opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/826/2005

Genf · 2005-09-27 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

     

              

         !"#$!"%%$ &!'"(!"%%$ &

) &*) &+  )  + *, - .  "# / - "%%$    

     0000000000 !" !#$"!%

# & ' "((%)"( !!"    "!    +11*  &+  2) 3*4* *& !(*+,-./ ")

   

01,201332 410514  1*& 56 #!7777777777)8/53 "9!5+:3"/-./ (.5+;))"!('(?!(!62?"5++2)")/" ('("(!"-"(%@@!"(!/A6 () )11B"5++:(( !.('@@"('!4 /(")C4 !.' D/"-'"!('!"(/ !@('!"6 16

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

 +*& 56 A/!'!A"?(!CD)")(@)""") (.5!B"133I !9"(! )(2 ?A(" !)(""/4 !)("2 )""5:?A! C!"65"6!"2: D6

   

01,201332 420514 O"-'"(')"(5:?A! ! !9@)()! 1, ?/! 133< C E 5I3  53:D  !(  A/  (")  5I @)/!!  ( " "!"! !A" !"""  !9 " ( !  ( )A!  ! - "! ?A ""!  ( '"""(')"(/=?A!6 16 @!)" - R!"6 2:  6 5 "6  G6 1   !9 " ( !  $"  " % ( """ !)/ - '!"62:(@)()!! !"A))!((!"(!( :"9!1333"!)/A!5!?/!133IC D%"!"/- !'!4/(")(5+?5+2+C D6O)" !?A! ((' .")"96 I6  ""!)/A!5!?/!133I"!$"(@"( 9!( ")A(((!6O! ")! "(/!%(!"R %("K"!"!G)-.! ( ! %!.A 9"/A!" S  @" ?!(%" ()"!"  " !(" C E 5I3  I1; (6161"16IQ51,<:,(6551:5I:(6<9"!)@)!D6

!/G%! !)(!"-()@"(!.A"!"! "!!/(!"R %!)!/(.?!("!) /A!C E55,+I(6:9551I:3(6<Q # 5++;8I, 6I5:(6I9D6 R" !% !)(! ("5!?/!133I "!("  !. "" (" (/"  "!9 " )""  ".! (R!"!)A !/!.A( !)(!" ( " !( "( !)(!"((@@)!" )(@) ! 6  ()"A*")") !((!('!)/"! ! 133IH133<!!)A ! "/(!"/A!(.5! ?/!133I6 <6 ) ) (  @! " ())A=!!"!/9C!"2:" :3 D6 26

' .'!)"" !(!"".!('/(")%)""!/( 5!B"5++,6 :6 O'!"62I ()"()! "@!" )@!"-!)/C !)(!D'!)'!! ()/!9)%"(@"/= !"""!/(*( !/% /"K"! !(" !/"6

   

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

="!('!"65, "=('/(")(9))@!(!" 9"(@""9!""('@@!((!)/) ! '/!-/!A")!)(")%! !)6 "(/!"GA"'K" !("("K"!"!G) !" @""%' !)"""(()"(!"" !" !)A" - ') % (  () "A C E 512  I:+ 53+1:2 53: ;, " 532  I3D6   @@" ""@  %' "" (!) GA) ! '" "  !)) ( .! (@@)!" C E551I,1D6;6  "A !" !  " ( /!  '/(") ( !!" '" (@) "! 55 /9! 133I (" - %  (!" -  !" ".!  )") @!)((!(!)/((!"15"9!133<("- %  )") @!) %  (!" -  !")""  !)Q  ('"! "!'"-9(!"%' "( !!(!"(!!"- !"('/(")6 536

 ' . '!) )")  !".!"  - (= = !"  !.! ( "! 7777777777  5++; "  (=. ()( (

   

