opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/874/2004

Genf · 2004-10-26 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (1 Absätze)

E. 6 A   "! A5" " 7! &  #  "  8  -...;6*4: A P   ! > *-)-..- 80 :: 5  $0-<4   " @ 8! &,?*.: 70  & %+?-$,70 8 !0   G "?(! " =.C4  ( "  "   ?!'(  & +,N,6: 70 8 !0   5' 4  " !   8 " 7 >  8  "  !  A"8!4 @  8 ? 8  " RA G !B'4  "!(B!   >   ! ! 8 88 G !   8"7  8( @  8#! 8  @  (0

4  G "   B!!  7! &  #0 2 ?G8!4 " "  4  8 !" " *. & -=C   ">! "  5;2 *$$: 80 *%$4 80 -$,<0  "!" " -=C ?( 8" 8 " ' B!!  " A> 0  7   G    5 " ? 5 "  "    8 4  " > 4  ( A#8A!> " @ !"0

 4  ?#  8  " 8!" & " "!" " 8 A " 7   "!      !  A"84 ?RB4  ! " (4  !   !B " 8  " !9    G "?80  7 5 8H 8!" &  !( B54 "    " 8("?88!4 " 77 "  7   ( "?("4  8  " ? 5 "  "  0   @4  D  7 !  5  " *=C 8   8  8 "  ! !B' "   " ? 8@A  & 77 " (G "  "  !! "?  8 )"!5; D  85! " +. ( 5 -..*  6--).*<0    @4     7!  5  " *.C   "    & " (! !B' "  " "?(!  8  !8!( > (   "  8"  " (   B" " B !( "?(! > (  !B4  "( ( >?

)*+,$)-..+ / *.)** /  5 B77 "  (!  !B'  8  ? " 8   " "8! G A"8 " ! >  8( 8 77 " (G "  "( !(  8 > 8B!; D " -+ 5 -...4  85!4     *%%)..<0  4  D "  >   7 " !"  7 > ?!!  (  ! & G  ( &  8 80  774 B!! 4   8#! &  8 8 BB 88   > G > ( &  8 8; @ " D " *. 5 -..+4  6*-).+ P (2 *$$: 80 *:- "0 65 *$$: 80 -$% P 22 -... 80 -6 5 $<0   98" " 5 7!"! "   # (4  8   8 "   "?8' "? 5  G  " *.C "F & ?RB4 &    " ?!8 BA  " 7 >    8 ( >?&  8 8 "  (! !B'4  > " &   ( ("! " +-N$:+ 70 +=0

 G "?("! ! "   8 "  "G (  "'  ",+0$*C;$*?+$=/+-N$:+0+=G*..)$*N+$=<0

 G ?(  " >?&  " / "?("!   8 &   '0 %0

 ( "  > 8!'"4    9!   "! " ?  " *:  -..+  7 !0

)*+,$)-..+ / **)** /   .(-4  (-, (.  , .-

 809   :  ;   5< "$& .=   9 

*0 !   (5

 9

-0  90 +0  >  8!"  B0 60 7   8 "  >? 8( 7     8! @ "  "! " +. 9 "'  7 8 8  "! "!  5 7!"! " 4 2AYVA7>,4,..6   4   G 80  "!  8 @ 8B!0  !  " S < "> G  > "!   "! 5    8 "  "! >!P 5< G8 8 > 7    8(" "   "!P < 8  B   "  8!0 2  !    8   !!  ! !!   < 5<  < /"4  5 7!"! "   8 8   '    >? "( "! (50  !  "     # " 8(4 >  94  >  "! >!  ?(88 " >   !! G8!"!  ;0 *+-4 *.,  *.: <0

 B77'S

1/  Z

 !" S

 [   

 !/9 S 1 0 2   

 8 7  " 8! @  7! G 8  >?& ?77 7!"! "   8  B77

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

    

         

        

!"#$%!&''# (!)*+!&''+ (

, (-, (.  , .- "/ 01 2  &$ 02 &''+

  

 3333333333 



.44- (.  5,6-7- -(  ! " !  " # $% & '(

)*+,$)-..+ / -)** /  4-(*0 1 233333333334 !  "! 5 *$6$4 " 7  !4  (! "8  * 9 *$:. 8' " 2( " " '(;/8' 2 ?  &

 14   !! (  "? " " 0  " ? "! 8  7  ( "  @ A ! BA  " 5" ! "  B@  8  @ " ( & *..C0 +0  " " *$  *$$$4  8A' "   !!   8 8  

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

)*+,$)-..+ / +)** / :0 ?!  ! "!7(   (! ( "'  *- 8 5 -...   "? " " " & ?!8 BA0 $0  *$ 8 5 -...4   "!8! 8' " ?77  " ? ("!;/8' ?  !  7  ( "  @ A ! BA 8!! 8 A8 A !  B! >? # (  77 8 "  77 "    8 7 80   !(! & *..C ?8! " ( "  87 " !  & =.C "  (! !"0

