opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/754/2004

Genf · 2004-09-28 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (2 Absätze)

E. 24 !#

55555555556  # 7. ( 2*826 9. &  :; #  ((.# # &% <    < #  2*==4  %  .     &%#.#&# (& 2  : 2*=*  >2  2**?4   #  @( A# & #   (# (&  &#B C  D &%.# 2**0  00 # 2**>6 & , ' # , . :(4 E ## (& .#, 2??F  &(G'% = G# 2**H4   :#  :B :#  * # 2**34

E (&# #  6    5555555555 6 &   & 3 # 2**8, %  # & %AA#   & %/#.#&# (I#/- % J6 ( &#B # #.  K &# <#  #. & %( &# 6    # &  #AA &   ( &# 6 :# B# B< #BL, ((# #6 # &# (B( @ #.@ >/H  H/36 # &# #   )  %(B &  # 3 B<6 &# <# 20/26  :# (# I. :: A# &##J6 &(B(( &# >/H  H/36 B# & %(B .# (# & >  H  ( @#/&(#A4    #( ## (& .#  #- &#  * # 2**36   (# '%  #.# ((B-6    # #  

& <B & (# & (,  ( &  (4

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

/ >122/

1203+12***  ( B<  H/36  :# (# 4   A( ' #.  K C  &   @6  .   (& #B & / B## (  B &(#  <B )<B- <N  <  # &  # &  & - :4 %(. # )<# #'   (.#& & : &  # (  ( &(#A4

  6 #  #&((&%# # ()4 IMJ % .   : )<# #' '#  &(#   # (& .#  #&(  &# # '# %(#    #.# (<)#' &   # %  & # #  

& <B4

  6  :- )<# #' %  # #.#&  %( &(G, (#( #- A# .  #   #&( &.# (. A.: D4 (&, & ' #  ##-6  @    #('    & :- <)#'  )<#'6 %(( #  # (& .# & +?, =?F &   #.# ((B-6 

& <B    %  & # #6  &  A# & #4 A#6  # (& %(6   -     :#.  &# &#AA##  #  9. &  A#6, %@ # &% #&   '# # A.#  (# (B # &  & A# IA4  &%@ # & 0H O 2**=J4  (, & ' # (   (&# # & % 6    !55555555556  @   #&#'(K C  .    &   (# # '  A# & #   & <)##  & : .#   '';< (#A#' .#:  %# (4  #   .:    #  # (& .# & +?, =?F4 IMJ  # (& .# @#( #/&  AA #.4  (# #  (#  .#B: - #, '  # D IA4 # & !  & 0 .: 2**=J4

H4    55555555556 &  # & +  2***  & # & %(6 !"  # $6  #&#'('%#) .#  /#&# #    #, AA   (# & #6 '#  # 

& <B &4   A#  #('% .# ( # .# ((&&(   55555555556 <#B#4

34  &(## & 2H  23 G# 2***6 %   )(, %(    #- &%#.#&# (& 2   >2  : 2**H6 & 2 # 2**3  >? .# 2**86 #  &#/  &%#.#&# (& 2 # 2**8  >?  : 2**=6 ## ' &   ( #  (  A 4  .#  AA ( ( ## ( & .#,  # & 00  2**>  .# & &# 6 -  &(# &  &% (6,     #- &%#.#&# (&-  2  2**H4 -  + O 2**H & 6 # .# .( # ( & .# &   #.# ((B- 

& <B6   %  &

/ H122/

1203+12*** # #6  &  A# & #4   

 &% &B(& 2??F .# ## ((#( &- '  # & .# <) <(#'6 #: @#B#:6 .# &(# #6 # &-  2 .: 2**H4  BB. # & %( &  (& %(6  * # 2**3 %.# P<(, .  & .#4 A(, % # 0*:# & -B  %/#.#&# (6  &#,     #- # &-  2 # 2**36 # &-  # G & %BB. #4 -  2 A(.# 2**86 %(.# .( # ( # & .#  .# &(# &#,  &#/   &%#.#&# (&#  2 # 2**84  @ # (&# .# #  ((&(6 '# #,   # &, &  #  #.# (& # & 2??F6 .  & &##(, +?  =?F &-  0H G# 2**=4

