opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/916/2005

Genf · 2005-10-20 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (2 Absätze)

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

   

40.,,41..5 6-476 J(*#*"#*#3#*#J")*3!"!#";#* (';##C("#";;#==('!"8  "!### *?!# ()##  (!8   (!) ( ## ( !#*##!;;!*)#3#*&)##C ?** ( ##& 3# *#* ##!# #""*8   * 3 !"!# ==*C##")=#!#9#""(*3 ")3#;#;8;J")*)'*##!"9 (!##;C###3*#*&(!P*##?#"2 ( '*#9!# 98  "#) ;# (*#!# *## ( 3 ' #=#?#!*(&)'*##"8 C)"*##( '#!**")*)###3#*&!G!*!**&(3#G#*8

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

   

40.,,41..5 6D476 (# "!### (  (  ! ( '9?# ( !9  !##(F!#L8 -8 J#!(#8:-80#1 &##('J?('* ###((!#*J)'3#"(#C!)''#*#*( 9;#) ###'#R(?;2"#28 '?# C (' 9?# *? C )  # !"9 ( (*? ;  J"*!#"*3"@#8:-81 Q#81-80 A8 9;(#;'9>#('J!!#J(=)"#8

 (# #!!# G# * )  3!# ( (  "##  " ?!"#!###*???3("#C ###8 #)(;##*#*#((#J# (*##!#C#('*???383(!G! )' 9?# ('3 ' " *#* !"  #!" #& ##!#  C  # (' *?? ?38  B  ;# ?3 =);)  *#* ('  =?!# 3 # *3(# @ 0:7D"8DD7A8B*???3)'#**;!"C ) "# G# 9!# J?* ( " "9 ( (!#&  #3#(##(#)#(!G!#8

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

   

40.,,41..5 6/476 D8 '"2#"##(9;!#;&""!#&)'' "!!#(!*;#)'3#3*(3*#*)' 3#;(*823C#*?()')#"#*##"*( ;!('"#C';;#('!"8!P' "L?#!*(&;#)"#(*#!#&3B#" );#)'##!!(#(*#*#3( 3##(2;#9#3!#('(!#*(=E!?8 #9(*"#?'")"#;;#3!# "=&3#&('3*#*(!3;8 ;;#&C'*")&)#'*##""*J*(3'3#(3 *#*#)EJ#!#!"#"2(##(28 # (2  "=  # ( '3 " ""*)' '?# C (')# (*#!#8 )'  #&   #  C  *???3(!P=G#!#*"(C##)#)  # *#* "*8  (# (  9; (# ( G# (** !!!"8

&#(!8#3B*C'##*#!*;) ##(2J!((#8  

   

40.,,41..5 67476 +  0  +, ,,  +,  

  1/ 

08 *398  1/

E. 18 '(!#8,8 (*(:(*!91..,#(,.!1..58 58 3C$ KC=?"##(2(3*;( (#(!#**#((3(*8 -8 (! '#!* C 3  #  !! ( +80'1..&66 C ## ( (*"Q D8 ;!  "# ( )' "3#;!  #  "*# G# (  (* (,. > (2  #;# " " !!(* (*  9;*(* ( & $=ST=;) D& D..5   &  # J!"8  (*  "# G# "?*8  !*! (#U A () J#!#)(*#(*9##"((* ##)*Q 9A J" ") !#;  #! "3 (!( ## # (*Q A "#  ?#   (  "*##8 $  !*!  ## "  # **!# *!**  ## A 9A # A 6(&  9;*(*(""#!#2)' (3(*398!*!(!#!B ( "3&) # >#& )  (* ##)* # '3"" ( )*#*J"*(*#@#80,1&0.D#0.7A8  ?;;2U  ++     *(#U  V$ V    ";!("*#G###;*J"#)'C';;;*(* (#$*##(' ##C'*!"?;; 

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

 

      

         !

      

         "#$%%"&$$' "(#)"&$$* ++ +, ,,  +,   -.  %  &$ /-/ &$$* 

    ! !"# "    $%&  ' #(()*#(! #  # ++     '  "*!#& "#,-./&010023, #!* 

   

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

   

40.,,41..5 6,476 :8 (*(030::7&$ K*C'*(#J"##( =E!? (# ## "*(8 ## (*  *#* ;!* "  " *!#8 0.8  (* ( 0: > 0::7&    "  (!(* C '*  !9!#((!#*(F!#"L(#"*((**&# +8::M.1:868 ##(*##;*#*"(('###('#*;((030::78 008  (* ( - F# 0:::&  !! # (   !#2 ( =E!? N  !"*## 6  ;!*) '* '3# " (# J (!#* ( =E!? (#  "*( (**8 ## (* ' ";# '9>#('#"##&#(3(*;#38 018 (,.>1..,&'*#*!(!##)*## *!*8  & C)  3# (*  (!(& ' #! C  $ K !!9>#(!"*#8 0,8 (*(:(*!91..,&$ K;*!!#;)'* 3#!!*???3##(;#!;#!#!"###)(#(9;'*##"**8 058 '#!*((&'*;!*""####(*  1D >3 1..58   *?*) ("  (*9# ( * 0::.& % $ 3#(*(;;#**!)#)(*"E# (9'3#"G#"3!#*3#*)?OC!(# ((###C(3!(;(38J")*)("*# (*#*&#2'*##(*3""*"!##! #)''*##;#"#('=&!?*(;;#*&C"(*3 ")3#;#;#C*3#?#!")"9;# ; ( "3 =  ## ( !#  8 #  #!# 0::5&  3# *#* (*(*& 3  ## (*# (  *#*& ( ""!  "# ( (#&  *#* '*## "  ! ('  8'*#!3!!)*##;!##( "#C' ###'3>!('###)('!"B* *(#8##*?!#3(!*;#)'*### !>#(*#*#23C#*?()(!#)#*#*! ;#  "# !# (' !"#9#* #  ### ('# !"B*('*#*B!#(#J(!#*&") 3#*#*"(*(!"(#"!###('9#((!#*8 =)''#"(**#;#)'#*C(( J(*#*"3*;)##(!#*####9)!=*8 ;?*)')#*('#&'3#" #=* ( (3(( (#  "*( P  *## #  =E!?8  '3#

