opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/32/2005

Genf · 2005-01-20 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (1 Absätze)

E. 9 ,@ 0@,@ =Q -  ,@ 0@,@ G);@ 9  B0, 03 340 2,' 00 ! 2+,30 (0500 3330,,DP55 6  0 40 2, 0  (   3,0  5/ 633 5(03,0: .%%=&)I0 @%353Q

.%%)$I%0 @$;@; 2,'0260  3*0,C003  35 40 >,0* 00,00033 033@  00*420,(",,C  **6 '  4  60   033 (0 33 0'* 3363 D

-08888888888  4  C 0 (0 B +3  J *00360'* *! 550@ 35 (34*,,23%))# 03  &=* %))G 500 3 2 C3350  G&H=?= 5@ E%  2 00 500'3400C3@06420 3*003230,303*, 4  (0   60 30 ( , , 05500 D +**0 26*0 !055 2550 033@ ,,PD ,0'  042033 00,23 %))#2333*3D0334, 300 E*%))G4* 23(0D##H=II5@G#@&=*%))G*, 033 03,  3(0 500 550(* ,,P  C3350  44 G&H=?=5@E%@ 35 ,(0 '3600**,4033 0* 240 !60%))#55 2,400 *0 B(053(0%))G(033,A3@ 0,0', 0,203(0 033?I(*C&II$ 3*066 -0 888888888850*34230550(*

-0 8888888888 40 2,0   60   033@  003(0 **>*"*0C3 35   ,C003*0+,04, ,40 35 2, 33,C'*,J@*630(0360'**! 550 +063 ,,:00423*06,, 3(0 &=*%))G; 3 03*00*: .,C03R&G#<I& ?B0&II?;@ 50 '4202,33* J0330 3*003 &EB0%))G@ '   0C  3  2(0 42 (  0  3606,",!3@ 35  44

   

<%&=&<%))) >%&<%?> *0(  3*00*0,50605 2(0  2"0 ,,(0 05( NB23,6O@  30    0 0 30C  ,! + 35   2(0, 3*003 0**3 0* 0 ' 2,,00 ,*0,C'*500(0%))G@

36 +0 3040,3'  * *0(3 0 B3@ 0C 3'(3*04 35 60D 0*0 3*3035 ,00,D,3 00420(0  0 (0 '42,,042,'*+0*04000@  0  ( ,00,0 *00*  35  D ,3   3,50+3D#II5@

   

<%&=&<%))) >%?<%?>  ,*6  *)+ +,+  )+ ,*

 .474   8  944 4  : ";# ,   74 

%@ 3(C * *0(3 3,3$*%))),0  6(0  *,0 0063  -0 8888888888  8888888888Q  74

&@ BQ ?@ 3C,0 00Q $@  *06(0 *,0D(+ 35  D0  3,** #II5@ #@ 5* ,0   42,( 5*   ,3 "   30  ?I B '  0500,,0 ** 3  3  0C 53 3   9!V0X!540 G GII$     0 +*,0@  30 , ",63@  *3*0 0S ; 0 04 +*4 300 30C00,  300 43Q C; +,, 4 *05 0 0*,(0 *    300Q ;,  06     ,3@ 90  *3*0  0,  0 33* 3*33   ; C;  ; 0>   0C53 3 ,,*0'420 ( 30(C@*3*0 *0*A ,( 40  B0 00 4  300 43  2(,,  433+,3 03:@%?&%IG%I=;@  6550'S   0..  30 S   T09 T     30>B0S     .-    ,05* ,3"0503+,00042D255053 3 0,655

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

        

         

      

         !"#$#!"%%% !&#!#''() *)+ +,+  )+ ,* &-  ./ 0  #' 1 #''(

 * +,+ 2+3,*  , +*,+  !"#$%&%%'(&) * 

 4 5555555555 4 5555555555  +*,,-./0- - 123  40 30 *00 35 

0 6   033 78888888888 9 :500;

   

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

   

