opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/581/2007

Genf · 2007-05-24 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)



          !"   

     

       #$%&'#())* +#,-%#())& ..+ / +.0/ +!  /. !0 1 $  ($  ())&

  !"#$%$&' (

( ))    * *

* *  (  +,-.  (!"

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

    /.#01/$%%2 31/#%3 6( !6!((  (((   (  6( '" 6 :3' ("4'(6(C(  !( 6(!'( :("9  " ((( :F!4*::'& >:""@ ""!( 9(8=(; > 'G"+=(36((">'(6(! (:(  ',( ((" !! :  '(   !J( 99('  66>(6=&= !( 9("(86 (4?4#(4= (#0 3 */ 4N 04  :6&  (  G      9"' $%%.  !((  $$:.%1940%@(( "((9 : !(";& :3' ("4  6  !,! 6"  :     '"  6(( !6"!(4 :(!"   "> "!"  (  (((  6(( 6G(66 " #A!$%%.4:66(9!"6( ( " ((("(";("6:(!" ( $?9"'$%%24 (( ":6"("((" (>:(("9 +;="9!$%%24*;6 !("(( 66(@(((: 6( 6('"6  @(( "((9@9 ! !$%%2 (@> " (((( 'F"(4   :  ( (( >:  6 6  ( 6(4  &=:,( 6!8  ((>:'((("'3@3' !&( :!6!(( 6('!(-:%%%94( $:%%% 94= " 66'89 !(6(6(!!( @:(( 94"=!("(8>6 (!66&6!( "((9   6"'"A:%%%946!8:(!"4  8((>::6&:  9"!9 (@((   !!( H  "  (((  "("    "( >  ( '(  '( 6  !E 94    6G(  !!(H " (((( 'F"((@9!$%%2 '( :F! :('(:(   6('"6:3' ("4 :  :6'(="6(466(  & 6" @ (( !6"!(  ' :"(8   ((  ( "((;(9" (   (( 9& "(( ( >:  D (    6 '  8 ( F   9   =   &=   !( 9(4 A4  '   > 6"&     6(!(  !4  "  66(  ## (8 $%%2 ( " (   'E" @ :(!" 6 ((!6"!((' "4

    /.#01/$%%2 3#%/#%3 .  !+02  +.0/ +!  /. !0     3

#4 "'84  3

$4 : !(6(!(( "66( ##(8$%%24 ?4 '   @ :   6 (( !6"!(     "((' "4 .4 (>6" (=((4 -4 (>6>((F6((!6"!(9" "6(  >I6'(9!(6"(,(  " ?%; &  (9( 6&  8 9" " 5*+ST+9> 2 2%%.   76' !(&  (689!"!(F (4 A$     9" "   8 9" "  #0; $%%- 5)7L  !"!  ( >!(9(!E 6'( 6(  =(  (    ! (L  (,(  " 

89" "6'6(6'"(>F ( :(4.$ )46"(,((6&6 ('>"!! !E 6' '(,(;(@:'4  =99&       *E' U V  " (O         69! 6"(,(((9"F6(>I@I999" " 6=99