opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/315/2007

Genf · 2007-03-21 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

             !

      

         "#$%&"#''$ "$(&"#''%   )* ))*  )   *

+, & ! #(, #''% 

   ! !

"!# $!##%&'()**+,

-./0.)**+ !

-- 1  -2   - 1 -  ,$(## 345!67+,  ,89! (4!##814!##  :2; !84

   

.)/  ?@ 4!! 89A4 9B # @!9 C( D  -> >,    $44E4 # ! E8 9  E! (!,?4#!3F  7GH8,4=><>%0&+I8BF2>   7 JH,4/%><>%0&&I8BF2> >  !E8!4!4#49E!#B%#48$ %000'?@K?@!!!!@5C#%=,!9!(8!/%'!)**%!/%L!)**/>)>  %% (8$)**), @!44  E84  ( #8# #@! E89E!(!F  7,4%+>+>%00+I8BF >   74!,4%6>/>%00&I8BF2> .   724,4%6>/>%00&I8BF2> .   72J,4%*>%>%000I8BF>    E! ? 4'! 4C8! ,   E # 9 !E4 E8#C!#> />   #8# #  --  @  - 2   -   @ -     - M79BFN,9#!)0#8!#  4!4 O -   !E P (8! EE!4  >  (8! ! 4!4 EE!4 9 ?! 9 #EE4! ! #4 K P 9#EE4!>8!!!!#(8!EE!4!%& (8$)**%!%  6> @!444C8!E!9(K##4!4!#9B,  ? #  P7$79B !E! ?@  #(4  = '()**) # #82> > =>    ! 9#!  #4! # #8   # 8)**/ !E! ?@ !  C#78B # E! 8!4,  ? # >,4(8$%0&6,!?@C##E!#! 9B!@!44>8B9!(#E!!9!!!4? P74!!93C9#8>,C#78B>

   

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

> ?!#(9?@(!98!4! E!#98B#8#E4()***,49#?@(! ?@ E! "! 84 (  8B # E! 9 $44E # ! E8, !!  #8!!! ?@ 4!! K @49? 84 ( #8 2>, !  8B # '8> !E, !! #B (! 4!4 (A4#->@(!9#44E!#( P749,#8Q((!9(>-E!4!!4

E?!(!#44K@EE!#99!>-@C!# (8!EE!49@!84##O - ,P9?4? 9P?(!#@C!(!9(!9"!4# @C!!1(!#4KC#78B9@!!#E!> (8!,8$!E!889"!4>,C#7 8B9(!933@C!,#8Q94#!9 #99#@#!!4> 9#!,R?C#!'#@3E!4!! 9#!99> ?9?!EE!4#9 -(8!,P9?4?#8 !#8>  4!!E!!8"89>@C!#E88 ?@(!494!(?((!KB(>?1@(!9 !89#E#(8!,#8#!KE88#EE!> !K ,4!!#8>(!9"!4#@C!,E ?@9!!E!>

   

.)/ 6(8$)**6,!E84 $#4?E! 4!! 8!! C#4 9  #B E88 #  9B, #8 S > %6> )%#48$)**6,@!!!##!894E!9( $ #4,K#8#,(##!!EK#4!!#@!!49! #9BE!,#!(!494,#!C34> %=> #8## $#4,1EE!#99!M79BF  N  !8 %&'()**=#?1!!4! !> %+> #4!8!#%E4()**=,@!849!4#>

E!(?A!B8'#?4!!!B#EE4!#A!B8, 8?!#(!9!!BC8!C- C44!KB(9!,9?A(!#E# ?8!#9!##!8!B> !!!4 @!!! # $ # 4   94# # !!   !E!#A!B8#!E894(A!!88! 99#1!#@!E8PE!((!#9A (!4!!43#@94!@#9!!#8!!# ! E8  9( #@3! # # 9A (!4 ! 7 88$#@94> %<> %68)**=,!8!> %&> =9!8$)**=,!!8 $#4,K#8#, !8$#1!!!!E8!3!?> %0> "!#%&'()**+, $#4#8!!A4 !!E84!!(8!%(8$%0009 E!>, >, 2>! 2> E!, $#4!88#!# #49T!###8##1!E8%%(8$)**%>9 #8,#19!,?!4!!9B#E!>,>,2>!2>, ! #1! 9! ?1 #4!! 1!!4 9!  P7,  (! # #! 99$#49$?#3>4C8!#44?! (!EE!4!#4'K;9E!G>! >!4C8!K 1!!#E!((! E?,#!?1A(!#948 ?1!!!E8E!9E!>,>,2>!2> E#!E$> !"!19E!1$'!#1!!!4E#3'C4>)*>  #8# # /% 8)**+,    #8#4  4( # ! "!,  !K!!E#!!!E8>#8#!

