opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/460/2004

Genf · 2004-06-17 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)



      

        ! "#

      

         $%&%'$'((% $)*($'(() !! + !,+ -  +! -, ./  01 2  %3 " '(() 

 , - 4-,  - ,- !" #$%&'()* "+"   !  ,----------."+..!!" ./!/ 56666666666 01..2 "/1" 

   

3%%&3&''% 4&3%&4  7,

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

   

3%%&3&''% 4E3%&4 /!.!"C I !!K.+8 !!8 =)+"!/?>.*.!.4 +$+  !/5   /:/ ?>.  . *.! 8 /!/ 8 .= " ! *  8 C !+8 ! ?>. *.! 8 .*. >!.*.!/ "   ./!/ " >8 . ">8.5 % ."+..!!I .!C"/!+.!.  " !.1.! +/".K 1.! /!! "  8 =)+ " !/ ! .".?/ ?>. *.*.!"!">.*.".!/5

 !-,

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

 * "  ?. 8/)"  /!.  " 7  88.!.  "    !  1 +C !.!!. :* .5  >/!.  " I:  O! 8 . /!/ / 8  .= 1/"/" $!"&;I*.&''" .:* ." 8!/ %E 1/*. &''  ".8 .!. !.! .8+!!! 7"./:  C ! . I: !.!.  " >!!! " >/!.  "  *K 5 &5 1 +/+!C>!5E5E"".8 .!. !.! ..! ".! *!>!/*.:" .!8"!"*! ++.. !  "   ! /!/ !+. "> 11.  .= !  "   .!!!.!.? !!!. +!.)">4

   

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

  " 1..!  "   "! 8 ="  ">!.1  . > 8 /.+!  . " " ++:  + +! +! N  8!  !  != " ".!.=!.  !   +8! 1. /!=. 8 > 11. " 1..! .?."! C"!C?J .!!""/1!" =.5 11!.?.=.!8!"1..! "8 /"   "!.!*!.!!!. " ++:4.!/$!://   8!.? " !.=K "/IC 11.++!  . " " ++: 

   

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

   

3%%&3&''% 4(3%&4 +.*/% .!?!!> 88 .!. ??$! +.*/ !*=C1 +0!5(%5E!(&5& 725 5

K!+">!5& 7>+8 O" .! *." ++:?>./ *. !8.8!. .!!. +! 8/:.::*5."" 88?>!5& 7!".8 .!. 8/.0 % !8 !!/8 "/1"5 G5 F!5%5% 7 /!. *!5E 78.!F =.:!.  8 F+8 O""/".#?. !.!. "./!"* 4. C  . "  +8!.  *  8 8  !.!. 5  +8 O " .*! * O K . 8/. ".?+!  8.)  +8!=  ! .*/C./"+.)C? !.!. 8.!. 8.!$!/!1.F =I!""/.. 5 F =.:!.  " 8O   !.!.  ! " 1 .  "/ +8! ! 8  F+8 O!Y#"" .!8=.8.!8 .5 !/:" .= 1/"/"0 D 2"//C/.!//8.?8 =..!/ " F+8 O   " F!5 &  7 ! ./  !!! " " .! 8=. 0 D%%&% ."5M % 11.1/"/" .

   

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

*.+==+! .+8 .= ">  !. .   !./ >K8 .!!.  " >!8."!8./ ?>"+..!!"..:!.! .?./!/ "  8.!/ "   ./!/ C +=   "!! K.:.= ?. :+!.!1!C+">/ +!"!+85 !">!!8

*.?"/1"*.!88 * .!."/.":+!1.K/ *.5 8"/1"8 *.!.=/"> =.:!. ?. . . +=.! " *. 8 +!  8.+! "  !.!.   . 0 D%%&&E ."5M D 8=./P&G3'&"EI.!&''E25 1. .>):8* .8."+8!..)8 +8$#* " " ++:=.   !.8.?>.::/ +8 O/88/+!.  ? ./!/>/!.!"/IC8+"8O"!!5>!8  88/ 8/" =.:!. +!.)"> 7!8"8.+! /# /8  "/".> !I+./!/8!/5 .8 !   ./!/ > 8   8 !+. "  "/.  .:+! 8+!!! "    !.!.  "  ! ?  .  "L  1.K 8 !K!. "> 11.58 =)+"!/" !.!".8 "+ N..!"L"//:8 =..!/?... +=.!5

   

3%%&3&''% 4%%3%&4 88.  + ? >  8 *.! . =+! !!" " . * >/!! " "!!+! "   ./!/ ! ..  " ++: C  .   " >!5& 7. 8 ?"+""+.*/"> 88 .!. " "/1"!"+.5

   

3%%&3&''% 4%&3%&4 !  -,7  !,+ -  +! -,

 809   :  ;    88 .!.  1 +/ 8 H .,---------- C #!"D5G>'GG5%M E5 /= !8!."! !!  !. . M 5 .!?8 /"!:!.!M 5 1 +8!."?F8*!1 +  !8/!$!"  "/. " E' I  ")   !.1.!.  8 8.  ++"/ "/  .= 1/"/"7#S.T# 1?.GG''  ! .K+8.5  "/.  8! $! 8  :/5  +/+ . " .! 9 2 .".? K!+! ? "/..    ! "/. =!.  . ! 8 "  "/..  !!?/M =2 K8 8 ?+ !.1.!.+8 * ."+"!!!"/.. M28 !  .:!   "   8/!!57.+/+ . !.!8! . //+! /+//   !! 2 =2 ! 2 .4"  .= 1/"/ "   8  8 !  +!.)     ?F. "* "/ .*=5+/+ ." +!.  + O"8*?.  !I .!..?"/.. !!?/!F* 88"?/!/ K8/"./ !0!5%E&%'G!%'(25  :11.)9   .DD  /."!9  ,.7,    /!.4I.!9     H.P HH    8. 1 +"8/!$!! !.1./K8!...?>C>11.1/"/ " .8:11