opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/429/2004

Genf · 2004-06-02 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (2 Absätze)

E. 08 ($$#(5@ *&/66/! *$# &?$(! (*$7 (25# #&/665&(! '(!$3$($ (>6B8 >8 ##(55# #&/66/# # 1!# #$(!   $28   ?2 1 !' $ ( 9    #  ) $  *# $3  #$#?$)$! (3$(($?? ' # 8 -8 #3$(>J3$/66.! # J (#823)K9

E. 9 $!+ $#(! (#$#%#&)$#* !%$  (!' $* $7($$$$8 @8   *$ $&(5#A /66.8,8  ($ ( #* $# # (  $ !    (  ( .?3$ /66D8 !   #?$*)  *$2 ($$#  *  (?$$ $3  $  &    $?$  *($'  (#$  ) $  1 !' $( 9 ($$#(3$$#((#$ 1 3$  ( $#(#$#%#&( 9 8# ) 1$#  )!#$?$'#$#%#&(*#M! 3    ( ($??  $$ ! $ *# $38 #  $  # $  $(( 3$8

!$(!($$ ($() $&#2($ 1$  $# #** $2( 9 8

   

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

!$(!($ %(1J%8, - (5< #$%3#$!#%$ $#J($$$;< *#($?$ $ $ (2 5#A /66. $& #(#$; 85 8<8 F (.6*/66D(  $&(*$$  $?;$72 < #  (!#??$$ (! 85 8#$( ) K3$   3$# $#(! 85.5( # $  $#%3#$7   78

   

45-0-4/66/ 704567 &<R# (#  ) #$#$ $ $&(' *# $?$3 O 7 ?$%(($#$ $?(!F 8($#$ $?(!J%*   )$! #$ (C#J% #*# $?8! #$ (C# J%  ! ( 1 '7$) (  * #M  ($#$ $? + 3#$ '*  #M$#  1) $#$ $%$; R,>/,0ST $ ( (#$  (*$$  $? D2* ($ $# 5,,5 8 /D@ S "&C$( (#$  J($$$$3$5,@58.5. 8<8 7U #$ (C#J%3 )#$)!$#$ )#*#+) $&#3$ '*$;?8T#8$ 88/05<8$V !2 (# ') (3$  *F*#3$ 1!#$#(!#$ J # 3$# $#((#$ #$ $)# F ( #$(!  ?$' ( ( ! $# ( J%   K # P  # $  $#$  (  #$ $ $   J$($ $#8 7  #$ $# $  $#  $  F  ( 8 K !  $  $ $# ( 7$   &;?87RN#$ & (  C  (KCW$Q3#85,,585-@# D.6<8#3$ (3)! $&(#$ 2%%(!%$3  $$2* #) #)(! $#&#3$  # %$*J$($); R 55/.5.<8  *$? * $$(2#)#$(  #$)( !F ( 3$ 1$!'$ (!J$($ $#)$?# $#($5 #A /66.(J1 (# J% $ $$$)J% #   %$2* 8 <  K'*$(!#??$#* S3!F ( (.6*/66D$  J)!1#'$ $%* 13$?$#?#*$ 1! 85.5   ( #$!$ $  8  K J$($ $#(*$$  $3$)! $ ( (#*$ $$(#$8+$()#! 8 0- (  #$ ?(    $ % ( (#$  (  #$ 7 7    3$%  5 J3$ /66. C)  # $ $   $& ( )$     $  $)   # (  (#*$ ( #$8  ($#$ $#%?(#&$% #1%# # #  $'(#$#*F* #$ #  $'J)1  $123 ($3#**$$# #(#  8 !  $$##(1!'$%##$?()%$ %3#$  K8 K#! 85.585   G#$ &$ ( $&'* #J% #    $3$   S   2%  #*& !#%$ $#  J$($ $# #* H8#( $#( 5,-5($#$ $#

   

45-0-4/66/ 7>4567 # $  $# #* $/$&#**$ OG $& (*$$  $? $ $ #  #((#$ (*$$  $?( #M#$3#$ H8  # $  $#!$ 2 #*F*$$)#$#($$8 2%(!$   $#*  J%((%%(!($#$ $##  #O  ($   #$ 1  $   $# $  C$ #$) ##%$)#+ * $)(#*8J%(3 $$#$ $* ( ' $(#$8 (#F (.6*/66D#$() '  (! 85.58/   $$ (#(!  $&'      # ( (#$  (*$$  $?S $  $   G $&H #** $%$?$  G $&H8! 85.58/   $) $& (*$$  $?   $ $  G(   #M  #$  3#$ H8 !  ($) $*     ( #  $' (*$$  $? 23 (!  J$($ $#8