   

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

   

.)/    (! !4  E  3 ! 99! ?1 4!! !'  (> !E,  4!! 494 #  8 #9  4>  #4$!,  C#78B # #4E# 14!! 94 #  E!> '#13,$78B#7C#!> C!9 8##EE4!8B#E!#8,K1P9!#948# 49944#!?199!2>> (!99?E!# 8((!9(8B9!(>,$78B 199! >S > !E84?#4E#(!(A4 4CB8!#1C!KE!391!84##O -  >?11(!9!89#19,(!#41C! !1###!!3,E?19B#!E!#E#>

99#1((A43,9E!##4E#,#1C! K>G ! > (!#8#4K149?K8 9?  1(A! 9 1C! #!4 K  E! #!8! K  C#7 8B,9K8 >(!49#?>G  ! (!(41C!91!!#E!!?1 #(!  8$>   E84  ! ( 994  C!   E8#O - !EK(8!#)**E>#!#%= 9!8$)**)>   4C8!  ( C4  #8! U ( # 8#E!U#!4#/E4()**+!!41!!8#1( EE4  C!>  ! 4C#,   #8 ?1 !! #P C! #EE4!>  C! 994   !! # %* 8)**+ #4 K  #8#4!!#!?K?1(!!49C99!>

- !!  9! E8 ?1 (! # C! #EE4!>

9#44(!4E8U (#8#E!U# $V!P!!##4E#,K1#8'C,#!(!C#4 4>  (!  9!4 # C ! ( # 8#E!, E ? 1! E8 9  E ! (4   89! #  8,  9! ?1 1C! #1 ! #149C 9  E!>   !,  (! 9#! 3C4 #1(, #B  ?1 14!! # 89! ?1 (! $ # ! C!9((> 1!K88!,?1(!48#1(EE4 C!>)=>  (! # 8 , !! , #(!  $ # 49%%!$)**+4!44,7A!#?4?1 #4!9"!#!494##4E#,#8Q# 1(!84994>)+> %+!$)**+,!B9$49!##8#, E#!99!#9#)*9!8$)**+E!4!!#? 149##4E#(!#44(8!#$!#K49P, ?1 14!! !! (  !! >  (! 4C8! E84K9($!$C4#EE4!?!!#O -   9#! 9  #4E# #  94#, P9! 9  9

   

.)/ )<> ;)0(8$)**+,8 49#P?! ?(!94 $#49!!#&(8$)**+>  E84((149##E##4$!#14)**+,?!4 #1!!# !#1!!#!4M --N#97

>149(#!!K#($ 98?(!4!498!(1E!#9# EA #1C>  ( 'C 14!! 9#! #B   # 1E!,#!?149#L"!94((74K8  #, K  ! # 13T9!> 1!!  (! 9  9 $(1!!!##4C!##4E#(49,K?(!#!?1 3!!9#!E!,?118!9E88!!?1! (A$4$4 E?3W8B#49>?!!#B 14!!'8E84#T#(!8!(!!E8#3P ##4,E!EK(#8B!!(,1!!  9! ?  #4E# 9!  4(4 !B (! !  1P!9?E88(!E!1$'!#8C(?!9 !##8#E!48CC>#4E#(!99E44# 8K1!#1!! --!(!8"84#( 93A? !  9$ # 14?9 #  2- ->  #4!  #4E#889!!8!#CP> !E84?149 ##4E#(!8!4E!4C!9941(#8#E! #/E4()**+K1!!!##8#,?114!!!(4# $> !4C#,C4?1!#!(!!4K9? !!!4#!!,#!?19(!A(#18943# 9!> (!9P898?48$?C!994 #8!U (#8#E!U89!!E!#1!3C93#8>

E, K  ?! # ( ? 4!!  C! !3!? # 8 2, 1!!   49# ?1 !  C! # !! #B   !! # %*8)**+!?14!!4C8!7? 149(!!4!!C#( -->)&> ='()** #?4?1!!(! ##9#9#4$!)**=!#8(9#9!,?114!! # --9CE8,8!!4#1(9E44# 8  ( 4 # (> 9B ? 1!!   (! E4 1# EB, !8! ?  ( # 9 #49!  $B8 99$,1(!E84?1(!K3C4C8!9!E!3> 1# EB  (! 4!4 48 E4>   9  #8 ( #4498E88!,#B?1(!#4'K9!E!> 

   

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

) 

   

