opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/46/2004

Genf · 2004-02-03 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (2 Absätze)

E. 4 05,4

5/6-750880 !# 6 "

/9 $" ::::::::::. * ;2" /,</. (  "" * ="".  2"*  )!*   ="  ! " >:::::::::: % ? % "@+;)! /;" /,,0. (  ? ) " ! "" 1 ( !AA"   ( !" B"41 ! C9 " . "  ==*   "2" * (!"( *"" ( *""  (!2" ( A&")9

E. 09  ;  O 39 A"  (*"" ( !  ( /< 2" 0880 O I9 A   " ( )P 2 A     * D (  (*" ( 38; (1   "A" "  " (* (*  "& A*(* ( . %=U"L=A)" 6. 688I   .  " '"9  (*"   D  @*9 

*" (" K C "(") ' )P (*""   (*" & "  "   (  (*""  )*O &C ' ) "A "  " 2" ((     (*""O C   "@    (  *  9 %" 

*"   "   " **  ***    C &C  C "4(.  "& A*(* (         "1   )P" (2 (* "2&9 

*" (   "   + ( 2.)" ;" . "")  (*""  )*  P2 ( )  

* * '*("*   B 9 /30. /86  /87 C9  @AA" K "  %

 *"(  K & %  * "4;"  K

# $   " A ( * D   "A"* '  " "")P? PAA" A*(* (  "   @AA

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

           !""!## $% % 

         &'()*&+,,+ "&-(&+,,- ."  " #/ #"#/ ! #!  /! %  0 12 +,,- +3   

   4% 5555555555   ! " " #$ %    &' ( ) " *" ("" 

  66 ! #"#/ ! /7#!8 #9/  "!  ( +,-. /0// 12 /3 " "*

4 05,4

5/6-750880 !# 6 "

/9 $" ::::::::::. * ;2" /, :::::::::: % ? % "@+;)! /;" /,,0. (  ? ) " ! "" 1 ( !AA"   ( !" B"41 ! C9 " . "  ==*   "2" * (!"( *"" ( *""  (!2" ( A&")9 09  06  & /,,,. !*  (**  (( (   " ( !4 "2"(" * 1 ( !AA"   ( !4"2"(" * B"41 ! C9  ((" ? D  "  &**A" (!  (  "  ' (4 &@" =") ( " AA" (" /,7-.  ("1 !*  @@2* "  ?  =  ;" /,,79 !*  (** D   &**A" (   "   (* ' =E  A" ( (" B$ %C9 ". (1 (*& /,,,. "  F (   " ( !G" @**9 39  /  088/.  ( 

::::::::::. *(" "  .  *("@*   ? !  " ( !  ( ) "  ("@ ")* ( &@" =")9   "" '")") ! "  ?   * (" (";" /,,7. ) !*

* " &*   ( ( !"9  ("@=" (   AA * ;2" /,,,   "  ( *"  "). " ( *&=  *=+ " &.  ("1  " ? 2'" * ("    " <4%/9 !"" * ( 2" ( !* !*2" ? /88 H ("  / 2& /,,,  . !"

* " "& ( 2"  ) *"" ( *"" ( A" ( ( &"  "  (    " (& . !" **

* " (   (!AA   2" *( "9 I9 %"  ? !"" " ( !" ** ? !AA" *@" (  B"41 !C  0  & 088/  ) (( (!". !  (  (*""  /7 (*& 088/ (* !* "     " "  (" ' "(" * ( !4=E@9 <9  07  & 088/.  )D  ( (  ::::::::::. *("4" ( ! .  ( 

::::::::::  * *    *"*) !*  (  * (   "  !* "  ("A"* (" /,,, )!"

