opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/694/2005

Genf · 2005-08-25 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

       

        !" #$

      

         %&'&%())* %+,*%())' ""

- ".-! !  -" ! /0  1 2 $ (' 3 ())' 

  !"!#$#"!%&    '!($(  )!*+#($,(( !,!$

,$! %%     - &&    ! .,/0 ",$123 4244   45 ($(#

   

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

   

603062771 836428 ,$!($ D !$! D ,,(( $, D >,"!   :$9  ;($ !"!(  ",(  #)! 4//5 ",! :(! $(!    $($ >J$! *",($#"!:$$,!(+(>$$($DJ$!!;( >(($" $$,.?$>"$($"+>*"!("($#9

;($,$!,::!$>,:($,8!,(,!"! ,$,!?$"!,!"#(9

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

   

603062771 8/6428 $(")$!;(!9 ,$! ,##(,$($$##$ $( ",! #$!(! + $!;*, "$ ,! !(,)$ *(?!  >!#E %4232C4,(91 443451,(92 441541,(95 473 43B,(94F9

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