.)/ C(@C!'#MN4!48#E4!!!4,#B %L!)**/, $!#,894#='C, #!94#!!(794#!,=994!!%+'CM!>%!> !=+ N> -!K@!#@4!#%+'C,9 $E4#4) )> (!#1!>=+>)!>, $#4!894!!9 !!!94(K1!>/& #!!E8 #%8%00+M 2N> -894!9'C##@9B#!#B"!#8> /> P!8#1!>&0#!94##8!!(#%) 9!8$%0&=M N,1!>&*#!!!99$9(4K 1!>=+>)>1!>&* 9!?1AK4(?,#  EE 4C4 9  #4 #4E!(,  99V! ? # E!  # 8A # 9( (P ! 89!! P!! ?  !  9(! V!  (? #  94# 944#! M!> $N  ?, 9 #(!,#4!!989!#E!(?4!4!$99B M!>N>-1!>&%>%,#8##4(#!"!#494! K'#!?##4#!8#B#4(!#8!E #4(> 6>  1,  #8# (? ( #4(! E 8)**+ ?  #4E#(!EE49$#P#O - 94!4# 94##944#!> 149 # #4E#  !!4 ( C4 1( # 8#E! # / E4()**+9#%*8)**+#4K#8#>B,(! # #4 ? 1! K  #! # 49! # !! 8( ?  8!E # 4(4C44!4#4(!>#8#A!4!4#494/%8)**+, 9!#44C#!8,?8!E#4(#1!> &*!>$ > #8##4(!94?!($> => -1C! # 1 # #! (?4,  ! P! ?  #8# 1! E8E!1$'!#944#!94##(!4!4#494 %%(8$)**)!9%%(8$)**%88#?4#1"!#!  4( ! 94!8! #8#4> ,  #! # #49! # 9!!

   

.)/   # 9#! # #4 ?1 1C! #1 8!E # !E!#!"!#1!>&=,P!8#?'#! ?  !!4 9!  !! !89 !E  E! # 4#! !   # >4?!, $#49B#K!E!# #!P9C),0!%*,#B!#9#1"!!E4P9!> +> #8#E!(?#4E#EE4##8!,? 4!!E#41"!#%&'()**+,!?,#8BC44,#4! !#4#!4999!#!> 8!!88!#!?  #4E#  (A4 # 1C! K  E!  3,  9! 9 1!84##82 >

 98 ,  (! # ( ?1 EE! # C! 1! 4!$>  EE!,  9! 94 9 EP #  !!  4!4 4 9  !B9$>  ,82 #8(4 K!! #4E##1(EE4C!1(#8#E!#/E4()**+>

  4C8! #44 ( #P C! #EE4!>  ! 4C#,  ! K (?1 EE!(8!C499!(#PC!,! ?EC1(#8#E!!(?C4 !!#%*8)**+> ,9V!!!8!89$$?!!(A4#1C! 91!84##O - EE!C!#49>

EE!,(!9?!4"!!994!9>V!, 8$89$,#8QO - #8#9B #1#!!4 #  9 ? E! (A # 1C!> !  9 9!7 18C ?  #4E#  9#! # EP $#P #  94# # !#4##8##%)(8$)**/,E#E ?1E!(A4CB8!#1C!KE!949> 9#!,4C8!#!!3A9!3B,!98943$ 9?#4E#1994!4#$#P#98!C4 998!K1##9?C#!E!,#P# !> !!K(?82 9948##P 9K?(!(A4#1C!3!9?8!E1C! 1(! 9 4!4 (A4 #!8! P 9 ? C#!  E!>  !4C8!9?C#!(!C#4E!>  EE84?#8#4!!9B#3!E!,(E# #8C>

   

.)/   #8# E! ( ?  99 # 8 2   ! 9 4#$#8Q#4E#4!!388(!!Q!#B K99?1184> 9#!,1C!?#99!?! 4!A49E!$'!E> !4C#,!K(?1!! #8! 78"8 ? 149 # #4E#   89V! 9 #  T # (!8 ! ?1 E! E P(#8B !!(>,K 1!#1!!,149##4E#!94 $# 49E##4994#8,(!9#> #4C8!#!!?#4!#149##4E##(!  $#4!!!8!E8K##,#!? 4C!#94##!(!!E849 C8!#94!94##4(> <> (#?94B#,#8##4('!4>              

   

.)/ B#K!E!#1"!#%&'()**+# $#4,

- /0.)**+,?#!#%%(8$)**%!8949#%% (8$)**),K9C),3>),!9C0#>0,?#!#% (8$%0009#%(8$)***P9C0,#>0,!%*,3>/ ##9!E>   

  10,

)> 4#8#($> ! 10

/> '!!> 6> !?94#!C!!>  CEEB      S   -  94#!     A 

      9E8#94!"!!!E4P9!?@K@EEE4#4 #9CEE