opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/612/2005

Genf · 2005-07-19 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)



       

       

          !"#$##$ % $$##& '''( )*+, - ,.-'/ (''/  -'( (,/ 0 " 1 $##& %23 (435  

  !""#$!%&&'  (')(%$$% ((&%!%* % ' '$+,- ./01   " '$'(  $(' 22       ) 33  *   '  4$56 !$(,/1 ./..   .7" %(%& 

*/8./*  

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

*78./*  

8.6508/00/ (((%(  (( %!%(& ($(  ('?% ( &(%( %*K &($&  (( %((%$"," ) (('&(%:''((" '&>$'%'*(4!D'!%'D'$'((-$H(/00."  '$'( 4 %%F )?$%' B% ! @''  F$F (%?%(& '(%?(''%!%(&('?%" &'%(!&B$'(%$ F%>%&)%%% $&(((&" 1"

 )$%$) '!!$'( &% (&  /, $($=' /00. &(=% !'  'D)  '%'!$%+$(%('$= =$''% +'? @%(( !%  $=' &  =% ?( F  '$'($(.55C")%!%(&('?%&(%(($(!% & (  !$%=%%(&  '&%'(%$ !'$>%$ )&(%( ?%+=  $&%('%((" -" $'!!$'((&1>&?'%'/00/&(=%D) !' '  >%( (%$) &(( ((%$%' ) !'$$(% ?% ()%!%(&('?%$!:(" 6"

@ (') $( (&  .C ' /00/   &%*$%  )  $%:' F  )&((  (& &(( &'%( $ ((%$%'        

                  '?( F  &%%$%%(%?%(&(&$>%'&''$'(F)((%(D(&&(%( '&%(%F" C"   $ $( (&  /5 ?'% /00/   &%*$%  )  &()?%$F%)@%('%(!$%>%(%$&$('&)&(( (& '?(F).5C.&BD('$=(&@%(%(" 5"

(.5'/00/ ) '&D'$'(!'$B(&%%$ $('B('&?%%$ $(%>!'%>%(F)++'?(%$ )&(((&)?%(!&(&'!%=" .0" '$''%'1?'%/00/  33 '!'&(('$'( @!'%%($ &$'?$(!'$B(&%%$ >%(!'($%'&%(& B(  %(%) +'&)%?%%(&  10A ( $%%(%(  ('(%  $%%'$'((!'&$&%('%((" .." ' $''%' (&  .6 ?'%/00/ ) &'%?%( 33F!'$&')%(%$  !'&?$4%( !)('(%  $%%  '&"  '!  ) $%&'%(F%(%'(D10AB(%>%%(!'&) &(((&((%$%'"

*,8./*  

8.6508/00/ ./" KB$' ) '%(D'$'(&%%$'B('&?%%$  '!'(('$!'$B(.5'/00/" .7"

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

)$%$)'!!$'(&%(&.0$H(/00/ '&D $%%$ ($'$' '@!$%(;                                                          !                                                "       #   $      %    &                            '      

          #          (                         '                        

*18./*  

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

*68./*  

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

*C8./*  

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

*.08./*  

8.6508/00/ + ( ,6 / ,.-'/ (''/  -'( (,/

  7 33 8  0

     0) %$ /

  7 3

." &''$''?=M + 3

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