opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/898/2004

Genf · 2004-11-09 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (1 Absätze)

E. 38 +   1'8  9

58 &  *  8 78   &+** & 33 A 5667 & !==*   & !"*1*&* +8;8 *  ) 9* ::::::::::  &* /     *0 & 3 A 5665  5@ =+1* 5667   &*"  /  * & 3  56678 <8 & !  / 1     & 3!666 =8% /

*  &  ** * /  =*  &+8 48 =   * & )! 1 =     + J &  &+* & 76 B &0   *=* *  * &+ &+  *' =+&+ & % #FW*UF=)* 4% 466;   %  * (*8  &+*   J  >+8  +* &* X D *&*) ( ) &+**   &+* ' *  *   &  &+**  )+G 'D ( ) *= *  * 1* &&     &+**G D   *>    &  +  8 #*  +*   *   * ++  +++    D 'D  D *"&%  *' =+&+ &         *0   )!* &1 &+

*1'8  +* &   *  , & 1%)*  B* % **)  &+**  )+  !1 & )   + + (+&*+   C 8 375% 364  36@ D8

 >==*0X

9*"*  Y

 +*&  X

* Z   

 + *"B*  X

*

E 

 * = & + J   *=*+ ( * **)!/ !==* =+&+ &  *   >==

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

    

         

        

!"#$#!%&&' !()(!%&&* 

+ ,-+ .  + ., "/ 01 2 ) 3 2 %&&*

    

4444444444   ! "

##     $ # %     #  #    #% &  '(& ) * +* &** 

 

.55, .  6+7,8,,% *  & , -. / 01 * *+

23.3425667 " 5237 "  5, 38 9* ::::::::::% +  3-; >*   ! * ?:::::::::: &* 3-@68   + + 1* * & &(*=   * 3--  *   ' 3---8   + & 1* /   & 36 B* 3---   + + **+  B* 56638 58 !* ++  &++  37 1* 5666  && &   * 0 & !==*   & !"*1*&* + C*"0  D 1* / ! * &!  %  *&*) ==* & '0 &*)8 78   ::::::::::% +**  $9E  F*>*  +&*" *  & !+%  &   & + & 5  *)+      *=   * 3--   "*  *  3--@%  F+ *   3-@   *  *  3-@;%  F,**&+*% & '>*   ,& 1 +' &8

 +&*  +*+)   * 1* &+B/ '*  + * > *)   0 > &&+%   & F* *>*  1*   *=    * '>*)  * 3--  F* * *   * * / 018    "*8

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

23.3425667 " 7237 " 5663% !+  + +  J & 1* C=8  *=* &  :::::::::: &; B* 5663D8     '1+)  & & !+  & &  > !1*  &++ **  *   &   / *  & ! *%  * !, 1*  & *'** + & = * * &!'F  *8  *%     / 1* + *   *1* + &   *  )  &* * F,*) + * *==* 8 >*  / !+ 8  1*  =*)   * +&* + *  L =1' & =*)   *   *  = F,*)  + *  & =  & *)8   ** &) !+ * ::::::::::   *1* + +>0  & + / * % 1  & F &  % )* + * =*+   &+ ** &   >      >   *8

48     & 5@ A 5663   /   * &   &  *  *) +> / *  1  & & .  +* / 3 + * *8     +*+)  &** * & & *   & ) & ,1 *+  F&*% !+ &1 +1*   NF

+*'8  + * & + /  **  * + * (& F=="*1 C+>D%   &  CN>+% F&*+% = D%   ** C+>D% *>"1* &! *% ,+ &   *"1*8 .8  &+** & 37 =+1* 5665% !   ,+ / !+  &*"  & !"*1*&* + /  * & 3 B* 5666% & /  &>+ &!*1*&* + & *  F*)8    /  * & 1* + &*) %  = * , *) >' & 1 * >F &*0  &**+ & *0 *F>0%  +>>*  *

*  &*0  / &++%   * , *) &  1 * &*)* !  J  &+ *+8  *%   ::::::::::% ::::::::::  :::::::::: & E 

23.3425667 ";237 " &*> *)+  @ B* 5665  *=  *> &,& *=+*8   1+)  =* & >,+*%   =  & *) &*" 1*% + * &  8   *  + + =++  - B* 5665 /  **) & *   +&  * &*)8 368  5.  ' 5665%   ::::::::::  +*+  * & 55 A 5665  *1)  '  * &  * &*   & !* 1 **  +*8   * 1* +1+   *  =1' 8  +&*  + !(*  &! ,& 1 +' &8