$ +*,0  033 0040 2 *000 (0,(0 50,0 60D**CD0@ ,,(0*553L! (0 B42D 3*000(&EB0%))G@ %E@  4"  $ * %))) ,'   **00     *0' 2>(00 (0(  0(0 03 M  *,3 >  0 * 3*0(3 ,,0050*0  300  3,0 %?B(0%)))@ +,0434 35 ,(0 0C3 ,C003*05420230,!63 60   033   * K   42 *00 0 0 F 205*360'* C*! 550 *  ,, +J06+@ %=@ 30** &G*%))) 35  3C* 050(04*63 3!60(0B+3  J 0   033     360'*     C*! 550@ , 0*, 033:*, ,,50C0;,%))$%))#@ +>0 03&=*%))G,  033 50 00  . 9  (0,33, %))#  C3350  G&H=?=5@E%00500'3400C3@ 35 (3420 (0 3*003&EB0%))G,4(0 60 (0, 05500D+**0 26*0 !055 2550 033@3*3*3,036 4   3*,, 0 >0 2(0, 04* *,C003  00 0 *0 36*  00 !J*6  42     ,0* 002(0**3D2*42D,0  * %))G  033 AB 33 DBB4D@  35  , 00 0 %53(0%)))+,044* 40  30 3*3 :%%IH$II 5@)I; , 0 D  00 3!  ?IB0%))G*0,AC%IB0%))G@0634**3! &EB0%))G30 )$HGE$5@##@ %)@ 3,04 #(0&III0(34 *  3360   60 D -0 8888888888 ,*0,  23C0 5** '42026004 20*,003 063%GB(0%))=0,43,'500 033@   * 3, 0 ,'>(C 3 0 2 *000  4 3360 *,3(033 30 3@  063 4 C 3360    *00 30   (0,!63 60 06360'* *! 5504 35 2(0,,(3(050@  400C0%))#0,3034!055 0,0* 9 #,2*,A@0C3350(033 36634 00 0 2* #EHG=)5@G#,%))#30 *30*,A3@  50*44 35 2(0,,3,300*0' J(00335532(0,+,043,4002(0,34C060*0' 2 92(0,33,3@ *  **63*30 *0420 , 0+003!,ACD   3*00550(  35  0  &E B0 %))G   3 0 ,30 + 00 0*,A3?I*0%))G@ ,3034053 3!J*6,*0 3*00 2>!J*60*,A3,C00 203,0  **6@ &I@  % F &II?    33 *0 2550  0C   0@ &%@ 0 3+,0)(*C&II$ 0C 3 (43*,0,,4"%=(*C&II$@ &&@ 0 %#(*C&II$ 35 3, 42D(0,0,0  04  3040 0 200A33 *3*0 3 &G*%)))@340,,3D* 200 550@ &?@ 0 %G(*C&II$ 0C 3*0+ 35  ,0 2 0   *  2(0 &III  ( 4 +>0 2(0, 3   0    0 00 420  (0 20@,30342 000**,3(0 0B0,   0C53 3 *0' ,0,0      0  ,C003 03,  0  *00,C@ &$@ 0 %E(*C&II$ 35 ,03 ,0  (,,3D 200@ &#@   2 0  *,0, ,0  24"  %=(*C &II$  *  2 663 D 50,(0  3*,,30  **63*3+ 35   30  +*0@  0 -0 8888888888*,43*0,30 420230550(*,3 033,* *K 0(00,033.    .9 06 3(00 033  3*C%))$B42D500@420+00 0553* 00 043 *, 033 +50620 0%))#@(3420,3 0D  !!*0420+00,50550(*44 0553

   

G *,C0030@,303 0C403  420(0(03323050,C00 -08888888888 40  30  006 5505  40 0 0   05*0 30@   +,043 4   0' 3 0 (0 550(* 3 4  033 (0  05503 500'  420 (0  03D-08888888888  3,C04 0(050  0,'@(3,,(0,30D,0 4 033 230(33  *@,0 504 0C  3 !00 C0  ,0  *,   033   D,0  4  0' 230 (3  3   * ,'> (C+ 3 0 2 *000400,000 4'6* 2600 033@ &G@ 0 &)(*C&II$ * ,303 0C 3 4  *  F,  35  23(0 D)$HG%) 5@ &#  40 , 0 D  03  00 ,     23 %))#  B42*0%))G@ (3400 C 0  B(0D*0%))G23(0DE#H&E)5@+40500* ?=H?$)5@$I0D0(*553B42B0%))G4 00 ,  %))#30 #EHG%)5@&#@ &E@ 0 ?I(*C&II$-0 8888888888, 0*,   033, %))$  %))#  ,0   ,,  3(00  &=*%))G 00 4  2 ,,  -0 8888888888 05 D 2+0%))$@,303420(03C050! 0 *,A3   033,  23 %))G  42 3C %))E -0 8888888888 2(0 05*3   *(0 00   033 0, 4 0 0 (0 03  3,  C0 , (0 *,   !055 ,!04 *0@  *,  2+0 %))E 2(0  33 0 C303(03@ &=@  0  E 3*C &II$  0C  3  50,(0 + 35   ,0 ,'>(C  *,0,  %=(*C&II$004 +0,05  *   3*0 &)?I(*C&II$336 3DB6@ &)@ ,50363,0 ,0,04 C0 ,0N 0O0>,'@

