opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/630/2004

Genf · 2004-08-18 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

             

   !"

      

         #$%&'#())$ #*+)#())% ,,  ,- - -  ,-   %.  /0   $1 23 ())% 

  -,, 4 -- 5,- 6  ,66-   4, -, -  7- , -8 4,9   !"#$%& ' (! 2 4:::::::::: )*+" '  !!,----------  *   

    ./01#..233/ "2.//" - 4 /4,----------  5 "6%  ()!)7 )!) (! !) 8 %& !  !  9 !  (''  (&': /##/4 )! ! ! &   (6)! (

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

9'!  ?! (> (! !! ( !)  :!(  (   )) ?  )! (   ! :  6(& ! K! ' &*()(9!((!*))(!>(>!4 D1   ( *))  F (!(: 2333   6!  9))  (!  ( 5 74 24  (*(')'! 8 >!  B  ) B   6( ! ( ! !(  6)!  !( ! &! >!)  & 9   ( ! 6! &!  (''  (!(('! %>"&  !& &!)!) !'  >(**    : !(   (  !!!  ! ?!('6( ! (6)&6>! /F2(!''!   (!!! ( ! & 8  ( *))  >"&   !

    ./01#..233/ "D.//" & &! 5!4 DF 74 ('6)!6( @9 >6%!  )!: 4 B4  (*))6! 9))( F(!(:2333 5 7!!)& 9/@& 233B!L!'(* ! ( (': 6( ! ()9(' > (!''!?  ( >!  D2   ( *))  >"&   ! & &! 5 74)(' 6(:  !)>'6(A!)9)' %6)! )?>6&!8>! D2 !! $/!$2%9'! >"&  !& &!5 7(!)!):(9)4>6% !)'()9 6 6( ! (& 9@?>B/)':2332 )96  6(%966 :(!& 9'('! (J* !@  ?'!)!' !(6( !5 =/220F1( 4 /74 6( ! ()96! !(!%( !)  !4 04

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

    ./01#..233/ "F.//" ((!  (! ( @  ? ('  /#$D 64 22074  6!  & ?E ! )*!  : )*  ! * 6%    (!) &) ) ! (6):4  6(%"&:  &!!)*!: )*  ! *(?E   ??:   :*(!! %'!)*!5!4 //D4/! (&E!4/0#O =4//B2D$( 4BO /#$$64 /B1O )((64 !464/1#22074 )6! (6(%" &:     &! ! )*!  : )*  ! * * ! (  )  

6)'6! (E)E! $24/ 4

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

    ./01#..233/ "1.//" ('6! (   >(:&! 6 !! ('! ( 6 )9 9 9& 6 6! ( 5 =//0223&47 *!'K''(! + 9!8>)9>'  !! (? (6!( ! ( *('>! (6(:  !)*()>!4D2 5 =//##F M/##B64//374

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

+!'>! D2 >'6(A!!(& (''9 ?>   )  & (!  6 6! ( !! ('! ( 6 )9 9 9&)!!66)?> >9 !> 6( ! (6) 5 /#$#64//174 

 >(  (''9 ( !   6!   )  (! ! ( : 6  (*  !()!),---------- 6( '(!!/#ED00*4136)!!(! ! ((  '6A)6(

6) ( >&  /##1 8 ' /##$ 6  ('6)'! >(!(: /##1 8)': /##1    ?   )9 '  (! ( *'   >(!(:8)':/##15*46 %(4/08F  74 E! /0 )/ ()! (&! B0! &!  6 !E(: 9! (6(E'6(A) ;? (! ! ( )!&" 8 ('6! (&6(6(! ! (4  '6(A (&! &(A +   6) (?'!  6 % ('6!:(! &)8'6(A)' %8? (! ! (6 ! 6 !K!)!* E(:@!)  (4

    ./01#..233/ "$.//" E(: 9! (  6A  (! ! ( !  *(  )('6! ! 6( E'6(A!U;(!6: 6 !6(4 !)9  : *))   )) 8) !)) 6  ?  6(:  !)  E'6(AE! D2 !)!!!(!6: 5 = //2/DD( 4DO /#$16922374E'6(A? E? !!6 !!!U;(''!& (! (6 6! (E! D2   ?  !L 6(   E(: 9! ( )6 ! %'!  (''9    ( ()5 =////1B( 42O/3$/$F( 4//#2( 42O  /#$D69F0F( 4B74  = ** ')+6)'!?E(: 9! ()9)6(''9 (! K! ( ?    (J  (''9 ! C 8  & (! ( !! ( ( 6 )9 9 9& 6 E'6(A  6 6! ()9 ! E  5  /#1$ 69 2D#O   /#12 69 F$174     ('6! ( ?  (!! ?E  :   (''9 6  !   (" (:&! (  6 6! ( 6! '!! ? E'6(A  & () "  !! ('!('(6)9 99&'(J E+ ! 6E  * !(8)9 ! ' !)(('6(!'!(8E:E *!5*4 = 2$@ /#$2 /#$B69/3/74 (? E'6(A !  6( '(  (9)6(! (  '! 8 ! ! :     (''9 ) 6  "  (!''! ?  6( '( E+ ! 6  '('! (J  6(:  !) ! 99)5*4(F33B ! &E= 66! ((! ! (" O = //0  1# ( 4 BO //B  2DF ( 4 BO   /#$$ 69 /BF ( 4BO =////1B /#$D69F0#( 42474 N(9N *!!!(!6(6;A ?? 6)!6( '( 8 E+!)  ( ?  6! +  *)  &   ('6(!'!" 5*4(F33074(?E !  E()!) (A' = E!!(@()*))8E! 1D0/ )()! (& E! 1D#/ ) 4 (*(')'!8! !(!6( ;9)E'  !! (9! (((!G)6(!8E)9  ()!)  'K' ?E& ;? ! (  ( )  (   (''9?E'?! !! ('!(6)9 98 &(!6(? )6(!E'K'(''9(!! (  '!4(!)6!);9)E'  !! ((9! ( E! 1DF N('!(9)  () 9)+6)'! ('' ! ' )9'!  6( ?  6! **! &'! )  (&!(9(? '!9! (6(6'! !!(!   6!6)6()!8*('! (&((!) ()!)N 5 =/31BDB( 4DO =//2/#$D!EK!2/& /#$$  O =(!'(   R! ;! ; !V(! ;R ! 2%')4 69 23#!74

    ./01#..233/ "#.//" F4

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

    ./01#..233/ "//.//" ,  4  ,- - -  ,-  

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