opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/77/2008

Genf · 2008-01-24 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (2 Absätze)

E. 047    5 C( 0336 :"  (@("  ( (( "7  9<>:!!( = : ("(("-9 )  =<#!!(,#:(,#, 8$((7 =>  ( > 7  &-> -  > :  -(" -  8$"=":(>!(--=(#88&-! "((--">:("( (( - :=7-$#) , (((>:=(>((!(8 : ((>: ( 03 ,   - = (("  (((   "> : 8$ 0:A3387-$ :=;" <-(( :<!(  8$  !!(- "8=;-7  9<>8((!( :  "!-(>:-(- =8((-#>:(7 007 =("# "(!)  "- 42-(!;0336 @( 7-;(<!( "=--"   "--(7 027   !-(-:(( ( 02=!;03367

    *0536*0336,A*5,

((!9 :"&->"="("((#8((  >->: ! "<!(( 8$-8( (   8!7 :(   - >   (("   (""-$>!(  &->(  ((   8 > !  ;   (> =(( ((!( 8(7("(" "- >:;""8( :N (>N7  ! -"(() &->">;(=( ( !-!( =  > - # > : !  (( #

- $<7 ! -8(!>> :-( =>(((!(-"=(#>!!( ( -""!( 88(" ->: :D =( - <7 :" -=( $< 8$ :"#:(((!((-8:" :-9  :" :=(7 8  !   --" >   -((-$< ((!(:=(((":((( :"8(>8$(>(,-((#$<( "( -(7 + -(!9 :"&->">8( :K

-"" !!(-(""-$N (>N 8:-!<" ">" 7 017 : : "("< "#@<7

' %

47 8!"!(#:(7A/74(7$71 <=:<( @ EJ;( ?(( >  ((( -"= # M( A/    8" "   -( <""  (  /(;0333E J(=# 8" "M,!  4.!4551E J7+!-"(- @<  M-9("(;7 07  : ( :(7470(7; :;<(  - $<C( !B!-((>: ! E(70.  J7 <8>: ""(=# ( (- $<!;#:! -$<(<(&!B!  (>::<( " #! 7  :(7 /1 7 4   -"=( >  " -(-( & C( 

-(( (;""8(7-(-(!- !((8&- "E8$J(43I C( "-(8$E>(,-(O(7/170

    *0536*0336,/*5,  J78(8$:(&<"(!((!&!!  >(,-((" ( !("E(7/171 J7 8$ ;:"9=#23387-"=E43274 :  M,! F GJ!(-;(" --# " 8$-"="E8$#-(J A33874:33387 4:A33870:333870:A3387- (E(75274 J7 :-9(-(" 94@=033A-8$#-( !(( 0:A3387-((-#>((!(!" &88("  :"=>((( -((;<( M, ! (#$<# !(( 0:A3387 , #   !(( ( "<!(   -(-(  43I  $>

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

-(( ;8-(B(=>"-"!-!( : !-(!(  : !(( -(; :"= $R : !(" 

    *0536*0336,.*5, (((-""<(!E T -;" /!0330)41A*34 7 2;J7(( (((8: !(( (B((=#:"<  : !(" ((9((, (=-8 ( -!!-(!( : !((  -(>: ( ! 8  ;  -"@  E T 405  2.4  7 674 (  "8" ("J7   :  @ >  ( - = $<" E$(V <J -  !!( W  <!(  "(" "7   (&(  =( : !(( > -  <!( (  - : !(" ( :((  #  >:  ( - 8!  (  =< !-(( $<!("<(8 -(>7  :-9  --?( >: :D  -   <!( " # --!( -!!( (!9 ((;( :(!"7  88(  ( !-!(   "-    ( >:  "(" --("-!9 (>:! ((#-  $<((!( ( :"7(( >:( -"  -("<(=#-(-( &C( -(( (:";""8(-(7"(> <8 (B("<!("("(@("7  

    *0536*0336,5*5,   / .  &' ' ' % &' 

 0 12 (

E. 47 "=;7 12

07 @((7 27 (>-" (<((7 17 8!  -(   >M -=( 8!  (  -"( B(   "  23 @ 9  (8( -9 ; 8" " E+$QR$8>//331  J-= !(9  ( -;8!"!(&(7.0 8" ";8" " 46 @ 033A E TJO  !"!   (  >   !(8 ( !D -=(-(<( ( ! (O ( B(  " ; 8" " - = -(  - = "(> &  (  :(7 10  T7  -"( B( (  -9  -  (=>"!!!D -= =(B(@(#:=7  <889     <((+ '  -" (    )+ ) -8! -"(B(((8"&-(>M#M888" " ("-;>-<88

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

                   

     

       !"# ""#

## ""$ 

%& &' ' ' % &'  ()  *  +,- ""$    !"# $%& ' (

()

*   ++,  -(./012334 (!"

    *0536*0336,0*5, ' .

