opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/799/2005

Genf · 2005-09-12 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

       

         !

"

      

         #$%&#'(($ #)%%#'((* +,,, ! !,   !,

 -' . " '((* 

 #    !"""## $%&&'()(* +, --./(-$%(( ./ $ /000000000 $%&&'(-' , -- ./(-$%(( ((%/ 

   

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

   

01230"1 4?054 -(%C&($/-(99//-,&-=(-)-&$(-,&-(%(($-%E$($-%/(7"U6

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

   

01230"1 42054 !6 @//8-/7E8((-6

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

-$(:@222P$3&6#$(-6?$&=(/C A#1#;6

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

   

01230"1 41054 :L$&=(/Q6-#!$)%=#""1HP30"!I$(-6161G(%&((%

A !"  !?? $(-6 ?61G &$ S( -$(  '  #""! T P#5" &6 #3 $(-6#622!TP2#1&6?#$(-6!;6 $)(&--$.,/)(8E)(#""!$( 9/-/&(8//--$(-$(:;6(. -(&$(($--(>$(&&&(=%(>-&$/- &> - (= =( $ :6  6 # 6   '; ( ,) & - %L%--(&$(($%/(6 $%=-4(9(8,6#5(9 7  (($ -&($(-J%$ % /-6&6 ?2;6 @$E(&-S&/%($ &/%&($ - $ -$(  (( -  -/( -S / S$8 - %/-(($$)($S(-$((($/8$(==(-  -%-  (($ : '  #""! T P #5" &6 #3 $(-6 #6#6   /9/;6

,&>  $(-$-$(7/&($--/(($- $(9/-/-?%#""!6>$$)($-) (=- /-- %#""18(%&(6  

   

01230"1 45054   +1  !,   !,   2 

6 /.L)=G #6 @-/$%&/&$$W-((8G !6 $-% ((.7&D/%$%-A6!""644((.9(   $(9(($ & &( $%%-/ -/  (= 9/-/ -  @ $.,( -)-/()=6%/%$(-$%($$%$D - &) .( $ E$( (( .  -/(($ ./  ,)$&& - .//C&/-(/$:6!#"3" ;6     899(>F  (AA 

$%- (= =( -  /(-&&/F  P(@ P $&($9$%-&/L$(9(/C&(((.,7,99(9/-/ -/&=(.&899