-  (#& & #  6 # &% #&(   )<# & #, '  #6  (# # (# .#B:4 - 6  ( &(' %#.#&# ((# & %& & 03F6 &B(#AA#  # #  &# @   #

6  &#/  &%#.#&# (.# ((#(6 . AA  >?  : 2**=4

84  # & 2> O 2***6 %(6 ( ( !"  # $6      &(##4   A# .# '    55555555556 '    5555555555 %.# &(6 .# &#B #'( <# &# H/3 /(&# B< @( &#  6 '# (# #  # . # <#B#4   (# (# &(G, .##:    & 2**36  # #  4  + G# 2***6   .# :# %# . # <#B# (.  ( # &#  ## ( & .# G'% 8 O 2***4 %P & .# # P  B(  (&# #  4 %  .# & &  &(## & 2H  23 G# 2***6  #   &  . ( &  (4    , % # &%    #- &%#.#&# (G'%,  A# & %( 2***6  ( &  (  &B(&%## (& .# &. P   ((.( . '% . &(##  # #4

+4   (.# & 2? G.# 0???6 %   A# .# '6   (&# #6    !55555555556 # A# .#  #  #  ((. ' (#  # ((#& & .#6 # , %# . # <#B# & %<# &#4

##6 %  .#   (' %( &  (& %(%(# BB.(&# %@ # !  AA (  # & G# 2**=  #  # &   A# &   %(,  . @ #4

=4  # & 2+ G.# 0???6 !"  $  A# .# '  &  %# ,  # &  (& G'%, ( # &  ( # &%@ # & ! 4

/ 3122/

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

   #'6  @  #,  BB. # #   &# G# 2**=6 # .   , %(  (#4

  )<# #'6  ( &(#A) . )&  #' (#   (4    &@ @ # (#  & ((  )<B#' .@4   (Q#     -B & ) R (.'  : &(# #  S #  &# & .#@ '#  &(.##   '# & #4    )<B#' :# %(. # & )<#    #  (.#&  A # & # ()< #'6 '( %B# & &  #  &  4

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

/ 8122/

1203+12*** 2?4    5555555555  &  & & %#  # & &# (   ##   & 

E/ 6 (#('% #  (&# @ (    55555555556 @ )<# 6 .# ((#  #&4  #  .# #  (# #      )<#'6 . &## # & <# #4    5555555555 ,  (B& G ('   # %.#  @#( (# 6 &  &#6 .#  & <# #4

224  & :. # ( # & 2=  : 0??06 %  % (A((,    &  (&# # &

E. 28 GB 6   #: A(&(  0+ G.# 0??H I U 2>?  2?8J6  & # B.#  & (6  2> A(.#6  &## # # # B     #:   &  # & #(B  , # GB # #6 6 & %   & %( # & .@ GB 4 E      & &# :#6  #: A(&( 6 &  P & 2 G# 0??H6 A#('  &## # # #  # #   #    #  (# A6 & " 6  &# A(&( IP 24 2=>10??HJ4 % &  # # (.  % 4 280  '  #: & (    &  (  4 04 A(, % 4 > 4 > &  # B.# &#A#  #  %B# # G&### IJ & 2H .: 0??06  (  .#B  2 O 0??>6  (  6 # &#   2> O 2*** &.  ##   &    #- &% E/ 6  ((# &%AA#  #: & ( IA4  4 38  4 2  4  <40 J4

