opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/495/2006

Genf · 2006-05-26 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

 

      

        ! "#

      

         $%&''$('') $*+)$('', !!

- !.-   -!   / 0 1 # (,  ('', 

  !"""#$"$%& !'($'( )$( (! *    +#$ ,  -"$ #$"!  !"" (!($

!$( ..     + **  %  "( &!/0 123 "$"#

   

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

   

4567748779 %A458% (. (>$!!; $#88I3"(877A:*!(>$!!;   ($"$"!'#("'>#(",'$"$+#$"$"$#-"#"""$#G (>" (3" $ !( #$"$ !"G !=""$#!="(+3"$'#$# D"#  ("!   !3;(!  +(#G !J '!"$  -"=(!&;" ( "D%>"$ #$"$ !!(DG  $>&" #$"$ !(:  (>$!!;!("",#,+"$"$#!(="$!(!#(#  !=('!"$!!(D#$$'=,+5///:'$"$$(3""$ ' '" 5//6 " "$ #!"  ($" !=(  $K> !$",: 3"$!"F$('=+--$($(3"'#;(, "-#; 197H: /: $50I"877C +(##$#!"1D'($"$"""'""(     +*     + **  %   ?"%'(2   @: $$ D'($"  !$$ #$# !"$ '(  (   (>$!!; $   '&>"$(:   '($" B""!B   D'($ !$ (3# L B +;"$ + '$"$," !--( + &(! !!(D >(!",  $!>$  (>" $  "$( '"( $ '3" $'!(,"3$";$"!!'#$"( $$="!!;",,+ ";("#" +!$''("($"(#$"!!;"'(#": &(! $ ! ''($# 1 , ($" !$ -"=(!&;": +D '&>"$(",  (#32 '  $(!= !$= ?M@B:  D'($ !$ $"#,+$"3"$#3'!"=""$#>;('!"$"!$4!!3!"('!( (#'#(( '!(("$ F$( ('(" 1 '" $'  "#"$$: +$"3"$# D(# I,+!( #$"$ !( D";"=  ! (#(3  ($("$"! $"!#: +(#+3"$2!('=!"(#'$$"!: 57: (''!($(3"#"(#;"! ?*@$#57'$=(877C  ( $"# D"", ,+'"$#$!$ $(3" #$"$ D";"=  +$"3"$# >="$  3 ($" ""$$"! -!$"! ?#3"$(  '!"$"! "!=" '(!!;# $  '!"$"! "!!@: #"'(#"#,!(+3"$'#3!#'" 5//6 $,+" #$"$ ! #;"$"  !(,  >!(" '$%F$(  #;( #$$ #'("- ';(  !$  ($"-"$ #"3(# '(  #" $("$$  +#$$ $#$"$(-$","'(#3"$("2(#G"+&3"$I" +$$"$1$#+(%"3""$#: 55: (#""!C!$!=(877C + (I$#'($$"!: 58: (!(("(5(!3=(877C +(#-!(#!''!"$"!1$$#""!  !$ 1 +!$(!" + ($ +"3""$#  "",+1 '!3!"( !'#$(  #("$(: 5A: ( !(("(  87 I3"( 8779  +(#  -"$ 3!"(, !  ( $. #$"$+"'"$#"-$('((

   

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

   

4567748779 %0458%

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

   

4567748779 %57458%

 --$  " -$ "( +D"$ + !!(=""$# '&>"$(", + "$# $ +(#"'!($$I("'( '",+D'($"#'(#$ $(!='&>"$(",: *'!2!(,$"!'(##3$+$(("$2(!$ '($+''(#"(($2("3"$$(!=!$!-!(!!(D:

 +D  +D'($"     ! '$ $"( '!( #$=" +D"$ +--$"!!('!(>(!",: (3> !'$$IK; (!($    '"$# +(  ('!=""$#   ''($  $K>,!$""'($""($#;"",+#$"!D -$ -!($!$$(,++'#'"#(!('$$"3$,+="$''($+"$#;($"!!"$!$"-$$"! 3":("$3$;!(1+D"$+#$$'&>",("$"# " 1+#>$("$$=$!"(!$$"!"(!-!(D(2;+($ #3!$"!'!"='$>#('$", '",(!($ ,"! #" $("$$  !--($ '(  '#  $(!= #'("-   '(#$ ' $$'$>!!;"'&>"$(",:

 3  +=   ##$  $  #'"$  ($2( >(!",  !(  +(#  ! !"$ "( % + '!"$  3 I("", %  ($2( "3"$-"=(!&;":($$ ("$'(#$(1'($$"! +(%"3""$#: (!(-!#('(!#,$(I$#:   

   

4567748779 %55458%

   

4567748779 %58458%

!  2  !.-   -!  

# 345   6  7   89 %,(:;   5 

5: !$$,(!($(3=: # 5

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