opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/676/2006

Genf · 2006-07-31 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (2 Absätze)

E. 017  ##  "## 8$# #  $ # $9##  A# A2  %  22#"0;+55= 72 $# $K">#2# "!7

   !/  !*    *   !  81030,, 9  700 0  :4;(' <   30,

07 "  $  897  30

E. 17 ;#! #2#7 .7   "22$   $!!$2#2$10$#$9 155+;2#2"##E; $ ! ##2$$!"#2 ="" 7

   

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

    $!2$=$ ! "# *##$#2=2"I! #222ER>R==2=""   $2! A == 

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

            ! 

      

         "#$%&"'&&%  "()("'&&(

* !*    *   !

+,- %  '(. '&&(

  ! "#"! $## %&#     $ #

$#  ''      (  ( ( 

(% $# )*+,%!$#-./+%0100   -  2#2"

   

3.4+53155+ 613016  /! 07 %"/$89 04.1%## ":82 155+ ; (  #822! ?;==2#$ ! $@A"B26! ?C  D7##%$##22E" *# ! $! 2"#2 ;922$922 > F# ?);8 1/5;555 = 7 ##8 #! 2 ###"! &# G8 G   % $#2 %E$##"%$828 11:82 155+%E;2;A22#;2$;)92##2$9""=22#;8$2#%$! # F66 )"2=" 2 #!" 2 %"#A#!#2#"!7 ! "#2# #$#$$2#"B92%H %)==AD## ?9)2"7  2$  "#" #2? # "$8" B#$2# % )"I # 2#" 2 D%  $ # E;"#2#I#"##7 .7 $$ 2 .="8 2 155+%$!A#! ##2$% ##   22E" E;2  ) A"  $#2  E2  "2A" ;I! #2  # $8   E"  2$!!2' %E2!  #!!$  =$ 2#" > $!2  B#$ 2#2$  29 ##"2  #  ; #$ 2#"   82% !2  "!#  ?) !$  2A   #D7   $2#2$%22"#2#2!$29 "A = 2!2$; (7,7 0-="8 2 155+%## $2E">;  $!2;## #"0  ="8 2 155+E;2 J;$#2 E2%$;% 2# "2#"A #2$ $2#;292> F#7##  :$#" E !    $9 I$2%$ #E;22"#2#2!$29 "A =# !#!!2; (  ;2#" "  ! ##2$ $!"#2 ="" 0;..0= 7! $2?0 :82 155+7 =2#% 2  ! 2  $2" #2$  =$ # 2$922?  #  ! $2# =2#2=  92 2$922 ;$##01;0+5= 7; "$# "#"29""=2 92; 627 -7 0L8 2155+%; "% ! "#"! $## %=$ "$!!$2#2$>## "22$$#>;A##2$! ##2$$!"#2 $##  .;.-+ = ,+7   =2# 8$2  E  ! 2I  !2$  ; ( -;-55= 7$K! $2%$ E 8 ;"#2#$#2#"E; # (1;05+= 7#; #1?!22  0;014= 7++%$2##$#.;1.,= 7++7 22%"$8 #;"82#>.;.-+= 7,+ ### 8$K2#!$#2!$ 2# "A ##$:E;>8# ;29' 7

   

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

   

3.4+53155+ 6,3016 0+7 14 155-%## =2#! 82  29"$!2##  ; ( ! #2 82A F#!  $# "# $2# # 2  1%+ N2$?# % ;8" 2# #28# 2==227  ;I2#2# ! N2A! $! >2$%$ #E;2"#2#"2 A  $A   8$2 $7  ! $I22#"   2$ ) ;I!$2# >  $9 I 826>6827   2 % 2 ;K 82# !  # 2 ### >  927 ;)92##2$;"#2#!2#"!  "!$#9!92%2! $   8#I#  "2$2 %E2!$ 2## & " 2I ! $9?  "92#  "#"7  =$ !#2E 92# *#  $ > I)92##2$7  # 2 "2  > ;"!A !! #2# >  #2  ! $7

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

 ! 07 $2A8$2 R$ A2#2$:222 BD"#"$2=2"#2#2#"%? 0 $S#155.% 29#$ $2%$!$"+:A% $#! "2##826! "2#%+!!"##0-:A B #70#7 #+- D7 (2#>R#2$R"#2$0-:A %!  29=""  1/:82 155,B '0.505-D%  $2A8$2$!#"%0.="8 2 % 2!$2#2$# 2#$2  A#! ### 29#$  $2  2"A     > # $2 :A #2#2 % %  R###  R"#2$$8I:A 7 17 $=$ "# > ; #7 +-  7 0 #7  )7 . % 29 #$   $2$&#2#2E$###2$! "8>R #7+- $2 ! #2A""  $2# $2-$#$9 1555 B DE2$# #28>$2=""  ! ##2$$!"#2 > R 6822% 828##2822#"04 04-+B 'D7$&#

   

