opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/373/2003

Genf · 2003-12-18 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

  

            

               !"   #""#$$$$$$$$$$ !"!# "#! %&&'"()*("++%",,"(-'(."+'')/!$ %"&' ("#)*+ *  ,#,-.     '0"()1 #$$$$$$$$$$" # /2,'()/#"","   ) #*(,'2!'+'33 44/50,",,,,,

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

  $"! (!-# " 8"!- $ !!E,/ I" " ((!.,#,"   #!$(",#,", $:"##-!C$3,#G#!!.$ #,3,#.(!"8," !"!#("3#!#!,>?C!(! 2"!#(",#,"$:"##!#-,#(!2"!/ (!"8,"$3$, (!,,#,-(",:   !," $  (",#," $:"#/ # @  (,#. $ #!3,!,":-#7,E,: ,#,-.>?.#,#$$7@#!",C! (!2"!/ /  "#! 1111111111  $ " !(("!# $ *& "H# *555   "8,!-. ?,(,#. $ #!3, @ 55F $(, &&+ #  $,E"#, $ "#! 1111111111/I!.8.!#!(("!#$"#!1111111111$*-!# 9 3!, *555 , ,$,>. >? !.,#!3#," C,!!E, ?.#,# ( 3,E./  -.$,  .E-# 8,# .## $  >  #,3,#. $  3, >"#,$,$!"!#.#,#,-,#.(!$"!/ */ "!(("!#$'-,*55 "#! 1111111111,$,>.>?.## $  (#,# .#,# ##,",! -, >  $,E"#, 3,# CE.  $ 

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

4  $%-(#D-,.@!3,":!C,E,:,#.!!!3,!#C!".36!/ #!":-(GC,##"##,3,#.(!"8,".>,3"> " (!#,,/ */   "# $ *& 3!, *55*   "#! 1111111111  -.$,", $ ?!,3,$,#.  ?# $.#!-,. !  !#,8,# -.$,7 (!.,#. (!"$,#(!!"!#$(!.#(!".$!/I""((!.,#,"  .,"":2#,3$"".#,#!#,-#!#.-G- $6"! >? # (#C""E, ?.3",# (  >> 2"! " -,/  .#,# " (! ?7(!#   "#! 1111111111  > ?.#,# $" (!"".  #"# ", $ /  "#! 1111111111  ,, #,-. >? .3# EE!3#," .#,# (!"::-# ("#.!,! @  $.,,"##>./ (!,!!((.$,"!$#!(,#$ !"!##"-("!#-#":!3.@", "!$(!".$!/ *)/ $.#!-,#,"$'-,*55* ? "!2#$!"!  8"$#!!(("!#$?7(!#,$"#!1111111111>,!.("$,# " # "88,   #" (",# 7 7,E (". (!  2!,(!$  # ?((!.,#,"-.$,$"#! 1111111111/ *+/ !""!!,!$9"H#*55 !"!#(!"$,#!(("!#"(.!#",!$ *+3!,*55$"#!1111111111#!(("!#$4-,*55*$"#! 1111111111/ !.#$(!-,!$"-#>?8,#?":2#*)3!, *55$?"(.!#,"",##$,:.!#,"$!8-.$,(",E## $? #!(",#," -,(!"8"$ $ !8 ,!  "$ EC/ ## "(.!#,".#,#,$,>.!,"$EG8"#,"#!##,-# .#!"!"-%"E!(C,>/ "#!1111111111!3.:",# $##"(.!#,"#8,#>!3,E,.#,##:,,./($#  (#,#  (,E,# $? !!$ $ $"! "-:,! C#/  ?7-   -.$,  "##. 88#,3-#  "#!#! $ 

-#!(!3!#.:!(!.$"-,#@EC#,3"-:,!C#  8!,E$"-(!,"!$,,!/ *4/   ":!3#," $ ' "#":! *55  ?    (!,#. $  "," #.!,!    8"$# ! ?((!.,#," -.$, $ ! 1111111111 ">#!":"..#,#!E-#("#.!,!@ $.,,",#,E,/    / ",E3",!?"!E,#,"2$,,,!; =.#.-"$,8,.#,#,#.  $6  ! "H# *55   !,: #" $ ! ",/

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

#"#!1111111111 ,!63$"!(("!#$4$.-:!*55 ,>-#>!"!#(,#N#"2"!P$!3,E,,3,$#  >,"#,#$6"!(..-#"3/

&  ,3#?3,$"#! 1111111111 !,:$.#,->?,# ((!"::>.,"":2#,3,#.3".$?#8Q"#!8, 2,#*55 $#$?7-(!"#!1111111111 #8,"3-:! *55 $#$$.,,",#,E, >?(,#2#,8,!EE!3#," $ ,-,##," 8"#," ":2#,3 "##. (!  -.$,/ "-- !3.,$ "#!11111111118,#88#.##>$(,# :2#,3 #  "#! 1111111111  : .E-# !  %-(#"-#""E,/EE!3#,"":2#,3?#$.-"#!./

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

 

-!$!.$(##,"(!"8,"((!"(!,.#$!3"%!@ ?,#,-.("!-,T3!$,/ 777

*  2  #6 /        1)")"() +"&*1 .!!3:!"!,#!2#.(!0$-01111111111"#!$.,," $?88,#"$?!,3,$,#.$*&"3-:!*55/ &*(1 / ?$-#(!#,-#/ */ "8,!-$.,,"(!.,#.>? !8.!#$?,3,$,#.@ !"!#/ / ?("!!(/)/ 0#!"!#:..8,$-!$!.$(##,"(!"8,"/ +/ 3",(!.#@?,#,-.("!-,T3!$,/ 4/ ,#>?,?#((!Q$?.-"-#,".$?,$-,#./ '/ 8"!-  (!#, $  >L (3# 8"!-! !"! "#!  (!.# !!G# $  $., $ 5 2"! $6  "#,8,#," (! (, !"--$. $!.  !,: 8.$.! $ !  ICU,O!C"8>, 4  455)    #!", 7-(,!/  $.,  (# G#! (!""E./  -.-",! $",# V =,$,>! 7#-# >L $.,,"  !"!# $.,! ":#,!  , # ( $  $.,,"##>.S:=7("!("!>-"#,8,#,-("3",!$-$!## #!$.,,"S=("!#!,E#!"$"!(!.##/I,-.-",! "#,# (  #!", ..-# .-.!. " ##! = := # =,$   !,:8.$.!$!("!!(#!!-#,6!!!"!>L, $3!$.!!,!!3:/ -.-",!$!"!-#,"!"!-"% $ (!3  >, !"# 2",#  ,, >  $.,," ##>. # L3"(( $ >.#.7(.$,.!"!#;!#/* 54#59=/  

  E!88,6!V WX Y  (!.,$#V 0%0   (!.#2E-##"--,>.("!"#,8,#,"7(!#,(!E!88