opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/439/2004

Genf · 2004-06-01 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (3 Absätze)

E. 4 8 */// C D  !  (< , =( *//- S  "6 "  8 ": !< "  "  " ; B) 0   ::8   ";:'3  "! < " " *5  *//-0 50  < : @    @ " "!   ;! " ! "    8  <<( ": E *//,3 " & @  : ' "! " 6 " :

3 !  63 ( !! " : ;  C0,%  D0  40 ; . !,   "!6 ;("!   !  "  "  :! " <3 :! ! :   " < "!3 @ ! ";  &  ! :7#@3   :( "; 6 ! <!3 "; "  "; "0  @; ("!  3   ! " 7@  @; "< !" :  :! :  :!  @    !("  "  : "  :! " ( C M,*%  *$$D0  ?7 " !"  & :  =<   ;! " !  & "@ " @   : @ (! ;!  :8 " (0  3  "! !"   !!   : "!  @ (F  :  8  F< " ;! C M,*5  *4,3,,5 ,-.3,,.  -,.3,/5 ,5>D0

   &  ! :#7@3 @ :(3     :7#@3 :(@  ("!   " W0 . 0,  3  " ) & :  "  ::  ")    :#7@ @ !@( & " "0   "' :   " !@ "W ! :#7@ "6) " :   " 66 & :"  7< : W)("!)  "  "  :! " < @ W! :  :H7  6 :( " 8 (! Q   "  @  F<8 " H "! !  8=(  @ :80  6 " !8   " @   ! :3 <!  6 ! 3 F  (! @  7! " (  663  :  "  :"0  : "!    " (@ (! : 8  H F<! "  0  "  WF "W

) $+,-)

+,.*$+*//- :! " < ! :   &  ! 3  W " : "!6 @ W! F  (! ( 66 Q  6 8 :9  " " W #   "W"  @   & :6 "  :! " (  :3 :@ 3 : H 8  F<! " 3  @W  H  ::8 :  !! CB */// :0,5-D0   " W &  ! :#7@  = : " 9 @"  W< " "!"  ) (H    ' ("0  @  "!63 W " (   &  ! :#7@3 "!:"  "  <3 S  :! " (  " < C M  :8!  4>+/, " *%  *//,D0

  @   ( :8 "; :: !"3  @  "! 3 ; @  : <F :  6 ;8= "; !" 6!3 @  ::  6"  " F   :3 @; : !<   "!  : F: !3 @;  !! !8  :  " " C 'D3 @  ": " F !"    6 @   " ;F:  8 (! C M,** ,4/ Q B *///3 :0,5.D0 %0  ;:'3  "< " 68 #<3 (,> : "F ,>3  !! :! :   22222222223 "  :: "!   2222222222  *> =( *//*0  ;< "'  " "!    '  :  M : "   ("!   "       !!0

B  =:"3 " 8  6  "F :(3 "  3 :(@  :! " ( C M,*/ ,,$ "0 *+ Q B B,$$% :0 %5Q  1,$$4 X  *54 :0 *,%  "0

E. 4.3 "0 *8D0 B  ( " F:  : @  " 7#:7' C 6 @ ;(  7<3 @;   < 666 "  @!3 0D3    "  8=(3  @  !"   : '    "  "  :! " (   " :8'  ";" :#7@  (  :  :  (0 >0  ;:'3   2222222222  (! 7O  :   68 #<3 " 8 "    ;7! ";< "! !3  @  =6 "  :  "< " 8 "!:6 !0   2222222222 ;!(@ " H  @ " !< # :9  "!:6  = @  ! "!:(   "   :! " (0 B   2222222222 : " 8 "!:6 ! ": ( 8 *//,3  @  :    : 0 B  !"3 ;<<( (  ( 8 *//,    " & ;! "!:6    ;:: "   "!< 0  8 "!:6 ! @;  (! ;::S "'  @ @;  3 : ( "<! ";! "!   ( "  =:" " M 0

),*+,-)

+,.*$+*//-   ' "!  : ::!  ' (" " 8  6  "F  68 <3  " 7! " 8 " H ::!!0  ;3    2222222222  22222222223   66 " 68 #< ":,$$-0 M  :" "  @  "< ; !! :! @; *//*3 :   2222222222  22222222220 3   2222222222 ; !! ! @; 6    2222222222   ;! @ ": :0  3  "F !" ! ";( @; : "; (! :6 & 5/G "; 6 6!( *//*  (<80  !    : :9 6(80

