opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/307/2007

Genf · 2007-03-20 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

 

           !" 

      

         #$%&'#())* !#$)&#())& ! + !"+,!   +, ,",-./  %  () .  ())& 

   !"#$!    %

%  &&     ' ((    ! ")*+!    %#$

   

,-.+*,/001 2/,.32  0"! .4   ! $ .*51!  %6$  %% 7 8% 9  $%$: (!"#/000-."$#;/00/4 /4  /5 %; /00/!   "$9$  "#" " 9%% "  >%86"'26"%$?29=@ ' A4$8%>>"9.*B-"""%6 ";C"4 -4   99% D '  " /1 6#; /00/!   E) ! 8$$%!  F9$ 7' 6% '$ "9  3 G% /0004  %% " "8% )%  $9   9%$ " %6!  8%  $"6"'C")#9%#%752(.%"#;86"% %%D8C!9$%"9.*B/!7'#;$%%"/D (.!%#%"9."#H#7"$"$8$$%6" #;"-D(.4'$6%$%$9$$"'C"D"F 9!  .*B3 %  /0004  #$" %%% $67%   8%% C7!  C)9$#!  C% 87 %  "$9 $%!  >>% '$%% 9 6"%4  9% " - "$#; /00.!'$6%%$!97"%!9$""'9%$ "%6!%%I%%%!%%I%9%4$%%H%D.00J"9/-K% /00/4"#;'#9HC%"%8%#9!'%6%$ "; '$%% 9 F8;4  %6%$ "9%$! 9#%%% "'%  9% ,";% % "'$6% % 9% #%%% D %;%  "!96%6CH%68$!6"#%""#%4 #9>9%"7$4 34 "#""' ! !C#%8!9$"$D F9%"'$4(99%"/3"$#;/00-!'$98% "#;8$9"7"9'L8".+!"'$%%%>$ D9%".*B/4 .*B3!;"C"3258C4

9=F#"$$"%!'$'%$%;4"6"%!;K%6$D'!$%%$99!6%6%C8 G%/000?"C"52(.8C9 2 M$%;#% C9%MA4  ##% " 'F9%! '$ >>% " #;9)88C"$>%!%"C"3258C % >% ""! " "9%C "$8$$%6 $6= 52(. % " "9%C9%6-2349$%%#;$%%$%8$" -D(.!6C)9%9C"#>%!%%%9="F  " C "4 >>%%N%"#;8#$7 6"%"%#9;%%%6%$9>#9%9% "C8#"$$D"#9%"9%%8%9

   

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

   

,-.+*,/001 23,.32 *4 "$99%"/+K6/005!' D'$ "#2%"'6"%$"9/-K%/00-%%%="9. K /003! % % # 9= '886% %%$!  "$ % "'%"'"#2%$%%$4 %%"$'9$%$7$4 .04  # "'G% /005! '  %#$9$""$6"%4 "!#$"%%%8$7'$%%"%$"'$$%% "#$%%!#7')6%C8#%""8%" "'8#%%""%C%"#;$%%49 #">$6/005!9%C66%86%>% 99%4 ..4   6 #9$#% "'F9%!  "% " * # /001!  

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

   

,-.+*,/001 21,.32   "! .4 86 $%%%$!"= .G%/00-!;%"!#9$"5K8! "%9$"%%629$"%!599$%%.1K8?%4. %4%51 A4 (%D $"$ /+K6/003? &.-0.01A!" 86"9%$!.->$6! "9%%%8%9#%%%;%"  " $8   D % K8 %%! ! "  #$#%D $"$ %" #; "9% $8 "  "# "  4 (  9#%$!9%"67"%'997"%H%%C$D#= "997=899;%68##%T >%K"7#%"$%#%%9"%? &.-0/-0"4.4.! --5"4.4/!./*3"4.4/!./+31+"4.!./1.-1"43;% $>$A4=8"9$"!7%D!'997%$6"= K"'%$68"? &..+*-"41;!../-10"4 3O

.**BU-+94-.1"4-;A4;A   D  $6 "  % "'6"%$! ' 9 99%$ " #">% F 99 K9"% "$699$   $8# " ' % 3.  !  68 K7' -. "$#; /00/ ? & .-0  -3-! "4 -45A4   #H# !  "9%"6"/.#/00-#">% ?3=#$6A!%$ 68.K6/003?/00--B5/A!%99;? &./+31+ "4.A4 "A 76C9$"!%D"$>%"=8%% %!  6 "% '997  $6 "=  K "  %$ 

   

,-.+*,/001 2+,.32 68? &..+*-"41;!../-10"43O

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

   

,-.+*,/001 2.-,.32 .54 #9%%"79$="!'%D7' %79%$" %6"%6%;#">%%;"%D> "8$"'6"%$!"%"$6"%$%%$4  99% "  #$%C" 8$$ " #9 " 6!  "8$ "'6"%$"%%%%>"10J%"50J4 99%"'%4 BB; !'%DK%%%7' $"%%6>>%9#K ""F=##76%>%""$!%"=.%; /0014 .14 %9%#%"#!%)%"%D%27%" %"=.%;/0014

   

,-.+*,/001 2.3,.32 ,  !"0  !"+,!   +, ,"

 12 3 .. 4  5        6 7 %*( 8   3 .

.4 $6;4  3 

/4 '"#%9%#%4 -4 %7%"%D%27%"%"=.%;/0014 34 '$##%!>F$D/00>4!%#DC8"'%#$4 54 >#  9% "  7 #  %  9$% H% "  "$ " -0 K "=  %>% 9= "; >$"$ ?(C[QC>71!1003  A!96"#%=""% 9;!>#$#%F%4B/">$"$;>$"$".+ K /005 ? &AO  #$# "  "% "7  ! #%> % #)"96%9%8%"%"#"%O"% H% "$ ; >$"$ 9 6 9%  9 6 $%7 F "% " '%4 3/  &4  9$% H% %  9=  9 " %!67$###)"96!"6%H%K%D'64  8>>=   2  Y  $"%   E      $%2K%@     "QQQQ  9>#"9$%H%%%>$F9%7 >>$"$ "98>>