opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/975/2006

Genf · 2006-11-07 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (5 Absätze)

E. 2 21#2662!*$$($)(#"*"("(D* ((.<:(")=0!:(" (==("""=0!:("$'$""E9( ":$#=0(:('"$'$"(=0. F. "#!*$$($'$$':(##():#$" =0$"(=((($E(0>'"9'D.  24 # 2662!   "  = "(  #  $)"  ((( "$=$$() :$#/'( '$"#(  )( 9(!  :( #=9("'(D*:(""E:$#9( )":($/($!"$'#(#@.  2 )  15 ) 2662! *$  )  $$"( % ?$(<#( 0'(?.*')("#>#<(:'#. G. *$$($'($"()(("21#18@(2662!'% 86H"(("(18'(#<2662.''#(()($ ':.

8. */"('0=$D"("(.

E. 7 G(2I'(#<2662! ( !#$"% ?$(<#( 0'(?! ( (($  $)( :)<!  '((  "$'J(#E9.=K)"="(("*$' =0<(('"(.#$"=(""(  = "( ( % *$' =0 (  D "*(0 '$#($ " = "('#'((D"L($''$.

4. (:(#$""1G(<2662! !0:"D "@(%?$(<#(0'(?!D)*$!(($0M"  " " *$' =0 %  #<( =K(  #)#(  0(."=0'$((9("$:("F6N!"#( " '( " 26N  D*"%#<(()!(= "(  "$:( " :9 " 16N("$:("*9("8N. =$(( "9!(##(":J'('("<((.

   

3114532667 /F312/ I. ''(#$"9"#K##$""2G@(1(<266F!(#  $)"  =K '(> % *$' =0 ' ((  ()($ $((>)#(()$"0=""$'." =0'$((:9#"18N!:9(''(!: #(((=$((#9.="(#(("::($% '()(   @#< "( )  :9 " "::.  '( =$ #( =(#' (( ":: $=#(.  '(( "$)((<@()"")"((": ( " =.  '( "$'"(!    ! " *#'(":(D#:(((#('"*(0) #'(("D")('$"#*$'("% =0("="(. #$"(#(D*(9( %*"(@("L"*$)(".

5. 12)#<266F!*$$($'$$'<("'D" =0"$'(#("0=(0'$"D"?$(<#(0'(?.

16. $'9D("*/"("2"$#<266F!  !0:"D"@(""$'(#('$($!9'D$D '(( ''((  #'(:( "##<'$ =0 ".*'$'"%D(")"##='#(( %*"($((%".

E. 11 $'"( %  #K# D(  27 :$) 2667! "( % D  ((#( #$"  ' :!     (#$ D  $D " *'$(#:(('(0#'(()"="(! ')(=K'(":939(!''("'("<( :"@$.(($=#("(%*9("" =0! D '$((   $= "$:( "*9( " # " 8H.   :#$''$('(("14#266G.

E. 12 */"(  "=($  9'( #$"   ! :$7@2668. D(":("(== "=0!*9'((($D$"()($($(:(!# )  ' ( *$ (  '( "( " <(.  :( *$(( '=)#("$":J(:(!)=( (((<((*0#$D*("(*0#$.*E)('" = "*0E''((. *9'(  "$$ D  $"( " (( :(! #'((!)($($'(>#(<.<(('"('(("$:( "*9(A16NC!D')(=#($=>#("$%)! D*'(("#(":#!#K#*$$(("(. #"#<($"":9/9($(("1G631636.*9'( $)$(((((%IH!D((#'(%:"*9(

   

3114532667 /G312/ $'$(" "!%'("$:("*9(!D"*$)( '$@(("*$)(''("*(0.   ) =0! *9'(  :#$  :( ##() " ( #E )  '(( 0)0#( " "9 :=#( ''9! #  "$'#(()#(##."''("='0" @( 2662. - *9'(!  :( *( "$ '  ((#( )(!)'((=($D)":(! ($)(#('((#(")"*"#/(#>(! D*)('!!"*::("*##<'$=0.