   

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

   

=  0C53 3 :0>,' .;,3,00,420 *,0N0  **6O  0,00,303 D,0 **K 0PA,"2042 0 2  2*, ,0440 0,*,  (  00 *0,0 B050  C060 3, **6: .%%GE#0 @?CQ%%?%=%0 @ &Q%%&=0 @$ %#=Q%I=#&0 @#Q %)=?,6%I=;@50 3*0  4202AN0 ,00,500D 00CO :5@ . 9 R S N9! C0C6   TU  &'* 3 @,6 %%&; 2K3, 3  0@

   500    , C  205  0 2, 30* 0  **6  ** * K ,   C  00C0   *, 50 3C0, 2550  500040 D D4/0  35  C0@ 55040C0, 500 ,3   0(00 **6>03"633 ,04  0C+ 3BD 550** 0  **6 

** K  0  3 0  0503  D 0 K 23  020(033 3,3,("3@ **> D  30   (0"  633 * P 23  050 3 0(0  ,CC: .%&G$$$0 @ ?%&%&?G0 @$%%))&0 @?35303;@ C;    2,'  0   0  **6  &=B(0%))= D42,C0323 0@ 050 3003,0  **6D-0 88888888888888888888 %?B(0 %)))    60   30 2 3,0, 2@ =& @% 9@ + 00  300036*5*3,,00*, 0&53(0%)))0  300*,0,2@=%@& 9@

500,3 30 B,3(,2@=%@? 9 3,0*0(3,'  **00  *0' 2 9M*,3>$*%)))@

004042 0 35  0 0  * 3,0  **62,,0@ 55 0C53 3 B63 4,400 30 ,3*,0 2+30004* +06340 *,0  300 **6>03"  04400(300  **64H H,,00 60D*,@ 50(0D*, *  3,0 0 6050,, 4,00@ H4H,'

   

)  0,3  5  ,3  4H0(0 ,0,0  H+30H@%G@& 93,,0C,60:(D200 0 *,0%))%0 @&,@%?G;@ 0020 0 0,0 **42330B3D*, 5* 4036*@ #@ ;006,,C003  35  ,3B 0C0, * + 00 2@#& 94,3(042*,A 0 (0  **6 420  3  (0 ,0,0 00* , 3606 6(@ 90 2*,A  ,

*,C003,23 D0C0 00+64060 *: .%&?%#0 @#C@%&&GG0 @$%%)$I#0 @& 353;@ 2@ %$ @ %  9  30 (  @ ?$  9,0 4 2*,A 0 3 0   !4,0  00  03  ( >0D0 *,0*"**,4,,00@ *,A 0( *,30 04* + 0 ,0' *,C 0(3D*,A3 *0'D400,00,0 " 3  50 2CB  300@ 2C060  2*,A ,(000 36*,L!  0,C0,0,0@ 36  0C53 3  33 D 3033 ,0 4 0 40 3606  2*,0 50 ,0,0 2@#& 9 0,343,03  **6 00 03 : . %%=  %)# 0 @ &   353

.,C03R?&I D> 0D 40,50 300**3(3+640,(0D6000D5*0 (30 2

   

%I *0' 3*0 : . %&=  ?I 0 @ ? %%E  $$& 0 @ &C #E% 0 @?%IE?#?0 @#;@5,   0'3(03 4 ,  40 0  ,0C003    **6   2*,"! 2>D> 0 2+ 550(*  05   *!  550 033: .%&=?I0 @?%%E$$&0 @&C%%%=$ 0 @&;@   *00,0C3 ,C003 (0,* D400,00553+0(30,A3D 0   420 500 50 D  '6 !63  2 *000 , 2,0 (*  000D 0 *,0@0 (0 2+!(0  , !63   60, 2 ** 42 C(0'6*00 3:@E%G @%!@# ;@90**C 0 2 *00040,!63   60   , (0!4 550 , !63 60 ,30*0,(0*0J   00    *!  550 0 0( ,    C060*360'* *! 550+06  ,,3 0*00*C0 *  06* *,3*0A 00 23(: .%%$&&? 0 @ $Q . ,C03 R &G#)#0 @%?Q99 - 0R56 V6!

