opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/91/2007

Genf · 2007-02-05 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (2 Absätze)

E. 015 '!''"'1-!:C'1223  ""7!'#B'#@!("("! #("(#7!("!'(;'#:!H;'!7"!5 0/5  1G #C' 1223  B'#  7"( "( 8    :'(  1237'512 #'"(8 "@B:"('("(D;H'('!;!("("!

);!'#066A(0666("(#"'"(8F(5

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

  @" !';;'(""='(  !("7"("! B #""! ! B !"("!  B""('("! '#;' !''"' !'""'   !"(  !"+(' #(C" 9'#:'"C;'#;!#'('@"("=' B' !" < L 01- -21!"51C 0103!"5/C?5 B(!'"(# ;;!'( !  !#@  BC ;': <!  :'"C;'#;!#'(?@"!("7"("!!(!(!((#(@B" E"(77(":(!(8F("H"7!''#'("! ("("'B:!"5 35 ? B;= "'!'(;"=!"'@,"1223 "#(C" #!;(!("("!"(;;'M('!!("("!;' '!'(12208122-""@ ;!'*@# "(#'+(!'(!"'( 7'"!("!  7'"(E("!(;!'"(;!'(!( 123 7'5 125  " B;;;'!:' ' (  !("7"("!5 ;(  '!'(BF";'#(:!"''J('":("(#!;( !'( @!F'";';'#"(# "H"!'@'!("7"("!

   

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

).A21.1223?5  '!'(   ! '"' !''"'  C B"' :!"' '!# 8  !((("!;"(!((1237'512;"@B;'!"('##;"# ((((:'(!((06F:"'122G8"5 ?)B9"(7"'@+('!'(!'(B#(('# "8!!(' !'(';'#("("95 G5 :@";'#= '!'''F(#5

   

.-/,0.1223 43.34

,  2

- ,- -  , -

! 34505 // 6  755  5   8 9 &)' - :   05 /

05 #''!'':C5 ! 05

E. 15 'F((5 /5 7!' ;'("   @K;:( 7!'' '!' !(' ;'#( ''+(   #"  /2 F!' =  !("7"("! ;'=  '"C 7##' <)*N"O'*!7@"3 322-  ? ;':!"'!'("=''!"(;C" !7!'#(E'(5A1!"7##'' '"C7##'0G F" 122, < L?P  #!"'  '!' !"( ""@'  !"!  !("7 ( !H;':(;!'('"9(''!'(!!("'P"!"( +(' '#  '"C 7##';' :!";!( !;' :!" #('!"@ E !"("!  B'(5 -1  L5 ;'#( ''+( ( ;"= ;!"!  '!'(":!@#!!H;': !":(+('F!"(8B:!"5  9'77"='  H)  ;'#"(  #'"  !;"!7!';'#(''+((!("7"#E;'("""@K8K77"7##' '!";'9'77

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

               !

      

         "#$%&"'(() "*&"'((+ ,,  ,- -  , - ./ ) ! % 01  '((+ 

  !"""#  $% & '!'( !('

))       )    )   "'("! '!( *+,-     "("#

   

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

;'#""(#!"'7!@;'!(":"(#'(":#("( ( ;H'  "(#'+( !'(!"' !'@B :"( :'#  !;( "7#'"' B !" 1,I E !("("! 77(":(  (  "#;((!(7(5 025  0/ !:C' 1223  B'#  #'"( 8  " @B :"( 7" '#"#  F"( 1223  ;'= :!"' "(# :  "  @    !("("!  '#7#'"(E'( )4 ;'!F(#''#125 !#@ 

   

.-/,0.1223 4/.34 :"(!#8 "06F"(1223@B:"('#9#!(('("7 E#""!8BE;("!"(#'+(!'(!"'5

  ('"  !;"   !''"'  '"C (!  ' !" @B'9"('#!'!'5 005 1/!:C'1223  "('"8B'#!:#!;(;!' #12228122, @"'!'(@:'(B'##(#77(# ;'"!'"(#E!("("!;'!12228122/ ("='('#9#(( 7J!(@!1237'512#("(D;!'!("("!;'!122-  122,#((#9('#9#5 015 '!''"'1-!:C'1223  ""7!'#B'#@!("("! #("(#7!("!'(;'#:!H;'!7"!5 0/5  1G #C' 1223  B'#  7"( "( 8    :'(  1237'512 #'"(8 "@B:"('("(D;H'('!;!("("!

);!'#066A(0666("(#"'"(8F(5

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

  @" !';;'(""='(  !("7"("! B #""! ! B !"("!  B""('("! '#;' !''"' !'""'   !"(  !"+(' #(C" 9'#:'"C;'#;!#'('@"("=' B' !" < L 01- -21!"51C 0103!"5/C?5 B(!'"(# ;;!'( !  !#@  BC ;': <!  :'"C;'#;!#'(?@"!("7"("!!(!(!((#(@B" E"(77(":(!(8F("H"7!''#'("! ("("'B:!"5 35 ? B;= "'!'(;"=!"'@,"1223 "#(C" #!;(!("("!"(;;'M('!!("("!;' '!'(12208122-""@ ;!'*@# "(#'+(!'(!"'( 7'"!("!  7'"(E("!(;!'"(;!'(!( 123 7'5 125  " B;;;'!:' ' (  !("7"("!5 ;(  '!'(BF";'#(:!"''J('":("(#!;( !'( @!F'";';'#"(# "H"!'@'!("7"("!

   

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

).A21.1223?5  '!'(   ! '"' !''"'  C B"' :!"' '!# 8  !((("!;"(!((1237'512;"@B;'!"('##;"# ((((:'(!((06F:"'122G8"5 ?)B9"(7"'@+('!'(!'(B#(('# "8!!(' !'(';'#("("95 G5 :@";'#= '!'''F(#5

   

.-/,0.1223 43.34

,  2

- ,- -  , -

! 34505 // 6  755  5   8 9 &)' - :   05 /

05 #''!'':C5 ! 05

15 'F((5 /5 7!' ;'("   @K;:( 7!'' '!' !(' ;'#( ''+(   #"  /2 F!' =  !("7"("! ;'=  '"C 7##' <)*N"O'*!7@"3 322-  ? ;':!"'!'("=''!"(;C" !7!'#(E'(5A1!"7##'' '"C7##'0G F" 122, < L?P  #!"'  '!' !"( ""@'  !"!  !("7 ( !H;':(;!'('"9(''!'(!!("'P"!"( +(' '#  '"C 7##';' :!";!( !;' :!" #('!"@ E !"("!  B'(5 -1  L5 ;'#( ''+( ( ;"= ;!"!  '!'(":!@#!!H;': !":(+('F!"(8B:!"5  9'77"='  H)  ;'#"(  #'"  !;"!7!';'#(''+((!("7"#E;'("""@K8K77"7##' '!";'9'77