opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/572/2004

Genf · 2004-07-15 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

   

               

            ! "##$     %&'(" ))))))))))* !"#$$$$$$$$$$% & &'  '& ++,  -.*& ' " ()*%+,- .'.#/  "/0'$1%2 #"'*3/("'$*%((4"' 4$(##  *! 0(5 

    +  0 &"/.. "& ' 1&22%344.' "3&.-.".'/5. 6&, 3 7  &  + ! .& 8$$$$$$$$$$% & &'.' .'. /  )9:'&& .&."/6"'"6& 4. %1//4."36&#.%";&/ "3.-.".'/" &'"&'"3.-.".'/"3# '' "?94&06&# .6 &6/&. ""&#&)))*"/#1&2220 #6'&"&@-.&22%3.'/&//'/#.1//4."3&''.,& "3.-.".'/% 1/ &  ";&/ "3.-.".'/ " 22=0 3    &-A &4/+3&/3 '& ."3"#.&'"3.-.".'/6 &6/.1# '.4 >   &- "/'&#.'/'.'6/&.&# ''.6&#'''"3(- .& "& .'0 0 &  &&.& " &  -#1& 22% ! .& 8$$$$$$$$$$  .'&@'/ & & 6&," ##.. ' "& &#'.,&"3&.-.".'/ 5.6&, ##.. 7% & #6/''% '''&4"3"#.&' 6 &6/.10 /;/> &-&/3/-.'+?94&06&# ."& #& )))  * "/#1& 222 ' >  &/'& '.4 "  &' "3.-.".'/% '& (/  22*% -.' /'/  #6/ -  -&#' 44'/ 6& 3&AB#; ' 3C 6.;//&0  "-.'  &  &/'& '.4 " :D*4&029+."AB#;06.&#&22%./'.'1//4." 6&''.  #6/#'.&4/"/&'' "3# ''"D*:4&06& # .0 *0   6&/-. "       44'/  4 &#/#' E ".6 .'. "   . 4/"/&&6&''.  #6/#'.&%"/6"3&/%/  3 %3/-.'+*D9?4&0'& &+*FDF**4&0G "&.,& "/6.' "  " 9D*: 4&0  #E.## " "/6 & % 3'6 &> .3&/3-.'6"& .'+"#.&'6 &6/.10 "?@-.&22%3&/ ''/# ''"&- &'044'%6 &'.& #6'"3'&-%.&.'4>3. .' 1//4."34 &#'. 6& 4. %>.3/'.'6%6.> 4 &#'. "6. '>3.-.''&6&.""&"3&.-.".'/ -.' /'/ &&H'/ -'   '&#0   - (.' ",  & 6  ##' 3  6 -.'&'.&'&-% .% #6,'#'.&&/.'04.%.&66/

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

"''&A'"&8AS.T%- 0 %))%60:F% ' 3'&.1" .'&,;;//&"3;.&- &'% 6 6&'..,&#'  &>   /> " 3'.  1 -&&.' ' '  &/;.# @&.".> 5M   **70  ' #.4'#'..%", &> ."/&'' 6.>"3&&H'" &-.'+.&3E.'"3@&.".'. >.4 '. "6.&  L'22*"/@+%'" '@;'.'.&%..>@;66/'% '/'/&/;.,&#'/0  7 8E#."3 44. #6/'G-3&&H'""*2#&22 3+ E.'%./;#'+-/&.4.& 4 &#.'/+3&'0*' " .3.'.''0 8'@&.".'. "#..'&'.-6/.%>3'&.'" " #.6&'..&"& .0 (."&66&> 3&'0 9:" .4/"/&&6&'.;//&""& .'"& . % '&/  -.;&  & @-.& 22*% A> '  .'.'  '&.1 " &% >. ''  .' .> &  & & "  " #. "

