opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/529/2004

Genf · 2004-06-29 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (2 Absätze)

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

   

/0++/1223 49/034 095 !'.(&0*;'.(1223% !!'F&(G #  !! &%C!( &  7777777777  7777777777  !M(!;,((#!'&(!(.!85 &C.(.'#& (!8&.(5 0@5  '!(# & 1:  1223    ('G  !(' &  (  (G #% ;;( &;(8)G( #  &( '( &(!%G(( &(&'#%'(,(&''  &(!)?((#5 0+5 &!(#&:0 1223% 'G !('&( ';',!'.(5 0>5 !;('G'!(&!(!(# 8(&!(Q&(R(4!-5     + 05 (G.(%G((F&(((BE'' &(;('((' &-  0 I 122:  (8  &  ( B5 0 5  E5  M&:2 1223!& (8& (((;B(4!- E '&%;;(('&%505(&'# N.( ''''.((&%50:0& ((G.(B  E5 085 6&#((((8&'C (;(.S  4 ;(G!&&(!((;&%M5&(!((;&%FG  !#'(%('&?FG' (;5%('&? FG'  %'&, C4( # &   P  &(!((;) .( C!'   P (  !!,  #( ((G( B 6 *@  1*9T U!! '( & &( & (((; 3-  '&(( 0**0 !5 13> T J8?(& &(F&(((!(.'(0*>0!5:0:5E5  4 A('&?FG'.#(#%((#!)# (8!.(C (B;5U!!!5(5!5190E5(!!V%!- &C# &.( M !.(,%(&%(F' ! .(( & &(!((#M'& (&% ;(C &&%'(&FG NK((('& (((F(&((5

   

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

   

/0++/1223 4+/034    )  &  ;(' !  (!'( ?((#  ''G(#5'&.C!'!(B"' (&& (X " 40*+2!59935E#'G(0*+2&('CK'& F(&(( (.(  !' C( !'., %5 0:0 5 0     (8& (((;(&'!&&!.(C'(;5 (8'(&(',  !('X (&%  ((&5#( .(,V& &'((&&'! 5%'( !&!#(# ! (G''(!# (8%'(.&'& !'&%(8(5'('.(&#(  (( !'( &.( 8(    ( &   !((!((-B !((!((C!YE5N"' (& & (!599+Q&)- .(G'  (&%   ((!'(('& ((''&'(&'(& F(&(( & (((. &((  (&'!&  #  '!( !'R5 -  0 F.( 1222    '' (  8'';( &%  G'' &  !'5  (( &.F(&((& (((.!'(&&(   B5 9@  E5  .  (( &  (( &  !'(''C!' ';;('B" 0**+!5*3:2E5((('& F(&((%&!F ('' ((! 6(! 6 5 .(!&&((#(( !M?''G(## ' ! & & ;(   !'  (- &% ( F#,&'., ((&,F(&((& (((. !'( N%5 N(%&.((.%(!'(& &M&:2 1223    N ( 'G      (( &  !'() !(?' (4 M ((((5 % (; !''8.('!'G(5

 . &  #( !'-&  '( & N  !!(( &     ; , ((G.(5  %'( & FG  ) ! ( '' ' !  (8;'&'&M&1+F.(1223& (G.(&!' 0:;'.( 1223  &(!((((!  N&('G , ( FG ((  & % & %'( & .C 5 15 ; ' ,%59@50 NV((# & ( !'., %5 9@   (.,  (;'&'  %4(.(&('&0*F(0*9*B E5 !'& (8&' !FG&&%!-(('8(5

   

/0++/1223 4>/034 :5

  (F' & ;   &'( 'GC    .8 ; ' C59@9*@2 5 35 ((G!! ((#(&.((&  '&(C  # %;&' %   % (   C!( '(' !   7777777777 & N" '   !  

