opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/775/2006

Genf · 2006-09-14 · Français GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

        

      ! "#

      

         $%&'($)**+

$&&+$)**' !!

 !    !   ,-  % # (. /- )**' 

  !"#$%&$'!!'' (&$)$# *#'$' +, #!#$

!$# --     (..    # /!01 "!$234 5355   56 '$'&

   

7618573994 :3759:  0

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

   

7618573994 :1759:  !

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

500 $'!!$$$$(&%$ EE#%$'!!&$$$&; 8; !%'$"#!&#@P&%$'!E#&P'%''$&!"$$"!#P $#!'&$*!'%$M&$*!E&&#!"#'!#% &$*! 'F$ ! &$*! "&'B'>;  *!'F   &$*! &"  $$$  =&&B'''# "!$$'   #$M #& F#S$  $'%'$& #$'% @ $" !"$ #&F#S$$'%'$&#$'%@$""#$' #&!$'B; &'>P#&""#$'$@P!P$#$#!'$&E!#'B!$'!

   

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

   

7618573994 :59759: !  1 0  !    !  

# 234 -- 5  /     6 7 (') "8  4 -

5; &##!##%=; # 4

3; ($"#$'$!'&#$; 6; %!'   @ (BB' $!  (#:'%''$& @ *#E "!#  #'#  "#!&# @  !% >H$ &E?# $  ## '$  !%&''!; 2; ! P'$'& @ %## @  #!#$  !  -#;5(999 :: @ $'$#  &"; 4; B!#  "#$'   >P "%$ B!## #!# !$#  "#&$ ##H$   &'  69 I!# ?  !$'B'$'! "# "' #!& #&  #'= B&&#  #  .*U'G#*!B>' 8  8992     $#!' F"'#;  &'  "$ H$# "#!!E&;  &!'# !'$M D ''># F$$>&''!#!#$&'#!=$'#'$"&''! $$>&N =D F"!# "!# > !$'B ' $' "!%!'# # $$ $# &''!N D "!#$#  'E$# !   ! #"#&$$; .'  &!'#  !$'$ "  $#!' &&$ &&#& ! $$# D =D $ D ':   #'=B&&##"!##"$##$'?###!#>P' %#&##'##%=;&!'##!#$'!#!#!/  "#%  >' #!$ I!'$  '' >  &''! $$>& $ P%!""  >&$&F"&'&#!#$C#$;563 598$59 P@PBB'B&&# #!'"#E#BB