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

   

45-0-4/66/ 7@4567

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

   

45-0-4/66/ 7,4567 $ ?  )  ##) !  %(*    ( 3$ ( (' (

*($# #$ +C$  ##%#)!$$ ( 3$(3$ F ?$'1*#$-6B8$#(  #  #3$  *%  '$ $# #** $ ?#$ 7(3   $&8   #(($()$2()!!  ( ( #  #  $# ( $7$   $  ( %$   #  *$# 5,,@7/665 /66/?# $#$ $#( $1#A  /66/ ! #*/66/8

 #)  3$$# ??  !   1 # 8  #$( $# (#$  %* F '1?# $#$!+(($$# (# #8

#$##(*$($$#(! (5@ *&/66/    !  $3$  1 (($$#(   $2#$#( # $.6 *&/6658 -8 # )$#& $ %$((#$ 1((; R5560-S 8@0 8/ 8? K# $#3! 8>, S R(/@*/66/D@-465<)$ #  ?$'  !2 1 /U666 ?8 3   $$ !$  $#)$    $8 YYY 

   

45-0-4/66/ 7564567     -(2  (+, ,(-,  +, - 

 6/7   8  9   3! #:& -;   7 

58 #3&8  7

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

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

            !

      

         "#$%$"&''& (")&*"&'') (+ (+, ,(-,  +, -  &.  /0   / &  &'') 

  1111111111 !"#$%&' ()$$ (#*$$ #   #  -22 ,(-,  3+,4,5  (( +#,- # ./0123 $ $* 

   

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

!$(!($$ ($() $&#2($ 1$  $# #** $2( 9 8

   

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

!$(!($ %(1J%8, - (5 /,0ST $ ( (#$  (*$$  $? D2* ($ $# 5,,5 8 /D@ S "&C$( (#$  J($$$$3$5,@58.5. 8 4567 # $  $# #* $/$&#**$ OG $& (*$$  $? $ $ #  #((#$ (*$$  $?( #M#$3#$ H8  # $  $#!$ 2 #*F*$$)#$#($$8 2%(!$   $#*  J%((%%(!($#$ $##  #O  ($   #$ 1  $   $# $  C$ #$) ##%$)#+ * $)(#*8J%(3 $$#$ $* ( ' $(#$8 (#F (.6*/66D#$() '  (! 85.58/   $$ (#(!  $&'      # ( (#$  (*$$  $?S $  $   G $&H #** $%$?$  G $&H8! 85.58/   $) $& (*$$  $?   $ $  G(   #M  #$  3#$ H8 !  ($) $*     ( #  $' (*$$  $? 23 (!  J$($ $#8

$$!$   $#$ * 1(#) *GH (#$ F )$?$%** $* (! $$(*$8   +   (   #?$*   $   $# C$ #$)   ##%$)8    ( 3'  #$;9*#$ ( ( #$ E 9 75,-6800D8     X>6(  # #& /666; OK@.685 - #$(8 5 5/5  @.> #$(85&S?8%* ($#$ $# $ #$ 8@/85(#$?( U7$3$($  >/4.B*#$1(*$7 !$ $3$(106B*#$ #1) ( !$ $3$(1D6B*#$S($& !   (!2 ! 8 /@ 8 5&$    (  (*$7  !$   $3$(1D6B*#$8

   

45-0-4/66/ 7@4567

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

   

45-0-4/66/ 7,4567 $ ?  )  ##) !  %(*    ( 3$ ( (' (

*($# #$ +C$  ##%#)!$$ ( 3$(3$ F ?$'1*#$-6B8$#(  #  #3$  *%  '$ $# #** $ ?#$ 7(3   $&8   #(($()$2()!!  ( ( #  #  $# ( $7$   $  ( %$   #  *$# 5,,@7/665 /66/?# $#$ $#( $1#A  /66/ ! #*/66/8

 #)  3$$# ??  !   1 # 8  #$( $# (#$  %* F '1?# $#$!+(($$# (# #8

#$##(*$($$#(! (5@ *&/66/    !  $3$  1 (($$#(   $2#$#( # $.6 *&/6658 -8 # )$#& $ %$((#$ 1((; R5560-S 8@0 8/ 8? K# $#3! 8>, S R(/@*/66/D@-465  >66D     #$ '*$8  ($    F  ##%8  **#$ (#$ O   56@<8  %??$O  $$   $( O  &&#$   #$#?#*( F  # $?$' $$$)!1!??$?( (#$%??