opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/328/2003

Genf · 2003-12-11 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (3 Absätze)

E. 007    %  ( :;%! .66. "( 8888888888    !  !! ('%% !  %! ( ('  %%! < &! % (& ! !%1  (&%2%(%!' (%  0  2 % 0++C ! ?%(%% ! < &! % (& !!%1 (&%2%(%!'(0 2 %30;%!0++C%<&! %(&(%4 ! (&%2%(%!' <  !%  ( 0  P! 0++C7   B%! 2% ) 

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

4C5064    (&'!!(B%!)%(%!F!  '%'; %(%)!)%('); %(%)= H0./-C,%(70A0.C0CC%(7-?@B%! ) &! %!' (   ! F!  ' <     (  ( (& '(  (   ( (%! (%%! !%B '!!   %  D)%  ! (%!;)& ! (  ('%% (%%! !%2 %!%E% = H 0.0  3CC%(70?@7 37

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

 %%;E &' !!%B%' !%B(%(& D !% '(%  !T$ ( &D ! '!!  '%'! ( !!   % '% <  (%%!% ( ;!% B% ( &'%      !'(%D(&'!!(B%!('7G; % (!!%!   %(&' ! (&D !%;(%%% B%!)4%!%!( ! (%!% )&  4D !%  ('    ! %?  %B%   % ( %1  2%!7  !   ) (&!  '%%! '!!! ( %% ! %  ! < !!  ' %!  (! 

4,5064     !% ( ('(!% ( &D !   ! D      %!  '!!%(%2 E!(%(( %  ;E?% %! !%'!% B (&2D !%'(% = H00:.+6%(70?A00.3.!7! 'B' @7

)%  % 2  ?!(&  !'(%)% !('! %!&!)%!%!%E%D% !!%!B%!&?;!(& '!( B%')   !  B(   ( D !)&%   'E!  %(' !% %!D %')&%%!'!''!?%% %((% =1@)( %!%(!D!'(%%! % !B%)%(&D !%!?%!%2'= H0.. 0C6%(70! 'B' @7&''!('! %! 2  ?! &! %%%& %E%(*( 2%('%E!%B  (&  !(&D !%%?!?%!= H0..0C6 %(7 0A " (% 2%(%!U!?E % (  ?%E! %$ B2 %$ E7.+,!7A" B(%V%%$E!$!E% ( G %G G3.50+::733.!7@7

 ! 'E ( "   %E) &D !% (%! F!  B('    (!!% 1! ! ( (%E!%  '% F!  ! E T <  (%%2%! (%!'! ! ( 'D$!%2!  ')%2) D)!% ' ="   &D !% '(%  G%> !%B%!4 D D%E ()%!' !Q % G G 0+++ 7 3, ! 7@7 F W D)&D !%(%!F! 1!)! DB%! !<%!D 'D)!%'7 (%! F!   '$%? ! !   ! $  ( %! ( (%! = W  X !E(%$! ( G$2 !U(%E% 0+++7 /C,!7@7 37?

 &    !  '!' % < (D D !% '(% BB!'  H8888888888('? 0+++!;2% .6607  ! (&D !% ( 06 2 % .660 &D ! !%) &'!! ( !' ( &D !%'!!!<B%! ?<%(('? 0+++A%!!  (%B%!% !? ((%! '!!7  (%E!%  %%D ! %(!%)>!!! *( B?%!!!'%! $!%( ((%!2 %!%(! ?%!%B '%(=0++/@!!!  *( B'(% *((! %<(%!=0++/@( ! ?%!%B '%(( B?%!<(%!*((! % <E$=*!!%)@%%)(?E%7&D !'2(! ( %1  (%BB' !  %!' ( ! 2% ( & ' %%)  !%2%!' (!' <  '!! ( !'7 ;2%  .666 % !%)  !%!  %! ?(&BB! ! 2% ''!%!%B(&2 %1 (&%%((! (&BB ! <,/L =% ! 2  (%%!% ( (! ( ./L@7 

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

4+5064    37(

 &   2 ( ! (%!% % !! ! (  (D  !(&D !% %?('&! (B E  %%A  BB! %  ! &*     ''!  !%% )% %  !! %!(B(  %(&D !%!S!)(&! 7  %!%%&'!!!% %%!'(! 2%(  !% !%2%!'(!'<'!!(!'B%(('! % !D(&%2%(%!'7  2%( ( ( 2*   (%  < &  B%)&%  (  D !% ! (&? 2!%'(%(& 4%2%(%!'< = " @   ( ) & ' (2  F!  D%'    D !  $%  E% %%)&  E)%  ! ( (%E!% ('! % ! '%'!%!'(! 2%D%E%?!%2%!'(!'%%) '$'!(!< !% ()%!'(! 2%?%(%%!%A &  ( ?(!! 4D !%2('%%7 -7

2()% '1(  !(% ';(% &&!  ( !%((%(' !7 

E. 07 O%!  A  8

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

E. 7 7 7

4065064     # ".  ".! #"  !# #.

   8 

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)



               !"#$ %  

             

                     &'())&*++* "&,*)&*++, -" ! ".! #"  !# #.  '+ #  *++, /0  #1 2 

     3333333333 ! "#!  !$ %  &'!(()'%!(%%    !    !     .# #"  4!#5.6.." (*+,!-./0.001203   %!%'

4.5064     ." 07 "( 8888888888 '  2 % 0+-,  ! 2%'   &!  % 98888888888)%!'(&2 %1 '%%''! %)(0 2 %0+:0  30;%! 0++/ -./$ $?((% @A'!'%%'%! ( ')% %2%(! 1 * ( B?%!(%!=2 %0++/@!!! 1 *( B'(%(%! K 2( &D%%)(; !(?% E%)%?*2%  %?;!%2?;!%B%!%%!'(! 2%(066L(!!!%2%!'

435064    ''!%!%2'%!!(E BB !!)(&2 %1 (  % ( % %! % %'7 (!  ! (!!   'E1  (%%!% (  %!' ( ! 2%  !% 2  *( ( D  %!!  %2 ( ?  ' %  (%! !  ''  !%!    ! ?%!%B E $%)( B?%! (  E1( ! %!% ( B?%!  !%B%!4 D D%E ()%!' !Q % G G 0+++ 7 3, ! 7@7 F W D)&D !%(%!F! 1!)! DB%! ! !!! *( B?%!!!'%! $!%( ((%!2 %!%(! ?%!%B '%(=0++/@!!!  *( B'(% *((! %  K (   E1  %2 ( ?  ' %  (%! ! #! ??!(%%!%( (!((! 2D ''!%!%B (! % ! % !!)&%  '%!!  ( B 7  (%%!% ( (!!'2%(!(%BB%%  @ %(%)  D!!)R ('%%   ! ('%  ?!%   % !  (  ('%%!!)'A?@D  )!%B%!%2% (( !! ! ('%%A@ ! %E! (  '!!7G%'%  !%!   ! % ''! '' '  !!  @ ?@ ! @ %4(  %?B'(' (  !  !%1    )R% (2 ('  % 2?7'% (  !%  * (  2)%  !;%! %%)  ('%% !!)' ! R2 ( )'!'D'(%'  != !703.06C!06:@7  E BB% > Z%(  "    '%(!> %    '!% 4; %!>H '(' %) G   %B ( '! F!!!%B%'D !%%%)R<RBB%B'(' (  % E BB