " ">"1 .1 1

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

*0/.*.,,/.+2".,,/J1 :1 1 =%  N" " "$ A$"  '"I

*0--*.,,:-0N".,,: S " J1  >  A %"   % I

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

'-7*.+'

*+,-+*.,,/ >"" "$L !=#%" %= ! #$ A%$"%$ %A%%" "%1  

 (# " > %%F )(2 >%2  " "F"'"1$2S2% "#  > " "%  #  $%" A %$ % A%%" "%1 >"# "   %   F  %"  AS     % (2   #"5 2">    )F % A%%" "%# !  A   %    2"2"$"= ! -/2 "2  "?7N".,,/1   C  % L N  "  F  %" C  #    %$%" C" "% F C " +, " 8 != " %>?#   "2 FC"  C"2%" %$" % % "%C% "%"  2"FA">>"" F !=%" %  %%%"  2%">" AFS  " 2   " "%%   %"FAS  " .-  2 % ""N     %>%2"    6 .9A-,+'.8/   "   %   @ % $( *%A2"% "%"@%U% "(2"% %$5 "="( --1  "  %%"#G%$%2 0# =   -#.# $%" # %   %22    "  " " "% ">>"   %%  ") .1,-  )2 "    "   %  %" "2     "  X''AX   "  " " "% 5" 2""% A=$" ,#/ -1

'-9*.+'

*+,-+*.,,/   %22$"'#A=A2 %#A?$L,#/: S %>L" "F %" 1   %   "2"  "%    " $    "   ( % 22 L$( "% % -.1  % >% ("> %"A  A$%"  H% " #  "2?  " "("@  >"  C% "   !=1 5)?2 A" ">""2 2"   %  "%#"%  F" %  "%F"5% "2 F  "?2 FF"     5)? " 1  2S2#  $( "% L $(   "2  ">"F%" %'"2? $  % "$  " 1A ".?(2 "L (F ?"  %" S $#5%2"F"%$( "%%# !=#F"  " $% %S #  5(#"" 2 "?#%$"%" ">-2.,,, % " T2 "%2   2%">"%F1

 ""#A"2  "% %2 @ " "% " "  A%"(   H%F " 1   !>%#(">% N 1   A%"2  -01  % "( " FA%2   %  "%R.R=" (2 2"" % "%  A" S   %  F   %$ I

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

 A "0". P#%"F " $%" 2  " "%L% @$%"@"  # ""F"(2 %(% " $%"#" "( $%"  " # %2%" $ "0, "$  %"I 101: PJ1  1 =%  %2 == 6 :+,'.,,   "%%   % #@2 $"# (+#+,2? %%"2 @$%" L$" ., &2*) +#7,2? %$" 0,&2*) %)"    @2"  F "%">>" " "%)2"$"""$ (SF %" %"% >" %2% "  %2% "2S  " -1/0,*.,,.0>$" .,,0J1  

A?#%2  %>"( "% "  "%)2" "#$" 2@"2 %""$" 2"> 2  0,&2*)1=%("2 +#-,L+#7,2?  "">>"  % $"  %  ( %  " "%    " %1  A"  F   2  A  >"  $ A $% >" % %  " "%# " F 1  

>"#  % 2   " 2 %% "%# (@% ">" "%%"$"  F)2" NL @"      ""# F % A("2   2""2   FA"  "  A  %F A  2 1   " "%2 "?$ "% " "" -:1  =%  % #  "   "22 >"  % 22  %  F" % A?  '%2" L A"22 " 2   ?  '%2" %>%2 L  " "$ 6 8  A" %   $"  >1 >"#$" %>#""  %2"#2"$">$% A" A 1   ("> "" % 2 >%2  N 1  2"@" %(2 %N  -81 

 " "#  %  ?$  F A%  $"    " "("@#  % " L %  2%(2 L ?%"A  " " FA%"%" "A"  A"  "%$$" "%%  "% $ A  2   2"         %# F "2 %>"" A@2"%>%2" " "("@ @ " "%  2 "? A2(2   " %"#  F "% A%% " ) %$%"A@2 " %#%% N 1   A"" "(#2%2  4;/A,,,1'2"L)( % #"%N%" 2  %""2 1"2"  4;.A,,,1'L  )(  % # " %N%" 2    %""2 #  % @ F"5% I 178 J1  \\\\\ 3 0      ;#=*>*"!"& ? %%  N% "%  % % *+,-+*.,,/   *+,-:*.,,/ %  6 *+,-+*.,,:O

'.+*.+'

*+,-+*.,,/ @*,#!"?  $  (# !%" (% !1 2&5#  %22   %%" "  A"22 %2 "%# L  %22""%  %  %2 "?%  "%""FA %"A  1 ="( M!2%$5#" #!15)?#!24"#!1)"#!2%# N(1

%2 " M (>>"?'N" N1M   !1 %%"  $"'" M   1%$5   %"%>%2 S  %22"F@ "1 ?$#   (>>"?M