* "  &""*9  *" (*@** "2 &2*  "2 ( =" !'")"    "  (  " 9  " * ( 2" ( !* (  2" *( " (" ( /88 H9

4 35,4

5/6-750880 69  (*"" ( /< 2" 0880. !   A* ? !*    (!( A")!   ( !4"2"(" *9  !+ 2"  (  4 "(" " ?  " ( 2" (  "  "2" * (!*   ="  ! "  ?   * ( " AA" !2"  2 (!"2"(" *9 -9  0 " 0880. !*  " ; *      (*""  !" *("" (  "  *@). ("  (*E (  ((   & /,,,.   "  ?   * !* " @@2*.  ( !  !2"    9   . " !* " ") &*    ( ( 

::::::::::         D)  (". @* " * ( "  . !2";" ((* (!' * " " "" * !2" (! *"" 9    ""   2" ' (! "2" *  "2  " ( ! "  ?   *  " ? ! " (!    "1 (!"2"(" *. &"("" ? !( (!' A("  (! ' "   = @9     ( . "  ("   "A" (  *(" "  ( 0/ A*2" 0880    (  "" * ( 2" ? /88 H ("  / 2& /,,,9 79  *2" ( 0;" 0880. !   *  ; ( . @ ( A")  *(" "  2" *"*)  

* "   ( 2" ? /88 H (   "2" * *( " ).   "2" * =+").  ( 2 *&  "  &9  )" "   "A" *(" ( ( 

::::::::::. !   "")!" 

*("  ' '"@ *  ;"(   "1 ( 2 &  (!  *(". & 2"

* * *("@*   &" (  9,9

* ?  (* ".   

*")*  /< J 0880)   "A" " "@"' 2"

* *

* &"  0/ A*2" 0880 )  (*"" ( ! 

* " " 2  /I 2" 08809   . " !2"   D 

* &"   &" (   "") 

* (" ! 9 /89   (") ( 38 J 0880. !   " * " *@ (  "   "@)!" !+ 2"  " ( !*  ( *" " ( ( 

::::::::::  )" "  " * ( 2" (  9 //9  < (*& 0880.    (" (' 2 "1 K   ( 0<;" 0880 *("@*   (  ::::::::::  ::::::::::. *(" "  ?  ("2"" ( = @" ( (*  ( *(" "  ( GE" ' "2" " ( 12 B"41 GC    (!' " ( 0< 2& 0880 ( (  ::::::::::. *(" +=" 9   ""

4 I5,4

5/6-750880 ( G  ("@ ")* ( ="@"   

*  '"4(*"A. 1 2" 2      " & " ( = @"  //  /0;" 08809  ("@=" (   (4&" A5A" ( //;" 0880  "  *2"( ( ("  & (*@** "A.  " (" <4%/ "")!

* + =*" ( <4%/9   (  ::::::::::. "  ("@ ")* 

*  (*"24'"'.  =+("  ( & '"' *21.   " AA (  & (" " *9 

*  &"( !* " " * @"2 .   *; ("  *. (   "  ? 2" ( AF "2"9  * "   & (  " * ( + ="LM(9  ("AA*  & +="). =")  *21.  N"  "" * ( 2" 1 . ;"  ? !D ( 2" ? /88 H ( * ( / 2& /,,,9 /09

1 2" "  (   2" *(" *@" ( !4 "2"(" * B"41  %$  $ C. !  ! (* "*  < 2& 0883  "  (  "9   "@*) !2" ( (  ::::::::::

* " @  *" ?  (*"" ( A ( !4 "2"(" *.   !' AA *   G 

* * 08809   .   ""  "" !*) (" A" 0880  .  *). "  2"    (! "" *  ( 2" ("  /  & /,,,9  (" ". !  2")!2  (  (  (*"" " "@".  2"

* * ("@ ")*   "  ?   * =+")   !)!? A" 0880)  *(" +="  2" A"

*  .   "1 A". (! & '"4 (*"A9

!#  " /9  " A*(*    " @** ( (" (  " ( 6  & 0888 B C   *  2"@  /;2" 0883.  N ( & ("A" " (  (" ( !4"2"(" *9   (!1 (  A" *@"   ("" "  2"@;)! 3/ (*& 0880.  *@( ""  ) ;@ (  " !  ? (  "(* "  ("A" " ( ("  ( !*  ( A"  *" ?  (  (* "  (  (*"" " "@" B # /0-  I6-. "(9 /. /0/  376. "(9 /& O A9 *@ ("" " " ".  9 70 9 /  C9  * " "@   *) '"* ?  "1 ( ("" " (  "  !4"2"(" * ( /,;" /,<, B C  (  1@ ( /-;2"

