opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/973/2007

Genf · 2007-09-11 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)



      !   "  ! # $% % 

     

       &'()*&'**+ ,&-./&'**. ,,0 ,     0 12"  (% ((32"  '**.           !"#$% &'( )!(  *!(+(','  

- . ''(    ('    //   * --     ' 012  (!

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

    3#"%$3#$$4 5H3"65 '!')9B'('!) C'8 /""21F 74E""#F4$  76K  "11H,F2&7F"4 7FE;7 R&9= (!(' ('((?(&(!' '?R('!) C' 7!@'&(!' ((' 9'*&& @  &'!(  (C !(( &'! ! @   = ( !C (     (((  '9C C!!' )'  =' !       B' &''() C(*(&' ( (I('('>!&'(= (( @* &'!( ((!    ('(( '( '!C( ? *!&@   !    (C  8 /"F$ F%"  7F7%7# "#%F41 7#('!=!'K) '!C( /""#F2# 7#E( F1$ 7"E;7

( >C( &'((   '( &'&' ? ='  C'! * )  (!(' (?'(&(()''!)  *'("2  7'(&(I(''!) !( = ( E *!(((!  '@ 5 ('(! I @ !@ '  & (!  C  ( E   >C( &'((

    3#"%$3#$$4 513"65 8 /"F$F61 7F7%""F#2% 7"K) '!C( /""#F2#  7#E(F1$ 7"E;7 '@*'!)  (!&!5  (!(E '=T& E @* )  (!* &(*'!*( = ! 9'? =' ' (8=7'(7H27F ;7 *0((= &(9'?'!)  '@ '(('! >C!(@(=&&'   ('('!   @()&&'! (8 / &E !"#(E' #$$%H3$6 7#K /""#F2# 7#E(F1$ 7"E;7(= '!)  *'(7"2  (   '(''(' '8 /  &E !  "# (E' #$$%  H3$6  7 #K    ('  '(PC'(')   ') )' >'C(>9/' E'C #$$#&&7"FF;7'!C((''!)  '(' (==( (('=(B'  @?'! @8  )!=(('(';' (' @ '('(!' !''&(? *(!C'   @ 5"$7')>&'&!* )(C' *  !&>!  @''7*) *  E('('C @>'  (( &(>  5!&  'C &  % LC (  )( 5  *>' P( )  E'

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

    3#"%$3#$$4 5"63"65

  5,04 ,0 ,     0

%   6 2

"7 !'''')E7 % 6 

#7 *((') ?* &' ('(&!( '  !'(7 F7  R (! ?)'' ?  ''(    H$$ ='7 ? (('  &'( &(?=' (!&7 67 *!(= 'C* (!7 %7 ='  &'(   @R &)( ='' '' ('  &'!( ''I(   !   F$ B' 9  (= ( &'9  ' E =!!' 8->V P'>=@ 44$$6  ;&') ''(9'' ( &E ='!(<'(7H# =!!'' ' E=!!'"2 B  #$$% 8 /;K  ! '  ''  (  @'    (= ( 0&')(&'(' C('''(( 'K  ( I(' '!  ' E =!!' &')  &(  &')  !(' @ <  (  *'(7 6#  /7  &'!( ''I( (  & 9  &   ''( )@!0&'))(I('B (?*) 7  C'== 9'   ' 5  W  '! (   ' X  & ='&'!(''I(((= !<&'(  @R?R== =!!' ' &'C'==