opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/390/2004

Genf · 2004-05-26 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

             !" #$

      

         %&'()%*(((!%+,(%*((' ! - !"- .!   -.  ." '/  01 2  *3  *((' 

 ."  . !"     ."! -"  !- !"!#$!%&'()) **+,--.,*-'(** (- (*&, -+'))'**'   '    455555555555 '())(*   +,--.*,*-'(**     5555555555 '()) /+,--.,* -'(** ,0-  1-*  1,*- '*,,23  0**

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

     1C4!51

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

  ( - +* :# *, !  3  -'* - -(- ,)*' -+-'((8)*'. *-'()*'0*)&'*)-,**'-,)*'-+,)%.+'*- -'((8'7+)**'-+-,*-*.7'()-0* -'((8;6 '*( 7   -  -*)'**' * +8*  +'-+-,*-),()*'7'*-,-+'00*E D!!@!:!Y  !9:C)6B$C D!!#:'*-6"Y !9:B)6"9@G6'.

-'* -,*& -+ )*; '(*)  '-), 7  -,* -)*)*'-)'8-,-,*))*;E06*:#*,#  3G6  *; 0,-, -  E D G )', )**) .H * - '()*'Z'*--'((8Z--*)'**'),*,7

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

  - 0** ' - ''-) ;-' -H*0  * H) ,*( '* - -'((8  ('( ( 'N ) '  ; - -**;*'   '() 0*,;*) H00* - 0**'*.*-'7-7.R'*--,0-;*6 00*.*;*)-0**'-)',- ''-*&**'-'((81*,K8,,' )*. - *;  -,A7 00*(( '* - -'((8  ('( 'N  ''*' - , *  '*0*, ' 7 * 'N H, - ''*'H*&*',,-,)',)&K',6 ('(1 7,*'-&*K8,,(-'QH,- *0''*'-,-*&*--)';;E06 D!!99# '*-6@O!!:!9B'*-6@O3!995)6!B91!C$'*-6#O D!!B !B!'*-6"O!!BC5'*-@;Y !99$)6"!5G6  ( Z %8 '-**Z *8*0* . )**)  * - '()*'(-H*(00*((H,--'-'((8 ('(--,)L-H,-''*'6)'0'*.*(*' '*)'*;.-)J,*-*.*-*') ()) .('-*0-,)--)'-*-&-;**((';** .H-(***'-0**)0'**-**'7)')'-

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

+'0**-'*,,,,)'',#:&*!99:+, - ''*' ,, -,)', )(*% 0'*  - - C A* #$$$6  -(-)-8*''8-'*,,@!A&*#$$$ -,A76

 (*% - '**'  -'((8 )'-* '(( '. - '**'-(*()I,*'-+*'&;**,-+()'I6 -'((8,),&('('N'**')&) K)R ' )',- '-** ,8- 7 +*'&;**, - -,;*'**-%+'&-0**E D!#@!51!B'*-65;  A*)- *,O D,-  )';**, - +()'I)'  '1)*(-'**'-+'*'+*5# 33 !9:C ' :)8 :O  3JS*T*J 3'T*&*J8J &'( )8B9G6 )*-('(17*,,)8*.' '8-0**.,)'-7*;*-**--'((8,63* *+)+';*8*'-+8*-%('(-&--'((8) .+ +)  (* ' ,,()( - ('*&  -(-A**+()KJ)--0*E06 D!!:!951 !9B'*-6@;,0,O;(*-'()*' .)*7)',--,)*'-+-'((8'+*5#  3 !99!)8"$CO D -#-,(;!999>!$5499G63*7 ('(17 +() - -'((8 )) K (, *  ( * ))' *(*&().-*&*--***-'*-

     1!$4!51 -,**',)*''-' )';-)I'*,-(' -',,)*&,('I*'-'-'*7-*&*--,& E D!!":#'*-6@;!!@!:@*&'*-6@;G6 -(--(*&,-'))'**'7-,**',)*')K A,-+(;,('*0.-*&*--'**6

 +)%  *  8* '0'(,( 7  .*),%- -% ' .+  '*0*,  *' ,)*' - -'((8 &  -,)L - +, - ''*''.-*&*--,***(*('I*'-'

-'* 7  -*&*--,&  -  -,* - *.  7 '() - 0* -'((8;6 -%'8*()*6  -,0- ' 0'(, '))'**' -   A' E06 6 :! *, #  3G6 '0'(,(7+*:!*,@ 3**-'()*' (**-,**',)*'--'((8-'*)'),* -& +'*, - ' -'-.+()'I7'-'(**6 3'+ *-8*-'(('*,,'I(23 &*'*%8 7%&-)*#:0,&*!9:56 +-'7;'-'*.-(- **  '((**' ' - '  (*% -+1&**  &*&EA'-+J* *;-,G--,*,8-A'7 '() - '))'**' - -,0-6  .K  (*&, '  ',.&;0'(6 @6

 (-+*5# 3+()'I-'*'&*-'((8.+* ,&*')*)*'**'('),8*88&6 *--)).+*5# 3-*)'**'),*E !9:9)8!!CG6

 +'  -'((8 '*  ) -  , - '**' ;*)**'-0**-'*,,23 )'('- D6 #@HB@!@5 ), '**''**()I,)'),*'-- -,(;!99CA&*&*!99:E06)*%F#@J8,-B@$( #$$$*G6 H*!"*,! 3',*'&*@"*& 3)*H';*8*')'H()'I--,-*J.*'**'- *,-&1*7*-'()*'&)')'**'6  ()'I -'*& &'I   *),*'-*.( )*% '();'*&,7*,-(*%7. '**')**)*K,0*H';A--,**'6 H';*8*' -)I  '**'  - 0'*  -,'() )' H()'I ???????????,***8*-'((.*,- -* -  '*,, ;,,0* -+ *8 *-*&*- -%  !@ -,(;!9:9E06)*%F!J8,*G6'&J&'*

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

     1!@4!51

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

+)%*,,,;*.-,0--',-,(**'!@''; !995)'('*0),(*,-''*.++&*) (' 7 -* . 7  8*' -  '*,, E06)*% '6 # -,06G6 ' ,('*88 ''-  &* '0*( .  -,0- +) (, -%  -  0'*' -+'8 -  '*,,6 3'  1,)'  -(***'**.)*-,**'.7(J -00*78*'0**%-'*,,E06-+.K-,*' - -( ??????????  - 6  ??????????O  - '()*')'-6>???????????G6-,0-'*,7&*- +)*  .*, - ,*   '&, )'*' *-*&*-)'   *&* -  *,@ G6        

 . !"6  !"- .!   -.  ."

     1!54!51  07   8  9   :$ &3*     7 

!6 , &;  .K  (*&, -,)',)  * - '()*'-'*,,*-)B(@$(#$$$O  7

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

  ,*-=  *        ')*'0'(-),K'*0*, )***.+7+00*0,-, -'*)800