01,201332 4,0514 # 133<6(== !"" !)()-= " ""=()""(")6!@!" *)!'"!( (! " " !))  .  ."6  ! !")"9 " !")""/)6"@"("(=-" !)%"?! !(""(/"/!!$"! /! !9"6 ""! 7777777777%)(( # 133<"9" K (A"  "!9 "@! (!= " " "") %  "!9 "% '@"  ")("!/6 ('=' !/)"! "4"!"%))"(A) *G"%9?"/)6 ""(=-'9(!9(") *G"!%A!/6 E!(.!"(""!%'@"/(!"65,"2I  ')"))/( !'= !"( # 6' ')"" (!"( !)(!-!)/("')"" ! 6 556 " - =! ' /" !()!!  () ('"! ( !"6 O '!"62I61 L'!! "!/!!()() !  " @!" )  @! !%' " @"" !!)"%!!"@"!/K" !""9M6 516 !?A!R"(9(!()!!() !"@%R "("!!)@"@(!!""?!(%="" " S  () )") !(  " " (  !"%  /A! - R) % C E 55+  <,+ (6 590 "  !)@)!D6 !  9 (  !()!"!!A! ""!!)((!"(K %R""" !!)!)""(R !)"(@"C E55,5, (61Q552I5<(6<0D6

!A!(()!")?!(%()("!"/"!)@! (" /!K"!(@) !9(!()!"%!)/. @""!!)6 ""=A)/"%!()!"(/ "!""!""!/=(("-9( !""(A(!)6  !"!!A(R "!" !)(!  "" "  -  /  !)" (  ""  !.  =  !@((@"6 =""(@"!"K"! ( !% R"! (  !"" () ( ( (" ")! (" R=  /!(R !)"%"-!"(! " (!))""%() !$"(9 ""("" (@" " ( (!" C!!K" 6 (5+()9!1331 111031 (6I61" !)@)!D6 5I6  'A" ( ()"!!   !".!" ()(5: !" :?" 5+++ @!)  55 /9! 133I)""   @"" !!)6

   

01,201332 4;0514 5<6 O '!"6; 6 5   " !) ") /(") ' ") ( A ""  !"%" !)) !"(A(!)6 ""( ")A "  )") ! '!"6 <   = "! ( % '/(") " !)"! ('@!")A)"('(('("6 '"""-")'"( -()"!""! ! ()!"%(!S"!$ ")("!/*" (@@"! ")(A('!)C# & 4 O (A"T U9!(/(/!G!AV!G5++, 6;D6 *( !)!%?! !("('/(")( (!"(!"")%")(Q"  )%)% 9?"/ ( ' ") @" %' !"(')/!C E5531,2(6<53213,(61D6!%' !('"/")('!)())%@"()@"* (@(!!()('!(!)((!S !""" (')/! ")("!/('")!)(("/")!9" =A9C E5525II(6153252;(65D6 '!)(!"-!"'"/(-<3N6 !/! %!"(!"6O'"/(-23N/!!"!*)(!" /(")""":3N!(!"-"!4%!"(!""""",3N-!"".!C!"61;65 ("!/A!5!?/! 133<D6 526  !"((/!! !")(=@A!"((!%'"""- ") G*% (" @@! '!)  (/!"  ' KG! ('=!!  "/")!"/- " 6)(" )(A"("!9 "@!(!=6 !  """ -  ") *G% % /"   """ G*% !/%!  /(")   ( R!"6 < 6 5    (" "! 4 - !"  ( " ! !" (" 4   *G% %)%/" - ( (6   (.!   ( )% (R)"" *G% (@ (   ( @@" - !(!G!A !R!4/(")("( ")(A %R!) !!" KG!@" !/(9/")Q!(  % " =A9 (" K"! ()"!)  9?"/" % 9 C E 5315:2QO1335 611<Q@6 E51,1+;D6 O  ?! !( ( "!9 "@! (!= /" ( !"!" (!- ")("!/C E51355+Q  #  5++:   12: 6 15,D6  " "!9 "!" (  ")A! ( @@" *G% !%= !" *G"!%" !  )! %(  RA" (  !! ! R ") ( "!/ %R "

   

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

(9"((= "!".!=A9(R @@!"(/")/(!"!(!"(!)")A!"( ! ( "!/  (G% " !)@"(R !9(") *G"!%(R")"(R(!) !""" (R"!!".! !)""!""")""6 !C5D ( @@" ! ! G!%  (R ! (@ R)"(" ! !)!)(!9C1D(R !"(R")A!"( ""  @"" (  / CID (R)"" *G% !") )/" 9   "G)! "% !%" ")" R)G "  9)!"( !(!)"(@" *G%C !@" !!"!)( (D@C<D(R)G("!""9"!""! @!=!.A(R!""(!(!)G9""() "( "/" " ( @@!" (  ! !) ! !"!  @@" ( "!9"@!(!=CO1333 6522(61Q!!K"6 !)") (61616I@D6 .!%RR9(!)""! "%(A"( "!9 "@! (!=  @@"  ! ?"@!  (!" - (

