opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/912/2005

Genf · 2005-10-11 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (3 Absätze)

E. 5 +10? 566@! 1)" D E =>C("  01+0"  & +: :D +/  "   :11+" 0>" "= 0?1  ""9  

* :  D 

*)F :D> " 0 0C1 + @66 B9 : 1 G9 @9  +1  ::" + H B1* 5667!  %0+  /:D1 D   + ?"1/ )1 "  $ "  :' + > :1!  0?0" + :"" BB"1 +  "" 00? >::1  B" + " "( I  1"1 01+!  +1 + 1= "  "': + :"" " " / D  ?" + 1= " >" + :""9

79 >"11  "="1  ,H B1* :( + ? + 19

49   :1* + 5, 0 5667!  %0+!  1B1" /:10" .    6@2- :?1 : >BB B1+1 +  "1 :?D  5@ 0 566@ "  +:"" "CD + >+   ? " + : " + >+

 +  +0 + > 0+ * BB" , =* 566@! ::  =" + 9

H9 *"1 .  +1"0! >"11 +( D E    6@2- >  . B +  010 + #$   01+0" C"1  & " +1?"1  '  +A 9 ""  >1"" : +"1 / 1 0 /  +>9 %  1"1 +1:1 D0" : "0:  ?9  +0+ D  B0 " "1 + 0109 >/" + B0

,,, "

,,5 >/" +  + +" +> D => J + #$  D  +1:1 +  010 + #$9  B0  :" : + 01+0" C"1 . >1")9  0D + "1 +  +" +>! => 1"1 +"   K = > : " 0  :( + #$  = > : :  BC +,L766 B9 +

2-3425667 % -28 % 00" D  01+0" C"1  $ +1:" ) 11  :"" :  +,L766 B9   0+ :11+" 0>" "= 0?1  01+0" C"1  & G9 89   +:D + 55 = 5667!  %0+ :" +  9

39    1"1 "0 : B0" . >"11 "    1"1)+1 . =)9

 ,+,9  )*  >)" =+;<  1"1 0+B1 "  ""1! +( , M" 566-!  ? " +  ! 0:1 +

E. 7 ::1" ",4 =) ;"9, "9

" 74

<9

$" . >" + >1" +,4 =) ! :  ? B1+1  5H =* 566@; &,-6 ,64<!  + )*  +:"1! ,- B1*!  +:" "" )" :0"""  ? " +   + 1)   . " =) ""! ! + >""" + >1" + */ =) 9 59 B010" . L"9 74  9, "9  C9 @ !  ? " +   N"  " D + """ :1* . >" 74  D " "* .   B1+1  >%0+ +,8 0,33@; <9 $ 0:1" : =) +  +>:( "  1"?9 -9  "! "="1 +  B0 " +1 1)/!   " *? B010" . >"9,   " -4 +   +>::" +   B1+1  >%0+ + 53 0,33H  D>/ "9 74! 73 " 46  9 @9  ") :"   D" + *   %0+ "   " + 0?  01+0" :" :  01+  0 C"1  &

*9 79   0 O >1"" + B" D +" F" ::11 =+D0" >" "(0" 11 :( , = 5665! +" + >"1 

*) + >+ + 5, =,333 "  B1+1"  +> :" "  00"1 :1 "  "" 00? +>" :"   ? " + :;  <!  ") +" F" /01  >) + >::" + ""

