opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/515/2005

Genf · 2005-06-08 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

                 !"

      

         #$%&'#())& #*$*#())* ++  +, ,,  +,   -.  /0   % ! ())* 

    1111111111    ! " # #"  $ ##% &' "(&) *   '"' 

" '  22 ,,  3+,4,5 '#+",-./0.     ! 

   

1.2341/003 5/1/05 , 2 .6 %# 7777777777!7777777777/8 .,-9#!("!## #('  " #$'5:# !./:'.,,9'"#$("'   ""('":"; #"' #"'6 /6   !(";$ : !#'! ' "'"#''("&? @7777777777A ;('2!:''.,,9(': ' #3$B00'6 36 '"' #'(("' #/B:' //(C'.,,9#!# '  # $'!  ' 7777777777    ' 7777777777 > $  " # $'5:# ! D ('E  F; ' (   "'  #$ '( "" # '& #"'"5"C' D#"' #"'"5"C'   "C'F6  '

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

   

1.2341/003 521/05 A$G  # ': #,4M000 '6 G'  '  (" #$' #  *  U AA  $G #$'" '  '! .,,, "G : '!!/0036 "' '(("' "# ## '' > ' #.- " "C'/000;#( '" :'"' $ (# ! $" G"'#"$! !'!#G!('E$ ' "; '( '#("''  >  ## # 'C  " # ' # .3 8  /0096   # ('"!#'     #?#"'! '( '! '300'6 B00'6 "  # .00 '6 ##!     ' #  "##$' 6/B 6 3.6 '"'#"#3'/00B 'C#!: !*  U

AA  A>('"#'#"'#$'"' '"' 6 3/6 '"'''#I8"'5! !: !>('!'' !! '  >  ('"G'" # "C' #    :     '  # $G L7777777777   #"' # ('!"; >#  >('"#'C' >$(('  >' # '"G6 336 *  U AA  A#!("!#"'"' '"'  # #/.'/00B #!! !" '"+!  : ! #':("'#$ '"! : >#   "" '6 $(('"# C6 

": (#" #("'  !('%   AA  A '!';$>8"' '"# ('"!#' # >:! ('":"'"#! :#$"((" ""'!('5I"#  #(+'6 

("' GG!('*  U AA  A"''("#>  "   '!! (' $'   ' #$ ('! # '# ";$' "'#!>'"' '(("' :"# #28:' /0006 ('"("5#;:"'(!#   ##!C '#('> #'!E'#$# !6 3B6  *  U AA  A  #!("!  #"' '  > '" (" #$'W  #"' X ./6/..6B,- "'  $'5#  "(! ' >  

  #"' X .46-3B643/ "'   '

   

1.2341/003 5.01/05 "' :>:!&%'#(('  >'"'  #"'X 363,26.,.":' ';!"#G$ G$ C6  #"'X./6/..6B,-": #' '(E: W 5  ('"(" " #$'5#  "(! ' >  

 #  #' #$ : !##' '#$"#G("'''!#,4M000'6#" ('$!E:>.MB-0'6G!.0.,,, # ;$'!'!("# R"S # #28:' /000"'#;$'! #"#$ & "!Q  5  "''' # // #!C' /000 #  *  U AA  A '! >"'!'   "#.9M339'6:'! '"($( !# ':+ ! ! $ : !#$"' 5G' # '( :#!" ' "###!' #$ #'':#$(('   -/5-9#'# '"G#;'! ;$(('  ; "'  ##'" ' BR ' S ('8"' #" $'!'  30>90H#(' '('# #" #$ &'"#$ : !# '(5##!'!('$'!Q  5   AZ 9B0("'&'>(#AZ3M000("' Q 5"(#$'  ' >('!"! Y('#$ '!#/9 8:'/00.#;'"' ;5$ !#('"   "#  $# ' ; G'  !'" # !!(&"('"" #'"' " 0-26409620620I!'";G' '(G ' #$ YQ  5"'''#B":C'/00/#$'"' '"' ;$ # !':'!##'# '6 

 # #"' X .46-3B643/1. "'   :" #  %'# 3/0 #  '"' >+"##':'W 5  "''' # $' # .3 8 /003 > " '!   !   # $( "('$'!##!# "#"  ## !:'! '"(#.9M339'6## !;'" :'! :"#:" 'Q 5"'''#.38:'/009#'" [ '"  "8'#; ': ; ! # # ' #  '"'  #;  '"' ;$ ": " #$# "("'  '"  #3BM000'6' #NI '"Q 5"''("##/08:'/009#*  U AA  A> '" [  '"  " 8'#; "   ;  ('!  " # " '! "  ('' Q 5#!"#.-'/009#*  U AA  A('"!# >  '!" " # " '  #$'5#  "(! ' 

 :   '! '" .0.,,, '! 'C"'  !G'#('  " :'!" "  #44M290'6-0" ;$: ##!":''; " '! !    C!! #$ #5'  #$:# ! #( .,,9 "';$:  "'''6 346 '"'''#..:'/00B$ "  !;!! ":  >8"'##'#$ ' "#"' $ 8G'/0:'/00B6

   

1.2341/003 5./1/05 , +  .6 "G:"'$"'G "8#'DF! !"#!   !#E .'"N /003 'C "#'""("!#B8G #" ('!#  :5('!# B((!  .48G'D' 6. 6 ' B4 F6 A >$ "#$! "#.48G'(' 'C!#!' /-8:'/009D O.30.04F'# "G:"#"(!.3!:'' #(" " ' "''G ('   'C "#' " # !G'  ' > '" 8G  '  # $   # $! "#":  M' 6 B4 6 .  6  &6 /   'C  " # '""P  ;#"   "('!:>$'  B4 ;" ' :>"'$'5:# !#.,8.,B,6  (( "#$' 6363##(" " ' "'#""#  ('! (# ('5#:  "" "#'"' E'

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

 ':& "  \' D A5\" ' " , # ' 6 2/F #  '"T; "#'   "("('E.'8:'/003": #'"    ((C #E "';M    !''   "('E" '! 