E (  GB &  &%-  ## (:#4

  # G (   #  .: I # =H  E  8*  J4 >4  # A(&(    # B(( & &# &  # I J6 & 8  : 0???6   (  .#B  2 G.# 0??>    "(

/ =122/

1203+12*** &#A# # & : &## # &  &# & %/ #.#&# (4  (B# #  .#B G'% >2 &(: 0??0 &  A# &(#   %-4  AA 6 &%-  G#&6  (B# # #:   & <B & -B & &#    '# (#  .#B  &  (# # & %( & A# '# &# P  (#(G#&#'  '#  & (' G#&#' I U 203  H8+ #&4 26 208  288 #&4 H:J6  A#   ' % # (&   P  (,   &  & &% (& &  & &# &##  #A (  # @ '#   &#  G'%  &  &(## &##  #. # #B# I U 202  >88 #&4 2:J4

@  & V 4 H  6 V#.#&# (  &## # &  # (& B#6 ((    & B &(6 '# (  &V  # ,   (<)#'   6 . &V #A## (B(# 6 &V &#  &V #& 4

V(/  &#,     #- V#/  #.#&, 88 01>F  #6,  &#/  V#/  #.#&, 3?F  #6 ,  ' &   V#/  #.#&, H?F  # I 4 0= 4 2  J4    (#:6  #.#&# (& H?F  # . &#,  &#/  I 4 0= 4 2:#  J4

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

E  G#&6 & :  A &@ . 6 &  # # 6 .'  ## (& .# I U 20?  22* #&4 01 S E E 2**+ 4 +3S  ! 2**8   038 4 02+  4 #&4 3 

/ *122/

1203+12*** 8J4   :   &   (B# & AA # )<#'6  '  @ # )<# #'   ## (# '& # %B# &    %## (& .# '%#   #: &% " IE 0??? 4 28?6 #&4 H:J4

 (B&6  & #  &(#  &(# ;< & %@ / (&#/6 ' #/#//# &#      - #.#& & :  A4 E !E! 6    )<# #'6 %@ / &#   &#B # &  & &% #A# #       &B(& B.# (& %AA #4 /  &# (.   - @#B#: &  #  %(/ &%  #.# ( #.4   # #&   & &#. # -6      &  # ((  & #  (:#&6  :#&# ()<# #'6 & AA #  <#'6    &%# (B # #6  (.  A# #(&  &#6   - <#' & /#  (## &:6  &( & # ( &  &# . & ) R  :   (. #6 %(< & #   A @ -B & % 4   & # - (# ( A&   # &(A.:4 A#6 %@ / &# %@#   & )<# &   @#(4

 & 6  & # & A &%   &# (B   &#AA(  # -4

 : & @/# A#B  &#.B    & &(#      :.(6 %(B # &%#  & &   (# #' & .B6 %: & && & #6  B& &#.B    #A # A#    #     & %-6  A# ' & #  - &(  #. # ##: %@ /6 ## ' %(B # & & <&# B( .# )<# #  I!E! 6  A E WB K B#< /&/[)<# #<]  < 6 E E 2***6 4 2  4  2?3  4 S E 0??? 4 233 #&4 0J4

 .#   &B(&%#.#&# (6 %&##  # I / GB6 %#)    J  :# & &  '  (&#6 (.  # &%  (## 6 &#. # A#4 ;< & (&# # ,   GB  %( &  (, #&#' & '    '  #.# ( %(/  #: & .#4   6  &( (&#  #   ((  #  &(# ' .@   6 #: 6 @#B & %(/ I U 203  082 #&4 H6 223  2>H #&4 06 22H  >2H #&4 >6 2?3  23= #&4 2J4

 ##6 / GB  %(    #A #( #A & # &% @ # (&#6 ;< & %@ / ( (#( &    # (#,  &## # &  G # A# & %(#     (&#@ &% ( & A# &(4 E  G#&6   #   # & %(  &% @ # G&###  A# ' /#  # &  &# #6  '% @ # &(   #:  #A# 

/ 2?122/

1203+12*** # & #- .# 4   6 ' &%  (##  (  & ##  #  ,   (#  &    # & &(& # & %@ /6    @6   6  # ( # &#.B  & # &  &#  / GB 6  :#6  #  # ( #   A &% . @ # (&# I U 22=  0*? #&4 2:6 220  >0  4   (A(J4 H4  %6    ((#, &@ @ #6  0H G# 2**=   0= # 0??04