**0  -% ( 5 -...4   33333333334 8! D1E  AB4 !" "  2 4   !4 8' G 4 >? G    "  5!  5" !8 & $.I4     !  " "  5!0   88!   " !"80  4   B! >  85'  " " " 77 ?! ?!  88    855 ( ?" " *=  *$$$  >? 8 @ !  @   8 >  8  AB " ?!80   88 "! " +.  -..*4   3333333333   8!! > J "  " "? (! "8! K  ? " "!  77   5 8! BA >     5 "?884  8! " (  85 & 8  8  & 8 "  L0 *-0  

3333333333  ">!4 "  88 !"  !" " -. 5 -..*4 > ?! " ! " ?! ! 4 > ?8! " ( ! " *..C "  7 " !  >? 8( GB " 8 >? G  87  8 " AB 6 A 8 9;(! " 5 & =.C 0   B! > / ?! 8   ( ?";" *=  *$$$  B! ?G "   "B> > ?! ( 9 8!!4 8 / @  ?B" 8  A"8 7 90    ! > "  (! "8!4    ( " 54  8! " ( 8  >  >  " 85'   5 !   & 8 " 0 *60  "! " -*  -..-4  2   ?!  5!!7 "?  "?("!4  " -?-== 70 8" &  8! " B "

)*+,$)-..+ / 6)** / +,C & 8 " * 8 5 -..*0    !B  #!  " ! 8  & ?!B! " -6?+.. 70 *=0  -6 9 -..-4 ?!  !! (>! 8  2 8  8 " 7 & =.C0 ! 4   " " (!5 8 " &    7 "  !8 BA4 ?! ? 8 8 8" ?(! 88!;70  " 

3333333333 " + F -..-  ?! 8! "  5B 88  -...4 " 8AB  > " ?!8 BA ( "   7   "!     85 " (0   D3333333333  "  > 8 !(  8! " (4  7   8  "   7 > " " 8!! 8 ?!0   "!! > "  (! !B'  5 " "   "!8 8 -.C  > "  (! ( "(B " 4  5 " 6.C & =.C 8( @ " 0

*%0 2  88 " * 9 -..-4  ( " !"8 87 " ?   88! "?# & ?!  " / 5!   "B! "?("! ",.C  " 8"  AB  7  ! &  8 "? 8#! " 5   " 2  ?! 7  " "0 *:0  "! " *:  -..+4 ?   7G!  G "?("! " ?! &,.C  !  " / ( 77  *  -..+0 ?       "  ("  > ?!  5  ( & 8  8   !  -..-4  $+N=$$ 70  ?  8! &  >? 8 !  ( & =.C "  8 "8!  ?>@     "  -...; 8' 22  & BB " =,?*+* 70 ?  ? 8!"! &  !" 88!    ( "?("0 *$0  : ( -..+4 ?!  7 88 & " "!4 !B >  85'  "G "  77 ? 8 !! 8   8 8 "!   G "?("!0 -.0    " -:  -..+4   D3333333333 7 ! "?  !!8A> (  

33333333334   "> /   7 ! >  85'  "G ?O 8    8! " ( "  (! !B'0

-*0  "!  88 " +.  -..+4 ?   9! ?88  7"  ?( " "( G8  ! &  "!    0

)*+,$)-..+ / =)** / --0  *+ 9 -..+4 ?!    " "! 8' "    " 

2/ 0 -+0    !! 7!! "?77  5 " !  * F -..+0  : 8 5 -..+4    7 8(  54   " 

33333333334 "! " - 8 5 -..+4 G   " >    ("! 7 & =.C "8  * 9 -..-   8! " ( "  ! " ! "8  $ 9 -..-0

-60   8!( " 6 F -..+4 ?     9 "   &  7  "  "! >!0

-=0  *,  -..+4 ?   "!"! " ( !(   " / "?("! " *  -...  -: 7!( -..+4 ! 88! >? " /  ( "!9& !! "! "'  *  -..+;"! " *:  -..+   "8      8   ! 7 4 " O4  " 7!"!; D +.  --,   5 " !  "  8! 0 -0   7!"!   8 B!! " " "   ", 5 -...;  " N88> " @ A! & 

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

 !B"4 ? 5 " !" O & ?!  8! " ( !" " =.C "  (! !B'0  ?" & "! > U

)*+,$)-..+ / %)** /  "! "  8! " " " ?!8 BA;!> " ?" " *=  *$$= ? !>  G  A"8 7  "  (  "  ( >"0   >    5B "  8  4 /  "   8!7>0  "B8A 8>!  "! ! >? G  "    >? ?B" 8  A"8 7 90