   

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

   

40.,,41..5 6-476 J(*#*"#*#3#*#J")*3!"!#";#* (';##C("#";;#==('!"8  "!### *?!# ()##  (!8   (!) ( ## ( !#*##!;;!*)#3#*&)##C ?** ( ##& 3# *#* ##!# #""*8   * 3 !"!# ==*C##")=#!#9#""(*3 ")3#;#;8;J")*)'*##!"9 (!##;C###3*#*&(!P*##?#"2 ( '*#9!# 98  "#) ;# (*#!# *## ( 3 ' #=#?#!*(&)'*##"8 C)"*##( '#!**")*)###3#*&!G!*!**&(3#G#*8

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

   

40.,,41..5 6D476 (# "!### (  (  ! ( '9?# ( !9  !##(F!#L8 -8 J#!(#8:-80#1 &##('J?('* ###((!#*J)'3#"(#C!)''#*#*( 9;#) ###'#R(?;2"#28 '?# C (' 9?# *? C )  # !"9 ( (*? ;  J"*!#"*3"@#8:-81 Q#81-80 A8 9;(#;'9>#('J!!#J(=)"#8

 (# #!!# G# * )  3!# ( (  "##  " ?!"#!###*???3("#C ###8 #)(;##*#*#((#J# (*##!#C#('*???383(!G! )' 9?# ('3 ' " *#* !"  #!" #& ##!#  C  # (' *?? ?38  B  ;# ?3 =);)  *#* ('  =?!# 3 # *3(# @ 0:7D"8DD7A8B*???3)'#**;!"C ) "# G# 9!# J?* ( " "9 ( (!#&  #3#(##(#)#(!G!#8

#*?(&>"((*3""*C""('#85/80 $3#" ?  !#2 (' =E!? @ + 01D  -.A8 '# ) '?& "  9**;& (;#)' '3# " (# J "## 3*;;#""(!##)'*##(9;8;#9"#E#)' #("9!#('##!! ('*???38'#)9;##)(#( ! # J ('!9* ) ;#) (# C '9?# ( ## @3# ( (3 ('  ( ?A # !"#9 C  !"#!# (;  C  *?? ?38  3=& '#** "# 3)  9; ) '#  '!;#;  ###)' 3#*?2('9?#('(?@ 1..0"80D.Q  0::7"8/.Q +(1,>31..1 800.4.0A8 '#*?!#("")'#*!#C'#*3?(  & +  >?*N(('*);#?;J?( '6=E!?('3!(';!);#(?#J# 3!#('(!#*(=E!?N)?('6=E!? #"#(?"#*!#'*3*#*)#*" 6  ('## '###)('"*>(8  #(!G! #  ) ( "( ( "## ('  @ + ( 05 !1..,& 01.4.1A8

   

40.,,41..5 6/476 D8 '"2#"##(9;!#;&""!#&)'' "!!#(!*;#)'3#3*(3*#*)' 3#;(*823C#*?()')#"#*##"*( ;!('"#C';;#('!"8!P' "L?#!*(&;#)"#(*#!#&3B#" );#)'##!!(#(*#*#3( 3##(2;#9#3!#('(!#*(=E!?8 #9(*"#?'")"#;;#3!# "=&3#&('3*#*(!3;8 ;;#&C'*")&)#'*##""*J*(3'3#(3 *#*#)EJ#!#!"#"2(##(28 # (2  "=  # ( '3 " ""*)' '?# C (')# (*#!#8 )'  #&   #  C  *???3(!P=G#!#*"(C##)#)  # *#* "*8  (# (  9; (# ( G# (** !!!"8

&#(!8#3B*C'##*#!*;) ##(2J!((#8  

   

40.,,41..5 67476 +  0  +, ,,  +,  

  1/ 

08 *398  1/

18 '(!#8,8 (*(:(*!91..,#(,.!1..58 58 3C$ KC=?"##(2(3*;( (#(!#**#((3(*8 -8 (! '#!* C 3  #  !! ( +80'1..&66 C ## ( (*"Q D8 ;!  "# ( )' "3#;!  #  "*# G# (  (* (,. > (2  #;# " " !!(* (*  9;*(* ( & $=ST=;) D& D..5   &  # J!"8  (*  "# G# "?*8  !*! (#U A () J#!#)(*#(*9##"((* ##)*Q 9A J" ") !#;  #! "3 (!( ## # (*Q A "#  ?#   (  "*##8 $  !*!  ## "  # **!# *!**  ## A 9A # A 6(&  9;*(*(""#!#2)' (3(*398!*!(!#!B ( "3&) # >#& )  (* ##)* # '3"" ( )*#*J"*(*#@#80,1&0.D#0.7A8  ?;;2U  ++     *(#U  V$ V    ";!("*#G###;*J"#)'C';;;*(* (#$*##(' ##C'*!"?;;