opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/652/2004

Genf · 2004-08-26 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

               !"

      

         #$%&'#() *#+')#)((% * *, ,*,  ,   '-  ./  )' 01)((% 

   2222222222 ! "#$   % &'()*!+!*''**,   !  !  33 ,*,  4,5,6* ' -./012345  *!*+ 

   

6073861221 916039 , 3*

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

::::::::::*'*(+(=**!+'! 5*'= ++!*!!!'40/)+5 * 0../@' 5*9' >*$K' *! *' *!!'= +!!'+ *), !!'=+5!*'=+!!'!*!'' +!' =+B')) !!  * !*(!@  *'=!*5*!+%*! % , 03, 30*0...  :::::::::: '  !*! +'** @=  '(**'*(+(=+5!*5 =*5*'*!+ **!*& %, !*!* (*  ' *! ' *  '= *  5* )**   *! !9H!  !! ' !* '=*!!*)*>+, 07,  '! ' 10 !%  1220  !  '=% 5!* +'* ' = 9 *5*'*!+E*9 4M # F(*5*!+!+'!+ =  & !*  *'**** '= + '  !'=& !*, # + '*>!* *5! -!  *)    *!+ ' ! 5*M ! % !)  ' &  *!! )  ' B*>* B *( ! '  5*9% B*>*' *!B *(+*''+ *)''> +-,

   

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

! ' +''+**!*'**** & !' # ! & *+5*+>4 !'*))+ !'*'-B*! !! ( =+!! '+ *)  5*! H!  (*)*+ ' - @ +54  * !J! ' -, =+!!'+ *) +!*!  4= H!'! 5*''+% 0..8!    !* 5  '+4 ') 4  ' =& !*+  0..1,  & ! =+*>*!'5!* !'=5*'-B*! !+(!@'! '= *!*'=+!!'+ *)**('+5+ *!+,

*'*!'5>%!!!'5* B!>*(! -B*! *(E(('+ +F'**!*'*!+'! 5*+!*! !*+@82D, 08,  00)+5 *  1221    K:::::::::: ' $ 5* +'* +>* + ' = 9*5*'*!+ E*9 4M $# +F   (=* =- 5*!  '=**!+ ' ! 5* ' %   ' = 9*5*'*!+, =+*' '+ *) **!H! !*!'!  +!*!%*! 5* ' + *)' 5**'= +, * )*! ('> +'**!!*'*!+'! 5*  *-B*! *() =%C!''*5 >& *+'!&!!(*!!**(* '4 ! =5* -B*! *( ' #  '* +'*!*!   ! '=& !* ! '*!*'*!%, 0;, 8 1221=  !*)*+@= + C!''+** (* C!*!  '' '  !!*    !*) ( =!!*! @  !+ (= +!*!=5*!5 '=*5*'*!+' *!4 +*  *%

   

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

   

6073861221 9/6039 $*!@=!*'=+!*'0;C>   *%)+'+  1/C5* 1227E "03202;F ' *>5*'!+03)+5 *  '**!*! *!*  >! !!! *%!'  * ' *+>     @ ! * C> !*!*   ' =!!! ' =+!*'5&C> , $!!!   '' *!%* *%)+'+ ' H!'0  C*! 1227 )* + (  '**!*! *!* !*!*!!* !*!+!*!) '  O!' *!)+'+ E H!0,0 ! ** '  (!* ' =*!*!!**!+ ' *% ! '  **'+ +( +!*'! *%5*!H!  * 5) '+ >!* '' *!)+'+ *!= = !,8/' *)+'+   !*>++ ' *';!% 1222E*9  4M F! +5*> 0 C5* 1223, 1, ) +!@P !,3,3''**!*! *!* '*'075%  1221 '*)*!     *! '*! 5! P! +  5*>  '  * +*!+ ! '! '5!  ** ! '    !*4  'P 9*5*'*!+ ! +!+ ! * 'P))*  *% ! '  *,+!' *%'+!'4 +!%*  O! ' +!*!*>, 3,  ! O+'% '*)*!*''*'= 9 *5*'*!+,'=4' !!)* +>* '**!*5*>  C(= 30 '+%  1221  +> '   **  (  C> '  *=@ ' *'+ !*'*)*!*'' *! '=+!!')*!!+ * @'!'+! *!''+***!*>*E " 01/  7;/ *',0 010  3 ! '**!* ! *!*  !,  +(&*+@ *4 ''**!*'*)+'+  = 9*5*'*!+'0.C* 0.8.E*9 4 F!' 4>! = 9*5*'*!+'0/C5* 0.;0 E*9 4 F5*> C(=30'+% 1221, 7, ++') !'+**+ * +!  ! 5%@ ) 5 !' !,;. !   C(= 30 '+% 1221E*9 4 $F, 8, =%C! '   ! ' '+! *   !& '=*5*'*!+ ' = + !   +(!' *!@ !'=*5*'*!+,;, $ = !, 7 , 0   =*5*'*!+ !  '**!* '  *!+ ' >* ++  !  ' > ' + (* +! '= !!*! @  !+ B-*(! 5!'=*)* *!+>+*!'='*'=