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

   

3114532667 /8312/

18. 2I@(2668!*$:(''(%(("$((("*'( *<""($(*"("21#2662(" = (! "*( '(!  (9 " *((( % *($=($ ( ' */ "(.  "#"( $=#(  #  O) "* 9'( (!  =" "  ")= "*' (    (   .

E. 17 "$''("25"$#<2668!*/"(:#$ "$!=("*'(D"*9'(*<" " ($ ( *"( (  $D " = *$(( ' ((< ( $'"(9$D(#(>(!"*('(!D(9"IH:9$' *(((%*($=($"=0*$(('(($!"D.

14.  ( "$'$  F ) 2667  < ( "  ! *$  (@($  ( (( "$  ''(! ( '$<#(%#O)"*9'('"$(#(9"*((( %*($=($'0ED=<(!''#(!(""$'!%*( ""$('(%"#("*/"('#( "*"#($'(((%*($=($"((9("$(#$'*9'(.  *'' "  !  (( D* E  ((( % *($=($   D )=0!D'"=0!(9("IH"( K( ) : " '"  "$( ((  ((( ( D  (((:((!:!D="('$((((%*($=($ )*"("2662.-"'(!D(9'( " ")= "*' (   !   (  (*9'(. 1I. $'"18#2667!*(#$(@("("$<(#( "'(").>)D'(D'(:*<@("( *9("*"(%*(((%*($=($'"##=="(.  ''!*==)("*(0="(("*"("2662*( ' $(<  "=$ ")#< '$'"$(  *9'(.  "$:( "*"::((!*E'"*$("()"*" )9'(. D*$(("*$'=0!@(: '"*(((%*($=($. 15. '>(#"$'(!$($="$%@=.  !)

1. =)P=(@"AC$($#":$((($!"> 1Q(266F! <("!#'$"8@=! "('$"(()/'$"(!8''$((17@=A(.1 (.(87 C.

   

3114532667 /7312/ -(%P("P$("17@=!' <:$"$ 24@)266GA &1F6167C!" =)"'($!1F:$)! "'(((=('#((( <("  " $=   % ( @= ((! ! " P((( " P$(")9@=.

2. :#$#( % *(. 87  . 1 (.  0. 8 !  < ( " +((D"((('$)%P(.87 "'(=$$""(""7(<2666 A C D ( () %   :$"$  P/"( " 26# 15I1A

C. -#'$('@=""P'>($(<. F. "$=("*(.76 !"$"("(#%#'(" "$''('(("'(("*/"(A(.167 

C.(@($F)2667("$''("25"$#< 2668JF@)2667!":#D'*(.87 !'$( ()<. G. -  ' " "( #($! *(. I2   '$)( D  "'( "   ('''<9'(((9$:9$)(  ($ )= A(. I2 . 1  C.  (!   @'"! *''D''D>=''<()= ##(R:(@"D#("$(#(('"(A &1F62F6 ".1.1SFF8".1.2S &125G".1.2S &124G74".1! 1271F7".G<($:$C.    ( ''<   "*'>! "  # R  "$  ''( (= "( " 25 "$#< 2668 (   :9( " *"#($'>(<("*$(("($266G.

8. (='(:9("*"#($'(((%*($=($. (#( %D((*(#$!((($#(*$)(" *"#($'*((("!#*<"" (((%)=0(="(. *"#($$D(<'(((%*($=($("!''("*(.2G. 1 

! ! ' ( " P"(! P$ :: "P ((( #'(( ( "<%($=($'0ED#(.P"#($(:9$!P$ '('$("%(!D((#(#$"((#$A.2C. ((( % P($=($ ( $'($ "< DP ( '$)< DP <( )  #  #K# =)($'"(((). ($'($#'(( D P($=($ '0ED! #(  'E0D <(! "$'"##( "  "#("'($"=!($($)"(=)A(.F7.1"

   

3114532667 /4312/ *"  P/"( " 26 "$#< 15I2 A

CC. P"#($($"():=(%P9FA.2C. (((D('$D:=('"(!E "*''D<>#'=!((#'("=)($"*(((A0. 1 . 2 " *9 F % *

C.  (( :!  ") #$" "    A(#(- C$(<"(<#'$#(#'((") "()"($%((D:'(*$=($"((#(( $. (<$#("*"#((((('" "((('@=!#($##'(<)*9F% *

A &12GF2".1!211".G3!117184".FC. *(.F7.G

'$)(D*$D(<#((#'("==)( '$)< " P((( % P($=($ "  :9( " *"#($.  @'"((!((>=)((:D==)("( )()#<<(*#'(D(:<A

155IF26 '. 762 ". F< (  $:$C.  $) P( '< DP  9'(!P==)((#'(((P$((''$)<.