7777777777 !-&  !( . !8  ( %  ( &I !'&,&C  '&(C!!' (5 35

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

#(!(.!8&A!! '&(#(  &' ( A #  !( ((G(C (;( A8F &A '&

   

/0++/1223 4*/034 ((' #  !! ;&  & C   ! #A( ! 'G (&'(!(C!('!!C ('#A( ('''8(!((&A -#&(!(&C '&(A!!'((&(( '&(((;(# ( & AC! ( &I  (.'5  &  A''  &' (!.!8A(A(G(&)&!.( &'(G(   !!    C!( ( 8  8(   B 6019:91(&5:0110@2(&50';'E5 ; ' , A5 @* 5 3   &C(-  !? A;;(;'&' ! &C;;( #(&&&A!F!(&A&'(('   ! & .( '&(C   C;( &AC (  &(( '&(&&(C!( !'&!'&( &.(,&C  '&(C!&'5NA(' : & &(!((;( &  &(;(( & 3 &' 8 1222 B'  .(G0F.(1220E&'&.(&('&A5@*53 &C(-  !?((',(5-AC &! '&( !)?(&A;;(&&&AC ((#&03.(122:;;' !N"' !F!(!M!;,((#5 385

 %!-, %!!( &  ( %;;( ((';( .( #  C !(#'!&CC!%!)?(N"' % ?(G((;!( CC(G#(!F(!&5  .?    &%.( #  C!(  &((   ( !-  #% ., % &% !(( '&(  ;(!7777777777((#! 77777777775  ( #% C!(  !' (  '(  #%&(M;;'!? G5  6!&&#!(((M(.(5 ;;  %C!( '('! 7777777777#;;'!  7777777777'!&C(-!'!F(!& (- &.!85 ((&C;&&C  !& %'B 7777777777%C ('009! 8122: 77777777773 122:E'''8(!-& -; (( !;(  !)?(5 ?# !((  &'.!!'  !!'(( '&(8&%(&&(&   (.' & (- (('  !( & .   ( C# (  !.5  &(( ((-# %' (  !!5  -. M  #  .( & G    #( &&'(!%' !(& !5 ;(# 7777777777(!? G (?(G( ! !&%'!!'((& P(!#

   

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

   

/0++/1223 401/034 %C(G(8(('&%!(&%(.('!;(B 6 !8('&>I 1221+>+/20(&5:8(;(E5  (8;'&'&(G'#%('&!'& #  & 8  ;  &C (',   8(&(' !)?((#G.(!(8&AV(.(&('&  5    8(&(' (   ! A & (-  (!,!&(&'(&&&A'.(G8& (( '&( B 6   !8(' & @ ( 1221     1+9/20 

6 !8('&>I1221+>:/20E5 985

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

   

/0++/1223 40:/034 -.!(#(-&?(('&&'&& #( ( !(8 &;&  !( &';.8, !! & %C(G(8(('&%!(&%(.('!;(!!V'(' (#%( %,(!;;(!F(;(&-(.(&&%(!(' &.(B 6 !8('&0*I122:9:/2:E5 "M ;(8)G(# &(? ( !M(( .%8&!(&C,%C!(&!('!(&)( !!& 77777777775

.&'' %,F(#% - (.(& & 8 & ;;     8   .( & C!5(&(MF'&'((&%  ;('5

   

/0++/1223 403/034  " +2  + "+   "  "

6$ 07   8  9   4: &;( #<   7 

E. 05 '.85 $ 7

15 F5 :5 ;(&'((!!((&% &09&' 8122:5 35 (#!'&G(5 95 ;   !( &  #% !.;     !' M &  &'( & :2 F &-  (;(( ! !(  &' &'  (8;'&' &  N?W(L?;#( @ @223     ( C !(5  &'(  ! M !G'5  ' ( &(S E (&(# C #&'((&'(8((!&&'(( #'T 8E C! ! # (; ( ( !.( & &   &'((T E !  (G   &  !'5 N(  ' (  ( !  ( ''  ' ''   E 8E  E (4&  (8;'&'&!! (-#%( &.&'(.85 ' (& () & !. #(  F( (( #  &'(( #'  %.!! & #''C!'&('B50:102@02>E5  G;;(-S   "(4(  _  '(&S   (`        '(4F(S6"    !(; &!'M(;('C!(((#A,A;;(;'&' &(!G;; 

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

     

    ! "  #$     

         %&''%())* +%,(-%())* +

+ "+   "  " $ (- .$ ())* &/ 01 

  

     23333333333   !!"# " $% &&# '(& ((        22" "+   4" 5 + ((' & ((('&)*+,-.    