2-3425667 % @28 % 1)" " + 0+B" +    " + >  D>  "N1; &,5H  @4H<9   * + 0F0 +   B1+1   :")11 +   P  + 4 "? 5666 "1 

*) , =* 566-9

  + >BB B1+1 +  "1 :?D % &$ :"   0+B" '" : ?=" >"+" +  " :1 +> 0+! >)0" + +"   + 1= C + > "" 0:1"" "  0:B" + B0

E. 9 :" +, = 566@! ""  : 1 " +"!   + 0+  + 0""1 +"  1=   "" +> " "" + 

2

  +  $!  :1"" +  " :1 +> 0+! + "B" :* + 0:0"  + B0

,,,! . ""  :""  " D >*(" 1 + :" + * 01+! 0:" " +  " + :"" " +  +1 :1* + 1=9   B" : + +"" "  001+"0" 1 "  19

 >1"+ + +" / :""   + 1= "0: . >1")!  B" D >'" +" " ""! ?11B + "! : +1"C1! CQ0  1"+" > : +>+9  D  M" + :"" B . >1") " 0?1! " +" +*" +10 F" 0: I  1"1 01+;,<! 0:" " +  +1 + 1=;5< " +  " + :"";-<9   + 1= "0: +  " "" +  00"1 :1 2 + >    $!  : 1  +" . ""  :"" D " 1 : D> : :*  1= "  +* : " CA  D0" :  B )9  " .  : ' * + *" D  : 1  + +  " "" + 

2 + >    $ : * +  01+/9 D> >' + /*0" . "" B!  M" +    " :  C) : >""" +> 0+ 0:1"" D  %   +1  +  +1*"  B0

,,59

49  >:(!  %0+ >" B+1   +"* : B + 0?  B" + 01+0" C"1  &9  +1 :+" +  :1* . >""" + ? + 1! D E = + .  *1"1 + + D >::"   " + +"* + >&$  0"( + :  C) + :"" "'1 +  :' + 

 + >  >" : + : 1*+" G9

 "

* D   + =" :1  "00" +  F"  58 *,338 + >BB %,56237!; + =:+,338  P 6,8-,<! / "0 +D   +0 D > "" 00? + D >1 1+" +*" :+  C) + :+" 01+/ C"1 + > "" 00?

*9 

2-3425667 % 728 %  B!  >" /:10" B+1   "9 -6 " -4 + "1 9 !  +:"! "* .  ? " + 0C+! >" : 1"1 "B1 :  $9  1D!  +:" +    " ::?9

H9 <

/ "0 + L"9 -@ 9 5  !   B1+1 :" +1+ +  :  C)! : L ?)" + ! + M" + :"" :1* / "9 57 9 5  53   B . L1") : +  01+9  :" +1)   O L ?)" +  :+  C)  M" +LC0" . L1") : +  " D 01+9  :" 0"  :  C) + M" + :"" B . L1")9 L"9 -@ 9 5   :+ . L"9 58 9 5 + :=" +   +  B1+1;&&,335  575<! +:"1 :   + "" ,H +10?,335;

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

*"1 0B"1 :   B1+1 1"" + B ) +  B"1 :1* . L"9 -@ 9 5   +(  D  0"   +11)1  +1:"0"   +L1"?  " + :"" D  :*" F" B  $! 0 DL L" 1)0" :1 + B/  + +  :  C) +  M";B9 "9 -4 9 @   K

&,58  H7<9 ?<   "!   " +0"" D! +L 0()11 " ?!  1 D L" 0! . L1")! . + ""0" 01+/ D  :*" F" +0"1  $!  : :  ?"  :  C) /

2-3425667 % 428 % +" + L"9 -4 9 @     0"B D  " +  ""0" L : 1"1 1"? " DL L" : 

* + LF"9   ="B" +L"" 0 D L& $ :( * : " + B" DL " " L" 0:0" : 1? : +L1*+" ! 00+! + "  " . " +"!  :  C) +  M"9  L" : : "" 1 + 0?    1"?"!   : !  " + :"" +(  D  () 1) " BB00" :1 : F" ::D1;B9

&,,- ? 45 +9 -<9  '    :" + L +L :" D  :"" %   + "9 57 9 5 " 53   % 1:+"  "( +L+1D"  : 10" : F" B  $ " +L" :"! D  "( +LBB"1 " +L10"1 " 1)0" :  0:"; &,58  H7<9 89  >:(!  " >" +  & +  ?" +>C" + 01+0"!  D /" :110"  "( +>)9  >" :  : 1)1 D  01+0" :"  :*" F" B  $9 & +(  " + "" D  %0+ > : . :+  C)  M" +  01+0"9