   

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

$G #$ : !:$GL7777777777'"'  GG!  '.M000 /M000'6#.,,->/00.(#/M000>3M000 '6/00/ /003  '3M000 9M000'6/0096'# !!(&" "  /00.(#.MB00>/MB00'6 /00/ /003 /MB00 3MB00'6>(' '#/0096 CF .,,-#:"' " '# '(##?#"'! (':!("'"  "+#900'6('"'!6 F'"' ('=/000"#44M290'6-0#*  U

AA  A"''("# ># !(' #G#2M000'6 #F "' $ : !#'"' ' ":$(('  #'# '"G$ G$ C'! #'(("' "# ! C('( ' # '.-" "C'/000 >##$"'G'+ #! '  ('  "  BR ' S('8"'_[5#6'"' '   '30 90H# (' M ' "#M'6 5 "('#(' 'M"CG "#(' #M(("' '#'"T ( I ''"C   '! !D O..-/49"#63C '!!'QA)1A 421/000(6/0/F6 A"8'('# #" 'M "' !# ' :"8G#":  "#!''    " ('":!; "';M "  ": #  '! ! D\' '#' #):('"?'&  9 !#6 ' .,29 (6 .34Q +G #:'_ G'& (G / !#6 (6 /-2 &6 BF6   #" # '"8G"##!"#(" "" ''#" ' ; #MI '! C#E'''! C((' " ( :'CC M 5>5#'; ('!    #G'! # :'C ('!("#!' 6     #" (;M   ( I ' "#!'!   "&+(" &E("C6 ' "  !!  #   !G! " :GC  8G #"    !&! ' ' $ '"' " "  !''#!'!"(': > C!!   # 2M400 '6 (' " D9 R ' S (' 8"'   ('  "  /9  ' ('8"'>.B0'6$ ' 'B8"'(' 9(' ""  " #-/M000'6('"#" '"' '  30H"  G  # /.M400 '6 #;  ":  # #!#'  .3M000 '6 # ' (+!('  '"' F6     (;('"CC;$(('   #( "&'#$" #$#8??  (#$:G # ('8"'('(("' ' C!!6 #'E'!' ''"' ('!;$(!('"G':  #$  : ! ('" #  '(   ""  #$"'  >   : !#':("'#$ ' '((;$':#('I 5"("' C#$(('  #'# '"G('" #;+ ': 6 #!' "" " '# ":(E##"'('"# (' *  U AA  A6  'E:'  (' '  '  (' # $ '!#/98:'/00. (G ' ('! ('  "  ' #$'  Y;*  U AA  A# ! '"' 6 :#('!"#"!#$' '$JG#$ !'!   ">:"'#   *  U AA  A6   'C#!'  #E"';'"'     #  # $# ': # 56  '!     ##  #"';  '"'     ': >  ' ('" ; ! # ('' #$' > # "C' '('("'':#;'( #"C8 #! ' "'#$#6A$ $!  G;#$('I 5""('#' (("';"'"' '  : #"' ("'"C '( ##!GJ 6 .06  '"'  $ ( ('"#  "   :  ! ! ##!  C # $(('     '"'  # '(("'  # ( ' #  *  U

AA  A;$ G$ C '!#(.0.,,,6'#" #; : !#'"' :$ G$ C" #!C ! ( '#.,,,6 

+#"  ';$; " $ ' #$:" '# +( %'# 3/0    :" # ; $' ('"("   :'  #$ "   # 3BM000 '6  "  :GC;$: # ': C   '!G':':#!'!(''"' 6

"" 'C#!"#E';$ ' "('#$! C' :  #G'! # :'C ('!("#!' ; #E  " #  .,,, $ '"' C!! #2M400 '6('";": #$8" '("'$!/00044M290'6#$# ! (' #G6  "#2M400'6"  ': (;$ (('P  (; :'CC;  '"'  ('="  "' '!GE'  # G   : "  : ! #$"' 5G' #"   "   $"  ( (#  I ' ! C6  " ';  '"'  #("  #$ "+ C( !&! #('":'" ''('"# ('   $"  " &G ("'  ;( :"'#'!('"'#'" 

   

1.2341/003 5.,1/05  $'!"$' 6--   'P(('"#' : '! '" ># "T! #"''("#'  " "#(.,,,(": G"'';G (":  :"' # '!('" ' " #'"  >  '  #$:# !  ;$ : $"CG "#$"''$ 6 

"!;(('"##5' 8 : '! '"  .'.,,," ># >;(I '! C:'  ##G'!# :'C('!("#!' ;'"' : !#$+:"'#'" 6  ((' #' > $  # ''  "   > '  ' >  E' # "#!' ;('!E# 6 ./6 '"' $"C  ; 'E('  G#"  #B00 '6'"'#!>  '##!(6

   

1.2341/003 5/01/05 +  2  +, ,,  +,  

 /676   8  966 6  3" $'(    76 

.6 =" '"'6  76

/6 $#  'E('  ##"#!' 6 36 : $ >''"  >'  '6 96 !C" (' # "  '"" ''""6 B6 "#$ !>:''>%# 7777777777"#B00'6>  '# #!(6 46 "'  ('  # ;$ (:  "'' '"' " '  ('!  ''I  #  #! # 30 8"' #E  "  " (' ( '"#! #'!  'C !#!' # ' A&_?'&"; 4 4009     '"  $!#!' #'"('G'