  '%   &@ @ #6 & ((  )<B#' .@  .4     ##- ((  ('%# @# # <N %(/&, & :  A &@6  :#&# ()<# #'6 (   A  G %,  # &% #.# (4

#  @   /# 6 &   & 0= # 0??06 '  # (& .#  &(#  >?F6  ' ' # % #.# (#&((4

:   # # & %@ #6 %   #&(('  &(## # #B# ##   &#,     >?  : 2**= &.# P  A#(4  %,  (B& A&(  &( # &    5555555555 & 0*  : 0??06  '  #  (&# @ .# #  (# #      )<#'6 . &## # & <# #4

34   &#    &    5555555555 & 2+ .: 0??06 '# -   ((& .#  &( '% @ # )<# #' # <# :4  #B ' %  %     &  #  <)#'    ## )<B#' & (# & # & :"  & #  ##   ( &%@ # A# '%# # &(#(#  #  (&# @ #  # ( 6    # % 6 & .#, .4

84  #: & (      ( &  '  #  (&# @  #  (# #   & : )<B#' #  (.#& &  & @ #4  .# & ,  (B& ' %  #  # & %# # &  : '  (&# .#  #( # (& .#, >?F6 ' ' # % #.# (#&((4

U &-   &    ' % # &%     G #A# 4    ##  A&(4

/ 22122/

1203+12***  -)3 ) -)   -  -

"

78   9  /   :7 $;%  !

  8 

24 (   .:4 " 8

04  G 4 >4 # '  (&  B # 4

H4 A   # &  'V . A     ( P &  &(# & >? G &-   #A# #  # &(&( #: A(&( & 6 E<X#N<A'# 86 8??H   6  # @#4  &(#   P  B(4  (# &# K J #&#' @  ' &(##   &(# : #  #   &  &(##  '(S :J @  ' #A #  # .# &&     &(##S J   #B    &  (  4 E#  (#   #   # ((  (((    J :J  J #/&6  #: A(&( &         #-    'V# &. &( #.:4  (# &   #  ) & .6 '#  G# 6 ## '  &(##  '(  V. & '   ((@(&#(   I 4 2>06 2?8  2?= J4

 BAA#- K !#/#  $

 (#&  K # Y   

 ( P  #'(  #A# # @  #6 ## '%, %AA# A(&( &    BAA

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

    

    !"   !" 

        

#$%&'#$((()#'&*#%++* ,)

) -)   -  - " %. /  %++* $0 -1 

  

" 2222222222   !"  # $   % & &' # (# &##

 

33- -)   4-56 ) # #(&###( & ) *+, -.

/ 0122/

1203+12***  3) 24 !#

55555555556  # 7. ( 2*826 9. &  :; #  ((.# # &%  2  2**?4   #  @( A# & #   (# (&  &#B C  D &%.# 2**0  00 # 2**>6 & , ' # , . :(4 E ## (& .#, 2??F  &(G'% = G# 2**H4   :#  :B :#  * # 2**34

E (&# #  6    5555555555 6 &   & 3 # 2**8, %  # & %AA#   & %/#.#&# (I#/- % J6 ( &#B # #.  K &# /H  H/36 # &# #   )  %(B &  # 3 B /H  H/36 B# & %(B .# (# & >  H  ( @#/&(#A4    #( ## (& .#  #- &#  * # 2**36   (# '%  #.# ((B-6    # #  

&  2  : 2**+4   B  ((#   # (&#  &  & 2+  : 2**+4  @  A#  #  # #.  K C IMJ  %(    ' &%:. # &   &( & '   (   #.#&4  A#6   #(&# &  ## (#'  " .(, %( 4 %# (( A# %:G &% #- @ # #&#### AA (,  ###' (&# #.# #, 4   ((#, &@   # (##(6 % & B#  %  & ) 122/

