opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/496/2004

Genf · 2004-06-15 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (2 Absätze)

E. 5 ; *..,:/ 4/ (! &  "! 2   1111111111 " F0 !   (!  6! =<; " (2  " 7(! ?; > "  (! "6!2 " 6 " 5.J 98/ 66 "7=  " D 8!( *..*:/

D/ M  &  63 " "! "  8 "  6

2  

1111111111  ( !6! > H

7! " !  "  6   6  6 "788  ( "!>  "   " 8O 6; & <     I 98/  ",, K *..*:/ -/  "! ", (; *..*2 7   8 ! 7! >  " " ! 3!/

%/ )  3!   *, (;  " "!/  6? & 7  " 7(6   6 " 66 " <6 88!  4 3 P  < 6  (;  ( ?< 6>! 6   1111111111 ,* 3 *..*  3 >7 88 3 "7 6# "; "/ 5/ <! & (2  F0 ! 2  6    M11111111112 "> >  6;'  <> " 88 7!   8! (  6! " (2 Q    " !"(/ F7< " ( "  6 =>  6!"!   1111111111 & 7!; 

) 4+,*)

+,-$-+*..* ?62  7R 6  62  2  6! " ( & <  /

$/   6!( ",, ( *..C2 7   "'   3 " /

 !

,6 :   <(  7< 3" 9:  !! "8!   !2 "' , K *..C2 ;  "   9/, /

:/

  Q " C.  *..42 6"2 ; " 8 9)6'

:  ! "788  ! " 7/, /

2 "! > 

F ( !! !!  ( " 7/,C, "   <()  )/

;: M  "  >      ; " !2 = 8 ( G)   8< 6 "  "68 " 7Q/ 2   "68 "7 3<  6 >! 7! "  ? 3<!2    8/ 7! "  ? 3<!  7!" & =) > "   S  "68 # ( =6!   S   66 &  > <

E. 9 M ",$ 3( *...    T/ !8/  DD4+$52 "/ *:/ 82 7=6 " 7=6    " 6#? "  6 = !/

 " 2   " " 8 "7  " !<  6  "88! '/

 ; " =) 8<  "(<   " "!    6 ;(!2 7!< "7 " "  !> "  (<2 7; " " " " 2  <" "(<   8  8 6  6    " 7 '2  8 > " 6 ' "! (  ; 7=62  > 7!< " " ?"6 <!  (  6#?  9A)E; 0F0 2 F 8  F[<2 ? " 96#??: ?2  G (  "    "  6!(# 68 9F F:,$$$2 6/,  6/,.D P F *... 6/,DD "/ *:/ $/ M  "  >   !"  " !  66!/   66 "7=6 ",* ; *..,2   1111111111  6 6'  !!  "< " 8; #<  8 >  6 "= ! # !>2  >  !"  88  >   6 " 8; #<  6!/

),,+,*)

+,-$-+*..*  6#? !  66! > 7! ( 88 "7 ; "!68 ! "7! !<' & #2  7 6  6 "(<  7# 6 ( H "6  ! I/  8 > 7!  7 6 !  <8 6" 6 !  >  !    !!/

; " !  8  "7( >  "(< " ( !  6  6  Q !  "  6!!  &  ( !" 6@ >7&  2 >"; Q  7 "  ( !  " 7=6 "! 6 7 /

F  8"2 ;   ( 6   " 3<  2  !<" = "" !   "88! 66 !"=/  #  "'   "7  "! >!  "  (# & 7 ! 6   6!  "72   8  "    \( "7 =6 6"6 " #6 0 2  ( "!2  ; "  " )/

),*+,*)

+,-$-+*..*    !4  !-,    , !

# 78   9  :   57 %&("   8 

,/ !   (;/ # 8

*/ 7"  6 / C/

  "! ", (; *..*/ 4/ (   & 788  " 7)("! 6    \( "7 =6 6"6 " #6 0   ( "!/ D/ "  7 ! & (      " 5.. 8/2 &  " 66 &  8  "!6 P -/  >  6!"  </ %/ 8   6 "  >] 6( 8     6! Q "  "! " C. 3 "'  8 6 6  "! "! ; 8!"! " 2 F?UL?8> -2 -..4   2   = 6/  "!  6 Q 6<!/  !  " G : "> =  > "!   "!;    6 "  "! >!P;: =6 6 > 8    6(" "   "!P : 6  <   "  6!/ F  !    6   !!  ! !!   :;:  : )"2 ; 8!"! "   6 6   '    >] "( "! (;/  !  "     # " 6(2 >  32  >  "! >!  ](66 " >   !! =6!"!   9/,C*2,.- ,.5 :/  <88' G 0)  ^

 !" G  _     6 8  " 6! Q  8! = 6  >]& ]88 8!"! "   6  <88

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

    

       ! "# 

         $%&'&$())( $*'&$())* +

, !-,    , ! # %. /# ())* %0 1 2

  

  3333333333 



44!    5, !! !   ! " !  " # $% & '(

 4!

