opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/494/2007

Genf · 2007-05-09 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

           ! "# $%  &! !

     

       '()*+',--) "'*.*',--/ "  " "#    # 

01) ! . 0,--/    !"#$%     &

& ''   ($$ )    *+,  &!"

    #-./0#122.)1#3-)  $" 3% "4563+7288&"99&:   :  6*: & ;&  3+03  &8& 8" "  9&" "  98 99 8& 96 ( &;&" 98 !9&& &  "&"  9 9  ?@!:% 93++,&&6&"&6&&96>% 1%   !   (A9 :"" (&""  8& (;B& ( ;6& 98 & (&":&98  9"&:"&& 0+D%*&?5 99&E 3,6!;3+++ 56F&C G;88&" & (E9"6 9&" %&49&&  &6% %; ( !9"?88& 96 (?*9&6&" &  9%   9& !; &!&  &&&% $ 6  &6   &&&6H&&99"9B F & &(546&% ("6&   " 4 6 9!&&  ""6  9;&" 9 %   &6  &6 9 &8% (& B& 9I& H&  & 6:;%  8&9*&&8&!" F6  (;&% %  & ":!& !&&  (   ; :& 88 !&&6JG ; F85&99& &:& "6"!&   6  & !&" F(  88&" ("   9  &6"&3+03&3+0- 9: 6*: & 9"  -431!%3+0-#0/43+07"&& "9 &%3+07&3+0,"&& ?@!: & !9*" 9 &  " !! 9"&& (% 95  >5!9"  ?@!:&6"9":3+0+&3++2 9 : 6*:3++39 &-!%3++343++."&&  6 "9 & (  ?@!%$9&( &9* &  8&%  3++.   ""  :  6 &   F(  >9&BF(3++,%  &&&6&"8&(;B& 9&

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

    #-./0#122.)/#3-) +%  ,&;122,("8!"&&& " &!9&!&4&%!&6"&!& 999&E 3,6!;3+++% 32%  "&!& /6!;122.(&!"B& % 33%  !9&9 9& 33B61227& ""F("&&&!&69 9*?&%6& 9*?&?"9?N!"  98 ("122.4  > 89!%5F9*?&9 &!9 9;!;  " 9 !  :!&"%  (6& 9 !!" 4 8  &: 4 (&O&F6&"&"99"9 8& &&&&"&(9&&99F(!":P& 9&">4 ! %8&&!& ;""6&&(6&9 &6"!""% 31% 12!1227 "9 4FFF&9"9

;  "%   "!  :&  9&;&  (&6&" &  (&&& &:6 9&"!9&&  && >> & 9QF ?&F & &)>  !9:" ( & 9*?&?"9&F% 9 &  9& 9  :" !& &;9*?F"&&&5"6"!9&&  &; 9&"% 3-%     13 B 1227 ;  "   "  >9& 9*?&F&!!4&&8956 "> 9&  9;&"  (>9!   ?>  (>9& &  F& 4  9% 3/% $(>9& 3.B6122, &88 ( &;!>& 9&"6&& *>9Q ?&F& >> 9&&;:   9&"  &6 &&  9 &  4 9&  6  & 

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

    #-./0#122.)7#3-)  #" 3% :6S:&B  ! &"6&4& (6 &"99"  9"" &(&"6:  * (99F99:""  &&&F)!H! ?:!& ;":) 5: 99; &   6:  !!& R  8& B F!& "&!&  & 9 &%   & 4  & &) H& >!"  :  ( &99" BF(-3 "!;1221&8&  6":!&&":95&& & :; &! S&%10%3 6:BF(-3B6122-S" &4&&5S&6 4771#-D!4 !)&S &6 4.2D!4F& &S&6 4/2D !W 9";S"9& S95S&%10%3; 9"&   !)&S&6 4/2D!% (&"6: /5!"6  ! 8"& (&%10% 3 &84("?!& &&> (6 &"% F( & &5 "&&  " 96& 4  " 5 F  :" (6 &" &&:&771#-D&& 9&9"6& "! (&*&)F&  & 4  " 9"&&  :" (6 &" ( ! 72 D &  & &54 &&>&9"4,2D &&64(& (F& ( !)& !&?:"%6?99 "699"BF(9B9 !&5 ("6& (6 &" 6&  6 &" F  &  (!9        /5! "6    9&;!&>: (" :; & H& "&!"  ;B&6!&F9;%8& "&;& F!" 9&!:"8!&"!&>&6&"F!?" &6 88!9&& 9&& %9& "&!&& 6F &6&"9& ;!& H&>:" % !&&(>& (9&" :"9&&&4&"!&(& 9 "8F(">&6&"&688&W8&;9&@& ! (* ( !&&F!498& 9&" &6 9&9&F!&9H&;!&>:" F(&!H! 99&;9"&"   & &  @  !&5 (6 &";8" "  H& '31, 1+/9""B9 &6>&&&4&"9*?F%  8&9*?>&8:&9!; &&&4 &"9&; (&I9&" : (&%/%3 %  F( 6 &" &   & "  ?F  F( ;&&!" 9&&&6&9&" &6  & & 99&  9! 9 & !95:& (!59&&F :&!" 9"(*&&&4 &"9*?FF"F6&4! % 88&9F&; F&&&" (&&&F56& 8&&W8& & F  &; F !9& (& ""!& 9&&  9 9*?&F&9>!9 "9 ;!" "&& 9*?F !; &   !9 ?! "96%  & &&& 9*?F F & H& &:"  8& & & F &  !5&!89&" &6&" "8&69 F ( 9 9 (6 &"%  6? 4 R (>9&  56 9 (& F  ""!& F &6&  >9& &     ?!9&9*?(*9 (&&&4&"4&5 6 & 9&9*?&F9  & % !! ( 6"  $  >9& & !   :&%   !&&&  88& F  & 88 ( &;!>& 9&"% "&"":!&!"6 9&& )&F(!& F&F&C GB&99I&8W9  ! !:W 9"99I&8& ":"% : 88&" !!&6&&9&&"9")

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

    #-./0#122.)31#3-) 3++,%99&  9&":!&"99&F ! &&&"&& & 6%!R"&" "9" !1223& "688&"&&83!1222% 33% 6 F9"5  !% 31% (&!"!;&"!!& 1228%!4?:99& (&%7+%3; % 

    #-./0#122.)3-#3-)   #"$  " "#    # 

!  2 30

3% "6;% ! 3

1% ( !&% -%  " (&!" +9&!;122.% /% &&& (6 &"&5 53!1222% .% ("!!&8>"41228%&!4?: (&!"% 7% 8!  9&   FS 96& 8!  &  9"& H&   "  -2 B 5  &8& 95 ; 8" " &%01 8" ";8" " 3, B 122.   &  (&% /1  '%  9"& H& &  95  9  &6F"!!!* 96 6&H&B&4(6%   :885     A 

$  " &C    *       98! 9"&H&&&8">9&FS4S888" " 9:88