   

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

   

/0++/1223 4:/034 +5  03 .( 122:   7777777777 !)?(    7777777777  '&(G'  !! (  & &%C!( !)?((# ;('!% N"' 5 !((C ('%'3  122:.'#4(!'(!&8; G(#& !'(&8& ' (&(&%(& (G;(&&(G'&'!(.(&) !K &(G'!)?(#5

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

   

/0++/1223 43/034 (  !. &% ## (!(' & .( ;;(; !(#%( '(& (!F(!&#%.(& '&(('(;.8, !((&(&;(5 025 &'((&1+8122:% ;'!(&%4 (.(&(',%' (;#C!( '&('('&& & %(( & &( .( ! ( & ;( %8 & &( !)?((#%.(! ('.(&&(((;( ! '4((5 %'  !'(  (,  ' ) .&%(.(&('5 005 (&+. 8122:%'%!!';F( ( &  '&( ( !!)  !!((5  0> . 8 122:(('&'(;(& !'!!((& &'# %  , '&(!?!(&!!&C!5 015  * &' 8 122: %('' ! % ( &  (    ( ( ( '&( & &C '  &  7777777777 !'((  '&( ? (  # .( &(G(#' ;(8)G(0+81221&'F,5!!&0&' 8122: &((&(#'#%(.(C ('%',(!(F(1222 #%( .( ;('  &(G( &;(8)G( &(;; (.(&  : . 8 122:5 (  C ( &  7777777777  7777777777(!(!#%!.('.!!( ;;(&& P;(8)G(%'(;;(. !  &( !)?((#   ( ! & (((;( ! &';(((5 0:5 &'((!!((&09&' 8122:% ;('&'(( & 1+ 8 122:  F' %!!(( & %' & + . 8 122:  .#( '&('((#&(.C!  ',  &' (    .( (' # %' !'&(  !(''(&&.(&022H&!''&(.('5 035 '(&:2F.(1223%'(F'&'(( ,%(&% !-;&'&G'&%(.(&('& 022H((#%,C!( !' (,;;!? G (&'!& & %  (' &% ;- !)?(5   .' # %C!( &  7777777777%.(!!(.!8 &  P  '( ( !-   &(( .  ;;' !  !)?( & N" '  (( #%. %.( &  7777777777 !'((  ? G(5  !   7777777777 %'(  ? G (?(G(%.(((! !' !&' (&;(8)G(&%'5

   

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

 . &  #( !'-&  '( & N  !!(( &     ; , ((G.(5  %'( & FG  ) ! ( '' ' !  (8;'&'&M&1+F.(1223& (G.(&!' 0:;'.( 1223  &(!((((!  N&('G , ( FG ((  & % & %'( & .C 5 15 ; ' ,%59@50 NV((# & ( !'., %5 9@   (.,  (;'&'  %4(.(&('&0*F(0*9*B E5 !'& (8&' !FG&&%!-(('8(5

   

/0++/1223 4>/034 :5

  (F' & ;   &'( 'GC    .8 ; ' C59@9*@2 5 35 ((G!! ((#(&.((&  '&(C  # %;&' %   % (   C!( '(' !   7777777777 & N" '   !  

7777777777 !-&  !( . !8  ( %  ( &I !'&,&C  '&(C!!' (5 35

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

#(!(.!8&A!! '&(#(  &' ( A #  !( ((G(C (;( A8F &A '&

   

/0++/1223 4*/034 ((' #  !! ;&  & C   ! #A( ! 'G (&'(!(C!('!!C ('#A( ('''8(!((&A -#&(!(&C '&(A!!'((&(( '&(((;(# ( & AC! ( &I  (.'5  &  A''  &' (!.!8A(A(G(&)&!.( &'(G(   !!    C!( ( 8  8(   B 6019:91(&5:0110@2(&50';'E5 ; ' , A5 @* 5 3   &C(-  !? A;;(;'&' ! &C;;( #(&&&A!F!(&A&'(('   ! & .( '&(C   C;( &AC (  &(( '&(&&(C!( !'&!'&( &.(,&C  '&(C!&'5NA(' : & &(!((;( &  &(;(( & 3 &' 8 1222 B'  .(G0F.(1220E&'&.(&('&A5@*53 &C(-  !?((',(5-AC &! '&( !)?(&A;;(&&&AC ((#&03.(122:;;' !N"' !F!(!M!;,((#5 385