338    & 5- 1' 5665%   #::::::::::% +&* +**   &*>* * 1 *%  =* +  &!  &!== == +  5  *=   *F+*,&*)8     + & # &*)    / !== %  ' * %  ' &  * F+&,*)    * & F,*),8  +&*  +>   +)   * + *   ,  *)% F*  &,+  & 8   1+  )!* !, 1*  & ' &, F &*)% F* & (,  1 ** &*)  )  &*   *  & & + "') 8 !*==* &*) + *   +8 358   &+** & 3; 1* 5667% !   ,+ / !+   

  *0   +*& & 3 A  76 1' 5665   &*" 

 /  * & 3 &+' 56658

378    & 76 1* 5667% !* ++% + +  ! * * & &+=  & &+   &    * + C D% ! + /  &+** +* +% +>)  * + & 1* + * 8

!* &  * *% !+ ! +=++ /   *=* &  :::::::::: & 5- 1* 5667% ( &) *"* =** !** + & 1*  & !+ &0  5. B* 56658 3;8 !    *=*+  33 A 5667  &+** & B &!* *%  =&     & +&* +**  & 5- 1' 5665%  *&+) !+ !1* + + JF+) * &!(*   * + & >* +*&8 3 >1+ &' % !+ * '+   =*  & +&* 1% &  )!* 1* =&+  &+**      * &   #::::::::::% **)  !1* + & #98

 & % !  

23.3425667 " *% &  & !+ * ('+  1*  *  >  1*( '*8  & + * *+ /   *1* + & * )!* 1* &A +&* /  *" 8 * %  &  *= * +>  * * & % *  * * *  F+  &+'*  &8  * * * + * & 0  &*"F &    + * ('+ (1 8 #   % 

& F> &+  *) M* + * (8  1   *+ + * &(  *1 &    "1*) '*8  !, 1*  =*  & ' >*)8  &  % + "   & + * B +  & J)  & +" F*) >F% ) + *  '' *+  '0 &%  L)!/ !* 1 *   *8   :::::::::: 1*)   * + *  * *  & (,  1 **  & &0 & ' *=+*)* 1* +& =1' /  *  +&*8 !*==* &*) + * +    *  + *  & &,+ &!==    G  =*%  &0 (*& 1* +*&*1+8  +&*  ** =*)! ** + & 1* + * * B *=*+8 3@8 # & & ! %   :::::::::: & 1* +&* +>*

 C#9  9 D %  56 =+1* 566;% 1+)   :::::::::: +1)*  ,& 1 +' & &   & 5  * &!>>1 * & !+  &  +  * &! ,& 1 +' & /  * & 5.  ' 5665%   ::::::::::  *&++)   :::::::::: ! *  +**% F* !+> * & &%   &!+ '* 'B *1 !+ *>*   **  *   1  &*> *8

 +>&% *"* !+ * '+ /  *)  & F"& >F + * *+  ,& 1 +' &%  L)!     F *  /  '+ *) *% + +   ( &*>*) +**+8      >*)% * **    !1*  *&* *)      +" **  &*>*)8

**%   +&* & #9% *   * &!&   >>1 * 'B *1+ *  (&!** + 

*    &1 &+'F  ! * &!  

  *08 3-8   &*) & 56 =+1* 566;% !   *   * *8

23.3425667 " 4237 " 568  * & 54 A 566;%  *' & +  &&+   ::::::::::)!* +*    & ,& 1 +' & &  8

538   ::::::::::%  * & 73 A 566;%  (*)+)    *>* & &  *1 &   &% 1*  '*% ) !+ * >*1 + & &*  *=  &! ' 3---8  &  >J* &  1*    1* + +  **0  *  &   > &    *"1* H::::::::::8  , 1* + & * & ' *  &*1 F&*)* 1* 1)+  ** + & 1*8  +&*   *+ / *% & &  *  * * *%  & 1     ** & 

& F>8  +&*  *&*)+)!* !1*  B>+  * &!==  & &*>F*    + >+ *)%  1 & !' & ' >*)  & =*)  *  +&* + * &    1 %) !F* * &!*>* &*  *18  =*% * ! &++ &+*&+ / ==   (  ,  &&