@#& R %))G!@= ,@%I=%Q.9 -9 0 U0!0! V0!U0&3 @,@&?GWE#=;@  ;,C003 2*,A 2@#& 9,,,, 03 34(0000,36066( ,0,0   (  **6 :-   9!V0X0! 9X0(0!6!(@,@EI @@5QT909! X,50!  C06C 0  R !' 10! %)=),@ #=,0*  00 2 02@#& 90(0 2%)=E,@%%;@

*0' 00 **6:(0 .%%&%#E0 @&;, 0 42*,A 3,D2 9,0 0420(D  *,A3  4  00 ,   ( 30* 5,,3 ,3*,0  2@ %G @ %  9  4  00 *0*,A30 20(C003 2*,A@,*0'

   

%% 3(03  **6  3,3 (  **  2('*  ,3*,0Q  **K00,(,",/  ,3   00  36  D 20(C003  3C0 : .%&?  %& %%?  &#G %%%  %E? 0 @ ?Q   %))I,@ ?I$ 0 @?C,0* 00,00033 033@  00*420,(",,C  **6 '  4  60   033 (0 33 0'* 3363 D

-08888888888  4  C 0 (0 B +3  J *00360'* *! 550@ 35 (34*,,23%))# 03  &=* %))G 500 3 2 C3350  G&H=?= 5@ E%  2 00 500'3400C3@06420 3*003230,303*, 4  (0   60 30 ( , , 05500 D +**0 26*0 !055 2550 033@ ,,PD ,0'  042033 00,23 %))#2333*3D0334, 300 E*%))G4* 23(0D##H=II5@G#@&=*%))G*, 033 03,  3(0 500 550(* ,,P  C3350  44 G&H=?=5@E%@ 35 ,(0 '3600**,4033 0* 240 !60%))#55 2,400 *0 B(053(0%))G(033,A3@ 0,0', 0,203(0 033?I(*C&II$ 3*066 -0 888888888850*34230550(*

-0 8888888888 40 2,0   60   033@  003(0 **>*"*0C3 35   ,C003*0+,04, ,40 35 2, 33,C'*,J@*630(0360'**! 550 +063 ,,:00423*06,, 3(0 &=*%))G; 3 03*00*: .,C03R&G# %& *0(  3*00*0,50605 2(0  2"0 ,,(0 05( NB23,6O@  30    0 0 30C  ,! + 35   2(0, 3*003 0**3 0* 0 ' 2,,00 ,*0,C'*500(0%))G@

36 +0 3040,3'  * *0(3 0 B3@ 0C 3'(3*04 35 60D 0*0 3*3035 ,00,D,3 00420(0  0 (0 '42,,042,'*+0*04000@  0  ( ,00,0 *00*  35  D ,3   3,50+3D#II5@

   

%?  ,*6  *)+ +,+  )+ ,*

 .474   8  944 4  : ";# ,   74 

%@ 3(C * *0(3 3,3$*%))),0  6(0  *,0 0063  -0 8888888888  8888888888Q  74

&@ BQ ?@ 3C,0 00Q $@  *06(0 *,0D(+ 35  D0  3,** #II5@ #@ 5* ,0   42,( 5*   ,3 "   30  ?I B '  0500,,0 ** 3  3  0C 53 3   9!V0X!540 G GII$     0 +*,0@  30 , ",63@  *3*0 0S ; 0 04 +*4 300 30C00,  300 43Q C; +,, 4 *05 0 0*,(0 *    300Q ;,  06     ,3@ 90  *3*0  0,  0 33* 3*33   ; C;  ; 0>   0C53 3 ,,*0'420 ( 30(C@*3*0 *0*A ,( 40  B0 00 4  300 43  2(,,  433+,3 03:@%?&%IG%I=;@  6550'S   0..  30 S   T09 T     30>B0S     .-    ,05* ,3"0503+,00042D255053 3 0,655