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

   

3114532667 /I312/ "''$("'J'$)(%*$=""*$. *( D*'$"('(>D"(@("*#'(($ "*''$(')(K("$$##<@()#(:"$.

4. "*'>!((($(("*9'(((D  *$)( " *((( % *($=($  ) " *$' ( " " =0D*)"="(. I. -*=(")=0!((#")K("#$ ( (@ " (#( ( " " %  ).   '$)( " ''(" D"DD*#'(("?( #:(?.

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

"(<"- .(#$'"( D8H(('#'("*$)('$@((16H'"(' %*9($'$(<(%). (<1A$)2666C"- $)(((%*($=($$((" (< :( " "!   " #<($ ( 635631F8N  (

   

3114532667 /5312/ 635631F8N % 16H.  (< 8 $)  ((( % *($=($ " " $(( "*(0#E""(8(16H.

*'>!#":9/9(''*9'(("1G631636.  "$:( "*9(   $($ #$ % 16N!  D *( ' (($ '  (.  *=( " "* (> :< "$:(! D '(!  *9'(! $)(#( =#( $=>#( "  $ %).  *(0! ''(#$"#($)"'$)$$)"". (%''(:(!((*9'(D (#( ''(:('<$)(. =""9="@'" )*(.F7.G

!)(::('')"#(( ))#<<"*(0##==)("("*"( ( D(:  #'(.   ( " #K# '  ==)( $=> $)(""$:("*9(.(!(9"IH(' *9'( (( =#( #'( " :< "$:( " :9 #$ 0M  (!="""$:(<'#'(("(%(9"16H :9$(<1- . "$((D$*('(D<'(.

16. (%$)$D"*"("2662*$(("="(! $D9((*(#$.  "( % " '(( "$( "* "( $ ''  ::(! ( *$)$#("##=<"(>"((*(((%($!" ($(.::(D*$)$#("##=<!$$)(#( % "*( :(! ( ')D$ *((( %  ($ '0ED  'E0D " *$.*=("*D(":(!D*"#((!$0$(! @=9#:"((#("=#("*"#$" A &1251I1".F.1!G67".G.F.1!115FF4".1!11I2I5 ".1<($:$C. ("($"$D(!D(""( D*''((%*"#((@="(0!("$!"*'> ""0(*9'$")!:("$$$((''% (+::("="D*('"(!)"$(( '(":J=$$:)$'((A &1251I1 ".F.2!G68".2.2!128G71".8($:$C. $D"*"("2662($($:(""E9(" = "( (  :( " *($'0E( ($ "  ( "(.  = #(:(#'>(!#=K'(:9/9((" ".  ) #$"9! ''#( 9 "   ( " *9'(!((D((=K("('*(09(( %).*9'(!D !("*)D*(0*( "$)''$ ( % *"( " 1544.  #$" ( '"(  '

   

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

!@($.

   

3114532667 /11312/

 + 0!)/ )  +)!   + !+

 12 3 -- 4  5        6 7 #(& !8   3 -

1. $)<.  3 

2. @((. F. (D'$"(=((. G. :#  '( "  DP ')( :#  (  '$( K( "  "$ " F6 @ ">  (:( ' ' ##"$ "$  < :$"$ " ! -0TM0:D 7! 766G   !  ( 9#'.  "$  '( K( '=$.  #$# "(B C "D 9(#(D"$("$<(('""$ ((D$S <C 9' ' D #(:  (# ') "#" (( ( "$S C '(  =(   "  '$((. -  #$#  (( '  ( $$#( $#$$  (( C <C ( C /"!  <:$"$"''(#(>DP ")"$)<.#$#"#(#E " ')! D ( @(!  D  "$ ((D$ ( P)'' " D$($9'$"$(A(.1F2!167(16IC.  =::>   /  U  $"(B   V      $(/@(B    -"     ':#"'$(K(((:$9'(DP%P:::$"$ "($'<D'=::

   

3114532667 /12312/ 

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

 

         ! 

