opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/716/2004

Genf · 2004-09-14 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (3 Absätze)

E. 06 3 ;+--? (#$(#(4#@# #" "#$ $ #A ,  '(' "#      B " 4   # "(  8888888888'$# #&$" %A '# 9()3  % **

E. 7 6 +16 *$, %###"$(#$ % "$"(#$### 0+ 011GJ R###6 ++6 ("$+;J$011G (#$(#($,(<$ "#,$3 $#(#$"3 ++--- "#4#/, % #$( ($ "  6 *%$/ $  J$$"( "$ A$  @"  " $( 9() 3 ! : #$<$ ((34 ""$#$A ##@#"#B " %3( (#($#"$ 7 $46 +06 #"$0GJ$011G % (#($$J"$(#$$ "4 #6 +26 (#$"$+2J$ 011G  A$ "(""$(#$%  $4$/('#'$, %'$($ ,<$# (#$#"$  &4""$01#D011G6 +G6 3#"(#$, %  0.#D011G ($&", J$&6

   

5+..150110)G5-)    "

+6  #&4#$ %#&#J$"(9:#"@$"3 +#D0112$ A$ (# "$(#( (##";J$& "#$"$4()";$ +HJ$&$96+ 6;H :6 *$, %$ #" % (#"+HJ$&$  ! 0.J4 011G9 !+21+1H: " # &4#"# +2@4011G$ "###$&$ A$ "&$, #J$&$ (" %" % (#"#$4$LJ$&$ 96+H0:6

*$$$(#$""#$A (  !"$B"$+J$ 011G (#@<$ "###(#$ # $#  $#  (#@#"$(#P$"#@" 9B+6+?25011G:6 06 #@#, E6;H "     A$  " ( $  ( $<$#3"E$()4 "6(#("$ A$  "("3 #A #$('"$ &6 26  4&$$ +J40112 (A $("%3(6 G6 #" @#" 4$  # (#$(4A ,  @#6;HH1 :6;6  (#$ "",  4# (#P $ (( " 4  " ?1I (#$  7 (#<$ "#,$36 " "#("(' <$#" %L("%$4 "$"  $ #$A ##@#"#$ #$$L/$"@K#$6 :<$(#$4 %$()4 ""#"#,"# A$"@"($L6#$J$&"<$#J$"<$<$#  #& "%$(   J$& " $( #(  "#4 "3 #  A $ " "#($ <$ # A     " "(

E. 9 ! #$A "$0+4 011G ($?.1510 ! #$A "$ ?J$ 011G "  ($  0?0512   0?2512: " #$A  ##@# "#$ #$$L $4 " ( ((#( (#"$, $ (( " 4 6 #$A  " (&#"@@(#/('<$#$ <$ $L/('<$((<$" E&"  ##( $ E(( " 4  <$E  # $(A  "EP 9*01116+H1(#"6GASB6"$+0011G", $A (# H?2512(#"606060 B(:6 #$""@@($ 3" $4,A  EL(""#$ $   $AJ(4" E$ $@@#$J$@$4 "93#$ :6 ("" EL"$"#$L#" E$(#(  E &#""#$ $ "#B(#@"#A4#"( (#($,"@$"<$# $ (# " ( "# $L #  $ B $ " 3 (#@#, E& ""$6 #"EL ("E$/('<$/4 $"  ") "#$A ##@#"#$ #$$L)$(#"#J$"<$ ((#$(#$A$@@#$<$ E#$ "<$E$ #" (("4 4B$((34 "6  @@  #  J$$"(  #$A  ##@# "#$ #$$L 

   

5+..150110)H5-) EP3& & $ #" #&$"$" ((" 4 #$4(#"$,$4 "$" E6G 6+ 9 %6? :6L(#,(("" $ (#T # E#"$"( #$A ##@#"#$ #$$L@4( $ 4<$"E$#"4$#AJ(@ 4 $"((" 4 $<$)#$4"("$ ##$"EL&#) $#A BL&" E$#$<$E B$#A  #$ #(9 !+10+H;S*011+600G(#"60A @(S B6((#"606062 B(S(@6$ !+0.0-?(#"6G( @:6

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

   

5+..150110).5-) " (#($# (6 % "  "$ (#$  @ %#AJ "%L #@#"6 %$#"4$'$# #&<$ (("4 (#=$4" .1I"+11I"$(4 &36 4('$  /('<$  (("4  ($ $ 6%L 4 %A("%@@(# /('<$ # "     @$ #AA  "% &( $(#  /## #&@L"$ $$  & "$6%L 34M %LB@A O "#$(/('<$ ($  ##(3#A6

 %$" (""(#$ "( 4$ (#$# L#$$"$#" (("4 "?1I( "%$ # " 4$ & #A 6 #$ "#   $#  $  $ (4 #(($#  6 *%& "$ "&#( " #$A  ##@# "#$ #$$L #  %3( %L("%$(##A"/('<$"#B"B<$#$ )#A"6 4('# (3" ('#(" "$ ""#$ $$##( M3#AOM %LB@A O"#$(  /('<$ <$% ($  %$ " #/ '$<$  ( #" %/('<$9@@:$4" " 4  # "  $ ('(6  (#<$(  (#($#    L, %$" $(""(#$ "( "#4B$4 #$A ##@#"#$ #$$L(#"(#4 " %3(6  $(("$ "4 "01I"$(4""#B$6 .6  # <$   (#($# "$ 7  #   $ (#A  4(  #"($L@&$$"##4(( $"$8888888888 /(', %L($#"$#A *7 7 6