 &  8

558   ::::::::::  ** *  *' & +  4  ' 566;   & !* *  &   $##  & 5  ' 566;% == +    ::::::::::)* =** !(*  &! *% &!  F &   1 +'% &! &* F* + >+ 1  *  F* &*  *1  *1 1*% &! &* F + >+ 7"   & &, & + >+ +&* &  +>* *=+*8  !1*  &++ &! ++* *= 8   *  ' &    *) & F* &   = &! * &++  O # P +&*  > & (*8  !, 1*  &!F,,F & =*% !*>   F  &  1 +'(+ * 1+8    *  &, & + >+ +&*  33"35 1  + &!  (%   F    *0 L     % **) & * + *) &  +&* *8

578 1* + /  &+ *%  #9    *&*)+  4  ' 566;)!(*1(&  1*%   + * &+*     :::::::::: + * *%  *' 1 !N> &  %   1* J  'B *1 ++ 1  * 8  !+ *  *1*&  &   *1* + & + +>0%    & J **  *    ! *1* +  *' 1  +  &*"1*% * %  *1   %    *1* +  *)  +>0%  F>% /  * 1  & & . *'** + + '*  ! *  &*"1*8 5;8  * & 4  ' 566;% !     * * &  &  +1* & 36  ' 56678 5 &+ / B>8

 ., 38  * >1*  !>* * B&*** CD  + + &*=*+   * * +% &0  3 A 5667%  *'   &  *% + & % &  +*&   1*"+*& %   C 8 3  8

  %   *' =+&+  5. B1* 566; C $ 376  364D%  & * >1*  & +%  37 =+1*%  &** * * * >     *'   &  * & *+>   / * B>

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

23.3425667 " @237 "    &!0%  =*  &+ * , &* / !& * &  &+** * *>* & 33 A 5667    55 A 5665% &  & &+L    &! && & +1**8 #    +*%   &!0   & +>*   +>* *  1*> B)! 73 &+' 56658  =*%  )*   +&% "* + * &   3 B1* 5667% &  )   &!0  +>*   1 0> & +&   &      &** * & +&   &  &*==+  * +* &*=*+    8

78  *' & +      )  % * B + &  = )*     *%  1' /  =% =+ / ! 8 46  8

;8  * *>       * & (&!*1*&* +  *  / &+ * *    &* / ! * &!  

  *0 "&/ & 3 &+' 5665  * &! >>1 * &' &  +  &  +8 *% ++    & > &+%)* +  &!  *  /   + F,*)    1 &! *=** + >+* % &! &*  &! *& 8 !*1*&* +  + + 1 &0)!  %       >1* +%  / 1* &* (  *    *&+ *8

R+  &* /     *0 R*  *1*& / 44 527K  *% /  &*"  R*  *1*& / *   1* (*>*' C &!*  1(F'*      *=D8   * &!*1*&* +  **   * B*&*)% '+  & ++   * +*)%)*   =&  =+ 1  (& !** + = *% )  &+ *  +&* G    +) +*) & !** + = *)!*

*  &!+1 C $ 36  +% +&*   *+ *  &>+ &R*1*&* +  &*=* & *0 / *=  &* /    *8  F>

*  & *   / *=  &>+ &R*1*&* +%  &  &* /     *1  +1**8  B> *   F> R &* % * =   =*  )R*  + * 

23.3425667 " -237 "  &  &+** &   ** * 1  *  +> / R+) &  &+** * *>* C $ 35   !"*1*&* + & 3. B1* 3-43 "  D8

#*  &* * +1 / R 8;3   = &+= %  &+** &    J  +1  &*=*+ &R0  0> *' /  *&+ * & &+** &**  *1 +  =8 =+ /  0>% R&**  *     1* &R==*   &+** = +  = & F B>+   )   * + B&***  R  +  R>  +*% / &* *)R *   &  + )   *=* * 1J  

*   '8  B>  %   +F+ % =*  &+** & +1** & /

  *= ' * +)  &+** &   ** * + *   &  + )   *=* * 1J 

*   ' C $ 35 + &!*1*&* +% !&**  * C  B>% !*,    D  '* & & )  +&*% +1  * &!  +** % &*1 * =*8  NF & +&* *  /   B>  !+  &  +  / *&*) &)   )  *1* + !+  *' & 1*8   %  &+ +&*  *   ++  *  &+ *) 1(  % *' % (*> & !+ C $ 35 *(

*   * =* !'B &! + & =*+%)    =&  & (  %)!*  +>  *&+ *  *  (*+%)!* * + + + '*  * * & &* C0D%)  &* * &  ( +&* * *  =*)  * & !( * '* *1+ C $ 355  346 *&8 3   +=+D8 !++ &+ *   1 '  !  ** * !*>* &, & 1% *  &+*> *%   = &!   &! ( *% * '  '*    C $ 355  346 *&8 3 G 9% * 1*&* T '> * & '*> *F =1*F> 8 5-.  8G 9 % =&*U**F > F > * & # % * # # 7523-@@ 8 775  8D8

