opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/73/2005

Genf · 2005-02-02 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

              !"       

         #$%&'#())$ #*%#())+   ,- ,,-  , - +.  /0  ! (12 ())+ 

  ,3,,-- 4  - 3,  ,  , 5 3  $)'"$    !"#$%&!'()$*(**   ** +  &! 6666666666 &+%!%, -! ./0!1 0 !&+   6666666666&+%!%, -! ./0!1 0 !&+   76666666666 &+%! %,, 2 3  /0! 1 0 !&+   04 56" +  !!   & 0!0 78888888888 4  9

   

:*; >* "(:*(" , 3 *? & 0!0788888888885 "%@A& 0!09B !%&-!/C!B! &!! &!D0/ ++-  1&  B! +! ++&-  ?,&  8888888888 0! !  ! &++ +  !!   & 0!0 @  *= &B+- *##$,& ,8888888888 E  ! !  (*B *###*>B (>>*!,& 8888888888+F+! !(*B  *###;*+ (>>>?,& ,88888888880! !%0 !& 0!0! !& +  !!-004   ! D!  B ? (?  *( GB  (>>>  & 0!0  &++ 10 E 

   .    /   " 

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

   

:*; >* " >(, ,8888888888!8888888888&!0!+ 0   + !& ! E  &!?  &! 6% 10 1,&  88888888880! !!0& /+  !! && 0!0 & 1 !0  0D  400?  B ! 0!0     %&-   D! &  /+  !! && 0!0?,& ,8888888888/B !4&! &01/!! 1/+  !!  4 ! !,&  8888888888  !! 1 %&- !C 1? /!0  &  /+  !! &   & 0!0 ,&  8888888888B !%0 0+!%&-!-004  %&4 & +/ 0D 400?/B !%@ED! && 0!0@0-! +!,& 8888888888?  B !% 0+  &0E  !! & 0%-?%&B!+% &- D! &B  MB !&++ 0D DDB?   &!&G! +?

* >(,&  8888888888 /! 0D+! 0!+ 0   +  / ! +0  &!  G!  " ?   0%0!0 /B&  % 06 4&+! &! BE& 0!0+D0&+-+?

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

   

:*; >* "=:*(",&  8888888888  00 1,& ,8888888888 B ! +  !0 0D+!/!& 0!0?&% +! B !L!!4B!,& ,88888888881B ! %&0 1  !00 ? &+% !  %%&1& ,& ,8888888888/B !%4 !!40  &! ! &  E    & +F+ 1/  B ! 6%0+! !! 0 & !!! &4 !1/ 4 !4 ?+&N,& ,8888888888 /B !%&0 !E+ B !0+  &0R% +! B (>>>?,& ,8888888888&!!00! &44 +!1/ B !%I0 1/& B !+0%I!1,& 8888888888/0! !%%!   & 0!0 %& !!  &?   0D+! &!!0 B&    &+%!- %&? &!0!0&4 +0%,& 8888888888?

* S  &! ! & &%& !F!0B!+!&B!%! 4+ 4  !?

B!! 4&+! &%! &!1 % &/ !! & ? *'? &&*'B (>> > > > > > 4?='?&& 0!04!-  0!00 B0?  +&!! &++D/0! ! + 0!/0B !%1/E#/'$)4?$>? %  +0% / !! &? *#?  &&  ' GB  (>>'   -  0  &0  ! E !! +?  

   

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

   

:*; >* "*(:*("    3 - ,- ,,-  , -

! 8/:1:  ;   9   1: 

*? 0+B-? ! 1:

(? M+!X;? @B&%%& ! &, ,8888888888!8888888888E& #/'$)4?$>X =4?'>X '?  !1%&0!D! !X =? 4&+  %!    1M %B! 4&+ & &!  %0! F!   0  ;> G& @  &! 4 ! & % %  &++0 0  - 400   CZ RC&41  = =>> =!*>$9?  D44 @A  7] [   0 !A ,I ,    &% &4&+%0!F!!&! 4 06%!   1MEM44 400 & %D44