 84   "  D33333333334 " (  " !" 4  

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

)*+,$)-..+ / :)** / "?(!  ( > 8 5  @ GB! " 4   8 ! "?  &  ! 8A#>4   8#A>0   "?8! " ( " B "!4 ?(! > 8 @ GB! "  8  ( "?  87  "?  "  "?(!0

G   " ?0 %  4  !8! 8! " B  "  " ? 5  "? 8 " 85! " B " ?!   A! " ( !>5! >   "!4   "  ! "?  &  ! 8A#>4   8#A>  >? 8 8'       " !"8 GB50 5  ?!  5 ( ? &  !4    8 " ?!( "  ( 9>?  " 8! "  "!; *$$* 80 ++- P

D " -: 9 -... 5! 8(   "! 8 ;A0 *.*% "   " ?77 7!"! "    ?("!  ? 8 " ? ("! W  X   "7 B7( !( ( 9>?  "  "! >  " !>   " &  8 >  "!  8 8!   8 " (; D *-:  *%6 "0 6    ( ( ("!   !!  -... " $*N+$= 70 8 4  "! "   8#  2( " " '(;70 > 8 ? 8# " ? ("! 7!"!;   " " @    "   ("!0  4   98"0  85!    8 > ?! ? 8  (! ( 8( @ 5  " "  8'  ( " ? &  !; D *-6  +-- P 8> 2 -..- 80 :=    5G " 4  > " ?77 7!"! " > > "B     ( " >74  "  "?(!   G4    "?7  750   !7!

)*+,$)-..+ / $)** /  &  > "  5 ""!4   7" 9   !"  (  "   "?(! !; D *-6  +-+4 2 *$$$ 80 *:- 4  5> -- (  J!4 (G " A L4 ( +; 87 8!! ? (! " 5  !! ;70 ?>@     "  -...4 22 -...4

* ! "    " =?:6= 70 8 0 74     5 ""!   8 "? A " ( " 6. A   "! A5" " 7! &  #  "  8  -...;6*4: A P   ! > *-)-..- 80 :: 5  $0-   8  "  !  A"8!4 @  8 ? 8  " RA G !B'4  "!(B!   >   ! ! 8 88 G !   8"7  8( @  8#! 8  @  (0

4  G "   B!!  7! &  #0 2 ?G8!4 " "  4  8 !" " *. & -=C   ">! "  5;2 *$$: 80 *%$4 80 -$,  0  7   G    5 " ? 5 "  "    8 4  " > 4  ( A#8A!> " @ !"0

 4  ?#  8  " 8!" & " "!" " 8 A " 7   "!      !  A"84 ?RB4  ! " (4  !   !B " 8  " !9    G "?80  7 5 8H 8!" &  !( B54 "    " 8("?88!4 " 77 "  7   ( "?("4  8  " ? 5 "  "  0   @4  D  7 !  5  " *=C 8   8  8 "  ! !B' "   " ? 8@A  & 77 " (G "  "  !! "?  8 )"!5; D  85! " +. ( 5 -..*  6--).*  (   "  8"  " (   B" " B !( "?(! > (  !B4  "( ( >?

)*+,$)-..+ / *.)** /  5 B77 "  (!  !B'  8  ? " 8   " "8! G A"8 " ! >  8( 8 77 " (G "  "( !(  8 > 8B!; D " -+ 5 -...4  85!4     *%%)..    7 " !"  7 > ?!!  (  ! & G  ( &  8 80  774 B!! 4   8#! &  8 8 BB 88   > G > ( &  8 8; @ " D " *. 5 -..+4  6*-).+ P (2 *$$: 80 *:- "0 65 *$$: 80 -$% P 22 -... 80 -6 5 $     8 ( >?&  8 8 "  (! !B'4  > " &   ( ("! " +-N$:+ 70 +=0

 G "?("! ! "   8 "  "G (  "'  ",+0$*C;$*?+$=/+-N$:+0+=G*..)$*N+$= ?&  " / "?("!   8 &   '0 %0

 ( "  > 8!'"4    9!   "! " ?  " *:  -..+  7 !0

)*+,$)-..+ / **)** /   .(-4  (-, (.  , .-

 809   :  ;   5   8!"  B0 60 7   8 "  >? 8( 7     8! @ "  "! " +. 9 "'  7 8 8  "! "!  5 7!"! " 4 2AYVA7>,4,..6   4   G 80  "!  8 @ 8B!0  !  " S   G  > "!   "! 5    8 "  "! >!P 5  7    8(" "   "!P  ? "( "! (50  !  "     # " 8(4 >  94  >  "! >!  ?(88 " >   !! G8!"!  ;0 *+-4 *.,  *.:  ?& ?77 7!"! "   8  B77