      

         "##$%"&''()"%$*"&''())  +)!   + !+ +,-  #  $  .-  &''(  

     !"#$!%"!&  ! #'()$(""#*$(""+($"   (    (   , -   --  --. .!("/

"(!0#" 12! -   (#$

   

3114532667 /2312/  /)

1.   ! $  1581! 9  ': "  '; (($%(("( "?-?

.  '(:  "* "(  $($ '! ">  1 @)2668!', A/'>B*/"(C.

2. 21#2662!*$$($)(#"*"("(D* ((. '"9'D.  24 # 2662!   "  = "(  #  $)"  ((( "$=$$() :$#/'( '$"#(  )( 9(!  :( #=9("'(D*:(""E:$#9( )":($/($!"$'#(#@.  2 )  15 ) 2662! *$  )  $$"( % ?$( #  % *$' =0 ' ((  ()($ $((>)#(()$"0=""$'." =0'$((:9#"18N!:9(''(!: #(((=$((#9.="(#(("::($% '()(   @# #( #("$%)! D*'(("#(":#!#K#*$$(("(. #"# (! D*)('!!"*::("*## $)("' *"("2662.')(K('::#(:"'") "::$((2662(2668."$$D*:("( "( (!"*('(!D(9"IH:9$' *(((%*($=($"=0*$(('(($!"D.

14.  ( "$'$  F ) 2667 )D'(D'(:* (#"$'(!$($="$%@=.  !)

1. =)P=(@"AC$($#":$((($!"> 1Q(266F!  ($( ='' ! "  # R  "$  ''( (= "( " 25 "$# ( #'=!((#'("=)($"*(((A0. 1 . 2 " *9 F % *

C.  (( :!  ") #$" "    A(#(- C$( =)((:D==)("( )()# =:#!#"(9#" #> C!D "'("(:$#$"((:D" *9'( ( "*''$((E'"*9'( "''(#$"9.A &128F82".FC. @='("')' D"(@("*#'(($ "*''$(')(K("$$## !((($(("*9'(((D  *$)( " *((( % *($=($  ) " *$' ( " " =0D*)"="(. I. -*=(")=0!((#")K("#$ ( (@ " (#( ( " " %  ).   '$)( " ''(" D"DD*#'(("?( #:(?.

- (($!@D*()#(()$"0=" " $'!   * ' #($ '  ( ( (##( '  (( " "##= '#( "  ''( " 27 :$) 2667. ( % *9'(!   (($@2668D))(()$:((('D #)#(""9$'$((E#$(D.(#$)" '((=()":(($)('((#(" )"*""*"#/(#>(!#"$$D*)(' "*::("## (!$'" ( '( 9 9= "  @'"   #(> (  ' : '  "#('(((%*($=($. 5. D(9('*(((%*($=($)""! ((((9"IH('-  # :("*9F

"( !#":9/9(''*9'(("1G631636.  "$:( "*9(   $($ #$ % 16N!  D *( ' (($ '  (.  *=( " "* (> : #( "  $ %).  *(0! ''(#$"#($)"'$)$$)"". (%''(:(!((*9'(D (#( ''(:('  $)(""$:("*9(.(!(9"IH(' *9'( (( =#( #'( " : "((*(((%($!" ($(.::(D*$)$#("##=  ""0(*9'$")!:("$$$((''% (+::("="D*('"(!)"$(( '(":J=$$:)$'((A &1251I1 ".F.2!G68".2.2!128G71".8($:$C. $D"*"("2662($($:(""E9(" = "( (  :( " *($'0E( ($ "  ( "(.  = #(:(#'>(!#=K'(:9/9((" ".  ) #$"9! ''#( 9 "   ( " *9'(!((D((=K("('*(09(( %).*9'(!D !("*)D*(0*( "$)''$ ( % *"( " 1544.  #$" ( '"(  '

   

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

   

3114532667 /12312/