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

*7 +7 7 28="" % 8"# 2#$! #%$##%! $2# =$ #$922? #2$922? B #7.70#79 D%2I2? =$ ### $P"!1+R555= 7!$ "29#2 B #7. 70#7 D% #%!2$## ! ##2$!" 2$2E%K$! 2 #R (#R B #7.70#7 D%# $ #! # =$ #$#K# $2#R#22B #7.70#7A D7 97  =$ # # "8" $  ?A   "A2#2$   R2!O# #$ 2 #  #$  $22 B #7 0/ 7 0  ;$ $ =""     ! ##2$$!"#2 >; 6822% 828##2822#"%0+ :82  04/0 B 6 (3 DD7 $ ER 29   # ! R)92##2$  E" # $ >  ! $ $! 2      ! ##2$ $!"#2 % 2   ! 2  $!# >  8  8" B #7 0/ 7,  6

(3 D78 8";29$2# !$  8 $==22$  8  $ $ #T  9$2%    "#92  $K; #2#2$B%8$2 )710052 #28;' ($ # ! ##2$$!"#2 >; (3 U VD7($: 2! %! 8  8";29$; #70/7, 6 (3 %;$#! 2I8# 92 # #2$E2" $#$2#2$$  B ' $!92"+5355 %L="8 2 1550%$271D7 ' $##

   

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

   

3.4+53155+ 6L3016 2=="  #    ( #  8 "# 2#  E" # B #7 0+ 7 0  D7 97  8"# 2#R #7+70 $! %$##% ! $2#   =$ #% ## $922?  ER2$922?  B#7 9D%  2E2?   =$ ###! ?"#2$R$##1+;555= 7!$ "29#2 B#7D%  #  R 6822 #  828# #  R 62822#" 22 E22#":$ 2? R 62822#"B#7D% #%!2$ ## ! ##2$!" 2$2EB#7=D#! ##2$$!"#2 =""  B#7D7 7 (;A2#   =$ # 2$922? % ; #7 / 7 /   ! "2 E !$   29 8#!;)92##2$! 22!I2#" "%$29 2#")$   #$ $ > ;"# A %  8  > !    $2" #2$ #  8 8"7 #$ ?A#;!!2#2$$#2# 8) 2!$2#2$$ #"# 2#2$8 $#28;297

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

;$ %2;#!$##"E $ ##2 ! $2# " 922$922 7 22%#! $2#!$ 2#*# ! 2$2" #2$ E;2K82#2$2"  E;K $"7  2#!#*# 2;!?7 ==#%2 $ #! $"  E ;2##2$   !$#9  ## 2$% $##  "#"% ;# # "7$2#2$%$#2$! 2#==#28#2==22% 8$2 2!$29% $P29E! $! 2"#2 $ 2# #2 "> $ # $2#;7  !! # 22 E; ! $2#!$ 2#8 299#*#  "2"!  2$#2$##2$%62;8" #$!2E"7 $"E#%2 ;K!2;2 ! ##2$$!"#2  8 ! $8#=$ #2$922? 7

   

3.4+53155+ 6053016 47 #2# = 2;# #2%;2#2"! 2$2" #2$$##1;01-= 71+ $ !$#>0/%+Q8 $#287  29"$##;!?E8 $#28922$922  ###2I2##7 2 %2;#!)92#"7 "##%2  :#2=2  !    $2" #2$% > #2#   = 2;# #2 2E#  $2#2"##$%>8$2 $##0;5-.= 7 057 22%    ! ##2$ $!"#2  =""  # #$  "# 2$2#   / 

$    # ( 1+;1-5= 7 1+;1-5= 7 # 0.;++,= 7-5 0.;++,= 7-5 '$ #2$922?  0,;...= 7,5 1L;---= 7L5 '$ #$922?  ..4= 74+ ..4= 74+  $2#  92 $922  .+= 75+ .+= 75+ !$ # '  .5;455= 7 0 01 %#2%'# 34 $52)%(34 6& "! !2$ 8 =$ =2#  "! ! $  L4;./+= 7  L4;./+= 7

# #29@#2# 0;5-.=  0;5-.= 7 0  7 $&26#5 34 $&26#5 34    "!6 $  .-;40+= 7 6L;.0L= 7,5  ##2$ I2 !$   .5;455= 7 

   

3.4+53155+ 6003016  # '  ##2$ .5;455= 7   ##2$  1;+/+= 7   E2! "?%2 "#E $ #!#! "# I2 ! ##2$$!"#2 ="" .5;455= 7! 7 $2#I! ##2$ $!"#2 #$;#!#!$8 #7 007  8   E2 ! "?%  $    ! #2# 2 # ;2#2"   $"!2#! ##2$$!"#2 ="" .5;455= 7!  7 017  ##  "## 8$# #  $ # $9##  A# A2  %  22#"0;+55= 72 $# $K">#2# "!7

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

    $!2$=$ ! "# *##$#2=2"I! #222ER>R==2=""   $2! A ==