39  " >1" :+" +  D>  " : " 0:" + B" D> " ?0" 0 0C1  &9  >'  :+" : + +" .  ?""" +  ::"    D >%0+ +*"   0:"  :""  ?)"0" .  C) + :     " : +> :"" 1); &,54  --5<9

  B" D  01+0" D  & "  >:( 0 C!  " F" :""9

,69  " *D B  B" D  :11+" %0+ :( +D  *" 1"1 BB1  " "= 0?1  B :C0"D 01  &! " D > *"  D "  " :   * >"01!  >" :  + "" +> * % " >" : :"1 :  BC +,L766 B9

 :: +  ? B

1)"  ::" " >+0"" " +0"19 >"  D> )0"   +1 1 :*" ?) >+0"" . " .  +0"1  *") " .  !   +" *" " 1 I

,9 D >""1 " "* +  "" (" . >1)+ + : +1"01 K

59 D> " )"  " 1 * ) +  0" +  0:1" K

2-3425667 % H28 %

-9 D >+0"1 >" :  + 0:" 001+"0" + >/""+ + )0" ?" I

@9 D>  " B+1  % : :+ + +:" D>  " 0+B  ?  :1=+  D> " 0!   ? +> )0"  +> +1 1 + >+0""!  " D> >" :  0 +>0:  ? + :1=+ K

79 D   >" : C)1 +:  00" O  )0"  1"1 +19; &  :?1 9 9 +,3 0,38@ K

&  :?1 99 + 54 =,38@ K

&  :?1 99 + -6 "?,33H<9

$ BB"*0"  " 0? + +" %1011 " 0:! B " + "" D >"01 > : %0F0 :  C)  M" + 01+0" C"1 :11+00"9   " +(  . :1" >?) . "*  B* + >1!  "0" .  9

2-3425667 % 828 %  ,+0  +!* ,  * ,+

 1/2   3  4   56)%& ,7   2 

,9 1   *?9  2

59  =""9 -9 " D  :1+ ")""9

@9 B0  :" +  D> :*" B0  "  :1" F" +  +1 + -6 = +(  "B" : : 00+1 +1  ? B1+1 + ! $CRACBD 4! 466@   !  " /0:9  +1  :" F" :)19  010 +" I < +D /"0" D +1  " +1 ?"   " : +  +1 ""D1K ?< /: : D 0"B  "0 :* +0+ "" " +1K < :"  )"   +  :1""9 $  010  "" :  " 110" 1011  "" < ?< " < %+!  ? B1+1 +   : : "  0"(    D> +* +1 *?9  010 +  0"   0' + :*! D " ="!  D  +1 ""D1 " >*:: + D   1"1 /:1+1  ";"9,-5!,64 ",68 <9

)BB(

%  S

 1+" I

 T   

 : B0 + :1" F" " "B1 / :"  D>. >BB B1+1 +  "1 :?D : )BB 

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

    

      !   

        

"#$%"&''("$)&"&''(

* +!* ,  * ,+ - .) )) /. &''(

  

  !

"

"

#$

$$ %   %   $ $  &! '"  () * + ,- . "/

"01

2-3425667 % 528 %  0+,9   " 1 :( +  %0+ +" #$! " &;%:(  %0+  ?)" + 9

  +1:1  55 *0? 566@!  +0+ :( +  %0+

*" . ?"  0?0" + A B" 1"?   :  C0 : . $"%  * " ? . )%%$(*  &9

59  +1 + - +10? 566@!  %0+    "1! B" +  0?9

-9 >"11  B01 ::" . +" +1  5- +10? 566@! 1)" D E =>C("  01+0"  & +: :D +/  "   :11+" 0>" "= 0?1  ""9  

* :  D 

*)F :D> " 0 0C1 + @66 B9 : 1 G9 @9  +1  ::" + H B1* 5667!  %0+  /:D1 D   + ?"1/ )1 "  $ "  :' + > :1!  0?0" + :"" BB"1 +  "" 00? >::1  B" + " "( I  1"1 01+!  +1 + 1= "  "': + :"" " " / D  ?" + 1= " >" + :""9