   

6073861221 9 5*!+    @ 5 *  ' *! &  !!* ! !  *'+ !*,' *!@ !!'+! *+ = !,1  '(!*C *'*((*! >*'= !C>' *'*5!%  ' '!(*!+!%*!*! '+'*E "01108 !   =+!! ' !+ !@*'*( '(  ! ( !*5*!+ = + ! *% ' ! 5*,  !   '+ +'* !*!!  ++! !*   '+! *  ( ! 5&  !   *%!&*> '= +E "0181;0*',7Q008037*', 1Q007307*',3Q02808F,

(* 5  %!'=  !+'*(*!'+! *! =!(*!*!*>*&* !!*!)*!=%C!'=+!')*+(  ! )'   ' & ! (=*   +>!  *'+ !**!& *+(=**!+!++!%***' '* E4F(' *!*'!&!+'**!* !)*(  * ' =& ! *! %* !*5+ E " 011  0;2Q $ 1222,087F,  !   ( ' & !*  '+  !' '   +'  '**! !*5!+!%* '+**!  %'=% 5!* )'* ! '=*5!*>!* 4! ** (= * * ' '* !(& !%!*!@' +!!5*!C> *!  + !  * >! (=*'*  ! !''! '  %*9)'+E "018383F, ' *!)+'+ )*&  *!* *4 '= +* - ' 5 **'*%  +*!*' 5=*(!!*4  ' +' '**! !*5, *! '  (!* ' ! % !)   *%)+'+  '  '+)**)'! **! +!''#$# 

   

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

   

6073861221 9026039

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

(* ))!*!*(*!!(**=! '=*) *!+)!*'! 5*5!H!  * *'+ !*'= +*!*' !4 *5*'!'! %!)  ' &(*!*!!'*'*)5 '=B >-B*( +!*   + 5  *) +>!*5   =)) ! ' 5!+ &*>*%  ! ' E "  +*!+*',3,3,1F, $=>*!' *!4 '=+!!-B*( *!*+>' !V)*!' '*X! !!!**'!*  )*! ** '9**%+ !  ' +!* ' )*! -B*(  "    +*+ (=)*! '* !* +''* *'=!!!*!'=!* ' B**('='+B >'=%*>!*(!*'*=+!*!C *'*(!  !*!E "  +*!+*',3,3,1F,

   

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

   

6073861221 9016039 **!!*)!*!)*'  !! !*5  5+ ' & B *( E, 0 * '  )*=+!!'+ *)!%**+X, ! ::::::::::*!+>!'=5* (=! *!!-B*! *(+**+ *!+*  +!!-B*(* +5!!  *!+ ' ! 5*,  +5!* % '4     *% !B+ !*(' !(!!'*!*' *!4  ! *,

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

   

6073861221 9036039   *3  *, ,*,  ,  

 7.080   9  :00 0  4" $+)  ;   80 

0, +  5%  *! C!+ #'::::::::::! '+** '1; 1221'=))*!'= 9*5*'*!+,  80

1,  C!!Q 3, )    !* '  (= 5!)     !    +!  H! '  '+* ' 32 C  '4  !*)*!*   * '+ ' +  *%)+'+  '   $BZ*L B)(*;;227     ! * &* ,  '+*  ! H!   >+,  +*  '*! M F *'*(  &!!('+**  !'+* %!* *!''+** !!(+Q %F &    ( !*) * !* 5*  ''  !! !  '+**Q F  !   *>!    '   +!!, $*  +*   ::::::::::!! *++!++ +!! F%F!F*9'  *%)+'+ '   !  !*4     (=* '5  '+   * 5%,  +*  '   !*     -' 5(* !C*!**('+**!!(+!=5 '(+!+&+'*+  !E !,03102;!02 ))*4 M  [\ ]   +*'!M  #-  #        *) ' +! H!!!*)*+& !***(=@=))*)+'+  ' * > ))