47   88" -9 )  ++,   +  - :;  ( (?"  " (7 07 4@=033A$8$#-( 0:A3387 27 5!033A (!#)  = (" 0A!033A :!(( 0:53087-((!(  (04 :"7 17  41=033A) 8!" >:-((

-  $   8( -(  B( (! (!( ( >  -(-( " (,-( 43I11373A((J7  "!-( "(""(; "!-((((!(8(  :"033A7 /7 +( #  (""-$  :"  ! (  &-()     8- 40@033/7 67  ( 41@033/ !!9 :"!8(" !"((!(( "!-( 0A!033/>:("#) 7 .7 05@033/) 8!"#:"> "!-("(((( =D"7 57  43@(033/!9 :"=D"=8 "!-(#" !((:"((-#$ "( (( ((8K :!-;(" :!7 437  6C(033/) &->">((!( ((((  -(( # $  (( -((  :; :  =( "(" !! ((!( 8(  7 ,=("(" 88( (9!( "!-(" :"033A>:!-("  0A!033/:"((-=;7 407 :(=) K8( -!((  0:34287.3>:=" (!(# 7 427) ("(;= "!-( ( A(;033/7 &(!   "!-(  8(    E0:342 87 .3J  "(" ! (" (,-( 43I -((8033/(( -9 " (   8$J7  "8(=  !! "!" # :" :"=(#2:60A8753E0:3427.3F8( (9!(-(" 8$033/GH4:35073AF-( 8(  (=#033A ((!;((" (,-(!((((88$("GJ7 417   ()   ((" >: =  =( "(" !!   ((!( 8(  L-((!" 806 @033AE058703J=("("-(":"033/ :B(M" 033A7) 8!":" ((- .@=0336( !!>"  = "!-( ("  A @= 03367 & (!   :" =(#!(( .58723E 88"( !(( 2:60A8753>=(;( "!-(-"" ((  2:.4A87038!( C-9(!("L0:3427.3F8(   (9!( -("   8$ 033/G H 4:45470A F-(   8(    (= # 033A ( (!;( (" (,-( !((((88$("GJ7 4A7 :":(>((" !(( .58723 ( 45@=03367 4/7 (((>  C 2:60A8753:=(-"("-D"-:")  ! "#  :>((#!>:((7 > "((-" 8=8>: "8!( 7 467  45!0336:"((" =2:60A8753"!"(   - ! " >  ( !;"  .5 87 23 -D"  45@=03367

    *0536*0336,1*5, 4.7  "8! A=0336) 8!"-(,#=> :" =( :>((  !((  2:60A 87 53 -  8(   ( 2!(41@(033/7 457  41!0336:"8!"--(#(( "7 037  "--( 2@(03368!" "  A= 03367   8( !> >: :"(( - ((" >  ((!( ( :""((( : (((((#((-(( ; " :(((   ((!(  8( "7"  "!-("(;!>(-8  (" ( -=(  ( 88("  !-"$7  

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

- $ > :-( =>(((!(-"=(#>!!( ( -""!( 88(" ->: :D =( -     -((-$ 8$(>(,-((#$ ">8( :K

-"" !!(-(""-$N (>N 8:-! " 7 017 : : "("   ((( -"= # M( A/    8" "   -( : ! E(70.  J7  : ""(=# ( (- $ ::   " -(-( & C( 

-(( (;""8(7-(-(!- !((8&- "E8$J(43I C( "-(8$E>(,-(O(7/170

    *0536*0336,/*5,  J78(8$:(& (,-((" ( !("E(7/171 J7 8$ ;:"9=#23387-"=E43274 :  M,! F GJ!(-;(" --# " 8$-"="E8$#-(J A33874:33387 4:A33870:333870:A3387- (E(75274 J7 :-9(-(" 94@=033A-8$#-( !(( 0:A3387-((-#>((!(!" &88("  :"=>((( -((; 

-((!((!&! >(,-("(( 63387-"= E43270(5270 J7  -(-( & C( (  - ((  -(-( 8 - :,! 7  ( "  : (:"((- (=(  4 @= 455/ ( - > :" : # :"-> ="  -(-( & C( # : " E$  + )P=$ --"((--;; #  8$ ;  233 87 >:& 8$ # -( - "=" E  455.)02-7A/J7  "  =( :B( "" :(  # @( (( > :(!"8("#:": :;!(( 8$$(>(,-( 43I!(( "-(0:A3387 27 =(#-"( :&!>:(=":(!"   "!-(8 ="8:(&(7 :-9 "!-(((,-(7">>:8( !-  ((!(#$= &"=( "-(  "!-($>-((!" 8(  (#>"(" 87 :(>:=(! 8:(!"  &-! "!-( !>:8(-""!(( !98!((  A

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

    *0536*0336,.*5, (((-"" : ( ! 8  ;  -"@  E T 405  2.4  7 674 (  "8" ("J7   :  @ >  ( - = $  -   :  ( - 8!  (  = 7  :-9  --?( >: :D  -    :  "(" --("-!9 (>:! ((#-  $ :( -"  -("  -" ( M -=( 8!  (  -"( B(   "  23 @ 9  (8( -9 ; 8" " E+$QR$8>//331  J-= !(9  ( -;8!"!(&(7.0 8" ";8" " 46 @ 033A E TJO  !"!   (  >   !(8 ( !D -=(-(  &  (  :(7 10  T7  -"( B( (  -9  -  (=>"!!!D -= =(B(@(#:=7   M#M888" " ("-;>-<88