79 >"11  "="1  ,H B1* :( + ? + 19

49   :1* + 5, 0 5667!  %0+!  1B1" /:10" .    6@2- :?1 : >BB B1+1 +  "1 :?D  5@ 0 566@ "  +:"" "CD + >+   ? " + : " + >+

 +  +0 + > 0+ * BB" , =* 566@! ::  =" + 9

H9 *"1 .  +1"0! >"11 +( D E    6@2- >  . B +  010 + #$   01+0" C"1  & " +1?"1  '  +A 9 ""  >1"" : +"1 / 1 0 /  +>9 %  1"1 +1:1 D0" : "0:  ?9  +0+ D  B0 " "1 + 0109 >/" + B0

,,, "

,,5 >/" +  + +" +> D => J + #$  D  +1:1 +  010 + #$9  B0  :" : + 01+0" C"1 . >1")9  0D + "1 +  +" +>! => 1"1 +"   K = > : " 0  :( + #$  = > : :  BC +,L766 B9 +

2-3425667 % -28 % 00" D  01+0" C"1  $ +1:" ) 11  :"" :  +,L766 B9   0+ :11+" 0>" "= 0?1  01+0" C"1  & G9 89   +:D + 55 = 5667!  %0+ :" +  9

39    1"1 "0 : B0" . >"11 "    1"1)+1 . =)9

 ,+,9  )*  >)" =+; " + >1" +,4 =) ! :  ? B1+1  5H =* 566@; &,-6 ,64 """ + >1" + */ =) 9 59 B010" . L"9 74  9, "9  C9 @ !  ? " +   N"  " D + """ :1* . >" 74  D " "* .   B1+1  >%0+ +,8 0,33@;  :( "  1"?9 -9  "! "="1 +  B0 " +1 1)/!   " *? B010" . >"9,   " -4 +   +>::" +   B1+1  >%0+ + 53 0,33H  D>/ "9 74! 73 " 46  9 @9  ") :"   D" + *   %0+ "   " + 0?  01+0" :" :  01+  0 C"1  &

*9 79   0 O >1"" + B" D +" F" ::11 =+D0" >" "(0" 11 :( , = 5665! +" + >"1 

*) + >+ + 5, =,333 "  B1+1"  +> :" "  00"1 :1 "  "" 00? +>" :"   ? " + :;   ) + >::" + ""

2-3425667 % @28 % 1)" " + 0+B" +    " + >  D>  "N1; &,5H  @4H BB B1+1 +  "1 :?D % &$ :"   0+B" '" : ?=" >"+" +  " :1 +> 0+! >)0" + +"   + 1= C + > "" 0:1"" "  0:B" + B0 9

:" +, = 566@! ""  : 1 " +"!   + 0+  + 0""1 +"  1=   "" +> " "" + 

2

  +  $!  :1"" +  " :1 +> 0+! + "B" :* + 0:0"  + B0

,,,! . ""  :""  " D >*(" 1 + :" + * 01+! 0:" " +  " + :"" " +  +1 :1* + 1=9   B" : + +"" "  001+"0" 1 "  19

 >1"+ + +" / :""   + 1= "0: . >1")!  B" D >'" +" " ""! ?11B + "! : +1"C1! CQ0  1"+" > : +>+9  D  M" + :"" B . >1") " 0?1! " +" +*" +10 F" 0: I  1"1 01+;,    $!  : 1  +" . ""  :"" D " 1 : D> : :*  1= "  +* : " CA  D0" :  B )9  " .  : ' * + *" D  : 1  + +  " "" + 

2 + >    $ : * +  01+/9 D> >' + /*0" . "" B!  M" +    " :  C) : >""" +> 0+ 0:1"" D  %   +1  +  +1*"  B0

,,59

49  >:(!  %0+ >" B+1   +"* : B + 0?  B" + 01+0" C"1  &9  +1 :+" +  :1* . >""" + ? + 1! D E = + .  *1"1 + + D >::"   " + +"* + >&$  0"( + :  C) + :"" "'1 +  :' + 

 + >  >" : + : 1*+" G9

 "

* D   + =" :1  "00" +  F"  58 *,338 + >BB %,56237!; + =:+,338  P 6,8-, "" 00? + D >1 1+" +*" :+  C) + :+" 01+/ C"1 + > "" 00?

