opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/698/2005

Genf · 2005-08-30 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

           ! "#! $%

      

         &'()*&'((* "&+,-&'((.  "  "  #"   # #  #/  ' % 0(1 '((. 

  !"#$#"%$&' () &   *+, $

$ * ! **    *** - **    * -   *!./0$$$1!2334  !"#$# "%$  " $0#

   

5436754337)4514) 2 " 18  9)":$;!$$" ,?@A$0$":?-$"B * ? 1=CC D 0 1===8 :  0 ? E, 1===!   #$#  $$ "$# ? $,?"@:0?F8 48 01===!?#"#?0??"$$?-),?$#!G ?#!$$!D""$?$?-@,$"H?-  9)":  ;8"$,$,$#D"$0"":?#$# I  *  ?: E, 43348 ": , HH$#  0" ? ,,$D?#$0$F?-,?$#!-HH$?-) ,?$# 9 ;  H# $$ "$$  $ " ?# ? E, 43348*!$$?##$#H0#"J$? @?#? 4C$@433K9

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

 $$ "0: $$   HH$ ?S "@:0 #$?<<8S,$H#,43348$$D"$$0SF"# ?HH$#8HH$?"@:0??8 S?$0$0)##@GS1==180 "$!ES"?S##0$DE$?0?0$?1==KD1==68 0$T0""$?404337DS$$$?* ?G ES?<$G#+?0?"?"8"#G?0"##?$ ""$! ES,$ "# ? "@@ +?08  0  ?<$ ",$ J$ H0#8 S$    "# ? " ##0$!  S  ?$$D##$5?###$!???$! "# ? 0F ? $J$!,$< $ $@$#8   ##0$!  ?<$

   

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

;8 *0"#$"E<??S":$#$@8 K8 H#?#"$<##??$??2$@ 43339;$$#,<1E,433K!$%$0?H$ ?0@?"$#<??0?8* "0$#!"$?,G?$-""G?$J$$/#D0:

   

5436754337)6514) ?""G:<""@$,<00$U H$E?G0$?#$0$$"?$9 .1K34K3?8181R KKL?8184R .14=7?8184R .146726?81!1421K2 ?87@$#H#;8:<?"#?G$D-""G$ #,?:E?$#,<9 .116=K?82@!114K23 ?87R

1==CVK6"8K12?8K@;8 S""G? ?S":8 78 ?#<$D-$23 G"#,$?#??K3E?: $H$??#""$!?#?$?$0"  ?#  ""$ "$$   "$$ ?-)?$!  ""$ ? -$ 132 ?   H#?#  -)?$ 9)": 

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

! G- #$$ 0?H "#F$$ $ <<,# ! ? 0: <##! ""%$ #$,0$ D  ?$!  ?, ? -)?$ ?- ? "$$-?$$$"$9$?#G$;? ?00<!$G?"F,0$?#$<:D -?$8 $G-#$$?$#?-$##$0DG F$$ 00#?$0$ ,$ -?$) $$ G $)  D  G $ ,$Q$$?!0J0-?$!"$?-?#,""0$?)

   

5436754337)C514) $$G9

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

  ?HH# ? $:,@   ?-$$$ D  $# "+/G  #$,D$0$0?$+"["?"\!-$"?#H?, $@?$$$$$-#$"$Q$?$0$G"+/G 9 .116K26?82R

1===K71"873C,8?8K@;8 ?; *S<$ ? S""#$ ? ",!   E<!  H?$   ""#$?",H",$<$FG   "#?# ?SHH! $ , G $ H$ "#$$  ?<# ?,0@"#"?#$$G?S$0"@$"$"

   

5436754337)=514) 0?H $$ ""#$!  $ "H ?S?0$ ?S$ ", 9""#$ $"# ? ",R V!  N$<,H/  ?

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

H!$"?$#?S##0$"+/G!@G$"< ?S#$$ ?#"H8 "?$! D  E$      ?G# GS  0@$GS$#$$F$$$0$!0GSS,$$$#?$ 00#?$0$ ": S?$! S$)D)? ?  4 0 D 4 0 #$H8!,0@4331&,$?#ED?<$G# ?+$/+0!$0@?"$@$?S/09?#"!F$$! F#$#; 9H8   !  

 ! $ ? $0 ? 0#?! 46:0#?8;8

!$?$#$$$@?$$ S?$ ? ,0@ 433K  "$ J$ $8  0$!  $@ G $+"G ?- $0$0 ? $+" [" ? "\ S$ G $: "$0$0"R0$@"#F$$DS?$!$ ""$ 0#? S#$@$  ?<# ?,0@ G 9H8 . 141  43C ?82@$11=KKC?81;GS$#$#<<,#")8

   

5436754337)11514) : !  S$ " # ?SF0  $: ?#G$ ?  ? $#8"$"?$?!S<$?S?$?<,$#0+!G  ""$ ? $:  $ " 0"8  "$  S+  " ? $ 0$$ "$:0$ ?0$G  ? $: "$:0$0"$?-?$!?<,$#?$"$: ?#"/+G!$S+"?S?$$0$0#?$%$ <<,$$@?#G?-?$R??HH$#"" ?<#?0"$0"$$R?#?$$0$ 0#?!?"$$$?<#$?#?-"$#?$, $ ? "#$! ##0$ G S $, H#G00$ ?   ? +?0 ?F "$$8  $!  H?$ $ 0"$ ? H$ F$#$G?HH$#"H#<0$0E8 C8 G"#:?!E$#8   333

   

5436754337)14514)  # " 2 "  #"   # # 

% 456   7  8   9:;+' $<   6 

18 #,@8 % 6

48 E$$8 K8 $G"#?$<$$8 78 H0  "$ ?  GS ",$ H0  $  "#$ J$ ?  ?# ? K3 E ?:  $H$ " " 00?# ?#  @ H#?# ? ! */NT/HG 2! 2337   !  $ F0"8  ?#  "$ J$ "<#8  0#0 ?$P ; ?G F$0$G?#$?#@$$"??# $$G#R @; F" " G 0$H  $0 ", ?0? $$ $ ?#R ; "$  <$   ?  "#$$8 *  0#0  $$ "  $ ##0$ #0##  $$ ; @; $ ; )?!  @H#?#?""$0$:GS ?,?#,@80#0?0$0+ ? ",! G $ E$!  G  ?# $$G# $ S,"" ? G#$#F"#?#$9$81K4!132$13C;8  <HH        *  #?$P       @* "H0?"#$J$$$H#F"$GSDSHHH#?# ?$#"@G"<HH