   

01,201332 4530514 !"" (R!   9 - R= !" *G"! (  (! !A(=(R(%!-R("!"C"?A("AD" ( % !  !) (  ( !! *G% % 4 )A!()A" = !".! ") 4( 4  !""" ( !"!  (!6  RA" !  (R)"9! ( .! 9?"/   " " (  """ *G%R!) "=!!"/")!!G)("!/ A!)  (! %R !"C@6!!K"6 !)")(61616<6"!!K" ")D6  !( ")(!") *G%"!!!(" (  R!) """  9 ( 9 ! "!G!  %" C?!(%D(/!"(%! "=A!(4%R"" /!""/") !!"!(!"!)")A!!(( "!/6(!(9! !)"("( "C!"6<3 E /R!"65+ Q!"6+261/55I"5I1QO1335 6 53;(6IDR("!""?AC("AD!"A!! """(@"()(@!!""")(!"/- ")C!)(D("!/ !)(!-= !)9(! !"( "(/((!"(!6  R   !"! !% R= !" """  "" (   ") ( "!/@()%"!(A"("!9"@!(!=6   "    !"" = "!") ("!"/ " ?(! (R=!/"")!R"")((R ")( "!/ !(()!")A"())")"!A!-R/(")C !"!(@"! *G=""!D%"  !"" ( "(/(!C E51,1++(62QO1333 65<+(6ID""C !"""D( ")("!/ " ?"@) !  !".! ?!(% ()"!"))!) = (6 4 (C E  9)(I3/9!133<:3303ID6

 !))  ?! !( =A  !) @" (R !9(") *G"!%(R")"(R(!) !""6!%R"!9() !@  A  "!9 "@! (!= " %R  !$"   !)" - 4   ""   @@" " ("" ( *(! (!= *GA.   (R !9(") *G"!% @"(R")"(R(!) !""C E5I3I2; E  9)(I3/9!133<:I303ID6 5:6 ' ."! 7777777777'/" !/)5++;(!9(") *G"!%A!/GT'!)6E!" !!(""!%" !".!(" !"?! !((%@!('/(" ( "!9"@!(!=')"" !)6 !"  !".! ( @@" ! ! G!% "4 K"! !"Q  (  !"('")A!"!/G !$"("9'!)*"A!()(

   

01,201332 4550514 9!"(@%! !".AQ!"(!"%" ()"/")""!""!@!) "!@!(!" !(/"!("' !"(@CWA)- ') %(%TD6 '="(')"" *G%!") "K"!('= !"AA)!"  *G"G)!  ) -   !G G!4"G)! "% "  "!/" ! '"!A C@ (')!  @"! ( " " ( !@!"( !""(!=D6

/('9())"("()!!%'/!(  ")("!/?A) ." "%("/")( ") !" !9"K"!=A)(!!"6()(5:!": ?"5+++)""(.!@"""! A))!(!"%' )""(!"(!()!!%'@"15"9!133<6   

   

01,201332 4510514

  +&*1  &*) &+  )  + *

 567   8  /   9: .(" +;   7 

56 )!!!!/96  7

16 !?""6 I6 "% !)(!"A!""6 <6 @!  !" (  %' /" @!! !! "!  !)" !!K" (  () ( I3 ?! (.  "@" !  !() (!)  !9 @)()! ( ! OGJT!G@% : :33<     "! = !6  ()  " K"! !A)6 )! ("X D (%! =""%()!!"()!9"!" (() ""%)Q 9D = ! ! % "@  " /! ((! "" "! ()Q D !"!  A"!   (  ! !)""6 O )!  ""   "!))"))!)  ""! D 9D " D 4(  !9@)()!(! !! "!!".!!!!%' (/!()!!!!/96)!(!!"!!* ( !/ % !" ?"  %  () ""%) " '/  ( %)")=)()!!"C!"65I153:"53;D6  A!@@.!    #!4  V   !)("    !Y      @!( !)"!!K"""@)= !"%'-'@@@)()! (! !A!@@