opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/780/2007

Genf · 2007-07-04 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (1 Absätze)

E. 45 #&?5 ! 6

25 '!"%$%"%5 15 !#!2/%?2330!'%"#5 /5 &D'%"#$"S&!'E$%$+9%>$ $#%!#$!%5 65 !" '%"# D &  %  !"%# ! 4'633 =5 D %% ! !#$5 05 '#""% =E#D233=5 %"D9:!'%"#5 -5 ="  $% !  >T $&% ="  %  $#% G% !  !# ! 13 7 !A  %=% $A ! ? =#!# @9LH9=>0 033/  C $&!"%A!!% $? ="#"%E%5R2!=#!# ?=#!#!4- 7 2336 @)CU  "#" !  !% !>    "%= % "+!$&%$%:%!%!"!%U!% G% !#  ? =#!# $ & $%  $ & #%> E !% ! '%5 /2 )5  $#% G% %  $A  $ ! % &>#"""+!$& !&%G%7%D'&5  :==A     ; 

  $#!%     +      $="!$#%G%%%=#E$%>TDT===#!# !$:==

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

           ! "# $%  &! !

     

       '(()*'+,,) "'-.,'+,,- "  " "#    # 

/0 1 ! (2!33 +,,-    !"#   "$%& #%!!"'#%!!(%    %

% ))     '  *       !+,-   %"#

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

    .//01.2330 *1.41* ="#5 %%$%%!'%$#D$%#$9+>D$%# !'!$%% % !'$$%:  " D  $%# !'%#:% 5  % #:! %"%#>%!$$%J B5  %% >'  !  & $%A ! "! $%$'#!"!%&5'%$$%D  "%% E A: ! :$ % ! A:"%   D  9#95'%&#D'9>'7-7!%&% $%%D$%%$&>#$%55$$%#>' !:% ! %? +%9+">  #%# $# $  $+9%5

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

    .//01.2330 *42.41* E%$'%%%!:%5&%!%% >$%#!%&!%'%'#%%$:=%&"%"%# $!$%9:"%>5 #>% E$%$+9%>'&A#5 435 '%%!!#%%"$A% +!'!#%%>#% !&+D'%"#$"%%S&E$%$+9%> $E$%!#$!%5 445 %?%%$%"%:! !"%#!4'633=5% %+#D%%!!#$5 425  #""% ! 233 =5 % " D  9: ! '%"# > "?   $$%!'%50,54? 5  

    .//01.2330 *41.41*   #"$  " "#    # 

!  3 6/

45 #&?5 ! 6

25 '!"%$%"%5 15 !#!2/%?2330!'%"#5 /5 &D'%"#$"S&!'E$%$+9%>$ $#%!#$!%5 65 !" '%"# D &  %  !"%# ! 4'633 =5 D %% ! !#$5 05 '#""% =E#D233=5 %"D9:!'%"#5 -5 ="  $% !  >T $&% ="  %  $#% G% !  !# ! 13 7 !A  %=% $A ! ? =#!# @9LH9=>0 033/  C $&!"%A!!% $? ="#"%E%5R2!=#!# ?=#!#!4- 7 2336 @)CU  "#" !  !% !>    "%= % "+!$&%$%:%!%!"!%U!% G% !#  ? =#!# $ & $%  $ & #%> E !% ! '%5 /2 )5  $#% G% %  $A  $ ! % &>#"""+!$& !&%G%7%D'&5  :==A     ; 

  $#!%     +      $="!$#%G%%%=#E$%>TDT===#!# !$:==