4 <5,4

5/6-750880 /,6/  2"@;)! 3/ (*& 0880 B C9  ("" " *@  (1  " * (  " 9 09  " @2"  !@" ";(""" ( 00 2& /,I/ BC 

* * ("A"*   " " *. (1  / J 0883.  "&   (  "9 A* ? ! " 3 "* 3 ( ("" " " ".   " ("  2 ! *  2"@ (  "  (  (2  ""   (    "1 (!4"2"(" * 

* * " (!AA"  "&   (  ".     "  ").      "   "1 (!4"2"(" *   BA9  9 <6 C9  *  ( "& ( *  ""

* &" ;@ (  (!19 39  ; *    ".    ?  *@(2& A* '  " 6,    7I (  " A*(*  !42""  2"2  ( 08 (*& /,I6 B %C  "&9 I9  " "@   "   " ( 2") ("" " (  " * ( @"   &"  " (!  "  ?   * =+")  +=")9

I9 ! 9 I 9/    ") !"2"(" *   ("" " (  " * ( @". **    ( @ (*.)" *  (!  "  ?   * =+").    2 (! "A"" * @*" . (! ("  (! "( 9 )! "2"(" * " . "  *". ( =) .)! ("@ " *("  " " *   *""  ) " "  *2"(  ("" " "   (  " * ( 2" B ( @"C B # /0-  0,,C9 "   "  ?   * +=").)" 2 .    "  =+"). 2)  "2"(" *   ( P 9 I 9 /  .  ("  " Q ?   ("    ("  4  " +="))" *)"2 ? ( ("9   "(1   ( *) (P

*  +=") ("A 4 (   ( AA " ? (  =@  P4"2"(" * 4  ("" " (  " * ( @") P* " D=  A" 2 ( & 2 *O   ( )"  '"@"& (" D  (* "* " &; "2) "&9  A (

* &" "  ()   *  . @*  "A"" *  . '   "2" *)  =* ( 2" " AA.    (   " (9  " (* "  "" ( 2")  "2" *  "& D  '"@* (  9  (  P'"  (P "" * ( @" *    "  ?   *  . " P ( 

4 65,4

5/6-750880 (*""A) P* '   "2" *  "2 "AA" O " A &"  E  (( P" +  " (P( )  " ? A" (  " * ( 2"   .  ") .  D  "& '"@* ( ". )P " D " &   "* * B # /80  /6<O % 0888 9 /<3 "(9 0   *A* O

#  &"*  6758/ ( 0-  088/C9   ( P "  ?   * +=") ;  ( E)(" P@" ( (*"( " 4" 2D     1 "2"( B /,,- R I, 9 0<6 "(9 I& " A"C9 )"  (*""A. P ( 2" "   "  ?   * +="). "(*( (  "@".  N  "" * ( 2"  ( @" B #  &"*  6758/ ( 0-  088/C9 I9&  !1. ! "  =+") 

* &". ( D) !"" * ( 2" ( 

* ")"  (*9     *@  2=.  " * ( 2"   "19 %  ( ) " ( ! "  ?   * +=").

* &"     *("' ("    ( *(.  "2  ( *(" ( G B ( 0<;" 0880C    ' +="  *" ( * ?  AA .  (  :::::::::: B ( 0< 2& 0880C9 <9  )"   2 &  (!  *(". )"  (* " . !)  "  " "@"' "   " A" !&; (!