*9 

2-3425667 % 728 %  B!  >" /:10" B+1   "9 -6 " -4 + "1 9 !  +:"! "* .  ? " + 0C+! >" : 1"1 "B1 :  $9  1D!  +:" +    " ::?9

H9  +  L%0+ + 5H =,337;   " + :"" :1"1 >1"" : 1?9   B1+1  %+11)1  :* 1)0"  0"( +L1"+ + :""  +1:"0" D! :   :1"1! L : 1"? + "9  L +0 : 0 D 

*"1 0B"1 :   B1+1 1"" + B ) +  B"1 :1* . L"9 -@ 9 5   +(  D  0"   +11)1  +1:"0"   +L1"?  " + :"" D  :*" F" B  $! 0 DL L" 1)0" :1 + B/  + +  :  C) +  M";B9 "9 -4 9 @   K

&,58  H7 :(!  " >" +  & +  ?" +>C" + 01+0"!  D /" :110"  "( +>)9  >" :  : 1)1 D  01+0" :"  :*" F" B  $9 & +(  " + "" D  %0+ > : . :+  C)  M" +  01+0"9

39  " >1" :+" +  D>  " : " 0:" + B" D> " ?0" 0 0C1  &9  >'  :+" : + +" .  ?""" +  ::"    D >%0+ +*"   0:"  :""  ?)"0" .  C) + :     " : +> :"" 1); &,54  --5 :( 0 C!  " F" :""9

,69  " *D B  B" D  :11+" %0+ :( +D  *" 1"1 BB1  " "= 0?1  B :C0"D 01  &! " D > *"  D "  " :   * >"01!  >" :  + "" +> * % " >" : :"1 :  BC +,L766 B9

 :: +  ? B

1)"  ::" " >+0"" " +0"19 >"  D> )0"   +1 1 :*" ?) >+0"" . " .  +0"1  *") " .  !   +" *" " 1 I

,9 D >""1 " "* +  "" (" . >1)+ + : +1"01 K

59 D> " )"  " 1 * ) +  0" +  0:1" K

2-3425667 % H28 %

-9 D >+0"1 >" :  + 0:" 001+"0" + >/""+ + )0" ?" I

@9 D>  " B+1  % : :+ + +:" D>  " 0+B  ?  :1=+  D> " 0!   ? +> )0"  +> +1 1 + >+0""!  " D> >" :  0 +>0:  ? + :1=+ K

79 D   >" : C)1 +:  00" O  )0"  1"1 +19; &  :?1 9 9 +,3 0,38@ K

&  :?1 99 + 54 =,38@ K

&  :?1 99 + -6 "?,33H "01 > : %0F0 :  C)  M" + 01+0" C"1 :11+00"9   " +(  . :1" >?) . "*  B* + >1!  "0" .  9

2-3425667 % 828 %  ,+0  +!* ,  * ,+

 1/2   3  4   56)%& ,7   2 

,9 1   *?9  2

59  =""9 -9 " D  :1+ ")""9

@9 B0  :" +  D> :*" B0  "  :1" F" +  +1 + -6 = +(  "B" : : 00+1 +1  ? B1+1 + ! $CRACBD 4! 466@   !  " /0:9  +1  :" F" :)19  010 +" I   +* +1 *?9  010 +  0"   0' + :*! D " ="!  D  +1 ""D1 " >*:: + D   1"1 /:1+1  ";"9,-5!,64 ",68  . >BB B1+1 +  "1 :?D : )BB