) *+,*)

+,-$-+*..*

,/ 0"  11111111112 !  3,$452  "!6!  " " " 6

 6' " 788  " 7)("! 9)6'  :  *% 6;,$$$2 ! ! " #  " " 2 6 7   ?@   "   ;   6 " !   "> G H 6 " 8; #   6  6; " ( &,..J " **  ,D K,$$$2 6 &  6 ",, (;,$$$/  6! >7 6 =  (! !  H  6  6; "7  ( "!> &  3/  #  ?L       ( " 7?  >7 ( " 7! 6#?>  >7 ( " ?   88  "7 "  "  I/ C/ 7   8!  " "7=6   11111111112 !")?8  ( " ?   &  ?=)")M"/ ) 2 "  66 ",* ; *..,2    " 2

) 6 " (  ;2

)    ;)!2

) ?#6;!;?>2 ?#6 !  " "!6( !2

)  "7; "    " "= @!2

)    ?  " 8/

) C+,*)

+,-$-+*..*

F 7=62 76! " (2  6  "   !!  6?#>  6#? 2  "!6 6 *.J/    "'  > 7! 6 88 7 6 > (! 682 ! 6!! > (  6?#6 9-, E 2 " & 7?#6 !:   6!8!; >7   6;   6 >7 = "  7 ( (7! 6   "7K,$$4 & "!;,$$%2 >7 7( (  6; N ; *.../   6!! > H  6  88 "7 "##;!2 " !6?!; 6  " "  "/   88 !    ; 6#?> I 98/  " 5 ; *..,:/ 4/ (! &  "! 2   1111111111 " F0 !   (!  6! =  "  (! "6!2 " 6 " 5.J 98/ 66 "7=  " D 8!( *..*:/

D/ M  &  63 " "! "  8 "  6

2  

1111111111  ( !6! > H

7! " !  "  6   6  6 "788  ( "!>  "   " 8O 6; &    " " ! 3!/

%/ )  3!   *, (;  " "!/  6? & 7  " 7(6   6 " 66 " ! 6   1111111111 ,* 3 *..*  3 >7 88 3 "7 6# "; "/ 5/   >  6;'   " 88 7!   8! (  6! " (2 Q    " !"(/ F7   6!"!   1111111111 & 7!; 

) 4+,*)

+,-$-+*..* ?62  7R 6  62  2  6! " ( &   

F ( !! !!  ( " 7/,C, "         ; " !2 = 8 ( G)   8 ! 7! "  ? 3  "   S  "68 # ( =6!   S   66 &  >   >7   > 6  # > ; 6( =  98/ T662 6/ / 6/ *D,:/ 2  66R  76' "= > 

"(2  Q  6(2 & 7 "7  3! 6 ( " " 6>   Q! "  "7  8=  " " 7! " 3 7;  "  '   !> " 7;(   !  9 M,,*  C,C:/   8    2 "'  >  "! 6> " 7Q "

( &  7= "7 3" > 8 "6 , K *..C "!3&2  "  3   3 7&  =2   ! 7  " "  6 "  /  #   " 66 >  7/ D% "   8!"!   6    ; " 2 >    >    "  "  "  /  "6 !  & !6 & '(  "(    "   

/ 7  6 !6" & 7=   !    "/  ' 2 !!   #! > "   /  3   = " 7/,C, / *     6 " 6 6 "7;=     " " " 8 P   6!! H ; I     ; " 8  ! H "   S    6!(I/ 7 " > !    " = " 8 '( "7

) -+,*)

+,-$-+*..* 3"/

 76! ! 6  &   "  >    H  I " Q >8!2   !! /  ! " (= 6!6 90!  " "  N 0),$%.2 6/ DD4 /: >  !  ( & R "    "! " "!6 /  7! 6" 6 > >   6    ; 7! ( "! "  6! "7;/  ! !(" >    6! "( ;2     "   6 6' 9 6 62 =6V:/ F  0!  " " 2 6/ DD%2 H "  #'  (   !6   6! I/ ' , 3( *...2 

 !!  ;!!8 "7     6Q?!  ! > ! 6 "2 " 8   6!  ' "7 2 3> & "!( &    " 2 &  3" " ( 6!2 

F  7/ F 7 "( ( 76! "

"  Q " C.  *..42    

F2  !  6!'"2  ! "

