opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/79/2007

Genf · 2007-02-01 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (1 Absätze)

E. 25  (>''( (M(' F!!; * '(* )  (!&    #$$#5 95  *  )'( *  (! ;)'   ''(  #*A$$;'5 A5 ;'  &'(   >T &)(;'' '' ('  &'!( ''M(   !   2$ :' 7  (; ( &'7  ' F;!!' 6.@X S'@;> %%$$9  8&') ''(7'' ( &F ;'!(E'(5H# ;!!'' ' F;!!'"1 :  #$$A 6 -8V  ! '  ''  (  >'    (; ( /&')(&'(' ?('''(( 'V  ( M(' '!  ' F;!!' &')  &(  &')  !(' > E  (  *'(5 9#  -5  &'!( ''M( (  & 7  &   ''( )>!/&'))(M(': (C*) 5  ?';; 7'    ,\ ]  &'! (     F.    & ;'&'!(''M(((; !E&'(  >TCT;; ;!!' ' &'?';; 

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

           !  !

     

       "#$%%"#%%& '"()"#%%('  '  *'  * *  *+,  # ! $% -. #%%(     !"#$% &'( )!(  *!(+(','   ''(

(' --   * ..    ' /01"#"" "2  (!

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

.&' !;  ()(;   #$$25('(( (@ ' @'?   () (! * ?( ( &'!  (  & &) '  ' ( '('' F&  &'F7 ) ((  (I@ !?7'  &'; > '> 7'(E 5

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

    3#2$$3#$$% 4%3""4 ) &>() (!' (&(')!&'((  (''> * * ( & F   E    *''  &((    &'F &' ?(6('&'()'&@(& (58  .'>(:*  >>&'(( E(F  (!& ' &!:'(5  '- ?E&!'(@ ''? &)() ';;( ''5.M('&!  (:*  >>*C &' 7' *'(@'7  & ?( *(; ( >* ' ' ''( & >* F   (((  & ?(    !')(  '& (  &!'( & '!*&7Q5  K* *  !(!)>* ((' (.&'74)'FE *     >  '&&'( !      &' ) !(' (5! 2$)F'#$$% !(!; E!&'; '5

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

- 8 )' &'F('&&'(! E((' (F &(W(*&&'! ' '?'' (7'(!6 525"V

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

    3#2$$3#$$% 403""4 ?'!)' F&'!&!'(5' (!!(; (!?! ) ?F:? (!@!('( 'E>  &' (& &'FF6 -"#%2%$ 5AF"#A"0A 5#('!;!'V;5

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

    3#2$$3#$$% 4""3""4  * 0' / '  *'  * * 

! 123,, 4   5     67 8&#  9   3,

"5 !'''')F5 ! 3

#5 *((!  "")F'#$$A(#2 #$$%5 25  (>''( (M(' F!!; * '(* )  (!&    #$$#5 95  *  )'( *  (! ;)'   ''(  #*A$$;'5 A5 ;'  &'(   >T &)(;'' '' ('  &'!( ''M(   !   2$ :' 7  (; ( &'7  ' F;!!' 6.@X S'@;> %%$$9  8&') ''(7'' ( &F ;'!(E'(5H# ;!!'' ' F;!!'"1 :  #$$A 6 -8V  ! '  ''  (  >'    (; ( /&')(&'(' ?('''(( 'V  ( M(' '!  ' F;!!' &')  &(  &')  !(' > E  (  *'(5 9#  -5  &'!( ''M( (  & 7  &   ''( )>!/&'))(M(': (C*) 5  ?';; 7'    ,\ ]  &'! (     F.    & ;'&'!(''M(((; !E&'(  >TCT;; ;!!' ' &'?';;