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

:   90  3 &&%  ' .'.;.  >'.  " 3 '& . "3 "#.&' "3.-.".'/6 &6/.1"&#&)))*"/#1&2220 E'&#"3&'0F  %3&/"& .'+>&'"&'3.'.-."+ "/6& 6& . 4/"/& " ) #& )?9 &  6&''.   #6/#'.& + 3& -.. ' &-.-' ' + 3&.-.".'/ 5 7  ' 6/&.& E &-"/'&#.'  0 3 "/'&#.&->3.-."6 &&.' 1'.&E&R'3'.-.'/ &'.- > 3  6' &. 1#' E.;& " .0  &- 6' H'& .4/&.&+.>3.-."'/ 1'.& 4 &#/#'+3&'0F0  % &> K;-/% /''"'/%.''. "#&A/"'&-.  ' ' '& # '.4 " ' .  &.' &/6 "& #6HA 3&/ "3'..&  6.'/&/."";. .6&#''>6&'.#'0 ." #6'. /'1.'"/6& '&-"/'&#.' 4 '.  " ".6 .'.  "  0 3&'0  6 &>3.3;.'""/'&#.&.3 '& - 6&/"36/.15&'0F1.0'* 70 8  3&'0  0  %  & &'.' . >. ' & " #.. ' & &/."A1.'8.'>.&#6.'" ".'. 6&/-E &'0  + " " .-' 1//4..& " 6&''.   #6/#'.& .  "/6 & 6&  '6/&.&E&-"/'&#.'08 30%'0 "''".6 .'. %/'&;&" .-' '##'1//4..&"6&''.   #H# '.'& >  8.% 3. ' A1.'/  8. 6"'  ".E  6&//"'.##/".'#'"'+6&'.&">."#"'6&''.  #6/#'.&'3. '"& .'+&'%+ '. 6 &.#6 '' + ."#.'/@ &.,&"3&.-.".'/%>.'"& &'% >.'" #.../8."6..%)#&)9:0 3&'0 * '&.' "  " # '' " 6&''.   #6/#'.& 0 8  30 : " '' ".6 .'. %   . 4/"/& /".' " ".6 .'.   '##'&3/-'. "&-"/'&#.'%""/6& ' "4 &'0 "/'&#.'. "&-''&.'/6&&'0'00

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

2   F0 36,%3 &'&-6&,.-.".'/1/&3>H'. &  '&'& " .& 5.6&, 887%  >. '  &&'0   /;#' "".'. /E.&&'&-6& -'"3&AB#;% >.'#.4'#'. &&'0  &.1 " /  .",& > 3   6' 6  1& &  &- "/'&#./ 6& 3&AB#;% "3 6&'% & ;. &/  '.' 6 #6' " &/ 6 .1..'/ " '&-. " & &' ' >% "3'& 6&'%  "&.&  6&R .' " ."#.'/ @ &.,& " 3&AB#; >3+ &&"F26 &'" ;.&/0 4"&" '.& #6' >"3&-6&,.-.".'/4.'.4%"/'&#./&1"88%>%1. '"%. -.'6"3@ '&."#.'/"AB#;-&/% 6.>.&#88'.' #6'"36.'#60)0 & &' ''6&. #6'"3&-"3.-."4.'.4%'.#' >3 366#''&1//4."34 &#'. 6& 4. ' >3.3'" 66'+;;&> >&-0 & &'4 &- .0 44'%"'1"388))F%"'.-.'/.#6'&/6/'.'.- '6&/-%>."#"'4 &#'. 6& 4. 5'/; &. & -&''&"6& "'. '"&-.%  " .'  44'  -.& >3 &'.  #1& "3'&   ' /;,& ' "6'/ + 3/'' " '/ " & &'0  ##  .& 1&' '"&"./ '.' #6'"3A &.&"'&-."  2226022%'1)07# ''" .'H'&6 &'/+9*D924&0 :26 &3)))0 #6''"4.'>6.'/&/.""'&-." & &'3/,-+:96 &'%# ''" .'H'&".#./+ ." .-'H'&"/'&#./6&&66 &'+ #H## #'G# ".4.'. "&-6'.1"D.4&"& .' +&'&-@>D# #' O"/.. '&"" .-'H'&6&.  #6'5M)'F: .366.> +3&'0F  3"#'6"&/"'. ; 16/&.&+96 &'5M ?  :F  ."0 970  36,%  &.  " '&-. + '#6 6&'. ' " .#.''. "3&/%. -.'"&/".&&-"96 &'%>. &6&/'&-"3.-.""* 3 6&'. '..&  6.'/ &/." ";.  &.  "   K; -/%" /''"'/%".''. "#&A/"'&-. "' ''& # '.4" '.&.'&/6 "&540&'0F1.0 703 && &.',&6&'..&366&Q'044'%3&/3)))3/'.'K;/>" .-'.-.".'/4 &#'. "&& .&."/6"'%>. #6''"6.'/6& 4. &".'' '+4.'''&'.46 & #6 (&&A&A'"#."3X-& >.4./0 # ''%. -.' &""/".&D2224&0 3&'0*0'0 %>.&6&/'&-"**D:9%*9'"&'.&>*%  >.  &&6 " +  # '' " D? 4&0)20   # ''% .  -.' "3@ '&>&'"&'"3&.-.".'/% .'*DF24&05?94&0E70 &-"/'&#.'"& &'3/,-'" +93)?4&)20 "/6& 6 &3/))) '.-'N?D 'H'& '& (/& &'%>. 1'.';."0  

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