(## (#4" <$ "("*7 7 #  $#"4 4( %@@(6*(@% 34#, 4 $ #A" $L @$ 4("<$% %&""( ""( (#$$" J$$"($# "#(<$ $ /4$L$"(#"()"$9(@6

*522;5011G"$++011G:6 $ "("*7 7  (# "&#(##((34 "$$ #@<$    $   7     "$ # " % 6 $($ &$##$    $'$6% /A 4#  $ '$# #&<$ A <$%$ /('  (, %L6  (#  %L%$($4 $#A$ ($ %L@@($6

   

5+..150110)?5-)  $L "E4 " "$ (#$ (##"  %#(($(, ( $ " # (( " 4  4$  (#($# "$ 7  # ?1I #$(& <$ #$4 "#,$3$" %60? 6 $(<$(3" (#$" "(#" % $  %#@@( 4,( ($  "$6(#$<$#A&"($"#," "@L %3(,+E?11@69(@6 !+0H++@(:6 VVVVV 

   

5+..150110)-5-)  # " 4 "  #"   # # 

% 809   :  2   5& (.) ;<

  9 

+6 ( (#$(4A 6 % 9

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

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

          ! "#! $%&

      

         '()*+'),,-')'

"'*(.'),,-  "  "  #"   # # )/  01  %  (- 2 ),,-    0% % 3333333333     !"# $ #$ %&#"'"( (")*)+,$  (#$

(# 44 # #"  5 #6 7  "-.$" /#+01234  

   

5+..150110)05-) 4 "

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

   

5+..150110)H5-) EP3& & $ #" #&$"$" ((" 4 #$4(#"$,$4 "$" E6G 6+ 9 %6? :6L(#,(("" $ (#T # E#"$"( #$A ##@#"#$ #$$L@4( $ 4<$"E$#"4$#AJ(@ 4 $"((" 4 $<$)#$4"("$ ##$"EL&#) $#A BL&" E$#$<$E B$#A  #$ #(9 !+10+H;S*011+600G(#"60A @(S B6((#"606062 B(S(@6$ !+0.0-?(#"6G( @:6

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

   

5+..150110).5-) " (#($# (6 % "  "$ (#$  @ %#AJ "%L #@#"6 %$#"4$'$# #&<$ (("4 (#=$4" .1I"+11I"$(4 &36 4('$  /('<$  (("4  ($ $ 6%L 4 %A("%@@(# /('<$ # "     @$ #AA  "% &( $(#  /## #&@L"$ $$  & "$6%L 34M %LB@A O "#$(/('<$ ($  ##(3#A6

 %$" (""(#$ "( 4$ (#$# L#$$"$#" (("4 "?1I( "%$ # " 4$ & #A 6 #$ "#   $#  $  $ (4 #(($#  6 *%& "$ "&#( " #$A  ##@# "#$ #$$L #  %3( %L("%$(##A"/('<$"#B"B<$#$ )#A"6 4('# (3" ('#(" "$ ""#$ $$##( M3#AOM %LB@A O"#$(  /('<$ <$% ($  %$ " #/ '$<$  ( #" %/('<$9@@:$4" " 4  # "  $ ('(6  (#<$(  (#($#    L, %$" $(""(#$ "( "#4B$4 #$A ##@#"#$ #$$L(#"(#4 " %3(6  $(("$ "4 "01I"$(4""#B$6 .6  # <$   (#($# "$ 7  #   $ (#A  4(  #"($L@&$$"##4(( $"$8888888888 /(', %L($#"$#A *7 7 6

(## (#4" <$ "("*7 7 #  $#"4 4( %@@(6*(@% 34#, 4 $ #A" $L @$ 4("<$% %&""( ""( (#$$" J$$"($# "#(<$ $ /4$L$"(#"()"$9(@6

*522;5011G"$++011G:6 $ "("*7 7  (# "&#(##((34 "$$ #@<$    $   7     "$ # " % 6 $($ &$##$    $'$6% /A 4#  $ '$# #&<$ A <$%$ /('  (, %L6  (#  %L%$($4 $#A$ ($ %L@@($6

   

5+..150110)?5-)  $L "E4 " "$ (#$ (##"  %#(($(, ( $ " # (( " 4  4$  (#($# "$ 7  # ?1I #$(& <$ #$4 "#,$3$" %60? 6 $(<$(3" (#$" "(#" % $  %#@@( 4,( ($  "$6(#$<$#A&"($"#," "@L %3(,+E?11@69(@6 !+0H++@(:6 VVVVV 

   

5+..150110)-5-)  # " 4 "  #"   # # 

% 809   :  2   5& (.) ;<

  9 

+6 ( (#$(4A 6 % 9

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