 %!-, %!!( &  ( %;;( ((';( .( #  C !(#'!&CC!%!)?(N"' % ?(G((;!( CC(G#(!F(!&5  .?    &%.( #  C!(  &((   ( !-  #% ., % &% !(( '&(  ;(!7777777777((#! 77777777775  ( #% C!(  !' (  '(  #%&(M;;'!? G5  6!&&#!(((M(.(5 ;;  %C!( '('! 7777777777#;;'!  7777777777'!&C(-!'!F(!& (- &.!85 ((&C;&&C  !& %'B 7777777777%C ('009! 8122: 77777777773 122:E'''8(!-& -; (( !;(  !)?(5 ?# !((  &'.!!'  !!'(( '&(8&%(&&(&   (.' & (- (('  !( & .   ( C# (  !.5  &(( ((-# %' (  !!5  -. M  #  .( & G    #( &&'(!%' !(& !5 ;(# 7777777777(!? G (?(G( ! !&%'!!'((& P(!#

   

/0++/1223 402/034  8 & ( ((# 8F(. #%(  ,;(, M  &%!!'(   !'(((5  (  (!;( #   77777777777777777777(!((&(;;'& C!  F &  &( & ;;    & %(!(' & .(#%V(,( C!(5 -.;;&%!#(& '&(&; (#, %!!'(( & %(!(' & .( & %'   . !8 (;'(,  & !'(( B  0*>> !5 923E  &% ! #   7777777777 % ! ;;'  C!( (  !- &  #;- M %(!'&(G(&;(8)G(5 &%(#%(!!!('&.('(&& %'&(G#;(8)G( &(#( % '%!-5   %) &-  ! ( &%& &%C!(  !' ( % 8 & &  '&(C! &&' (&5 95   #( & .( ( ;(8)G( & ;;    (.(&5 'G&!!#! ((,' !)?(##(!. (!?)(#!.#(.(&('  &( ( X, !  &(  !!  &( 4   (!)?(##('#(.,& &(5(&-!  &'#&A'!)?(# &(;4&! &;;(, !&  ?G ! A4(.(&(' 4  &((( &  !(' & G(#A'!( !M?;(!.&8.'T  &#(C(G(8&(M&' ('(8F(. #!(85; &'8((&# '! G'(;(('  C  (.(' #  ?' & .( (;;  !  &  !(&5  !( &' (  (( & .( # (.(' ! (8  M C(G' &  5  &  AC( &A (!(' & G( ' !  (,  '  ( A & ! &'((;#A'C(.('(.(;;(T(;8(!K & &A()(&A& # (,!;(&!('&.( ! !(#  ! M (8  C(G' & (  #A ( M (!!8!(''B 60210@9TN1222!509:(&51 ';'T 6 !8('&1+ 1220@>/20E5 &A(,'!)?(#F!&K#&(AG(& &'(&(4(.M-(.(&B 0**+[3*!519@ (&5 38 (;(E5  #(  &'((; A & .( (  (, ' !)?(#(&'!& &(G(V(!('&.( &G(B 6 !8('&1+ 1220@>/20E5 M'!8(' 6 &*! 8122:31:/2:  (8;'&' &   !!' # #%( %'( G( &%'.

   

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

   

/0++/1223 401/034 %C(G(8(('&%!(&%(.('!;(B 6 !8('&>I 1221+>+/20(&5:8(;(E5  (8;'&'&(G'#%('&!'& #  & 8  ;  &C (',   8(&(' !)?((#G.(!(8&AV(.(&('&  5    8(&(' (   ! A & (-  (!,!&(&'(&&&A'.(G8& (( '&( B 6   !8(' & @ ( 1221     1+9/20 

6 !8('&>I1221+>:/20E5 985

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

   

/0++/1223 40:/034 -.!(#(-&?(('&&'&& #( ( !(8 &;&  !( &';.8, !! & %C(G(8(('&%!(&%(.('!;(!!V'(' (#%( %,(!;;(!F(;(&-(.(&&%(!(' &.(B 6 !8('&0*I122:9:/2:E5 "M ;(8)G(# &(? ( !M(( .%8&!(&C,%C!(&!('!(&)( !!& 77777777775

.&'' %,F(#% - (.(& & 8 & ;;     8   .( & C!5(&(MF'&'((&%  ;('5

   

/0++/1223 403/034  " +2  + "+   "  "

6$ 07   8  9   4: &;( # E5  G;;(-S   "(4(  _  '(&S   (`        '(4F(S6"    !(; &!'M(;('C!(((#A,A;;(;'&' &(!G;;