F  66 "    8  &        ' "7 F)  98/  D-  :/ F  6! 6 3 7 C, "!; *..*2  !   '   "!    6" 9 M,*%  4-%2 "/, P,*,  C--:/ C/ 7/ 4 /,   "!8 7("!   !  "  "  6! "  ! "7  &  ! 6?#>2   6( "7 8 !   7!  6; " ( &,..J  > 7=6 (  (! 682 6  >7   6;    !"  " !  66!/

D/  662  3  )  " "2  >7 =6 "! 6 ;  8    " ' (/  2 > "7 6! !  " 6  6 &  !   "  6 " "!" " 7=62   6 =2   2  6! "(    ( 6; "7 66 !"2  >  "!  7 >  6    66  8"  " =   62 >7 6  "!  6 =6 !2 >7  !! !;  6  " " 9 ':2 >  "6 " = !"    8 >   " 7=6 ; (! 9 M,** ,-. "/,  !8/ P

M  6;! ",$ 3( *...:/

 2 0    7=6 " Q 8"!   "   6'  " " (> = > 6! 90  2 7=6 !"  F G 8) = = !  Y2  F?UL? ? 7 =6 " Q  6' > = 8 2 &    = !6 = > 6!/  " Q  6!?;2    6 ? " 6 " " 9 A 2 U 2; >  6 "  6  62 7=  >  >  =   6!     !(" > " "8 (  ! >/ 7   6 >  = "76! " (  !! 8=! & *.J  62  " & 7= 2 > 6(2     6?#>2 6(>  ("!   " 7/ 4 /  2  8  N   88  66  " N    6#?> > !>( & " "/   "' 6   " !> "7

) $+,*)

+,-$-+*..* ! 6#?> "8 N " 6   " 88 & 6"  ?  7! 6  6Q?  8 6( "; (! P   "  >  =  6;/  ( " " "!    " >   ! 62    882  6  "  6"2  ?! " ( !>;!/  6 "!    " (> (! 6 ;  Q =  7! =  (! ( 88 P  8; 6@  " " 7 #   "7"  >7   = 2 >7  & 68  6! " (  N " ( N >7  =  6!'" > 7!  88 "7 ; "!68 ! "7! !    6 " 8; #   6 88 " 8; # /

6 "  S   !; >7 #   6#?> # ( " "2   "!8 " (  " >  7! 62   6 ;  Q =   " ?#6?' 9 8 > 7(  ? 7    !2 /:2    " ;3(2  >  !"   6 '    "  "  6! " (   " 6;'  "7" 6#?>  (  6  6  (/

),.+,*)

+,-$-+*..*

F  36"2 " ;  8  "=  8; #   6! " ( 9 M,*. ,,$ "/ *+ P F F,$$% 6/ %DP  0,$$- Z  *D- 6/ *,%  "/ D  -:/   ;  "  ! 2 6 >  =6 6#?>   66 ! >"  7 7  6; "7R 9F *... 6/,-. "/ 4;:/

F 8"   " !" !2 0F0   "!  "!  W? " 7=6 !"2 > ) "  6   ' (" " ;  8   8; # 2 7=6 " 6  " 2 " 88 6 ?>2  6 "7!  " )  !  ";2  "! " 6 ! "  " ( " # 6@  ;   !(2 7!? "   8  = '  "  (  " 6 ' "! (  ; 7=62  > 7!    !"  " !  66!/   66 "7=6 ",* ; *..,2   1111111111  6 6'  !!  "   6 "= ! # !>2  >  !"  88  >   6 " 8; #  7! ( 88 "7 ; "!68 ! "7! !  7!  7 6 !     !    !!/

; " !  8  "7( >  "( 7&  2 >"; Q  7 "  ( !  " 7=6 "! 6 7 /

F  8"2 ;   ( 6   " 3 !  "  (# & 7 ! 6   6!  "72   8  "    \( "7 =6 6"6 " #6 0 2  ( "!2  ; "  " )/

),*+,*)

+,-$-+*..*    !4  !-,    , !

# 78   9  :   57 %&("   8 

,/ !   (;/ # 8

*/ 7"  6 / C/

  "! ", (; *..*/ 4/ (   & 788  " 7)("! 6    \( "7 =6 6"6 " #6 0   ( "!/ D/ "  7 ! & (      " 5.. 8/2 &  " 66 &  8  "!6 P -/  >  6!"  ] 6( 8     6! Q "  "! " C. 3 "'  8 6 6  "! "! ; 8!"! " 2 F?UL?8> -2 -..4   2   = 6/  "!  6 Q 6  =  > "!   "!;    6 "  "! >!P;: =6 6 > 8    6(" "   "!P : 6   ] "( "! (;/  !  "     # " 6(2 >  32  >  "! >!  ](66 " >   !! =6!"!   9/,C*2,.- ,.5 :/  ]& ]88 8!"! "   6  <88