  ( ";= @ ;!  :! : ";"! "3 @; ;F : 7O  " # :9  6" "  <! :#7@  @;  : H  &  "   8 "  :! <"3   8 7#:7"@0  3 ; ' :#7) "! :   2222222222  6 : ! "; : ";!<0 ;(  :#7) :S :9 :60

 ; @  #"  "F  6  :  68 #< "    66!  (H :  "<! " <(! 66 :  ";"   ' (" C60

M  :8!  *%-+/- " . : 8 *//-D0  ;#   :  ";<<(   " ;0,%  0

 "! " 6 " ;  " "'  H 6 !0

  & :: & ;! @;   8 " "!:  ( " " " :

   P  ! " ! 8  <<( ": = *//-3 " & @  "! <  !! "0

),-+,-)

+,.*$+*//-  / $ .5  .- / $  -/ $/.

 9   :  ;   6 &<($   9 

,0 T  0  9

*0  =0 -0 6   : "  @W :( 6     :! H "  "! " -/ = "'  6 : :  "! "!  8 6!"! " 3 B7UO76@ 43 4//.   3   F :0  "!  : H :<!0  !  " L D "@ F  @ "!   "! 8    : "  "! @!Q 8D F: : @ 6    :(" "   "!Q D :  <   "  :!0 B  !    :   !!  ! !!   D 8D  D )"3  8 6!"! "   : :   '    @W "( "! (80  !  "     # " :(3 @  =3  @  "! @!  W(:: " @   !! F:!"!   C0,-*3,/4 ,/> D0

 <66' L 1)  ]

 !" L  ^   

 : 6  " :! H  6! F :  @W& W66 6!"! "   :  <66

E. 5  4D0   8  "  !< " 66 :#7@3 : @  F: :#7@   :: ! @"  ;< "  :  ;:! " ( @;  :8 ";S CB */// :0,4/ "0 .8D0

B 6"   " !" !3 1B1   "!  "!  ?7 " ;F: !"3 @ ) "  :   ' (" " 8  6 0 B  3   : :#7@3 ;F: " :  "< "  " "; 6    :   "<! " <(! " ;6660  " !(  ' F<8 "  : : ;! "; (! (0  : "  : " "( '3    "  :! :! "  :! 8"3   8"! :#7@3 " 66 : 7@3

),/+,-)

+,.*$+*//-  : ";!< 3  !( :6 ! "  "3  ' 7@ " )  !  "83  "! " : ! "  " ( " # :9  8   !(3 ;!7 "   6  F '< " ;0    " ' :!! 6"  : "!6(8 C M ",$ =( *///    R0 !60  55.+$>3 "0 *D0 63 ;F: " ;F:    " :#7 "  : F !0

 " 3   " " 6 ";  " !<  :  "66! '0

  8 " F) 6<  "(<   " "!    :  8(!3 ;!< "; " "  !@ "  (<3 ;8 " " " " 3  <" "(<   6  6 :  :    " ; '3  6 @ " : ' "! (  8 ;F:3  @ ;!< " " 7": <!  (  :#7  CN)Y8 1B1 3 B 6  BZ<3 7 " C:#77D 73  L (  "    "  :!(# :6 CB BD,$$$3 :0,  :0,/5 Q B */// :0,55 "0 *D0

 ::3  =<  ;! :  6 :!6 "  "; F: !" ="3  ?7 " ;F: ! :!!  "    :! &  ": "  = 6 " ;!   : !"F "; ! " 6 "!0 B  =:"3 :    " ;! "; F: ="  6 @ )  " "3  @; F: "! :  8  6    " ' (0  3 @ "; :! !  " :  : &  !   "  : " "!" " ;F:3   : F3   3  :! "(< "  "  " :  =< 3  83    :!    6  "; ( F: !" C M  :8!  55.+$> ",$ =( */// Q

M,,>  *$/ "0,83,,*  -*   !60 !D0 ;!!  "!  :  ( :8 ;  ::  ;< " # " :(   "!<3   6  "; ::  "; F:3  8  8   C M,** ,4/ "0, Q 13  ("[8 <  " 8<7 6(7< :0 *$%Q 1 3 6 "O7 <7<  " B 3  B B -*+,$>> :0 --*D0

  @   ( :8 "; :: !"3  @  "!  ; @  : <F :  6 ;8= "; !" 6!3 @  ::  6"  " F   :3 @; :  "! 

