opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/428/2004

Genf · 2004-06-02 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (2 Absätze)

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

    /0123/4554 6+/016 6 % " &'=<9&. ("(%"" () ( "A." :"F;7T$7" 77410G7$"U  %-' :( '." $ O." $,%"'%  " < &  ." " ' '"  " "(    O & ' "'%  ;": ' '%& "'<9 #$  I "  "" &'"" "   <"'" "7 6 "" "  "" O '&&7#$% " " " ' 6"   A F;7 6C@" A $ '  = '#=V"E$.7$0**0$70+?$ 3B5G7."  '.(% "A'" -99&&'%9".  $   ""-  (  &( ' % " A."     &9" <"'"( F C 004  B0BG7    ";  ""$'-("'&  "('%O '

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

 . '  (" &-'$  & " ' #  " " '      ;,  "  "9."7

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

    /0123/4554 605/016

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

    /0123/4554 600/016 :" ' "- A< ". ) '.$((%"  .$"'&"'"' ,'"" "  '  <9  .A   '"  " "9":7 #"    &'":    '" "$"  =%;;"&"%A'.  "'"("(";'""&'"   F CA"&'0<" 455B02+/5BG7 27

 %-$ %9"  ' %&. "'" &' ."&"' ' % "." & "A :"9"A$      "&  0* .A 4550 ( %&." ;;  "." &&9-  "($" "". "A"" &'% " "$ '=9$&  " & ' 12J$ "   '  :"9"A ' +1J  ": = ' ." F+1J ' +1JG7 

 &9'$";  ( $  &?.A4550("  " ""( ' %& FA" 9" 9=$ )' A" "  $ 9& '% "9 ' -9 " ";   '% '&;""  " "; '&& ' A";&"9=G%'" :"'  $( " &' ."& " &'" ,1125J7 

$"'  %' &9 ,'&'" "  ' $$("." 0+<."4555( " & "   "    ' ."    " " ", " 7  "' '  '0*.A4550'". 'O  "." " &&"'' ."' ;":&,12J7 +7  &  $ " ."  'H:" ' (     A"   '"" "'" &'9":@  "." &' &,H " ,  &7 =E& ";$'9&'%"."'" &'" O '& "&A'% "'.7$.' ."(%"."'"  A ":@ % "." &(% "A  ''"$- :& "&. ''&'  "   '%"  " &(""A&'=&' ."$ &.(%"" A "%" %& " "."'F 74?4 G7"'.%;; $ -9 '""$  =";;  " :   ( "A     '  ':. ;  %.% $'";;&  '  :'%"."'" &F& ='9&&'"'.S C 04?B5"'70$0530B2"'74 4AG7 # '& " $'"'.'H 74?74  $9"'& "  '"''" ,&. 

    /0123/4554 604/016  $  &. ' '";" " "9";" ". ' '& =) =& "( .<(H R'&"" 'F C04?0+3S C  A"&'0? A4554+20/50$ C A"&'44N  4554335/50G7 ."."'" &'& "9&&'%-'""( %&A . % " , &F 0**09BB4G7=";; .'%"."'$ &;&:  " "($<"'7   "A"" &       "" ( %& % "$ -  . ' % " ,   &$   "." &  ". '      "." & ".. O "A  ''"F C043B44S #45557?1G7

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

    /0123/4554 603/016 " "(04/45547??$ A*74G7" &&"'' ."'12J$.''" %&-."",B4%3B0;7   '  (   "." &   '".   "" ." O  :&    $  '&"  '  ""  "; "$  '";;" &$  A   :" ' 45 J  < ";"$   <"' &" &$      '   "" & & 9-$ '  K9 F1?   4555G$ ';" (%"  ."(%,  "' "." &&9-7 &( $".='"'& " %&-.,41%*33;7?57  :'%"."'" &  '"'':. '- '1?$0JF20%***;715W41%*33;?57:055Q20%***;715G7  :%.'" (%,'"6 '%"."'" & ,   "-7 *7

.'("&-'$< & '&""'% '4B <."4554;"&7  666666

    /0123/4554 601/016

  * 2 * , ,*,   ,  

 7.080   9  :00 0  3" $&(;   80 

E. 07 &.A<" P /0123/45547  80

47 < 7 B7 " (&' 9 " 7 37 ;   " '  (% . ;     &  O  '  '&" ' B5 < '-   ";" "  " '& '&  "A;&'& ' $ #=V"E=;(" 2$ 2553   $  " :"7  '&"    O  9&7  &" '" Q G "'"( :  ('&"" '&"A "" ''&""  (&S AG :  (  "; "  " ." ''     '&""S G    "9    '  &  7 #"  &"   "    " &&  &&&    G AG   G "6'$  "A;&'&'  "-(%" '.'&".A7&"' ") ' .$ ("   <" $ "" (  '&""  (&   %. ' (& &:&'"& F 70B4$052 05?G7  9;;"Q  " #  &"' Q  A#     & "6<" Q

" D      ";'& O   ";"&: """(%,%;;";&'& '"9;;

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

              !"

      

         #$%&'#())(*#'(+  *  * , ,*,   ,   (-  ./   . (! ())' 

 0 1111111111  !" #$%& ' '("&" '""       22 ,*,  3 ,4,5 

* ' )*+,-.$ " "& 

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

    /0123/4554 603/016 " "(04/45547??$ A*74G7" &&"'' ."'12J$.''" %&-."",B4%3B0;7   '  (   "." &   '".   "" ." O  :&    $  '&"  '  ""  "; "$  '";;" &$  A   :" ' 45 J  < ";"$   <"' &" &$      '   "" & & 9-$ '  K9 F1?   4555G$ ';" (%"  ."(%,  "' "." &&9-7 &( $".='"'& " %&-.,41%*33;7?57  :'%"."'" &  '"'':. '- '1?$0JF20%***;715W41%*33;?57:055Q20%***;715G7  :%.'" (%,'"6 '%"."'" & ,   "-7 *7

.'("&-'$< & '&""'% '4B <."4554;"&7  666666

    /0123/4554 601/016

  * 2 * , ,*,   ,  

 7.080   9  :00 0  3" $&(;   80 

07 &.A<" P /0123/45547  80

47 < 7 B7 " (&' 9 " 7 37 ;   " '  (% . ;     &  O  '  '&" ' B5 < '-   ";" "  " '& '&  "A;&'& ' $ #=V"E=;(" 2$ 2553   $  " :"7  '&"    O  9&7  &" '" Q G "'"( :  ('&"" '&"A "" ''&""  (&S AG :  (  "; "  " ." ''     '&""S G    "9    '  &  7 #"  &"   "    " &&  &&&    G AG   G "6'$  "A;&'&'  "-(%" '.'&".A7&"' ") ' .$ ("   <" $ "" (  '&""  (&   %. ' (& &:&'"& F 70B4$052 05?G7  9;;"Q  " #  &"' Q  A#     & "6<" Q

" D      ";'& O   ";"&: """(%,%;;";&'& '"9;;