* ( A"*.)    A(  ( '  .)!"  *@  "(* "  "  '"*.)!" "

* *

* &"  " " ( (" B1C.)  (" " (  '  *(" " "  A")  " ( !' " &" "2* B # /00  /68 O  ") % 350888. 9/<IC9

 " " +  " ( *").  ;"(.  " A")!  "A" *(" "

* &" ?  (( (!  "  (" (  *( ; "A" .  ". ( ( ) ?  2 & 9  ' " * *    "  ( *@ 2"  + ( 29  2  ( "" **  ;"(  !*" " ( 2. ;@   A"  (!'" "    ?    ( .   "  " "@"' "  . !""   " ( !' ( *   "&9  ;"( !") " &" )! *  (   .  + (! ' " "2*.  " (! ' " *@*  !4"(     AA" ( !4"2"(" * B #  &"* ( 06;" 0880     /,580 =C9

4 -5,4

5/6-750880

 12 ).  ;"(   . ;@ (  " *"  *@" * ( (*""  )*.  1@ @**. (!1 !*  ( A" '"    S  (*"" " "@" 

* * ( B # /0-  I6- "(9 /. /0/  366 "(9 /&9. //6  0I7 "(9 /C9  A"  2  *" . )"  ("A"*   "  ". ("2  A" !&; (! 2 (*"" (""  "2 B # //-  0,3 "(9 I.

#  &"* ( 0< J 0883     3,0583C9 <9&  !1.   A"

*  (! @@2 " ( 

*  (  * ("  (*E (  ((   & /,,,9 %!"  D   " 2 &  '   *("'  "*. " "(( (   ) '4"   *" ?  (*"" ( /< 2" 0880 ( ! 9

!*  ( A" (  *  AA" !  ? " (! " "@ """ (*" ? ! #  &"* ( /6  & 0883     6<-580   6<7580   ()  "& A*(* (  B # C 2";@*) (' ' "  *" ?  (*"" " "@".  (  ( A"   *" ? 4".  2"    ("A" "9    " ""  ) " ( (*& ( ! "  ?   *. ) 2"

* * A"'*   *""  ( "1

*  "29  #  ;@*)! * (!"  "   " ( *" ( "1  A"&  (*& ( ! "  ) " "").   *=* .  @2" *   "A   " * ( 2" ( !*;)!?  (  (* "  (  (*""  9

 !.  (  ( ("" !AA" " "*

* " AA"    "  " * ( 2" *"( (  ( /88 H (   "2" * *@1 ( *  =("9     "*     ( !*  (      ". " (    T2  * (!"  "9  *(" +=" . !"  ("@ ")* ( 2 AA ".  *"*) 4" 2" (*& * " +  " * )! !* " @@2* ("  *9  *A* ? !D  "*. A  (   )! * (!"  "  "   ( (* " 2  ( *""  (*& ( ! "  +=") ?   * (  "")  @2" *   "A   " * ( 2" ( !*;)!?  (  (* "  ( /< 2" 08809

 2 (  ("2 ** .   (" D  ; *   (*"" ( !  ( /< 2" 0880 A"*9 

*  . " "(( 2). !"  A"  !&; (  *  *(.  (" (  ? (   " (

4 75,4

5/6-750880 !4"2"(" * "  ? !*2 " ( "  ("   (   D  '"* (  ( (! *( ( *2"" B # /0/  366 "(9 /&   *A*C9

4,5,4

5/6-750880  ! " 6 /! " #/ #"#/ ! #!  /!

%  14 

/9 * 2&   " ; *  (  ( 0 " 0880  $" :::::::::: ? !  (  (*"" ( !  ( /< 2" 0880 O % 14

09  ;  O 39 A"  (*"" ( !  ( /< 2" 0880 O I9 A   " ( )P 2 A     * D (  (*" ( 38; (1   "A" "  " (* (*  "& A*(* ( . %=U"L=A)" 6. 688I   .  " '"9  (*"   D  @*9 

*" (" K C "(") ' )P (*""   (*" & "  "   (  (*""  )*O &C ' ) "A "  " 2" ((     (*""O C   "@    (  *  9 %" 

*"   "   " **  ***    C &C  C "4(.  "& A*(* (         "1   )P" (2 (* "2&9 

*" (   "   + ( 2.)" ;" . "")  (*""  )*  P2 ( )  

* * '*("*   B 9 /30. /86  /87 C9  @AA" K "  %

 *"(  K & %  * "4;"  K

# $   " A ( * D   "A"* '  " "")P? PAA" A*(* (  "   @AA