),,+,-)

+,.*$+*//- : F: !3 @;  !! !8  :  " " C 'D3 @  ": " F !"    6 @   " ;F:  8 (! C M,** ,4/ "0,  !60 Q

M  :8! ",$ =( *///D0

 3 1  < @ ;F: " H 6"!   "   :'  " "< :!3 H  <? &  " ( "  !  :: " !: F7(   !@(@ F @ :! C1  3 ;F: !"  B L 6) F F< " @!  \3  B7UO7 7<O763 4%+,$$$3 :0 -%D0   H  3  N  F: @; F: " H  :' @ F 6 3 &    F !: F @ :!0  " H  :!783    : 7 " : " " C N 3 U< " 7  " B7(["<3  ,$$$ :0 54%0 Q

M  :8!  55.+$> ",$ =( *///D0

: "  P   !8 @; #   :#7@ # ( " "3   "!6 " (  " @  ;! :3 <!  6 ! 3  & :6  :! " (  " <  FT ;(! @ : 8  H F<! "   C M  :8!  -%4%+/* " *>  *//- "0 -0, Q

M,/* ,45 Q B *//, :0 **. "0 *8 Q "# *//* X . :0

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

    

        !"# $   

         %&'()%(**+  %'+)%(**' ,

- .- / $  -/ $/.  & 0 (**' &1 /2 3

  

  4444444444 



$55./ / $  6-/ .7.   ! " !  " # $% & '(

) *+,-)

+,.*$+*//-  5.

,0 1"  22222222223 !  ,$453  (!   6  " 7 8 "  79 ",$$* &,$$%0   :  : 6   "  '  8 8 :  " "0 ;! ;  :' " ;)79  ,$ =(,$$$0    (!   ")  6!( *//*0

*0 ;! ( "!:!  *5 6!(,$$$  : ' " " " :

 :' " ;66  " ;)("! C):'  D3 ( &  :  7 "! 8 *//*0  = @ I ; 0   :!( " % ( *//.3 ;    @   2222222222 ;:: " 6  !!  ( :  " :!" &  ::! "66! " 0  :: "'   = " 0

$0 (! &  "! 3   6 ( @    2222222222 @   2222222222 ;::( :  "! : : ; 0  "! :  @   ; : !    22222222223 ; : @;    : (8    Q N87"3 " =" :(! 3,$>, :0 -,-  0D0) ;! "  7 = 3  .-/D0  (  : " ( @; 8  "  ' +,-)

+,.*$+*//- "; B)  C60  54  D0 B  :! : = .  B  4$  D0 .0   6!"!   : D0

   &  ! :#7@3 @ :(3     :7#@3 :(@  ("!   " W0 . 0,  3  " ) & :  "  ::  ")    :#7@ @ !@( & " "0   "' :   " !@ "W ! :#7@ "6) " :   " 66 & :"  7 +/, " *%  *//,D0

  @   ( :8 "; :: !"3  @  "! 3 ; @  :  : "F ,>3  !! :! :   22222222223 "  :: "!   2222222222  *> =( *//*0  ; 3 "0 *D0 63 ;F: " ;F:    " :#7 "  : F !0

 " 3   " " 6 ";  " ! ",$ =( */// Q

M,,>  *$/ "0,83,,*  -*   !60 !D0 ;!!  "!  :  ( :8 ;  ::  ; > :0 --*D0

  @   ( :8 "; :: !"3  @  "!  ; @  :  ",$ =( *///D0

: "  P   !8 @; #   :#7@ # ( " "3   "!6 " (  " @  ;! :3   *//- "0 -0, Q

M,/* ,45 Q B *//, :0 **. "0 *8 Q "# *//* X . :0 4.3 "0 *8D0 B  ( " F:  : @  " 7#:7' C 6 @ ;(  7 0  ;:'3   2222222222  (! 7O  :   68 # D0

 <66' L 1)  ]

 !" L  ^   

 : 6  " :! H  6! F :  @W& W66 6!"! "   :  <66