1203+12***  ( B 2  : 2**H6 & 2 # 2**3  >? .# 2**86 #  &#/  &%#.#&# (& 2 # 2**8  >?  : 2**=6 ## ' &   ( #  (  A 4  .#  AA ( ( ## ( & .#,  # & 00  2**>  .# & &# 6 -  &(# &  &% (6,     #- &%#.#&# (&-  2  2**H4 -  + O 2**H & 6 # .# .( # ( & .# &   #.# ((B- 

&  ?  : 2**=4

84  # & 2> O 2***6 %(6 ( ( !"  # $6      &(##4   A# .# '    55555555556 '    5555555555 %.# &(6 .# &#B #'(

G#  8  : 0??24   A# %:G &%   # (##( & B#     5555555555  & ) ?F6 ' ' # % #.# (#&((  # .  & % #  ) ?  : 2**= &.#  (' P  # 4

204  & :. # ( # & 00 .: 0??06    #B('  ( %(# BB.(# , %# . #  4  #: & ( 6  P & 0>  : 0??>6 G ( 4 2H4 %( # G ( - & #: A(&( &  I U JS # , % # & %( # & #N GB  & #:   &  # &   & -.   #: A(&(6  0+ G.# 0??H6  U 6  P & 2 .# 0??H6  ( GB &   #: & (  .)(  A# '%#    &  # # A,  #4

  ) 24  # B.#  %B# # G&### IJ  ((&#A#(   # # (6 &-  2 O 0??>6  #:   &  #6 (& 3 GB6 &  (#&   .#/(#& 6 3 (   28 GB  I 4 2  4

 38

J4

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

/ =122/

1203+12*** &#A# # & : &## # &  &# & %/ #.#&# (4  (B# #  .#B G'% >2 &(: 0??0 &  A# &(#   %-4  AA 6 &%-  G#&6  (B# # #:   &  88 #&4 2:J4

@  & V 4 H  6 V#.#&# (  &## # &  # (& B#6 ((    & B &(6 '# (  &V  # ,   (F  #6,  &#/  V#/  #.#&, 3?F  #6 ,  ' &   V#/  #.#&, H?F  # I 4 0= 4 2  J4    (#:6  #.#&# (& H?F  # . &#,  &#/  I 4 0= 4 2:#  J4

#   # ,   () 2= #&4 06 4 >02 #&4 26 4 H0H #&4 2 S  2**0 4 2=0 #&4 0   (A(J4

E  G#&6 & :  A &@ . 6 &  # # 6 .'  ## (& .# I U 20?  22* #&4 01 S E E 2**+ 4 +3S  ! 2**8   038 4 02+  4 #&4 3 

/ *122/

1203+12*** 8J4   :   &   (B# & AA # ) H #&4 06 22H  >2H #&4 >6 2?3  23= #&4 2J4

 ##6 / GB  %(    #A #( #A & # &% @ # (&#6 ; 0  4   (A(J4 H4  %6    ((#, &@ @ #6  0H G# 2**=   0= # 0??04

  '%   &@ @ #6 & ((  ) ?F6  ' ' # % #.# (#&((4

:   # # & %@ #6 %   #&(('  &(## # #B# ##   &#,     >?  : 2**= &.# P  A#(4  %,  (B& A&(  &( # &    5555555555 & 0*  : 0??06  '  #  (&# @ .# #  (# #      ) ?F6 ' ' # % #.# (#&((4

U &-   &    ' % # &%     G #A# 4    ##  A&(4

/ 22122/

1203+12***  -)3 ) -)   -  -

"

78   9  /   :7 $;%  !

  8 

24 (   .:4 " 8

04  G 4 >4 # '  (&  B # 4

H4 A   # &  'V . A     ( P &  &(# & >? G &-   #A# #  # &(&( #: A(&( & 6 E 06 2?8  2?= J4

 BAA#- K !#/#  $

 (#&  K # Y   

 ( P  #'(  #A# # @  #6 ## '%, %AA# A(&( &    BAA