 B &   + '*   +&* *  %  B>   &* *   & =*)%  !(+*%  +&* *   >++ *%   & & % / &  *    *  * &   * & =*)* !* /  &*

C $ & 3; 1* 5667%     7-267% *&8 785%

$ 35; 

3. + 

23.3425667 " 36237 "   * %   &  *  * &!+1 * &*==**8  **% * =* & =* /   * % )*  F* '%   =* &  B 1 & !'B *1* + +*% >*&+)!*    *% '  *% &!J     * *' /   * 8     * & +&* & =*) / !+* * & !** + & 1* & !+  **  1 '  *=+* /  & +**  C 3-@@ 8   &!*)!*  +  !( * &    *  C# 5663% 36- *&8 7'2 G  3-@@ 8 + &!*1*&* + &  *   ' 3---8 #*  /  **0 * &*) 1  5. B* 5665% !* *+  ,+     

  *0% & /  &>+ &!*1*&* + & 366K% *   +*& ** + &)  *% * & 3 A  76 1' 56658 !* *+ 1*  == *&++) !+  &  + &   !+ * +B+) & *0 1** )!* 1* 1+  &* /  &*" 

 /  * & 3 &+' 56658

!( & % * Q)  +) & **0 *=  & 5. B* 5665  + +  *0 +'+% **) ! *&*)+   #:::::::::: &   & 5- 1' 5665% )! =*+  +&*" *  &   & 5-  ' 56678

 =*%    =* +  &! ,& 1 +' &)*

**)* %  *%  >>1 * &  +  &  +  +*  3 &+' 5665  %  1* & +)% ! * &!  

  *0 &0   & 8

 + &! ,& 1 +' &  + + 1+  *0 =*    :::::::::: &   & 5 F  >*1 8  =*% * ! =**   * &   & 55 A 56658    & 5-  ' 5667% * (*)*)   ==* & & &* !+ 5666 &+B/ )  & 1* + + ('+    > == + /    * 1* H:::::::::: & 54 B*  7 B* 5663 &  & &   >   8   :::::::::: 1*  )   1* + + '*>+ &!*    *1* + /   * * & % *  >+  &+'*  &%  + *  * >+  * * & &+'*   +8  * * * + * & 0  &*"F &   + *

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

,  ** * & =* ! * &!    *0 ** +% *1* &! &*" 8

 +>&% ! 8 @@ *+ 3   +*) *  * + & >* &! + !+* ) 

*  ! +% *,  * & *&+)  F> *%   +F+ %    * &  &* (  * &0)!  ! & / ) !+* *   +  * * &  U > +*&8   1 & J )!  F> &+ *  &+ * * &+B/%  *  *  '  )! * * F* * / *&8

23.3425667 " 35237 "

 Q &    **)  *  =* +  &!  * 0  & !*==* &*)  + + + '*    #::::::::::  &  & 5- 1' 56658 % !* *+  *&++) !JF  & 1* &+ &   == * 1* * =*  76 1' 56658  =* % !* *+  +  ** &+ & ! 8 @@ *+ 3  % *1)! F> &+ * &1* 1* &+ &* * * &+B/ )!* * *    * & &* (  *8

**% !* *+% &  +1* & 36  ' 5667%  &*)  (&!*1*&* +  &+ & !*=  &,& & 5. B* 5665  * =*  +* +) * * 0   &   #:::::::::: & 5- 1' 5665% * /  * & 3  56678

 &+** * *>* & 33 A 5667  & &*=*+ &  8

 1 & )* +0&%  *' & +   )     * &*8

23.3425667 " 37237 "   .,5  ,-+ .  + .,

  09   :;  +8  +* &* X D *&*) ( ) &+**   &+* ' *  *   &  &+**  )+G 'D ( ) *= *  * 1* &&     &+**G D   *>    &  +  8 #*  +*   *   * ++  +++    D 'D  D *"&%  *' =+&+ &         *0   )!* &1 &+

*1'8  +* &   *  , & 1%)*  B* % **)  &+**  )+  !1 & )   + + (+&*+   C 8 375% 364  36@ D8

 >==*0X

9*"*  Y

 +*&  X

* Z   

 + *"B*  X

*

E 

 * = & + J   *=*+ ( * **)!/ !==* =+&+ &  *   >==