opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/671/2007

Genf · 2007-06-13 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (1 Absätze)

E. 36 "(>6  2

46 F''6 16 )"!!'=@"C3)555=6'!CE< '6;6 =!  &'   DQ &(' =!  '  &"' N'   "  15 F 8  '=' &8  > =" " 7%EY+E=D2255;  :&( !'8  ' &>=!"!'@'6?4 =" " >=" " 3/ F 455G 7,:L  !"!   '  D   !'= ' !- &('&'<' ' ! 'L ' N'  "  > =" " & ( &'  & ( "'D @  '  )'6;4 ,6  &"' N' '  &8  &  '(D"!!!- &( ('N'F'C)(6  <==8    %-( # B   &" '        "'$F'9   '         &=! &"'N'''="@&'DQCQ===" " &<== 

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)



        !    

     

       "#$%&"'((% "%)&"'(()   !* *+*  * +!,-. /  &# 0  '(()    !" # $% !&'("'  !)"'  *'   + '

' ,,   ) %%     -./  '!"

    01.2304552 $403/$ * ! 36   7$&89 )": ''  ' "  3.;.6 "'" 3.?;6 46 (' )'3./.%)"&()"&! '=!'!&"!'' '')=='''(@  ''- I'!'  D &J  C )"& ''  ' '*"&'" '( ''6 26 4/F4554D'"  ' )'&H)" ") 'C% D &!'!&&E & ''"&' ' >&' 6 ?6   &&' '!"     34 K' 4554   $ E &>E '6&"'''!'(''&"(-' & '(C!$&'!>6 .6 %  ( &&'  33 ="( 4551      &  )"& 'L=''"$&" )"& '(&'&'   = !  $"&@L  '' &8 &' ' !$ '  >&>E '6 356 .!4551)""'"@!"&!" ) !' %     E 4551)" "&" !  &''C),, 

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

    01.2304552 $G03/$ )"D= "   '@)'('" ' !'' =' '&'6''!")&'" '( 5M G5M)'('"  'D!&''('")'&L  (E  )' !'"   '('")'& !&'' 'IE&E-D)&'" '("'' G5M6"''  &'"  '( & ""  4GM6  ' ' ''" D )" ('   && ''( &='!'  &'"  &'  '(  > ' ''   '('" &E-D &   @(!'@'(@  '6& !&!'('"'"  ""= (' '8 >!' &!&''&8 (   &>8!  '"6   !&  ( (' ( '"7>"!- >!' !&''3...'4553 '15)2.46$=:((>!'@ 7>"!-  >!' !&''4551'455;'324)2;36$=:L:)"''  &'  136346455G6 426 &F'  " 4;F'4552)  !D'''C'" 7($!> '"  '> " '' '')''&8&''!'D  & '  >& >E ': (' '*"  &'"  '( '' 3.F4554& G5MC&' 3F(455;6(E  '('" &'"''("  &" ' &&!' $   )E+' '  !(!' "&"''= !&D'  D  &'"  '( '' '86 )==''"D)"(' &&''( &'"&'  '(  '' !&'  !''='6 (' > " '('"&E-D&@(!'@'(@  ''  6 % = '    &&')DN'&'('"&=  "& ')==!&"((''&8( '"> 

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

'=   F&   > =" "   7$&8

,  L ( '!!', &>" 3&'!>4551   2?.054: !R(&('N'E=="@'!' ('N''!")&8""!' &'&8D )!&'(&&@!'(>'6 %)&' "'!"(K!' @(=' )&' !"'E &"=D&$'=7'64/ :&" C !& '('"'"(  '4/ 63 :"  ='D)( '")'&"(" '!' >)!& '('"6!!& "'!!-  ''!&D')!&NE!'&(D"&! )=!'" &8D)&&""&"!'==' '!&NE!'&'"   & @!& &   F' 7% 3..?&6343:6=='!& "'')@&''""  '&'(''&8( )( '"&!'  '   (>   !'   &'"   &"& "' D  "''  )@&'' ' "'" =" &  =' "' @ &!8' == C &&"'D''F') &'  !!>   =!  & '""  )'&   >'6 ""!'  !' !&'>  &!''' &  &   '  C  =' 7"'  )"'> D '  '('" D  & " &'@(''''C'"' D& '!& &'  !&6  -  "  " &'  '''C' 'IE D) !&' &(')' 'IE !@  &'"  E & '  ==6 '  ) E6&'  "'!()( '=='!& (6  &"D)()&&' 'N' "   (  ( '"  (   !& (  ()(  D)&' !''  &"& "'D)" )"'' !">'"''"C@)'('"'C &("!"'6(DD')!&' '' '('"  '!  '@)&' '  &''  '( @ !'@ > !- >!'  !&' )'& '6 > !&'CF''''D"6 !!) !')'!"$ !N!  "''  @ &'" C ) 4551 "& ' &D @(!' ''(P6)'&')'&  ''='!''>' F' &'' !)'('"6   ""!' ' "'   E!&)'('" 7 3./.&6415:6 !&'' !"'E  !&'D=' ''D)   &!'!&=='(!'&" "C"&'' '('"7= '>&6G )DN'&8332E !     '('")'&'   "6 )'('"   ! "!'&@(!'C 'IE&E-D6 '      '' '('"  -    F  '  ''-  @ !!  '"  ' &>D '  "&!' D  "'  !>' 8  "&'6 N!   ='''!&'>'""''$''"'('" !''('  '&"''G5M! '!&6)-&"D'&  )"' "&'' E!&)'('"'&) 6 D)' )&8"&'' E!&)'('"N'" &)=='=(> 8D!! "!'"$  ( '"  '('"  ' ' & "(" D @ "')'('"!6 %) !' @  (' C "   !!  &6 G  )DN':6  =='  '  > " '' '('" &E-DL  )==' & D  '('"  '  D  &'" '('''6&"''!!'& !'' 8 D='''!&'>'"$ !D'!*' &$''8!'$''"6=!!8()'!"='D 'D;E&FC'('"&=8(   E@ &6 %  ( !" @ '"  &' ! )"D(')&'!&  '('"  '6 "!"&&&!&(' ('"   '('"   ()&&'''D &"& "'D') "'' !"  > '" )' & '" C @ )'('" 

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

    01.2304552 $3G03/$ : 7() &  ( : 7()( :

IE ' G5M 355M 341)4;./ = 23)24;?G = 341)4;./= '('" &E-D G5M 5M G1)5;5134 = 42)G453G2 =6 $

' 355M 355M  ??) 3;G5 =6 341)4;./= %    ( '"   ='  ' "=8&'@'''DU7%%4554;3/E0!W3;M  &4551!- '1!!'"&'E!!'IE &@ ''!'!@! 4GM D )(  > "F'=& )&8=' ''D))"''& (' 4552=!"6 346 (' )'62.63> '"( "'!C = F' D ('''455=6'3)555=6 ( ' -   !'&!')"!!' 3)555=6 

    01.2304552 $3/03/$   1+!  !* *+*  * +!

    2-

36 "(>6  2

46 F''6 16 )"!!'=@"C3)555=6'!CE  =" " 7%EY+E=D2255;  :&( !'8  ' &>=!"!'@'6?4 =" " >=" " 3/ F 455G 7,:L  !"!   '  D   !'= ' !- &('&'  =" " & ( &'  & ( "'D @  '  )'6;4 ,6  &"' N' '  &8  &  '(D"!!!- &( ('N'F'C)(6  <==8    %-( # B   &" '        "'$F'9   '         &=! &"'N'''="@&'DQCQ===" " &<==