opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/664/2007

Genf · 2007-06-12 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (1 Absätze)

E. 37 S$"#$ $8 !#$;$!  &  6-B$344<$60%C#34457 27 %    ? S $ ! "# $#$  "!$ #     !#$$%!  7 07 S $ !?%##?##$  $!6&<44G#7?$ $# !"7 <7 &!$G =!?344G#7$ ?D#E& $ !7 57 G#  "#$    @S "%$ G## ## $#  "#!$ ##O$   !   24 A# 9  $ G $  "#9  # C G!!# 8+DW J#DG@ 55440  ;"#% ##$ 9## $ "C G#!$=#$713 G!!## # CG!!#6.

    /0102/3445 (62/62(A  344< 8 *;T  ! #  ##  $  @#    $ G $,"#%$"#$# E$###$$ #T  $ O$# #!  # C G!!# "# %  "$  "# %  !$# @ =  $   &#$7 03  *7  "#!$ ##O$ $  " 9  "   ##$ %@!,"#% %$O$#A $?&% 7  E#GG #:      ##+  "#! $     C+   #!$ #(A# $:    D  "" X  " G#"#!$##O$$$ G !="#$   @S?SGG G!!# # "#E#GG

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

            !!" #!!"$%% &     

     

       $'()(*'+,,- $$'--('+,,. $"   %$! $%%$! " $$%"  $!" /0  +  1+ 2  +,,.      !  "#$% !$   &!$'$#  (

)  ##$

$# **   & ++     # ,-.   $ !

    /0102/3445 (3/62("% $  67   8 ("#9 : &#!   ##$; !  6- $$( $?9% %#$ % $!$$$$@ #%7 37 !A#!30B$ $$(  6-14" " # # ? 9%$@" %C#3440!$ $ #?G$ )> N%C$ &D!#I##O$"# C % #  "# $$ "!I% #G  "# " =7A$!@&GG# $#=DD$

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

* "C !62#3444<-3/-- 7C/;7 57 ##$9EC$##""#$! $# $$@ " $!$#% $$$$ % $!#@& $ !"#!$@&$ $ 9#  $$ $ % $!  &"",$ #  #""#$  +7  $#  ##$$ $@#""#$#60B$3445& %#"#C$9#@$$# 9#&"$ $##"# *)$@& #" $"# $9#!%""!"#A# "#7

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

    /0102/3445 (64/62(% $ 8G7

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

    /0102/3445 (66/62(A# "#$  "#$$$    #'$#  "  G# "#C$ 8G7

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

    /0102/3445 (63/62(  "#G   #% &$# "#$    $=   $ "#  #   #$ $#' " $!$#% " @& #% !  7 17 "$$@ "#!9## $O$# 7##$C$$ E   $!6S<44G#7 ##!?$ $#!"8#$756 $7E;7 -7 %#$&#$75-76C  $#!% E#6#A $3445"#!# ##$ 9#$$$ "#$$#&$# #G"#$$   &  %$  # C  ! $   ?  G#   A$  @  %$ $#$#344G#7$6&444G#7 %#$## ,  #& $ !" $&!$344G#7 33333 $ "   !"  %$! $%%$! " $$%"  $!"

  $  40

67 !####%C7 $ 4

37 S$"#$ $8 !#$;$!  &  6-B$344<$60%C#34457 27 %    ? S $ ! "# $#$  "!$ #     !#$$%!  7 07 S $ !?%##?##$  $!6&<44G#7?$ $# !"7 <7 &!$G =!?344G#7$ ?D#E& $ !7 57 G#  "#$    @S "%$ G## ## $#  "#!$ ##O$   !   24 A# 9  $ G $  "#9  # C G!!# 8+DW J#DG@ 55440  ;"#% ##$ 9## $ "C G#!$=#$713 G!!## # CG!!#6.

    /0102/3445 (62/62(A  344< 8 *;T  ! #  ##  $  @#    $ G $,"#%$"#$# E$###$$ #T  $ O$# #!  # C G!!# "# %  "$  "# %  !$# @ =  $   &#$7 03  *7  "#!$ ##O$ $  " 9  "   ##$ %@!,"#% %$O$#A $?&% 7  E#GG #:      ##+  "#! $     C+   #!$ #(A# $:    D  "" X  " G#"#!$##O$$$ G !="#$   @S?SGG G!!# # "#E#GG