opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/790/2005

Genf · 2005-09-14 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

         ! "#  $

      

         %&'&%())* +%,-)%())* + " + " .+#  ". #.  ./ ! 0  &0 1 ! ())* 

   !"""#$%& '!'(

!(')      ** 

* "'!' + $'(",- "("#

   

./0/.122+ 31.//3  2 + /4   ( '# 5'%  )       

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

 ::( ! 8'(4 A  8!'! '  5'(("!  8' !9",(!"'!""6 *7 !'#'&8@5("!F( !("&# ('"((@#8;'5'"5( ('!"5'"%'# 5">#8;'5'"5(('!" #"&((:">#8;'(!(@" #("( 5'";',5'>'3"94 /?4  "  !5'("! 5'!  5'(" 8( (  (  /'B"122+ &(  '"9  #4  '!'(  @5"C# H(' 

   

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

   

./0/.122+ 3?.//3 "(4 !(='(40174 :" C"!'5'!#'($#:('%, ('"(!"' !('"'   !& '!"( 855"C  '#'& %  B!'  !('#&",'6)//E=A!"4?9M//1A?2!"4DM

 /==0PAE54A/?!"4A974 +4 C8A/#9'1221 8'(4DE!":##''>'3&""( '&"&(  12 #9' /=D? 6 *M 9'!,# & 8('#  &",'    7 #("( 55"9 5' !," $  '("(("! 5'  '#  5'(("! 8'3"!""F(&'#6)/1?1AM

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

* >( C ! '#'& > @5("! F( !("&# C  ('"(( 5( H(' 5!'"&"$:'#C@#5'"5'%5'"%'5#'"! ('!"4!'55!'(B"(122/ '!(( #&!("!:&!'9""C>''H(#"(4 ("!('C !("("!   5-;!(;#'5" $ '"!  @ # 5' " '"( !;"(94  5-;"(' ('"(( >""C ! 5 C (( :'#C ( #"' !('"'($C>!("(!'55!'(5'##(4%!'  ('"(( "!(B(":""(5','>'(414/ *4 >(!$9!'!"(C>"("##"#'#"'5'(("!$#;9!"' $ 5'("'  B&"' 1221  !"(;"( !" 5'%  ('!" 5'"%' #  5( C  '!'(  9##:""# > ('"((  @ #>;'5'"4

   

./0/.122+ 3=.//3 04 %!'C('"(($'"!@#;9!"'>#("(5$ ;',>'3"!"$5'("'B&"'1221 "'($@"' C("!'("(("!4 

 >5%  >(  (!( #&" 5' ''' 3 ":( 3 C >"("#  !("#$'9!''$'!'(('"((@#;9!"' B&"'$!&9'12214 ((5'";','5!"(::(' 9B'""C5'("(455'(!('C%B"(122/ (!''"'  "3" $  '   >"("# &"( 5'"  #""!  ""('5'(("!$#;9!"'$5'("'B&"'12214  #!"!">'''5":!''"'((!'# C" 5!''"(!("('&"!("!>!9",("!'",'>'(4/?   &",'BC>A/#9'12216'("!&>'(4E0 M :45!'((C("!5!"(="3!74 "" '9!'(5'>"("# 5'(("!"("," ;!'>#((:"(&"#5'"5!"("! >

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

*  5!9""(#('!' "!'#('"9@(!@ ' !" !'# $     ? !&9' 122174  ("(' 

   

./0/.122+ 3/2.//3 "5!"("!('"(!"' 8'(4014/5'"%'5;' 5''"( C"5!"("!(#'" !(555"9@5'(("! !'(@'#:"@#&(!('#&",'4 5("P"' ("#$5'!5!'("(("!3C("!!@ 5"C>('"!   '("(("!   "3" C >@"(  !,  #(# !3C'!NC("!'("(("!5!5'%/' B&"' 122A   !& '!"( ( 55"9 % !' C8" ( ((# '  '("(("!5'%!('#&",'(C9"H'("(("!5!'(' 5'(("!!'#(#'"'(6" *3P!(' !(='(40174

"" >!'' C("!!,5!::("&(5'%/' B&"'122A("!&"(!>55"C'!&'!"(H">#&( ( """(  >"("# >( 5'!"(  122/ ! 1221 ( C 9" H  !,5!'('5'(("!!'#(#'"'(4

>#(( '"9#5(5;''C("!>#&( &"!("!5'>"("#!&!"'>":!''!>'(4/?  >'(4E04 1   5'#&!-( @5'#( C >(!'"(# !5#(( 6 >!''  "3"7'#""!5'%C##"(5'#(# '#5'("! 6)  ! 59"#  /+ ' 122+     02?.2D74 ' !#C(  '!' ' 5'("( "M  #""! ' !55!"("! "(","'!:"'#C'("(("!!"(H('#'# 9"3:!# (  !"' '&!-# $ >"("# 5!' #""! ' ("!  '5!9""(#3B(($'!'&( '"9# (!$!55!"("!3  C>("&"(#$''59':#"4

:" !N'#5'("!'"(#'(#(C'!'( &!"( 5 "9#'#  >!9",("!  '("(' ' (( 9  >"("# ((' #,('C("!'">!9",("!'("(' !>, 9!:!"("(("!"::"" !:!'#($>'(4D 4  

   

./0/.122+ 3//.//3  . #+ 2  + " .+#  ". #. 

 345   6   1     78 &9(#:   5 

/4 #''!''&94  5

14 B(('!'!('#""!'("(("!4 A4  >#(( 'B((    "&# #:""("&  >!55!"("!  !(5-' 5!'"(J2A1/2/?+4 D4 &!"!"'$>"("#5!'#""!'("!'5!9""(# >'(4E0 ('B(((("! 5!'#""!' '">'(4D 4 +4 "(C5'!#'(,'("(4 ?4 :!'  5'("   C> 5&( :!'' '!' !('  5'#( ''H(   #"  A2 B!' %  !(":"("! 5' 5" '!# '#  '"9 :##'  '  *;[" " &'#''"''&94#!"''!'("!'!'!-  5'&  C" '!( B!"(  "" C  #""! ((C# ( >&!55  C#(#@5#"#'!'(6'(4/A1 /2?(/2074  ,'::"' \" 

  '#"(Q "    '#("'3B'"(Q )'##'"C'  !5"!:!'5'#(''H((!(":"#@5'("""C>$>::":##' (#59"C5','::