opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/539/2004

Genf · 2004-07-07 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

                ! "#

      

         $%&'($)''($*(+$)'', !! - !.- /  -! /.,0  12 3  & ")'', 

    4444444444  !!!!!!!!!! "   "  /55. /  6-! .7..# $"%&    ' '( 

    )*+,-)  5.,. /#( !!!!!!!!!!   " "0,%1, 2 3 /' #'4" (5 # 6( 6"#37' (6    8' #',%9,. 8 :"( '" 3'  ;#'4 '4'  '42 ( ' !!!!!!!!!!#  "'("'''52?!!!!!!!!!!'#)(@5#  /8((#6"''( '"'#30"#21-A4'"' 2 '" # * 7 B,  6" C 6"  (' #',%%C " # '" (#'. *. 3' #"#(##  '"5#3'4'#'  ,, 4' *--* "''   3" "' #3  .   '#'D "::' #3 :'0"($@'. B. " (#'#23::' "#3'4'#' E') 53 F*G4'*--*" " !!!!!!!!!!$7' " #'@" ' # #'"   :'0"($@'. 3 '  2    ;' '  #' #(0,%%&# #3'' # 4'#,--A. C. "# D '"'"(( '" "0$7'D

!!!!!!!!!!'#'DD ' "::' ##'"#'#(0,%%&H #'::'  # "  '" : '@ '"(' "0'   .    ' # "0#"'  # '' "(" (  # "' :(''"'23('@ '"6" #I # 3:: '"  .  47   '  4'  0" # "' 4 3 #  :' (5 '0 ' #3 :   ,%%% D3  ' 2 3D'@#." " 4#'::''# '  4";)('" ' 'D''4' 7"6#''' D' 34' D' ,%9-"D6(4' 2'';("'. 4 3#5(*--*"D3 ' 0"##.3'' # 4' '   #,--A.

1.  "  /' !!!!!!!!!! (#' '   @'   "  #'@" '#:'0"($@' '#'DD3 ' '' # 4'2,-- A #' ,G :4',%%9. 8"  (#' 3 '4'  ; 6D3'' 3 ' ;'@'0 ' # 4'"4' J ('". G. 3 #(#84'(#'@'" 8/ / #3::  ;($7' 'D#3."" #G(*--B$7'  # 8/  /   " " !!!!!!!!!! 54 34"'  "06 '4 # $(I(#'@$7" 'D D#'7' '"" "0# :4#3#'@" '##"( '"$7" 'D.3; ' 40'#3'#''#'  # "0#"'  ("0'#. #7"#3 5@5 '   $7' 'D #

    )B+,-) '('  #  "(.  #'@" ' "   ' # :'0"($@' 4 7( #'4.' # 4';'@'0$7' 'D #,--A. &.   !!!!!!!!!! 7( ""@   0'  "  (#' 2 3  '" # 3 ,&(*--B.":'(#'@" '#:'0"($@' '#'DD # 3 '4'  #3'( ' "' 3  '   '  '"0( ;'@'0#*1A.

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

0  #  7 #87R'S4".,%%,.,&9" CB-F."4'  #4D3 '0#"' 5@@#3@'4   ''5( "D"D#3 '"0"4'  " @'(6'#'DE M,,*B,BF.  (': ( ''#5 "D"'#  "'D#3J # 4' 2'3;' #3 6'#' '"D':" '"#',"K *--B#62 #" 6@ ' ' ''D6@ "  @'5( . F 8;('#3"::'"(<43J # #B-(*--C ' 6D32";' '@( 24':'":"(' 23 .,B,    #"'3' '  .  8   6'#' '" #(''  '4' D3 ' # #"(' ''#"'.$'#D"3 . 1& #  "' :#    ' @ # #"'  #  "'))    4'@ , 64' *--B 7D  " ' '   '0 #

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

    )G+,-) 5 , 64' *---      ('  0:' #3  @ # "(.    '' #4  6'#' '" #(''  '4 ' # #"'  "(( E . 1G  F.  "4  (' ' # "((''" # " ' ;( ::'(E/ ,%%&.%CB-F." '  '"' # 6'#' '"3#6(' ('' M' M . 4"' #"#' '"D'' (J7@' DD  ##":'"(( '5#3"'6D 2#4"2"((''"#"26'#' '"#(''  '4'  83". 8'3"#4' '43'   '"# #"J #B-(*--C" (   8 (' @(  "     "((''" # " '$"(' 7 ')(J(' '" '  '". 3(': (  0 4'@' .

 4 #  D' 5#   '" # 8  ' '" #      ":"(2 " '  '"@4"'. 3 '" # 6@  $   '      '0 :##"J #*&64'*--C# "'@4"'#" ,B :4' *--C  #'"' '" ' "' (    8 # '@   2 "' 6@ ' '  # 3   # 3 '" # "4; . *.  '0 "#"'  ' 'D" ((  "   '" '42"':#3'4'#' E:. .1G ', .7.,F. "':# '@##"' #"'#G" "0 *---E F  4'@,64'*--B P ("#':' '"# "(0#'"' '"@.  '023 :#"@ '"; E ',', F. 6 #:"( #'@;#4 3 "'  "( " 40E '1G19 G- F. B. 8" 3 ' C   3'4'#'  E ' 9  F     #3 ':'('  "@' #3(#'"#3'# .   4#5D3          @4'  " 2 "4' #"'  ;   '"     "'# '".

    '4'#'  3''  # @' "  "  ' D'   ( ( "#"@#E '9 F.'' #@'" # " #'(' '"#3(0"#3 '#"'0'' #@'#3   (7 D''0 # " #"(' #3 '4'  '   #'(' '"   #3  '  2    7$'D " (    D3 '  5  ' (  (##  '";'@'0E '& F."D3

    )&+,-) '4'#'  "'  " '   ' # 7D  D3 #'@" ' (#'  '  "'  "   ''    D "'  ('  4'#  #'(' '"'("  #' # 4'E #@'FE M,*&*%%F.

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

    ),-+,-) !  /.5  !.- /  -! /.

 819   :  ;   6# %<) /=   9 

,. Q"'   " ' 6   /#( !!!!!!!!!! "   #''"  ""' '"#3 #,*"K *--B<  9

*. 6 < B. ' D"# @ ' < C. :"(   ' #  D3 4  :"( " "     J  #  #' # B- 6" #5  " ':' '"  ' "((# #  '0 :# #  87R'S7":D' G G--C     "' ;('.  #'    J  ""@.  (("' #"'  H F '#'D ; ( D#''"" #'"0 '' ##''"  D< 0F ;" " D (" ': '  '( "4"' #(#     #''"< F "   '@  "  # "   . 8'  (("'  " '    "' (  ( "   F 0F   F ')#  '0:##" ( '5"D3' #4#'40.(("'#"( '""("$ # 4 D' "  6"'  '' D  #''"  D   34" # D ;#'" E .,B*,-G ,-9F.  @::'H  \'#  /   '# H  '          "'":"(# J  " ':'; '''D323::':# #"'@::